MOOC perinatal mental health in the first 1000 days A project by Module 1: Mental health and perinatal mental disorders Maternal suicide Dr Marie-Noëlle Vacheron, Psychiatrist, Head of sector 13, pole 14 at the Paris Psychiatry and Neurosciences University Hospital Hello. I'm Marie-Noëlle Vacheron, adult psychiatrist at Pôle 14 in Paris, who took part in the national survey on perinatal suicides, with the EPOPé team from Santé publique France. The subject of this lecture will be perinatal suicide, which was inspired by this survey on perinatal suicides.
Firstly, I will introduce the perinatal period and mental health, then perinatal suicide. I will briefly present the report on suicides in France from 2013 to 2015, including the profile of the women and avoidability factors. I'm going to talk about parenthood and psychological disorders.
And finally, how to prevent suicide. The three key words are: anticipate, detect and support. I will conclude with key messages.
When becoming a parent, there are specific forms of suffering and psychological constructs rooted in personal, social and cultural expectations and which can be factors of vulnerability for mothers. You must know that pregnancy and motherhood, which are traditionally happy events, do not prevent mental illness. Thus, we observe the onset of psychiatric disorders during the perinatal period, in any woman, more so than during the rest of her life.
Or a risk of aggravating a mental disorder that existed before pregnancy, such as bipolar disorder, even when these women have been stable for several years. So what is suicide? Suicide is the murder of oneself; a term suggested by the Abbot Desfontaines as early as 1737.
But above all, suicide is the tragic death, often unexpected and therefore incomprehensible, of an individual. Suicide is the cause of particularly acute emotional responses among relatives, but also among caregivers, especially when the woman is being monitored and treated. Perinatal suicide has been defined, by the WHO in 2014, as a non-random and non-accidental death of a woman during pregnancy, or up to a year after childbirth.
The 6th perinatal mortality report, 2013-2015, uses this definition to define the number of suicides during this period. It draws on medical death records, the CépiDc, and feedback from perinatal networks. Then experts will document, in a precise and specific way, all these reported suicides.
These suicides will then be reviewed and classified by the experts of the National Expert Committee on Maternal Mortality. The report, Maternal Mortality in France 2013-2015, is about improving understanding to improve prevention. So what are the main findings?
Perinatal maternal suicide is the leading cause of perinatal mortality, along with cardiovascular causes. To avoid repeating the figures, simply remember that this is the equivalent of one suicide per month in France, nine out of ten of which, based on results, is avoidable. So this is a serious public health issue, with important repercussions on families and health care providers.
We are going to see at what point we can intervene to avoid these deaths in the perinatal period. Firstly, the profile of the women who committed suicide. The profile was no different from other parturient women.
The average age was 31 years old, and the proportion of migrant women was 12%. However, there were some specific characteristics: social vulnerability in 43% of cases, with 24% of women not living with their partner at the time of suicide, either because of a separation during pregnancy or postpartum. In terms of psychiatric history, such history was known in one third of the cases, but joint psychiatric and obstetric follow-ups were only available in one out of five cases.
Psychiatric history could be present but unknown or not fully known to the obstetric team in one out of three cases. There was comorbid substance abuse in 14% of cases, bearing in mind that these comorbidities were likely under-evaluated. Finally, within the obstetrical context, it was the first child in most cases, sometimes a twin pregnancy, which adds to the perinatal stress.
Or in 13% of cases, it was related to a perinatal bereavement. When does suicide occur? Only one occurred after an abortion, all the others after childbirth, and the median was 126 days, or four months postpartum.
This poses a real problem of detection, because at four months postpartum, these women are off the radar. How do women commit suicide? They use violent means, either by hanging, by jumping in front of a train or by defenestration, thus reflecting a clear desire to die.
They mainly commit suicide at home, in two thirds of the cases, or sometimes in an institution, whether it's in a hospital, prison, or even maternity ward. The study shows that suicide is probably or possibly preventable in 21 out of 23 cases analysed, i. e.
91%. What are the avoidable factors that were often intertwined? We have care-related factors in 100% of the cases, factors related to the lack of organisation of care in 81% of cases, and factors related to the interaction of the patient and her family with the health care system in 71% of cases.
Among the factors related to the nature of care, we often find inadequate drug or psychotropic treatment or management in 19 cases out of 21 cases analysed, i. e. 90% of the cases.
A failure to diagnose, i. e. a failure to recognise the depression that sets in, a failure to take into account the specific nature of the perinatal period, mainly by emergency services where women are received, or by adult psychiatrists who are unfamiliar with the perinatal period.
We also have a lack of organised care, essentially a lack of communication between the various care providers, in 52% of cases. An inadequate place of care in 48% of cases, with women who remain in obstetrics, when they should be in a psychiatric facility. And the absence of a specialised follow-up, despite the warning symptoms identified.
Lastly, in terms of interaction of the patient and/or her relatives with the health care system, there may be a more frequent refusal of care in cases of addiction, or a refusal of hospitalisation, either by the patient herself or by her relatives who are falsely reassured by their presence with the woman, or a failure to comply with the drug treatment. There may be a delayed announcement of the pregnancy, non-compliance with prenatal consultations or frequent visits to the emergency room, all of which indicate a lack of commitment or poor commitment on the part of the woman regarding her pregnancy. What can we say about parenthood and psychological disorders?
Two main situations occur. Either the woman has a known psychiatric disorder. Bipolar disorder has a well known risk of relapse in the post-partum period, in 66% of cases when the woman is not taking her treatment, or in 23% of cases when the woman is taking her treatment during pregnancy.
So these figures show us that pregnancy is a very stressful event for these women, even when they are quite stable. For 7% of cases of bipolar disorder, the inaugural episode occurs in the perinatal period, either as a postpartum psychosis or a major depressive disorder. With schizophrenia, there are more obstetric complications that can distress the woman.
We also know that when the woman has been hospitalised for more than three months or in the year preceding the pregnancy, she is at greater risk of decompensation. For women with no known psychiatric disorders, the incidence of psychiatric disorders is significant, notably depression in 15 to 20% of cases, anxiety disorders in 9% of cases and postpartum psychosis, which is a serious psychiatric emergency, in 0. 1 to 0.
2%. There is a greater risk in the post-partum period when there is a history of severe psychiatric disorders, particularly mood disorders. For anxiety disorders, including obsessive-compulsive disorders and less severe depressive disorders, there is probably an underestimation with an onset during pregnancy.
Lastly, we must not forget addictions, with one woman out of ten drinking alcohol during pregnancy, without necessarily informing the obstetrics team. Thus, pregnancy and parenthood do not prevent mental illness. These perinatal psychiatric disorders represent the most important complication in the perinatal period and, therefore, as we said in the introduction, a public health issue.
The immediate postnatal period represents a high risk of new and recurrent episodes, in particular of severe mental illness. Thus, one to two women out of 1,000 require admission into a psychiatric facility in the first months after childbirth. 27% of women who are simply in psychological distress have access to a mental health professional.
This does not, of course, include the effects of severe paternal disorders on the mother and child. Thus, early diagnosis and treatment are important, as is tailored and progressive care in the perinatal period and in perinatal psychiatry. The three essential words are: anticipate, detect and support.
In the event of a psychiatric disorder, providing coordinated care is absolutely necessary. For any woman suffering from a psychiatric disorder and planning a pregnancy, a preconception consultation with a psychiatrist specialised in perinatal care must be offered to assess the pregnancy plan, the environment, the compatibility of the psychotropic treatment with pregnancy and breastfeeding, and any addictive comorbidities. During pregnancy check-ups, a coordinated care programme must be drawn up with the general practitioner, the referred psychiatrist in the maternity ward, Maternity and Child Welfare Services (MCW), when it is part of the care plan, and the independent midwife.
The woman should be offered a prenatal and postnatal follow-up by the same midwife. And lastly, we should try to offer the woman, depending on local resources, a consultation in perinatal psychiatry from the time of pregnancy, if possible. We need to anticipate the stay during the subacute postpartum period, anticipate the discharge of the mother with her baby and ensure regular written communication between the various parties involved, with the submission of a liaison form, upon the patient's agreement of course, providing us with all the written contact information of the various parties involved.
It is important to be able to detect any history of psychological vulnerability. However, such an interview is difficult. It is difficult to ask questions without feeling intrusive.
The midwives' consultation time is often too short and often focused on the somatic aspect of the pregnancy. Sometimes the presence of the husband or partner can be difficult for the woman to express herself. It also takes time to establish trust and it is necessary to be able to repeat the interview throughout the pregnancy.
In addition, it is sometimes difficult to know what type of question to ask. There are solutions such as a longer first consultation, the early prenatal interview, which has been compulsory since 1 May 2020. It may be necessary to institutionalise a moment alone with the patient and renew the interview, especially if we are concerned by small signs.
We can also use a self-assessment questionnaire, the EPDS, which we mentioned at other lectures, and which helps us detect signs of depression and anxiety in women, including during pregnancy. Regarding diagnosis, there are psychiatric clues, such as a history of abuse, sexual abuse, eating disorders during adolescence, addiction, family and personal psychiatric history, a history of psychotropic treatments or ongoing psychotropic treatments. You must ask yourself if they are compatible, whether they are prescribed and by whom and for how long and if there's been a recent modification.
It is important to ask about sleep and possibly about suicidal thoughts. Does the woman feel guilt, low self-esteem, does she have impulse phobias? Does she have concerns about her unborn child?
Is she experiencing body image issues? We also need to know if she gets support or on the contrary is isolated. Lastly, at the obstetric level, we must know her obstetric status.
Is this a first pregnancy? If she has been pregnant before, how were previous pregnancies? What were the specifics of this pregnancy?
Was it a medically assisted pregnancy? Is she diligent with her obstetrical follow-up? Has she had any somatic complications during this pregnancy or before?
Is the maternity ward suitable for these challenges? Does she have a breastfeeding plan? Was there a traumatic birth experience, was it postpartum?
At the environmental level, we must encourage meeting the partner. We need to know if home care providers are needed upon discharge or on a daily basis. We need to know if we can make professional adjustments when we feel the patient is fragile.
We observed that the peak frequency of suicide was at four months postpartum. This is the time when the woman must go back to work in France. We also need to know how she dealt with her partner returning to work.
Lastly, we must not neglect the family's cultural representations of the birth. This means that we must bolster follow-ups when we believe the patient is vulnerable, discard taboos surrounding suicidal thoughts, emotions, and isolation, and to include the family circle when possible. What are the warning signs, potentially signs of psychological vulnerability?
Cyclothymia, meaning mood swings in the perinatal period, sleep disorders, anxiety, panic attacks, even when these seem to improve in the pregnancy check-up. Possibly expressing dark thoughts, self-deprecation, ineptitude, a sudden change in keeping touch or a withdrawal that had not been noticed during the pregnancy check-up. The team's concerns are a very good sign.
Eating disorders. And then, as we have seen, delayed announcement of the pregnancy and frequent visits to the emergency room reflect anxiety. How to provide support?
What to do with a woman presenting signs of psychological vulnerability? In any case, one should not stay alone. A systematic evaluation by a psychologist and/or psychiatrist should be requested at any stage; during the pregnancy, the subacute postpartum period or during a check-up by the general practitioner in the delayed postpartum period.
In the subacute postpartum period, discharge should be postponed, weekend outings avoided, ensure a follow-up at home with the MCW, the independent midwife, hospital-at-home, book appointments yourself and avoid giving the patient contact information without knowing if she can book the appointments herself and contact the attending physician, including when the patient has lost her baby or terminated the pregnancy. In private practice, one should not hesitate to see the patient again and rely on the GP and the psychiatric network in the area. With the patient's consent, you must contact her relatives if you're worried.
Above all, you have to play it down and warn the patient and her relatives that the perinatal period is a particularly fragile-prone period and that they should not hesitate to consult. Lastly, we can recommend specific charities to the woman and her relatives, particularly in the event of perinatal bereavement or when there are signs of depression. But it is important to know that these charities cannot replace a specialised check-up.
So, organising and coordinating maternity care is also important. The goals are to prevent subsequent problems with mother-child interactions and the endangering of mothers. What are the maternity tools available in her area?
There is the development of support for parenthood, the implementation of psychosocial or parenthood support staff to coordinate complex cases and also express concerns, dedicated teams, local networks and orientation support tools. Orientation support tools are self-assessment questionnaires. The dedicated teams are teams specialised in addiction, in perinatal psychiatry.
Lastly, we need to develop collaboration between adult psychiatry teams, the addiction team, ELSA, or social services. Front-line health care workers must be trained in perinatality and perinatal psychological disorders. What are the indicators for referral to perinatal psychiatry?
Any woman who presents symptoms of severe anxiety or severe depression. A woman who presents a recurrent depressive disorder, a bipolar disorder or schizophrenia, even when they are quite stable and well monitored. A woman with moderate anxiety and/or depressive disorders, but with a first-degree relative who suffers from bipolar disorder or a postpartum psychosis.
The objectives: to avoid a worsening of symptoms, prevention, to support mother-child interactions, and avoid worsening maternal symptomatology. The referral is not relevant in the event of a child placement. When should we admit the patient into an adult psychiatric facility?
When there is an acute postpartum psychosis, because in such cases the mother is in no state to care for her baby; when there has been a recent suicide attempt as to avoid a recurrence; or when there is a major depressive disorder, with or without a suicidal risk; because the mother must first be treated before we can work on the mother-child relationship. Lastly, the key messages: interviewing the pregnant woman about her mental health, consulting psychologists and psychiatrists in case of red flag symptoms, even when they are minor, multidisciplinary collaboration in case of psychiatric disorders that are known or discovered during pregnancy, establishing a dedicated care programme coordinated between the maternity unit, the referring psychiatrist and the attending physician in the event of known psychiatric disorders or those that appeared during pregnancy, and postponing the discharge from maternity when in doubt as to whether there is an anxiety or depressive disorder. Thank you very much.