Thank you very much Michael for inviting me for your introduction thank you all for coming here today it's a pleasure to be here my first time in Sweden and Stockholm and first time in 47 years so can you hear me all right might not be on Oh No so no there oh okay it's that okay now better okay so it's a pleasure to be here and I don't know when I'll be back so I'll tell you everything I know in One hour as best as I can do that so we just we chose a broad
topic controversies in manic-depressive illness and I thought I would focus on two basic aspects in terms of diagnosis as Michael just alluded to a non DSM based approach to diagnosing mood illnesses and specifically I'll discuss mixed depression and mood temperaments and in terms of treatment a hippocratic approach which is perhaps different than what you expect from hypocrite erm Hippocratic and really comes down to questioning most of our current research in terms of its validity and emphasizing maybe that there is much more than we think there is two lithium's benefits so we'll start with the diagnosis
and I too started exactly the same years that you did in our field and I also accepted DSM three and three are and four without much doubt most of my career it was really not until the last five years or so when the dsm-5 process started going And I began to interact with some of the leaders and some of the participants in the dsm-5 process and I also finally met and interact with some of the dsm-4 leaders who you may know some of them were criticizing the dsm-5 process I got to interact with them for
instance there was a big conference in Copenhagen a couple years ago where a lot of those people were present and I was able to be there and spend a few days with them not just An hour but hours and evenings in the bar with beer talking about DSM four and five and I learned some things I never heard before never read about never realized and in fact I became very disillusioned about our profession more so than I already was and now the last two or three years I've been starting to talk about it and write
about it although it's difficult to do because some of these kinds of ideas aren't the typical kinds of things that You can publish in the scientific peer-reviewed journal there were historical really facts or interpretations and that's not what scientific journals are for so I write about them in non scientific journal settings like newspaper essays and books but I've started to publish them in the journals if you are interested in sources for what I'm going to describe there are a few new books that have come out about historical scholarship on the Making of DSM 3 by
historian Hannah Dekker and another historian Edward shorter both of them went into the American Psychiatric Association archives and documented a lot of material from the 1970s and 80s that no one had known except the participants they wouldn't necessarily agree with the interpretations that I'm making but at least the factual documentation is in their books I've also interpreted it on my own in my most recent book on Depression and I've said I've started to publish this in the scientific literature so there's this new article in The Australian journal that I published where I discuss some of
this and for that and for any of the other articles of mine that I mentioned I tried to have them all on our website so that you can download them freely Tufts mood calm so if you want to note that for your own later reference now in the 1970s the impetus for DSM 3 was Legitimate in many ways because before that time there was the problem of the chaos in psychiatric diagnosis complete lack of any organization to it a complete anarchy and at some extended no one cared for some decades because psycho psychiatry is very
psychoanalytic and from the psychoanalytic perspective you just had a spectrum from neurosis to psychosis and it didn't matter really to delineate diagnoses much more definitively than that the treatment was Always psychoanalysis anyway so it didn't really matter but as the drugs began to be developed in the 1960s and 70s and people had drugs for psychosis and drugs for depression and lithium there was a return of practical interest in saying who was really schizophrenic and who wasn't and who was really depressed or manic and who wasn't and some researchers who identified with crept Lin's ideas in
the United States led this effort they were Primarily located in st. Louis the Washington University of st. Louis which as you know is in the middle of the United States it's not a major city or a major university the major cities like Boston and New York and Washington and Los Angeles were all controlled by the psychoanalysts it was in the countryside that the CREP Linnaean researcher started sort of like Mao Zedong and China started in the countryside and eventually took over the cities so it Was very political really in the 1970s these groups started doing
research using CREP Lin's ideas to see if they could validate some equipments concepts as opposed to 14 concepts they had the problem that if you wanted to say that you diagnose a certain way you didn't have a pathological specimen in psychiatry you couldn't go as in some ranches of medicine to the tissue in the organ and the liver or wherever and say yes it's hepatitis because see you can Confirm the clinical symptoms based on this pathology in the absence of a pathology the clinical epidemiological standard was to identify multiple independent sources of evidence that point
in the same direction decide symptoms genetics course of illness and then biological markers which if you did not have them you could use treatment response in a way as a farm illogical probe for biology of course you have to be careful about that Because many treatments are nonspecific some even work in everybody like amphetamines or benzodiazepines or opiates so a treatment effect does not translate into a diagnostic validation but it can under certain circumstances more importantly course was very important and that was emphasized the most as crepin had always said the diagnosis is prognosis if
you don't know what the diagnosis is follow the patient for a few decades and then you'll figure It out and that's what he did of course if you want to treat them in the beginning that's a practical problem but from a purely scientific perspective the prognosis the course will tell you the diagnosis the outcome the number of episodes is it episodic what age did it start at now the genetics was always considered relevant for some conditions at least that were considered relatively genetic like schizophrenia maybe manic depression now all of these Sources of evidence were
used to validate symptoms so the DSM 3 grew out of this kind of research some of it that validated defining schizophrenia a certain way versus other ways because of genetics course and outcome and even biological markers but the interesting thing is even though they use genetics course bots and biology and treatment to validate the DSM 3 definitions they didn't put genetics course and biology in the DSM 3 definitions they only put The symptoms there's a couple exceptions there's a course criterion for schizophrenia but the vast majority of DSM 3 4 and 5 criteria are purely
cross-sectional symptoms but they're not based on cross-sectional symptoms they are based on course genetics biology and treatment but people have forgotten that because the textbook itself the DSM book itself the criteria themselves are just symptoms so people act as if the Symptoms are all that matter my my typical question is suppose you have pneumonia with chest pain and you have pneumonia without chest pain those two different illnesses the symptoms are different why don't we call one bipolar pneumonia and the other one unipolar pneumonia symptoms are different you have to say that the symptoms are diagnostically
important based on some other criteria besides the symptoms so how do we know that it Matters if somebody is bipolar and has mania and depression versus somebody who's unipolar and doesn't that mean you just has depression how do we know that those are different illnesses it's not just because the symptoms are different the claim was that they differed in their genetics and their course and their biology and their treatment that's what the research in the 60s and 70s suggested now that was rationale if the evidence supported that a lot of that Research was done by
jiulong and was published by him was one big study the Zurich cohort which he's still doing and the second major study was published by Italian researcher Carlo Paris in the act of psychiatric Scandinavia in 1966 those two big studies influenced the transition to the bipolar unipolar concept which I'll get to more so there was some science to it and the science led to the research diagnostic criteria which were about 20 diagnoses but those 20 diagnoses in 1978 or 16 or so almost 20 became 292 in two years when DSM 3 came out now there's no
way that we suddenly discover 270 till nozanne two years based on scientific research the fact is it wasn't the science supported 16 diagnoses the sm-3 gave us 270 more if you just divide those numbers out it tells you that the sm-3 was 91% unscientific by definition so people say is DSM scientific or not well it's 91% on scientific 9% scientific sort of That's not all or nothing and then in 14 years we added another 70 or 80 and then 20 years later since we're really afraid to change we've only added a couple dozen more so
we're at about 400 but if you ask the question go to the scientific literature for these 400 diagnoses how much evidence do you have on symptoms course genetics biology and treatment effects that these are different from each other and validly different the answer will be That you don't have that kind of evidence for more than 10 maybe 20% of the DSM labels that we use so where do the other 80 to 90 percent come from they come from what the DSM for leadership has been most explicit about this pragmatic criterion the pragmatic criterion means that
they make changes based on what they think is best for the profession that's what I learned in the last few years and I'll explain to you more in the course of this talk let's Let's go back to how this all affected mood illnesses it is important to realize that before 1980 before DSM 3 we had the concept of manic-depressive illness and we had other depressive presentations neurotic depression melancholia as Michael mentioned and what we did in 1980 was to say that all of those different depressive presentations plus the majority of patients that we called manic
depressive should be relabeled major depressive Disorder and a very small minority of the manic depressive patients should be labeled bipolar so one very important fact for you to understand that many people don't seem to is that bipolar disorder the way we talk about it is not the same thing as manic depressive illness the bipolar disorder is not the same thing as manic depressive illness manic-depressive illness meant depression or mania that was recurrent severe and episodic bipolar disorder Means depression and mania that's recurrent severe and episodic the whole difference was in one word a conjunction if
you convert or two and you have the difference so if you just diagnosed somebody today with current depression they have five depressive episodes that are severe and episodic you'll diagnose them with major depressive disorder right that's all they have well that's what used to be Diagnosed as manic depressive illness manic-depressive illness did not mean mania and depression and meant mania or depression the only requirement was that it was episodic and recurrent it didn't matter what the polarity of the episode was now the reason for that which I'll show you in a little while is that
crepin believed that there was no polarity to the episode it didn't matter if the patient was manic or depressed because patients are not manic or Depressed they're both usually they're mixed you can't distinguish the two therefore don't even bother trying thatwas croplands view and I'll show you some recent research that may indicate that he was right after all so these were the patients that were called endogenous severe biological depressive patients these severe unipolar depressive patients they were considered psychotic in fact in many of the research studies and Leonhardt Studies they were limited to psychotic patients
but DSM said oh they could be non psychotic - and they could even be mild to moderately anxious like and chronically so as the neurotic depression concept was so DSM mixed all sorts of depressions from the mildest and the most chronic ones to the most severe episodic even psychotic ones which nobody had ever considered to be the same and why did they do that because they simply put polarity above Everything else if you're depressed you're depressed and that's it and the story if you're manic and depressive completely different ending now there was some research evidence
to support that like I said but the interesting thing is that evidence wasn't as definitive as people think there were these two big studies that I mentioned in 1980 and there's been 30 more years of research since then and one of the most interesting facts is the same Researchers oolongs is still doing research with the same group with 30 more years of data so it's a lot better data he had in 1980 and it's showing the reverse you can't distinguish bipolar and unipolar patients often based on their course and on their genetics now it's showing
the reverse and so he went to the dsm-5 taskforce and he said you know my data now shows that this bipolar MD distinction isn't so clear-cut we Should have a spectrum and they said no we can't do that and my question to them is well why could you do that in 1980 when he had less data and you won't do it in 2014 when he has much better data why it's just based on the science why not because it's not just based on the science well you can see if you have many many types of
illness that are all diagnosed in one category you're going to diagnose a lot of people with that condition MD D I want to give you a Sense of some of that genetic research here where when they looked at patients who were bipolar versus MD D what you had in bipolar patients was inheritance of bipolar illness type 1 or type 2 but you also had a lot of depression you know unipolar depression in MD D you had unipolar depression you didn't have bipolar illness the unipolar depression did not distinguish the groups in other words the genetic
difference is not in both directions unipolar depression is Nonspecific genetically it does not run in families of unipolar people it runs just as much in other people bipolar forms what differentiate the two was a bipolar family history so here's the problem I face this problem a couple times a week with new patients DSM system is entirely based on the view that if we have these two big mood categories and they're based on genetics in course so if you have bipolar patients you should have a bipolar Family history if you have unipolar patients you should not
have a bipolar family history but I keep seeing all these unipolar patients with bipolar family histories these patients with recurrent severe and episodic depression but they have bipolar illness in their family so there's only two possibilities then either that patient does not exist the one who's sitting there in front of my eyes or the DSM system is wrong the only Two logical possibilities having unipolar depression with the bipolar family history is like having a squared circle it's a logical and biological improbability at the very least if you don't want to say impossibility highly improbable the
whole diagnostic system is based on the view that that kind of thing doesn't happen it's like having an Alzheimer's patient whose cognition gets better we have all these Alzheimer's patients cognition improves it's like Having you know well it's it's defined to not happen so if it's happening there must be something wrong with our definitions so MD D is a spectrum it's a broad mix of things there's the neurotic patients there's the classic severe melancholic so they're very psychomotor very anhedonic and then there's this mixed group which I'm going to talk about and then maybe there
are really purely depressed patients but they're not they're not the majority So the secretive DSM is this pragmatism concept this concept that why you decide to make a change in the criteria is not primarily based on the science if it was ox research from 30 years more data would lead to changes now towards spectrum models but nobody wants spectrum models among the APA and DSM leadership why because they don't want to diagnose more patients why because it's not popular to do that why for various reasons one of which is stigma In the public they're already
diagnosing 25% of the population with current DSM definitions they don't want to diagnose more because then they'll be accused of pathologizing and diagnosing too many people and trying to get more power and trying to sell more drugs it's unacceptable well why is it acceptable that 100% of the population is diagnosed with physical illnesses at some point in their lives but only 25% would be allowed to be diagnosed with mental Illness why who said who set the bar 25 well the the reason they do that is they set up this disorder concept where you have to
have functional impairment and severe symptoms to meet diagnostic definitions why what's the scientific rationale for that do you remember how we used to diagnose headache before the 1950s and 60s you could have a blood pressure of 250 over 150 every day for years on end like Franklin Roosevelt did but if you Didn't have I'm sorry a diagnosis of hypertension if you didn't have headache if you didn't have some symptom from the high blood pressure you were not diagnosed with clinical hypertension you had to have a symptom you had to have functional impairment and severe symptoms
it's not enough just to have a high reading on your blood pressure that's pathologizing then of course he got a severe headache and he died five minutes later from the stroke so he was Diagnoseable five minutes before he died and that's the kind of thing that led physicians to change their definitions of hypertension in the 1950s and 60s away from the requirement for symptoms and functional impairment that's not biologically rationale to have that kind of requirement well why do we have that requirement for every single psychiatric disorder because we're not basing it on biology biology
and science we're basing it on political economic and social Considerations I think that this whole term disorder is useless I try to use it as little as I can it's it's explicitly they gets meant to be vague it was introduced with the sm3 in 1980 as Michael was saying because they don't want to commit the leadership of the APA and of our profession don't want to commit to anybody saying that anything is a disease or anything is not a disease they don't want to commit to any of that well what are we going to say
Then we'll call the disorder and if you want to treat it like a disease and giving pills you will and if you don't want to treat like disease and not give them pills and get in therapy you will and you're free to do whatever you want well that's nice you're free to do whatever you want but is that the way science functions you can just decide to do whatever you want to I think the law of gravity doesn't exist so I'll just jump off the building Free to do what I want to that's not the
way science is supposed to function it doesn't mean you have to be totalitarian about it but the evidence needs to be accepted when it's strong enough for something so sometimes we might find that some of these illnesses or diseases people have an allergic reaction to that term disease process Creveling called it why can't we use that term kronkite processing why do we have to say that bipolar illness is not a disease where Schizophrenia is not a disease does anyone really believe that based on a hundred years of scientific research and why do we why can't
we say that some things are not diseases clinical pictures or stun building he called it and the Germans called it back then you have a clinical picture this kind of patient population exists we don't know what it is it's probably not a disease but we're not really sure what it is people get sexually traumatized and then They have unstable relationships and they cut themselves we don't know what it is but we see patients like that they used to call it hysteria they had other terms for it we call it borderline but that's not a disease
it's a clinical picture which used to be called something else why do we think that that's equal in conceptual terms to schizophrenia which is a disease that's existed for hundreds of years and has always been viewed that way or manic Depression what's been described pretty well for 200 years the same way and longer I think we're afraid to commit were afraid to draw conclusions it might have been fine in 1980 when we didn't know much we actually did know a lot then but let's it pretend that we didn't know too much but what are we
doing all this research for for 30 years 40 years why do we have these research centers like here and like Harvard will I've worked If we're not going to ever draw any conclusions from any of this we're just going to keep calling things disorders for another 40 years and not pretend that we don't know anything about it we've stood still since 1980 and that's totally unacceptable for a scientific profession science is supposed to be about progress and again some people don't want to admit that but if you're not progressing you know you're not really being
helpful there is another Aspect to this this pragmatism also reflects post-modernism I won't get into that much now but post-modernism is a cultural ethos that's deep into our culture we are all post modernist so you don't have to read something about it you're born with it it's bred into you just like 500 years ago everybody was very religious right now we're all post modernists and part of post-modernism is a deep skepticism about science and truth and progress and a lot of our DSM Leaders in my observations especially the ones who were non researchers have a
very deep skepticism about research and about science the leader of DSM for explicit he says the last people that should be involved in defining DSM criteria or the scientific experts they're the last people they're the ones you should listen to the least because they're the most biased they all just want to expand their own diagnosis because they want power and they want Money and they want prestige that's the postmodernist perspective what Nietzsche said everything is about power there's no truth at all and there's no progress so once you accept all that and science becomes just
another activity it's not any more important than playing golf you know it's not any more true than anything else than linguistics then literature then of course say you make it up how you like to because there's no truth to It of course you can be pragmatic but if you take science seriously then the whole dsm system is set up opposed to you now ask yourself this question why would genetics and nature and biology and pharmacology follow the definitions of the late 20th century leadership of the American Psychiatric Association who define things a certain way because
it's bent it's acceptable in our culture and we prefer it this way why would genetics follow those Definitions so we define MDD a certain way based on these social considerations and we define bipolar a certain way based on those considerations we define a DD a certain way based on social considerations we define temperament dysregulation disorder a certain way oppositional defiant disorder and so on so forth well if you do genetic studies of those made up socio-economic socially constructed labels if you do genetics of that do you think the genetics are going To be consistent and
positive if you do neuroimaging studies do you think they'll be positive if you do pharmacology studies of a specific drug mechanism like say serotonin reuptake inhibition do you think they'll be consistently strong and positive on labels that you've made up for political social and economic reasons not for scientific reasons so this is what does dismayed me the most I've come to the conclusion that the reason we haven't Made so much progress in the last 30 or 40 years in biological research most of which is unreplicated and mixed pharmacological research which as we know as we'll
talk about some is very weak and genetic research which famously has been negative you know in a large sense a lot of non replication a major reason that we failed is not just because it's complicated people say the mind and the brain are complicated it's not just because of That it's because our DSM system dooms us to failure it prevents us from having any success because our phenotypes are not scientifically valid if your phenotypes are not scientifically valid your genotypes will not be valid and your pharmacological treatments will not work out so it becomes a
self-fulfilling prophecy they say there's no truth out there and then they set up a system which prevents you from ever finding out what the truth is If we were to do it differently we might pay attention to the fact that schizophrenia and bipolar have a heritability that's much much higher than anything else including MDD which I know it's not so straightforward to relate heritability to disease processes but it's it's this is genetic heritability based on twin studies it's suggestive that we're dealing with something that's more of a disease process we might go back to having
10 Diagnoses like the original CREP Linnaean researchers of the 70s suggested instead of 300 and that's plenty you would capture the vast majority of your patients with 10 diagnoses like that we might use a hierarchy concept instead of a comorbidity concept where we say if you have illnesses that cause lots of symptoms you should try to treat those first before you diagnose all these other conditions and treat them And we would treat patients with many fewer medications if we took that approach I don't know why this is controversial except again for the fact that it
goes against the wishes of the political leadership of our profession for the last few decades but you'd be a very bad physician if a patient came to you with pneumonia and you diagnosed him with fever disorder chill disorder night sweat disorder and gave them a different pill for each one of those symptoms but Patients come up come routinely with manic depression and they get an antidepressant and analytic and amphetamine and neuroleptic for all their different symptoms when they get diagnosed with G a D and a TD and all these other things so I think that's
one way out it's an old idea that was directly rejected by dsm 3 but i think that it makes sense to me now i did want to touch on a few other things in relation to diagnosis people have Claimed that bipolar is over diagnosed and this is another rationale for not allowing diagnoses to be based on some of these scientific spectrum concepts that some of the research supports one of the most common claims is and children that the diagnosis increased 40 fold but what people don't often note is that it started at 0 point zero
one percent and it went to zero point four percent which is a 40 fold increase that's still below the Actual epidemiological prevalence rate of 0.5 percent this is not to say that some of these kids weren't misdiagnosed but that means that there are plenty kids who have it who aren't diagnosed because the actual rate is still here or above so to claim the illness is over diagnosed at least on the basis of saying it's diagnosed more than it actually exists isn't true there's no scientific evidence for that and not not in kids we did a
small study where we Looked at this we published it in 2009 and we compared ad D patients and major MD D patients and bipolar kids diagnosed by the child psychiatrist researcher that I was working with who used DSM criteria so you have to obviously you have to accept that level of that that daya's diagnosis might have been valid and then we looked at the histories of these kids and treatment by other clinicians as you can see ad D was diagnosed in everybody who had it many People who didn't MD D diagnosed was diagnosed and most
people had it and some people who didn't bipolar was the only diagnosis that wasn't diagnosed in the majority of kids it's useful to have a control group if you're complaining over diagnosis this is actually the only study that has a control group in kids and we found under diagnosed it's not over diamonds another thing that people don't realize is that bipolar illness in kids means depression it doesn't mean Mania if you follow ten-year-old children for a decade half of them develop manic episodes after having just had depression ten-year-old depressed children MDD kids half of them
develop manic episodes by the time they're about 21 if you follow 23 year old severely depressed young adults 40% of them develop manic episodes by their mid-thirties just MDD so-called MDD the point of MDD from the course perspective was that it did not begin in childhood And young adulthood it began in middle adulthood around age 30 was the average age of onset and based on studies in Paris from the 60s and 70s bipolar disorder began average age 19 that's been very consistent for a hundred years one third of bipolars starting adolescence that's been described since
fall ray in the mid 1800s in Paris this is not a new American thing a lot of people say the Americans are diagnosing It the British really like to say that particular but you have an illness that's been defined as starting in adolescence and early young adulthood and then they say that unipolar depression is different because the course is different it starts later well then how can you have unipolar depression in a ten-year-old again if you do and if you have a lot of it and you actually do half the kids are still unipolar ten
years later but if you do Then that goes against the distinction between unipolar and bipolar it goes back to the concept that maybe the manic-depressive concept is correct that you really can't distinguish these conditions very well based on genetics and course and it also reminds you that therefore this recurrent severe depression and kids may not really be so different from bipolar disorders everyone wants it to be and everyone's all worked up about even in adults this Is a Zimmer mends paper we had a little debate with him that was published in the British Medical Journal
where Dan Smith and I commented on it in this study they claimed that bipolar was over diagnosed because only 43% of clinically diagnosed bipolar could be confirmed to have it using the research interviews what they didn't say was that in their own data which weary analyzed the bipolar patients were this small bars here there was about 90 of them but only 1/3 of them were actually diagnosed as having it in other words the researchers said these 90 people had bipolar but the clinicians only said one third of them had it so the claim that it's
over diagnosed if you actually look at that the other way around is how many of the bipolars that really had it were over diagnosed or not diagnosed you don't see that what you see that there was 30% of the bipolars who had it who were diagnosed with it and 13% of people who didn't have bipolar were diagnosed with it and so really there was twice as much patients who were under diagnosed as opposed to over diagnosed twice as many people have bipolar and don't get diagnosed with it as don't have bipolar and get diagnosed with
it that's what their own data show so it's not just about looking at what clinicians say and then what they say that's reliability a reliability of 50% is de rigueur Kappa values will be about 0.2 0.3 that's where it is for MD D according the dsm-5 field trials this doesn't show bipolars overdiagnosed if this shows bipolar were diagnosed in MD D is over diagnosed - everything's over diagnosed but I think what's more legitimate is to say what's the validity if you take Page to really have an illness how many of them are diagnosed with it
and what you find is that there's a 30% under diagnosis rate and bipolar illness I think I stated that Wrong there's a 30% under diagnosis 27 out of 90 were not diagnosed 70% were and we found that as well that there's a 40% misdiagnosis rate we've published some research we've shown it takes twice as long to two three times as long to get diagnosed if your bipolar is if your unipolar to get appropriately diagnosed we published this repeatedly so there are no data in adults either that show that bipolar disorder is more frequently diagnosed When
it's not present than that then not diagnosed when it is present the under diagnosis rate is 30 to 40 percent so I think it's still a problem but again it goes back to some extent people don't want to diagnose it because they're really caught up on the bipolar label and distinguishing it from MD D and in fact that whole issue distinguishing these two conditions the way DSM three four and five have done it is something that with a couple of decades more Research is questionable I think one of the things that makes it questionable is
the research on mixed depression mix depression has been narrowly defined in the DSM system including the current mixed modifier in dsm-5 but broader definitions exist which I want to show you I want to especially emphasize for yuku Carlos's definition of mixed depression which is patients who have depression it's anhedonia suicidality low interest A lot of the core depression symptoms but it's mixed with psychomotor excitation psychomotor excitation so they're agitated the restless they're pacing they're angry they're irritable and they may also have some classic manic symptoms like periods of increased libido hypersexuality increased talkativeness racing thoughts
now you don't have to have it all the time the way he's thinking about this kind of mixed depression you might have A four month depressive episode and then for two or three days of it you're hyper sexual and talking really fast and running around and then the other three months and you know three weeks and five days you're down well DSM says ignore the two days doesn't mean anything well how do you know it doesn't mean anything maybe means something the other thing is you could be really agitated and angry the whole time and
excitable and that's a very different kind of depression than Melancholia where you're slowed down and you're not angry ratcheted at all at least symptomatically it is maybe diagnostically it's different the other definition that comes from oxd is what he calls the bipolarity specifier which is more the the brief two or three-day period that I mentioned to you more classic manic symptoms so he did this bridge study which you may have seen it was published where in a large international sample he found that about Half of patients with major depressive episodes irrespective of whether unipolar or
bipolar most of them are unipolar about half the patients with depressive episodes have manic symptoms multiple manic symptoms but very briefly not for four days or a week or 10 days or two weeks but for a day or two or three does that not count for anything diagnostically well he looked at some validators in those patients you have Much higher rates of family history of bipolar illness and very high rates of antidepressant induced mania so you have both genetic and treatment validators that it means something it's more like bipolar illness it's not bipolar disorder by
DSM definitions but DSM says look if you have one two or three days of mania ignore it doesn't mean a thing who says why there is zero evidence that the four-day criterion for hypomania is scientifically legitimate zero there's Plenty of evidence that you could argue for a 2-day criteria maybe three but to definitely and in fact fact the dsm-5 task force recommended that the hypomania criteria be lowered to two days and it was rejected by the dsm-5 leadership the scientific evidence supports it the task force recommended leadership rejected it why for pragmatic reasons they don't
want to diagnose bipolar so anymore now this mixed concept is especially Relevant I think to this larger issue when we think about the fact that once you start reviewing mixed states broadly to include dysphoric mania which is a term we used to define and these kinds of agitated and mixed depressions and the bipolarity specifier that's about sixty percent of all mood episodes and people with severe mood episodes it's about sixty percent it's the majority it's a minority about 20% that are purely manic and purely depressed the Majority are mixed and this confirms croplands view he
had eight mixed states and he had pure depression pure mania and he kept emphasizing that most patients are mixed that's why he did not I mean he wasn't unintelligent he could have defined the diagnosis on polarity if he thought that's the way to do it but his rationale was at least it seems to me in rereading him through the lens of this other research his strongest rationale was there is no polarity upon Which to base your classification it's all mixed or the majority of them are mixed that's not to say you don't have any pure
episode you do but there's infrequent enough that it's illogical to base your diagnostic system on what happens in the minority of patients now we've shown that this mix depression is therapeutically important because we did this the first placebo controlled study with a dopamine blocker so called antipsychotic versus placebo In mixed depression defined the way oxd hazardous by polarity specifier in a mixture of bipolar and unipolar patients more unipolar than bipolar and we show that it was effective the president's been shown to be ineffective in bipolar depression the way DSM defines it we found it effective
in mixed depression and that gets at this issue of if you have this very broad heterogeneous depression concept you might be dooming your pharmacology research you're not Going to see the efficacy when it's more specific two subtypes so it seems that dopamine blockers are very helpful for this kind of agitated mixed depression in contrast antidepressants seem harmful and we have only circumstantial data so far because we haven't been using these definitions to do research but if you look at the Stan Lee Foundation's randomized clinical trial of antidepressants in bipolar depression treatment emergent mania happened more
If patients had even just for a score of four on the young mania rating scale meaning this kind of mixed depression a little bit of psychomotor excitation along with depression makes you much more likely to get manic on antidepressants and you not only get manic you get more mixed you're already agitated and angry and restless and suicidal and impulsive and then you get the antidepressant and you're jumping off the building as one of my good Friends did who had a mixed depression and got lots of a depresses you kill yourself that way that's what dil
saver found in these classic studies of mixed states that mixed states have at least as much if not more depression suicide potential as pure depression when people say people commit suicide because they're energized when they're depressed or where they mean by that how can you be energized when you're Depressed the Preston is a state of psychomotor slowing and retardation if you're energized when you're depressed you're not depressed that's a manic symptom mixed with a depression symptom you're mixed so mixed depression is I think a very important clinical issue that we need to start thinking about
more for me it has really changed my practice a lot in the last five years and I learned about all this a great deal from cuca Poulos who was a Greek researcher in Italy from mint for decades who just died last year and it became more and more clear as he aged that his experience was right that he was really bringing it home that's teaching us and now we have access to his database and we're publishing from his patients who he followed for four decades and we're showing some of this evidence and it's coming out
gradually now mood temperament is the other thing I want to discuss it relates to Personality you know you can talk about personality disorders which come from the psychoanalytic tradition but mood temperament is a different way of thinking about personality it's about the original concept which came from calm bomb and then was popularized by crush murder in the early 20th century crush mur well Kyle Baum came up with the terms but crush were really emphasizing the idea that Kretchmer had was that dysthymia Is a mild version of depression cyclothymia is a mild version of mania and
depression hyperthermia is a mild version of mania and schizo thymio is a mild version in schizophrenia and they are all literally mild versions of those illnesses that get transmitted in the families of people who have those illnesses and furthermore people who have those illnesses can have these mood temperaments in between their severe episodes or exacerbations and it's been Very well shown that schizotypal personality is a genetic variant of schizophrenia and a mild version of it there's emerging research that shows that cyclothymia hyperthermia dysthymia are much more common in families of people with bipolar illness than
not and we've done research that that half the patients that in our clinic who have bipolar illness also have cyclothymic temperament most commonly or hyperthermic temperament or Dis lineman temperament these are mild symptoms that are present all the time now if you're cyclothymic or hypothermic you're going to be revved up distracted talking fast thinking fast pretty creative energetic productive a workaholic you might have trouble with relationships because you're so revved up and externalizing all the time and since the DSM definition of borderline personality doesn't include sexual abuse and only has self-cutting as one of Multiple
criteria you easily meet the definition for borderline personality if you have hyperthermic temperament or cyclothymic temperament and then the problem is how can we tell who's got bipolar illness say and enter in between their cyclothymic and hyper timing as opposed to having comorbid borderline personality and bipolar or just having borderline well we can tell that I think I should have just mentioning here personality traits is another way of Looking at personality that has tons of research behind it does link into the mood temperament concept a bit but it's more dimensional and again it was recommended
by the dsm-5 task force that actually was approved by the dsm-5 leadership supported by them and within a few weeks of the final vote on dsm-5 it was rejected by the American Psychiatric Association Board of Trustees kind of like the Politburo saying no we're not going to take it It's not a scientific decision but the science is really strong for it but it's not going to not in dsm-5 at least as a primary concept we can distinguish I think these mood temperaments from borderline because sexual trauma is at least twofold maybe threefold more common in
borderline personality than bipolar illness or the general population and self-cutting is depending on the study at least twofold maybe 50 fold more common in borderline Personality than in bipolar illness now the borderline experts often try to downplay sexual trauma and self-cutting these days they just emphasize the mood lability and the unstable relationships well every bipolar has mood lability and unstable relationships so that's really not a good way to different differentiate borderline from bipolar and they'll say well some people born i personality don't have sexual trauma at true but the Majority of them still do and
of course that's a highly underreported and questioned controversial issue about knowing if you've had sexual trauma self-cutting is very consistent it's about seventy percent or so the borderlines and much much less than the bipolar so i think that we should emphasize these kinds of diagnostically and differentiating validators not just the symptoms not certainly the dsm symptoms Again the whole concept of borderline personality grew out of people who had sexual trauma and who were self-mutilating but then those terms aren't used for the diagnostic criteria in the bridge study it was shown that these the mood symptoms
don't differentiate bipolar and borderline or mixed states and borderline but the non mood symptoms especially the self-mutilating symptoms and the dissociative symptoms did if we started Thinking more about hyperthermia and cyclothymia we would maybe also appreciate that many of our patients and their relatives have it and have benefits from it so here's the only picture of franklin roosevelt in a wheelchair man who i tried to show in my biographical description of him had hyper thymic temperament very funny very creative very talkative very high sex drive very charismatic very energized low need for sleep and that
helped him Survive polio there's research emerging research that shows that when people have traumatic experiences their likelihood of developing PTSD is lowered if they have hyperthermic temperament pre morbidly and also you know his personal trauma he got over and i think he my view is that hyper thymic leaders help nations survive political traumas in his case the worst of the year of the debt of the century the two worst things the worst depression economically we Ever had and of course we'll war too now a lot of people will diagnose this hyperthermia or cyclothymia adult ADHD
because when patients have manic symptoms they can't focus and they say people say adult ADHD is really prevalent people like to say that half of the kids continue to have it when they're adults well if that's true I wonder why nine perspective studies conducted before the pharmaceutical industry got involved in This field showed that there was a 90 percent decline in ADHD by the time you reach young adulthood the introduction of strattera at a time oxy teen in 2002 is the first fda indicated drug for adult ADHD led to the marketing of adult ADHD the
recent research studies suggest there's more frequency of it but still the the earlier studies don't find that I'm going to show you some newer data - the other thing that makes me wonder about this concept that ADHD is purely Biological and really persistent is that in the United States there's a good deal of state to state differences so ADHD rates are very high in the southern states which are the poorest states in the US and very low in the western states which are usually somewhat wealthier and and people tend to go outside more and exercise
more and so on so for instance you have literally a three-fold higher rate in some of these southern states than you do in California this actually mirrors the map for diabetes and heart disease which shows that there are you know generally it's thought of in clinical epidemiology as reflecting environmental factors like diet and exercise that influence behavior that then influences behavioral symptoms it's highly suggestive that ADHD just like heart disease has important environmental factors involved and I always wonder why the cardiologists are more behaviorally Minded than the child psychiatrists are the child psychiatrist wanted to
be purely biological we have this now this recently published 33 year outcome study what happens at with kids who have ADHD at age a with a control group followed until their how many of it how much of it persists and the answer is 20% persists 80% does not so still our best research is that the majority of kids with ADHD do not persist into adulthood with it what's Also interesting is that the biggest group that did have problems became antisocial and that there was a good substance abuse rate I suppose those aren't really good things
to have as adults if you're taking em fetta means for 20 or 30 years there were some mood illness as well I mean some of these kids develop new to illnesses as well the substance abuse rates by the way people like to say that substitutes does not increase with em fetta mean use and Children that's not true it's not true based on the only randomized data which we have which is the MTA study which actually found can higher rates of substance abuse in the kids randomized or amphetamines versus the kids randomized behavioral therapy at one
to three year outcome so we will talk about if enemies in a second but I just want to make the point that when you start thinking about in fetta means because of adult ADHD you might be making a Diagnostic judgment that isn't valid partly because we're misinterpreting mood temperaments perhaps as ADHD and we're also influenced by beliefs about persistence of ADHD which isn't really well supported scientifically now a few words on treatment and then I'll stop I don't like the words we use for drugs I don't like any psychotic mood stabilizer and antidepressant they were
clinical terms invented in the 1950s and 60s when we didn't know what the biological Mechanisms of the drugs were and they're definitely not true antidepressants don't work for all depression any psychotics work in non psychotic persons and mood stabilizer doesn't mean anything a little scientifically meaningful it's just a linguistic term I've suggested that maybe we should use biological mechanisms and call the antidepressants monoamine agonists you know like we say SR I think that's a better way of talking about them they Work better and anxiety than they do in depression anyway we could use dopamine blocker
for the antipsychotics we could use second send your modifiers for lithium and valproate and some of these drugs we call mood stabilizers in GABA agonist for the angio lytx and I think that would imply fewer assumptions when we talk with ourselves and with our patients I've started talking to my patients this way and it helps I don't Have to say yeah you have bipolar depression but I don't want to give you an antidepressant I say you have bipolar depression for which monoamine agonists are ineffective much better way of talking I can I don't have to
say I'm going to give you a mood stabilizer and then they're afraid I'm going to make a zombie I say I'm giving you a second messenger modifier to prevent your mood episodes it's much more scientific much fewer miss mistaken assumptions Something to think about I propose this and so far I've had this paper rejected a number of times and it's not published yet so I don't know if it'll of where I'll get it published but I tend to do it eventually somewhere sometimes it takes a decade all right in terms of treatment I want to
make a big picture point the hippocratic approach to treatment is not is not first do no harm that's what you probably hear Hippocrates never said first do no harm And none of his students ever said first do no harm and it is nowhere to be found in the Hippocratic writings what is there is ask to diseases try to help or at least not harm the term first do no harm was invented in the mid 19th century by a British writer and attributed in properties who's actually never pull it out you guys have Epocrates pull it
out at home see if you can find that phrase it's not there and then people say they want to be fancy They say premium non the cherry they use the latin which of course proves that Hippocrates didn't say acceding speak Latin he spoke Greek never said first do no harm never said premium no no cherry it's not there and it's that's not the meaning of his approach it's not be conservative and try not to use drugs that hurt people it's actually give drugs that hurt people a whole lot as long as you know you're treating
a disease and helping them and if you're Not treating a disease don't give them much of anything even drugs that you think are safe now that's different than the way we tend to talk about this if you read the hippocratic literature you get a sense of that I won't go into detail I've written a an article on this called Hippocratic approach to psychopharmacology which you can download from that website the basic picture which I put on here is that the Hippocratic approach is to try to treat diseases so a patient comes to you with symptoms
your job as a physician clinician first of all this is what you spend your first two years of medical school doing is to find out if the patient has a disease or not then your job is if you find out they have a disease to look at the scientific literature to see if that disease is treatable this is where the evidence base comes in and so on then you can Treat them that's all fine this this arc is fine everyone agrees with that well people don't seem to appreciate it that many times if not most
times patients go to doctors with symptoms but have no disease you're not supposed to treat them according to the Hippocratic tradition asked to diseases try to help or at least not harm that means if there is no disease you just don't harm you don't treat because there's no disease to treat drugs work for diseases now It's true drugs have symptomatic benefits some of them opiates for pain benzos for anxiety and fat amines for attention isn't it interesting that all those drugs work in normal populations for normal pain and attention and anxiety symptomatic drugs are there
because they have physiological effects but they aren't treating diseases tylenol reduces fever well is it abnormal to have fever is it abnormal have temperature if I take tylenol my Temperature will go down from ninety eight point six to ninety seven it's not treating a disease so yes it's okay sometimes we give palliative treatments when someone's untreatable but generally speaking we should try to treat them less a shorter amount of time lower dose of drugs and we should also remember thankfully most patients who present with you aren't really sick most patients who come to you are
not sick Nature has given them illnesses Which go away on their own so there's the famous saying that physicians know and physicians wives know as well that most things get better by the morning that's why you say take two aspirin and call me in the morning it's not because the aspirin works is because morning works by the time against the morning is done so you know in the case of mood illnesses these are recurrent episodic illness what is episodic mean that means unless they die In the episode they will be cured by nature how long
is the episode lasts naturally two to four months four to six months based on the very studies for mania and depression that means if you're seeing a patient who is farther along you can just wait I ask every single patient I see what's the typical duration of your depression and so frequently they say it's a few weeks a month and they come to me with three weeks of depression and they say the Typical duration is a month and I say well great you'll be cured next week no prescription make an appointment next week see you
then we have to give credit to nature that's the Hippocratic tradition nature heals the doctor just assists nature it's a much more humble of attitude than we most physicians have the old classic saying God heals and the physician dresses the wound that comes from Hippocratic surgical ideas in the 16th 17th centuries when they realized that wounds heal by just keeping them clean and putting a dressing on it not by continually cleaning it out with your scalpel that makes it worse and worse and worse we don't have that attitude in psychiatry probably because we don't see
the wound that we keep giving people drugs and trying to treat every symptom that's what the epic rhotic approach is about minimizing the treatment of Symptoms now in our drug treatments we have a lot of drugs like antipsychotics in particular dopamine blockers that are used long-term and I just want to point out that they're based on study designs where only people who respond to the drug can get sir the study then they get randomized to stay on it or come off these are called randomized discontinuation trials or our DTS or enriched drunk what's interesting is
There's almost never been I think I found one but there's almost never been a randomized discontinuation trial for maintenance treatment of any drug in psychiatry that ever failed in fact the FDA did an analysis which they're going to publish soon you know it in the acute depression studies with a depressants and MD D half the studies failed or negative half are positive well in their maintenance studies 15 out of 15 or positive they've never had a negative Study because they all use this design same thing with the antipsychotics there's never been a negative study in
bipolar illness of any antipsychotic the fda accepts the design and i'm trying to convince them not to but one point is look if you never have a negative study how do you have a scientifically valid method remember what Karl Popper said science is based on falsifiability if you can never falsify you can't prove anything either you get things like Withdrawal syndromes with this design everybody gets better on olanzapine then they get randomized to stay on or come off you notice that eighty percent relapse within two months because they came off a drug which they got
better on for a few weeks for severe mania well does that prove that you need to be on it for years and years and years you treat somebody in the hospital for three weeks a month and then you stop the drug and They relapse in a month have you proved maintenance efficacy they change the design they require two months or longer of acute treatment but still one of the things that's interesting this is based on a paper that Goodwin and I Fred Goodwin and I published if you look at placebo relapse rates in these maintenance
studies if you start out with an initial depressive episode your maintenance relapses into mania the opposite if you short out with a manic Episode your maintenance relapse six months longer into depression whereas in the first six months you relapse into the same episode that you had before the study started man your depression what this I think is showing in these double-blind randomized data is that in these maintenance studies if the relapse happens before six months it's not a new episode it's the same episode you had before the study started to really prove Maintenance efficacy you
need to show prevention after six months and that makes sense because there's a hundred years of Natural History data that shows that episodes lasts three to six months and bipolar ohm's manic depression and the other interesting thing is that the episode that happens is the opposite Pole manic depression mania is followed by depression depressions fall by mania it's not the same pole at least in bipolar illness and what you find with The antipsychotics very frequently is that they prevent mania but they don't prevent depression in some of these studies like era prep resolve for instance
well if that's happening maybe it's just because you are not preventing the maintenance phase of new episodes another factor that's relevant to this enriched design I like to use this chocolate vanilla cake analogy suppose you like chocolate cake and then I do a study of chocolate cake and I only Include people who like chocolate cake and then I randomized half of them to getting chocolate cake and the other half to getting vanilla cake how do you think it's going to go I don't understand how people can use this design and really take it seriously another
suggestion is that if you look at the this design and take placebo responders which this visa Andrews and colleagues in this ingenious analysis did they took people who responded to a Placebo in MDD not antidepressant and then got randomized to get stay on placebo or switch to antidepressant in the maintenance phase and what they found was that the a depressant made them a whole lot worse than staying on placebo they claimed that that means that any depressed is actually harm people it could just be another example that this design never fails it invalidly makes whatever
you select for seem more effectively The one suggestion that supports this is that lithium has both enriched and non enriched designs and in the enriched design it has an odds ratio of 22 non enriched 2 that means you inflate the effect size tenfold which is huge in fact size 22 is huge my question is what if you have an ineffective drug so that the real effect size is 1 but you inflate it by 10 you're always going to see a benefit you won't be able to falsify people have been thinking that These drugs just should
stay on because you get a cute benefit and they use these and designs to support that but I'm suggesting to you that the designs may not be valid and also the general concept like the happily ever after fallacy you got better on this drug stay on it and you'll be happy forever is not a medically proven idea there's some examples up here where this doesn't happen with steroids antibiotics propanolol and that's all relevant to Antipsychotics and antidepressants I'll just point out that if enemies are also a problem they can cause mania in this study we
showed they have neurotoxic effects and animals in the brain which we reviewed in this paper which you can get all the references there if you like it's on our website and a lot of people don't want to admit that they have neurotoxic effects in the brain they literally kill neurons so you're giving a drug for cognitive impairment to People you're improving their cognitive impairment symptomatically because the drug does that just like tylenol improves fever but you're actually killing neurons which will make them more impaired in the long run potentially and lithium had does the opposite
lithium prevents a cognitive neuronal death that's shown here that's an oil death that's lithium pretreatment and it's been shown in humans as well much more so that's an alternative Option last thing on a depressants I can't not mention they don't work the meta analyses are very clear relatively clear this is the most recent suggesting a very little benefit very effect size if any acutely we've just finished a citalopram versus placebo maintenance study and acute study and we haven't published it yet I just want to show you our results briefly in six weeks there was no
difference this is citalopram this is placebo they were Equally improving so it adds to the literature that there is not really a benefit with antidepressants over placebo for acute bipolar depression when added to mood stabilizers when you look at maintenance treatment for prevention of episodes we met analyzed that we published this data and ACTA and there really is not benefit for prevention of depression either when added to mood stabilizers there was some increased manic episode relapse in one Of our randomized studies we also found that rapid cycling patients have three times more manic episodes if
they were randomized to staying on antidepressants long term versus coming off so these are randomized data that showed that any presents not only don't work in general but in some patients especially rapid cyclers they cause more depression because we're cycling into not a depression so I think that's a rationale for not using them much but especially Not in the mixed depression patients where I I do think that more dopamine blocker usage makes sense any depressants you can certainly consider in your most severe Achille depressed patients even though they don't work you consider it ECT is
probably a better idea if you really want to get them better quickly and but be very very careful with them I can't emphasize this enough I didn't used to say this I used to think they just didn't work in General I still think that but I I think it's important emphasize that they really can worsen the mixed depression patients and that phenomenology of mixed depression is important for even more caution with antidepressants and for not using them and I want to remind you in the balance study that lithium prevented depression better than valproate and even
better as good as a combination of lithium and vampire for depression prevention lithium was really much Stronger than mania prevention the balanced study is a non enriched classical RCT there's again this false impression out there from these biased in my view invalid randomized discontinuation design studies like the lamotrigine data that lithium doesn't prevent depression well it actually does quite well also prevents dementia as August is shown you have a 22 percent dementia rate in your 60s if you have bipolar or unipolar Depression which is really high population norm is less than five percent and that's
basically reduced to normal with lithium but with not any other class of psychotropic drug and this is epidemiologic data it needs to be confirmed by randomized studies but there are some randomized studies that indicate some benefit now as people get older they can't take standard dose lithium but early stud animal studies indicate that even concentrations as low As 0.1 have neuroprotective effects so maybe low-dose lithium can be useful and this recent meta-analysis showed that lithium of RCTs showed that lithium reduced suicide rates with a odds ratio of 0.1 3 and it's the only drug that
reduces complete suicide in any psychiatric condition clozapine doesn't do completed suicide just attempts and it's been replicated in multiple you know this is actually a and it's a suicide obviously it's an infrequent Occurrence and RCTs so this meta-analysis was useful in providing power to prove it so it prevents suicide so it keeps people alive longer it prevents dementia so it improves their quality of life and it really is quite effective so these are all reasons i think about it especially at low doses as people age as well i think we can think about being more
flexible about that the summary of all this is that i think we need to get out of the dsm Straightjacket and think more scientifically and this would include the concepts of mixed depression and mood temperaments and i think we also need to be more critical about the some of the treatment designs especially maintenance treatment designs where people are trying to sell drugs as quote unquote mood stabilizers and in fact realize that that may not be as effective as that see and the lithium data are still stronger And of course we have these other neurological and
medical benefits with with you now I've this one last video I don't know if it'll work let me take off my microphone this is Martin Luther King who had two personalities form a conclusion I would like to see you today in a very honest man the last song James and our society and some things in our world which I'm proud to be maladjusted in the will to be Maladjusted to be saint until the new society rise on the silencing you that I know we tend to adjust myself through racial segregation and discrimination I never did
myself to religious stink and everything to dust myself economic conditions that will take necessity from the big give loves are super few the millions of God's children smothering in that decades of party in the missile affluent society so I think maybe when we talk About functional impairment and being well adjusted we should think about that and think about what some of the benefits might be of at least being mildly maladjusted and functionally impaired based on APA definitions and instead of ignoring that and writing it off and having bias against it and stigma against it we
should be doing our best I think to identify these these things honestly and clearly because we may find that when we do that with this Illness besides being scientifically honest about it we make hit on some very important cultural and social benefits that we're trying to hide with our current stigma against these conditions Thanks you