[Music] hello you're listening to a on Israel in Al monitor I am Ben caspit from Tel Aviv when prime minister naftali Bennett paid a historic visit to the Emirates last week his predecessor Benjamin Nano looked on with unconcealed jealousy he felt that although he had engineered Israel's peace agreements with the UAE Bahrain and Morocco his successor was reaping their fruit a new book causing waves across oceans and seas challenges netanyahu's appropriation of the Abraham Accords its name Trump's pieace says it all it was written by Barack Ravid probably the middle east's leading diplomatic correspondent writing
for waa news in Israel and AIS in the United States the book is full of original reporting revealing behind the scenes developments and slaughtering some sacred cows Grazing In Israel's political pastures in recent years Chief among these is the perception that netan and Trump are good friends members of an intimate Mutual admiration society and that this explains the generous American policy changes in Israel's favor such as moving the US Embassy to Jerusalem not quite as the book reveals the interview a Ravid obtained with Donald Trump three months after leaving the White House a bitter and
angry man made headlines around the world unmasking Trump's true feelings about the Israeli Prime Minister whom he dismissed with the f word and said he didn't spoken to him since the elections Beyond Trump's deep humili humiliation over what he wrongly views as netanyahu's betrayal the book contains fascinating historic geopolitical and diplomatic insights it unveils the backstage developments that resulted in an historic agreement disproving the age-old Paradigm According to which Arab states would never make peace with Israel as long as Israel doesn't make peace with the Palestinians the peace that Trump made is Alive and Kicking
and Barak r viid will be here Alive and Kicking as well to tell us all right after this short [Music] break hi I'm Elizabeth hegadorn and I'm the state department correspondent at Al Monitor and I'm Joe Snell I'm Al monitor's video editor let's admit it this past year has been difficult to stay on top of the news and sip through what's accurate and what's misleading let Al monitor help you if you care about the Middle East and North Africa you should consider listening to Al monitor's audio series on the Middle East with Andrew parisel and
Amber and Zaman and on Israel with Ben caspi you can now watch our newest video podcast reading the Middle East with J Capel you can subscribe to these series on your favorite podcast platforms and through a host of free daily and weekly newsletters we offer a range of perspectives with the highest journalistic standards you can subscribe to these newsletters at Alm monitor.com as an award-winning media service headquartered in Washington DC our monitor has a network of over 60 contributors around the world so if you haven't done so already be sure to visit Alm monitor.com where
you can find all of these newsletters and podcasts along with first class reporting and [Music] Analysis now I'm very happy to welcome my friend and colleague Barak rid hi Barack how are you doing and thank you for joining us here in on on Israel in Al monitor hi Ben thank you for having me and congratul congratulations uh with your first book and very successful ER by the way if it goes out in English what will be the title you know in in my uh I had two interviews with President Trump and in the second interview
which was in July I um I tried uh um you know um he he asked me what's the what's the name of the books going to be and back at the time I still thought about the name The Peacemaker how Donald Trump changed the Middle East he was obviously very happy to hear that that's the name I thought about later the name has changed and I think that now when it comes out in English hopefully in the next six months it will the name will be Trump's peace the Abraham Accords and the reshaping of the
Middle East and it h it is out in Israel and it is H it's leading the the the table of the bestsellers and it's fascinating and I wanted to ask you first H when and why did you decide it's not a simple decision to write a book about the the Abraham Accords did you believe the Diplomatic agreements with three states that had never been at war with Israel would hold an ENT an entire book um you know first I didn't even at the beginning like a year ago I wasn't even sure that people still read
books that was my uh you know my main thought at the time uh and then I you know I just asked some friends and they said no no no you should write it we think it's interesting thing and when I went to uh the publisher of books he basically told me after two minutes of phone call he just told me start writing I love it and so I did and I thought that the Abraham Accords were really the biggest breakthrough in Middle East piece in 25 years and I wanted to be the person who will
be the first to write uh as detailed as possible account of how those uh Accords uh came about and I think the result is a is very good now please try and sort out the questions of credits would the Abraham CS have yes I know it's difficult theyve come into the world without president Trump or without Netanyahu how would you split the credit between these two or would you say that nany actually delayed and and and almost sank this initiative uh well I think there are three people who deserve credit for for the Abraham Accords
first let's start with Donald Trump I really think I know it's a controversial thing to say but I really think according to uh the research I had for the book the conclusion I got is that the Abraham Accords wouldn't have happened without Donald Trump in the Oval Office and there are several reasons for that first because uh Trump's policy in the region like it or not it had good good consequences it had bad consequences but one of the good consequences was that it got Israel and the Arab world closer together and Trump also managed through
his policies to create relationships uh with a lot of trust with regional leaders and I think this was very uh important to get the Abraham Accords second uh the people that Trump appointed to deal with this file mainly Jared Kushner and Avi burkowitz were really the closest people in his inner circle so when they uh um get something right and when they have an achievement you know he deserves the credit he appoints Ed them uh the same way as when he appointed people who made mistakes it was also his responsibility and third Donald Trump and
I think unlike other presidents was very ready to put his hand into his pocket or into the US government pocket and take out tangibles for uh those countries in the region uh in order to encourage them to uh go forward with those uh with those deals and I think this was uh critical to get those deals so I think Donald Trump deserves a lot of credit now let's move to to the second person which is Benjamin nany when nany came into office in 2009 he started he started pushing this new um idea of outside in
diplomacy meaning and also economic remember talking about economic peace yeah yeah there was talk about economic peace which lasted exactly two weeks yes uh because then he realized you know in in in in economy as in any other thing uh Netanyahu mostly likes the revenue he doesn't like uh to give anything yeah exactly exactly this is you know in in many other fields in his life um and but but Netanyahu did manage to push forward this idea of outside in first let's go to the Arab world and from there we might get to peace with
the Palestinians and I have to admit that for many years I thought this was and he proved me wrong and for 12 years in power he managed to build a lot of secret relationships with uh countries in the region mainly in the Gulf but and there's a big but um the infrastructure that netan is buil this diplomatic infrastructure was very important to get the Abraham Accords but when it got to the point of negotiating them Netanyahu didn't really want them it wasn't his first priority his first priority is to try and Annex parts of the
West Bank uh you remember that after putting together the government in May 20120 uh he put this deadline of July 1st to start the annexation process and for netan this was the most important thing he campaigned on it for three consecutive election campaigns and at the end of June when the deadline really got close the Trump Administration really pushed back on this idea because they didn't want to do it they didn't want to go with this unilateral annexation they were willing to let's say accept some sort of annexation if Netanyahu gives uh territory to the
Palestinians which he never dreamed of of doing obviously and when we got to the end of June we we almost reached the biggest clash between the Trump Administration and Netanyahu over this and nany at a certain point even seriously considered going forward with annexation without a green light from Trump and Trump's people Kushner and burkwitz told netan directly well if you do that first you know what happens to somebody who pisses off Donald Trump uh Trump tweets against him which is you know a big threat and second they told him you'll turn your biggest uh
friend to your biggest enemy and Netanyahu held several discussions of on what to do and he decided to cut his losses and to go for the Abraham Accords but after the uh talks about the the negotiations were done and the deal uh was reached and a date was set for this trilateral phone call between Trump netan and the Crown Prince of ababi Muhammad bin Zed it was set for August 13th for this historic announcement 24 hours before as in many other uh uh cases in nany's political history he got cold feet and his ambassador to
Washington Ron durmer called the White House and told them listen um there this there's political turmoil in Israel Netanyahu might go for early elections because uh the B the budget uh won't pass so um we're not going to sign the deal and when the White House heard that Kushner uh burkowitz and even David fredman they basically went nuts because everything was set everything was ready and fredman calls the prime minister office in Jerusalem and tells nany's uh AIDS he tells them you know this thing is happening tomorrow with or without you so uh you you
can't stop it and then he calls Ron durmer uh the Israeli Ambassador he tells them Ron this is happening be there tomorrow uh this is the hour this is the phone number you you will be on the line there's no other choice and nany realizes that uh that's it there's no way back and and he goes for it so so while Netanyahu laid down the infrastructure that was critical to get to the Aram Accords when the Abraham Accords were actually negotiated he he really it wasn't his first choice and he tried to get out of
it the third person who deserves okay the the third person who deserves credit is the Crown Prince of Abu Dhabi Muhammad bin Z because he basically uh really wanted to normalize relations with Israel strategically and at the same time he wanted to keep the two- State solution alive and he is the one who provided the ladder for both Trump and nany to go down from the annexation tree and turn this whole thing into a historic breakthrough in the peace process while taking care of his two strategic goals of keeping the two-state solution alive and normalizing
with Israel this is an unbelievable behind the scenes story you know it it teaches us once more what kind of a Shakespearean actor is Netanyahu and also about the phenomena of cold fit he will he always gets cold cold fit before these kind of decisions historical decisions and it is highly interesting and because you answered my my next planned questions I will ask you the following ER talking about infrastructure that netan said for the this historical movement how do you think netan felt last week when he was fighting the state for letting his wife and
children go on using State cars and and bodyguards while naftali Bennett flew the first flight of an an Israeli Prime Minister to to Abu Dhabi and met mbz there by the way he calls him calls mbz the real architecture of the the of the new Middle East how do you think Nan felt in these minutes I'm I'm sure that net felt really bad and it's you know I can understand him it's pretty tragic um because when Netanyahu managed to get his biggest achievement in his 30 plus uh years in politics um this is when uh
he lost um he lost his power and so I really think that when he saw those pictures um he was really upset and by the way I think I and I also wrote it in the book that many of the things that Netanyahu did during the negotiations on the Abraham Accords for example um keeping Benny gun the minister of defense and foreign minister Gabi ashkanazi in the in total dark about those negotiations obviously that did not help uh uh to keep his government uh together and when his government uh uh collapsed that was the end
of his political career eventually and I will tell you something else the Abraham Accords in a way um created a big change in the isra in the Jewish Society in Israel meaning it softened a lot of the tensions the Jews in Israel felt about Arabs and I think that also contributed to the fact that today we have an Arab uh party in the Coalition so in a very strange uh way I think the Abraham Accords which were nany's biggest achievement also laid the ground for his um for his um fall from Power yes for his
rival to to to enex mansur Abbas into the Coalition yeah and then nany came out out from this adventure not as a prime minister but as a peacemaker he brought the AR the Israeli Arabs inside Coalition and and he brought he was one of the key players in the game that brought the Emirates and more states to peace with Israel and because you mentioned just mentioned Gabby ashkanazi in many guns from blue and white ER do you think what part did they play in blocking the annexation or did they not did not play a part
at all no I think they had a big part a very big part because even though the Coalition agreement between Netanyahu and them uh didn't give them a veto power over this decision about annexation Nan could just go for it they uh did many things especially in their talks with the white house that basically created an environment in which the White House felt that you know going for annexation without a broad consensus in the Israeli government would be a very problematic thing and they made it clear to the White House that they don't support a
unilateral annexation and they actually were the ones especially ashkanazi who gave this idea to the White House that you know if you want to go for with annexation we should do it as not as a unilateral step but as a step that also includes benefits for the Palestinians and the White House bought this idea and brought it to netan and netan wasn't ready to give anything to the Palestinians so this idea that gansen ashkanazi uh um uh promoted actually contributed a lot to stopping annexation uh for good so we see that the the the the
alltime master of politics in Israel Benjamin Nan was hacked by two rookies like Gans and ashkanazi and but I want to learn some more so many Revelations and Scoops in this book can you tell me how did the assassination of Iran's revolutionary guard Chief kasim sumani turn from being a a peak moment in US Israeli cooperation to one of its a most significant know because I didn't know it this is really an amazing story I think that it's really one of the stories in the book that that I you know when I heard it my
my ears started burning um and I'll tell you some of the behind the scenes in my second interview with Trump I asked him about the sulimani uh assassination because I wanted to know details about the cooperation between Israel and the us about it and then his answer shocked me because he said well I know exactly what happened there and I was very disappointed with Israel Israel did not do the right thing on suani and I said what what did you just say and he said it again that he was disappointed that this is wasn't was
what he expected but then at a certain point he stopped himself and did he get into the details and when I started asking people about it uh um I heard this amazing story that suani there was Intelligence that suani was planning attacks against us Targets in Iraq and in other places in the region and Israel and the US were discussing what to do and apparently what Trump understood from his people or again there's a dispute between the people who are involved whether this was really the case or it was just something that Trump got into
his mind and couldn't let go that but he understood that Netanyahu let's say refused to play a more active role in The Killing of sulimani and basically wanted the us to do it without Israel being involved at all and Trump got really mad because he basically felt like Netanyahu was using him um and he told his people that Netanyahu is ready to fight Iran until the last American Soldier um and again some of Trump's people say that his feeling was was justified some of them say it wasn't Justified but it doesn't matter because it it
stayed in his mind until today and Netanyahu at the beginning didn't know that that's the way Trump feels it took several months until he understood that and he wanted to talk about it with Trump you know in in four eyes but the the only possibility was to talk with him about it was when he came to sign the Abraham Accords in September 2020 like eight months later and nany asked the White House to have like 15 minutes of alone time with Trump and they told him listen uh we can there's no time he's in the
middle of campaign uh you can try and catch him like between things and and tell him about it and then there was this reception when nanyu and the other leaders arrived at the White House and nany sits next to Trump and he leans over over to Trump and he whispers in his ear uh listen this this suani thing was all a misunderstanding and Trump nods his head uh as if he uh acknowledges what Netanyahu just told him and Netanyahu was sure that that's you know that's it problem solved but apparently Trump wasn't very convinced and
until today he's certain that Netanyahu used him on the sumani killing and uh this this issue of trump netan relationship actually you you killed the theory that most of us believed in that we have here a love story two old bodies that are well connected and then and actually love each other and suddenly you go to interview the president here's totally different things and you meet a a lone bitter leader in his maral Lago mension can you tell us a little more about it well I think that netan and Trump for their own domestic political
reasons um were really happy at uh projecting you know to public opinion that there's no daylight between them they're best friends there's a bromance there because for Trump he needed the Evangelical base and he knew that the evangelicals love B and for BB he needed um to mobilize his own right-wing and Ultra orthodox space that loved Trump so it was very convenient to both of them but at the end of the day I I was really surprised to to find out that at least from Trump's side you know he didn't see Netanyahu as a friend
at all he saw him as a maybe you know a political Ally or you know some somebody who can help him in his own politics um but not a friend for sure and when I saw Trump as you said in the first meeting he was really bitter and he wanted to unpack a lot of the frustrations that he had about Netanyahu and it was only three months after he left the White House but even in the second interview in the phone call in July when Trump was already let's say more at peace with what happened
if if one can can can say that about him um okay so he didn't uh say uh him about Netanyahu again but basically his grievances about netan stayed the same even if he uh articulated them in a more let's say uh polite way why as you reveal in your book did Trump's son-in-law Jared Kushner throw Israeli Ambassador R durmer out of his White House office just before Israel's March 2020 elections is it something that you already mentioned or or a different story no no it's a different story it's pretty uh it's also something that I
found out for the first time when I was working on the book because as you remember Trump uh presented his peace plan in on January 28th at the White House and nanyu tried using him tried using it um to uh to go forward with uh annexation few days later and Trump blocked it and it was big embarrassment for Netanyahu because he ran his whole campaign on on him annexing parts of the West Bank before the elections so after this whole thing blows up at the end of January Trump's advisors and netanyahu's advisors they don't speak
for several weeks there's just a really it's a real low point and towards the end of February few days before the elections in Israel durmer comes to see um Kushner and his off office at the White House and this meeting becomes very very tense and durmer basically uh tells Kushner that uh they em they embarrass nanyo at the critical moment of his campaign and that Netanyahu doesn't know if he can trust the president anymore and when Kushner hears that he really explodes and he tells uh durmer he tells him Ron what you just said is
disgusting get out of here and he just throws him out of the office really unbelievable and and by the way yeah and this thing happened sort of happened again when they negotiated the Abraham Accords several months later because quite the beginning of the negotiations all of a sudden durmer calls the White House and tells AI burkowitz the White House Envoy tells him uh listen netan uh wanted uh to let you know that um he's ready to give up on annexation only if you get him three Arab countries to normalize and not only the UAE and
uh you know burkovich delivers this message to to Kushner and Kushner really explodes and he tells berovic okay call Ron and tells him that one country is all he can get and if he doesn't want it he can go himself and Burt calls uh durmer and gives them a more let's say toned down version of this message and he tells them Ron listen I can't tell you what to do but I really urge you to take this deal um so it really show it showed me that really we we you know above the ground and
on the table we saw this really great relationship between the parties but under the table and and you know under the water there was this really huge uh Glacier uh that an iceberg that we didn't see and and it was full of really bad blood of House of card style and the Turkish Bazaar and whatever can you tell us what was the real story behind the famous F35 fighter jets deal to the Emirates I think lied to the public when he said it was not a quit for quo but now we know that the old
deal is in danger but now we know that it was preconditioned by the Emirates it's this is a very complicated story and I think the answer is yes and no meaning as far as I understand from talking to all the parties who were involved it wasn't like a precondition meaning the Emirates didn't say if you don't give us the f35s we're not going to uh sign the normalization deal okay but the emiratis did say uh to the Americans and by the way to the Israelis for a long long time before the Abram Accords every time
that Israel raised uh the normalization possibilities with the imatis the imatis would say oh great so if we have normalization we're not enemies anymore so you you're not going to have any problem with letting the Americans sell us the F35 so theatis used this uh argument with the Americans telling them great we're ready not for normalization we want a peace agreement with Israel and if we're at peace with Israel then there's really no need to stop us from getting the f-35s so it was more complicated but netan definitely did not tell the truth about his
knowledge of the fact that the F35 is an issue that is somehow hovering over this uh over this deal or on the sideline of this deal he definitely knew it and he kept it SEC you know he kept it as a secret from the Israeli defense establishment from the Minister of Defense from the intelligence Community which is something which is completely crazy uh and we were really lucky that at a certain point uh it was discovered so that the Israeli Ministry of Defense managed to take certain steps with the US to make sure that Israel's
qualitative military Edge is maintained but Netanyahu definitely and this I'm saying from talking to like at least 10 people who were involved in this definitely did not tell the truth to his Minister of Defense about it to the defense establishment and to the Israeli public about his knowledge about the uh the talks between the US and the UAE on the F35 deal finally if you mentioned and I want I want this interview to to go on forever but we're out of time but if you mentioned the ministry of Defense in your interview with with Trump
he was uh complimentary about Benny Gans is the is there an explanation to this warmth that he that he showed towards guns and if for example let's imagine that n comes back to Power in Israel and and Trump would be elected in the next election I think they will start all over again nothing happened and and the the interests are still the political interests are still there and and let's go on don't you yeah so let's start with Benny Gans uh first I think Trump has uh you know a warm place for generals he likes
generals uh and I think that uh this helped Gans a lot in his relationship with Trump and second I think that Trump when he met Benny Gans in January 2020 before the third elections in Israel he really fa that Gans would be able to do something with his peace plan and to maybe get peace with the Palestinians much more than Netanyahu first because he didn't believe Netanyahu anymore and he did believe uh Benny Gans um and he thought that the Palestinians really hate Netanyahu and that they don't don't hate Benny Gans so I think that
those two reasons got him to this point that he I think was was hoping that Gans would win the uh March 2020 uh elections and about you know what's going to happen if Trump comes back to Power and Netanyahu comes back to Power which is as you know it's it's a it's a scenario that that could happen it's not unlikely and as you said I think that at the end of the day if this happens they will find a way to work together I don't think it will be this uh you know big crisis I'm
sure that if both of them will be uh um in a place that they're um close to getting back to Power they'll find a way to mend relations nany will Kiss the Ring Trump will be happy and everything will go back to normal the only thing that will be problematic is that I think Trump would still uh feel that Netanyahu is not serious about peace with the Palestinians and if Trump wants to try and uh start again moving forward on this issue netan will be in a problem and by the way mentioning this you see
the attitude within Israeli right and especially BB's electoral base in Israel you start you seeing the turnover since this interview that you brought when when H Trump mentioned the f word towards n you suddenly see I I saw in one of the religious papers in last weekend that the the deal of the century of Donald Trump that they all praised in real time suddenly it's a disaster and and everything is Chang but not don't worry they will forget everything if and when these two gentlemen will come to power I think uh me and the and
the listeners enjoy this interview very much but the author of the new bestseller in Israel Trump's Pie about the Abraham Accords thank you very much for joining us here in thank you take care and a lot of success to thank you toada [Music] bye hello I'm J Capel Professor ATO and noral in Paris and author of a number of books and articles on the Middle East through my new podcast reading the Middle East on the awardwinning media service and monitor we will take a deep dive into the trends in the region with the authors and
thought leaders who are shaping how we think about the Middle East reading the Middle East will be a fantastic addition to Alm monitor's outstanding podcast lineup including on the Middle East with Andrew paraziti and amberin Zan and on Israel with Ben caspit you can subscribe on your favorite listening platform we look forward to your joining our [Music] conversation thank you for staying with us it's a problem how to decide where to begin with all the major headlines and unbelievable stories that Barack Ravid just told us I cannot Escape mentioning the fact the unbelievable fact that
24 hours before the famous three-way telephone conversation between President Trump mbz from Abu Dhabi and Benjamin Anan in Israel Ambassador dermer called the White House and said listen maybe it's not the right time with have a political problems Etc they had to uh throw him all the way outside in order to to to make it clear and Loud that this is going to happen as Ambassador fredman or Jed Kushner said this is going to happen with you or without you Mr Netanyahu Ravid credits the whole three Partners in the the historic Abraham Accords of course
president Trump's way of doing business in the Middle East it had many advantages and also low points but the Abraham Accords mostly are signed under the name of the president but we cannot uh we cannot escape from the the conclusion that Benjamin nany was a partner and of course mbz that prime minister Bennett calls him right now the the architect of the new Middle East talking about Netanyahu Ravid said that the political or diplomatic infrastructure that he laid in the Middle East talking about capitals like like Abu Dhabi like Bahrain Morocco and many other places
was important and pivotal in in these Accords but Benjamin Nan did not really wanted this outcome he preferred annexation he planned annexation he promised an ation through three election campaigns in Israel and when he wanted to do it who actually stopped the the maneuver was the White House with a lot of support from the two generals Two Chief of Staff Benny gun and Gabby Ashkenazi from blue and white another important revelation of this book is that netan considered in one point to go for the annexation Act without the support of the White House and then
uh Gerard Kushner actually threatened the Prime Minister and his staff and said you don't have a a green light from Trump and you don't want that your best friend will become eventually your worst enemy Trump PE Trump Peace by Barack rid uh went I think it was published in Israel only in Hebrew in this stage and I hope very much for the English language readers that it will be translated as fast as possible because it's really fascinating I hope you enjoyed the this conversation and I hope to find you here next week next time next
place on Israel in Al monitor I'm benas speit from Tel Aviv take care