welcome to hydrogen Rising a bi-weekly podcast created and hosted by the global Law Firm KL Gates that brings you analysis of critical Cutting Edge issues impacting the global hydren market we look forward to your engagement and feedback and of course don't hesitate to reach out if you have ideas about new topics you'd like us to cover hi and welcome everyone my name is Sandy saffro and I'm going to be your host for today's episode of hydrogen Rising where we'll be taking a closer look at hydrogen exports as many of our listeners may already be aware
there are several potential methods for exporting hydrogen including using compressed hydrogen exporting via ammonia using liquid organic hydrogen carriers and exporting hydrogen in liquid form as lh2 today we're going to focus in particular on takeaways and possible Lessons Learned for lh2 from l& for context for those who are not familiar LNG is liquefied natural gas it's the same natural gas that flows into our homes for use in our cooktops and our fireplaces but it's just super cooled it's cooled to -260 De F or 160° and at that temperature natural gas becomes a liquid the important
thing about that is in its liquid state natural gas takes up 1600th of the amount of space that it takes up in its gaseous state which is a huge economy of scale and hence the preference for using liquefaction and exports similarly in order to turn hydrogen into a liquid it also has to be super cooled and for hydrogen it is a much lower temperature it's 423 degrees fit or negative 253° C this much cooler temperature relative to LG requires more energy to produce which we we'll talk about more in today's episode in its liquid state
hydrogen like LNG takes up a significantly less amount of space or lower amount of space than it does in its gaseous state for hydrogen it's actually 1 1800th of the amount of space that it occupies in its gash State liquefaction and super cool liquid products though are are not without their challenges and LNG has run the gauntlet on some of those obstacles already and we're going to talk about some of those today and how they may map over into the lh2 space so to help me dig deeper into hydrogen exports and the LG lh2 connection
I'm joined today by two of my colleagues from our Australia offices we have Josh spry from our Perth office whose voice may sound familiar to many of you is he's kindly lent it to us for our intro and outro for the podcast and we also have Clive CIA from our Sydney office it is particularly appropriate having you both on for this topic not only because you co-authored a recent Bloomberg article on point which our listeners can find a link to on the KL Gates website but also because of Australia's significant role as an energy exporter
and more specifically Australia has been a global leader in LG exports in particular particularly so in the Asia Pacific region the lmg industry is one that's been around for decades but it certainly did not evolve into a global economy overnight so as we'll talk more about today and as I mentioned there are a number of areas of potential similarity for hydrogen exports but also several areas of potential Divergence so shifting gears a little bit in episode three we talked a bit about the potential for the development of an asia-pacific hydrogen economy touched on Australia's possible
role to start us off Clive I'd be curious if you can talk about what role you see Australia looking to play in the hydrogen space and examples of concrete steps that you see Australia taking towards realizing that Vision thanks Sandy and hello to all all the list is so you're you're absolutely right Australia using this sweet spot um as it has abundant Beed stock for all forms of hydrogen production be it Renewables for electricity to produce green hydrogen or fossil fuels um to produce that electricity or for use in the production of blue or gray
hydrogen it also has strong existing trade links in all forms of Commodities and it has a proven track record in industrializing commodity production particularly in recent times with respect to to LG uh and it's safe to say that Australia will look to leverage these existing comparative advantages to become a leading hydrogen-based energy exporter so it stated strategy to do this um will be to remove and overcome export Market barriers to efficiently build supply and demand for hydrogen use in various uses such as transport heat and heat and Grid electricity um and to to also augment
its current material use um as an industrial feed stock Fe in oil refiner or ammonia production um additionally it'll also the strategy will also seek to accelerate our Global cost competitiveness in order to scale up quickly our hydrogen production distribution as markets develop a key tactic within this strategy will be to create custers of large scale demand uh these are known as hydrogen hubs at port cities or Regional areas throughout Australia and they'll be collocated with existing critical infrastructure and co-utilized with other existing Commodities Supply chains now the idea is that these hubs will make
infrastructure upgrades more cost-efficient and Foster Innovation and synergies in energy production and Delivery for both domestic use and for exports so so far over 30 locations for such hubs have been identified and a number of pilot projects are being developed over the next few years to demonstrate the viability of these projects to encourage private sector investment um the opportunities here have been recognized by all levels of Australian governments be at the Commonwealth level or state territory level um and each of them have their own roadmaps and incentive plans um and as mentioned earlier um that
was the subject of of an earlier podcast so you can find that on our on our website um as an example of the dynamic nature of this government support um even since that episode has dropped uh the national energy resources Australia or near a few days ago announced that it'll be investing $1.85 million in 13 Regional hydrogen clusters across Australia to develop Australia as a globally recognized brand for hydrogen and also to Foster the technology the skills and the collaboration required for hydrogen development great thanks I guess kind of building off of that in terms
of markets where do you see Australia looking to take a leading role and do you think we're looking at an overlap with the way that Australia currently plays in the LG markets yeah absolutely um as with Australia's enviable Market position in LNG there will be a focus on supplying East Asian markets in particular austal's population is such that domestic demand just cannot simply solely support the long-term and costly produ and infrastructure project development so export revenues will be needed to underwrite that expenditure it's important here to distinguish between the shortterm and the longer term Trends
in the long term the clear goal is to penetrate the lucrative East Asian energy markets however in the short term establishing a viable domestic market for example by blending hydrogen into existing gas networks or demonstrating its ability as a transport fuel will lay the foundation for improve production economics Coster the all important private Capital networks and develop the holistic Supply chains from production to end use and government support will be critical in this stage and as I mentioned various governments have already set the Frameworks for that support so that's the model that was used in
the infancy of Australia's journey to becoming a leading Global energy exporter and it provides an effective road map for Australia's positioning in the buring hydrogen sector that's uh that's really interesting and it's it's really exciting I think to see developments not just off on the horizon for hydrogen but also concrete steps that are being taken in kind of much closer time to to where we are right now so just to shift gears a bit from those goals to how we're going to start seeing hydrogen exports develop and thinking about some of the possible ties to
the LG space when you see an oceangoing LG vessel it's really hard not to be impressed by the size of the carrier we're talking about standard vessel sizes with cargo capacities in the 125,000 to 175,000 cubic meter range and typical lengths around 300 M or 975 ft going all the way up to vessel cargo capacity of 266,000 cubic meters and lengths of 345 M for the qax vessels which is Cutter's biggest l& carrier Josh I know you do a lot of work in the LG space and we've been having some conversations around lh2 vessel sizes
how do the lh2 vessel sizes compare to what we see in the l& space thanks Andy lh2 vessels are currently a lot smaller than the LG vessels that we're used to seeing you know it's unlikely that we're going to see them at the same size at least for a little while yet Kawasaki heavy Industries are building the world's first lh2 vessel it's called the swo frontier and it's going to be closer to 100 MERS long and less than 1% of the cargo capacity we're talking you know around 1,000 cubic meters rather than the hundreds of
thousands of cubic meters for for LNG vessels this is very much a pilot vessel though it's it's part of a project that was discussed on an earlier podcast episode um called the hydrogen energy supply chain that's a project between Australia Japan and a range of Australian and Japanese companies that will produce hydrogen in Victoria liquefy it ship it to Japan and then use it in Japan the idea of this part of the project is to test and drisk some of the technological changes that are required when you go from LNG to lh2 Kawasaki has a
long history of building LG carriers um so they're leveraging all of that experience in in doing this work but while there's a lot of crossovers between the two products there's also some areas where changes are going to be required the technology related for example the insulation needs to be significantly improved for lh2 it needs to stay at- 250 as we said as it to stays a liquid as opposed to you know- 160° C for LG that needs to be designed and tested some of the other changes are safety related there was significant work done uh
in the LG space you know in the early years to test flammability of liquid pools and gas leaks to make sure that they were safe and there's calls for similar work to be done to show that lh2 can be managed just as safe even it has a much wider flammability range that's really interesting um I just want to pick up on the point that you made about insulation for lh2 boil off is a significant issue for l& and I'm curious how that issue Compares and scope for lh2 and what what you think it might mean
for project economics in the hydrogen space so boof's managed a few ways in the LNG industry first off you try and avoid it it's a cheap by insulating the tanks Trying to minimize heat transfer to the extent that it can't be avoided modern LG tankers will try and either make use of the boiled off gases of fuel maybe to power the ship's engines or onboard systems or they might even install small liquefaction plants on the vessels themselves to turn it back into LG that can be delivered we'd expect similar principles to apply to lh2 but
the 100° Celsius drop in Boiling Point does create some challenges as an example boil off for modern LG equipment it's in the order of 2% per day that a very simplistic level you looking at a 10-day Voyage the LNG carrier will turn up with about 98% of its product still in liquid form but use exactly the equipment Banks insulation etc for an lh2 carrier and Analysis suggests that the boil off would be in the order of 5% per day so suddenly that same 10day Voyage means that you've only got 60% liquid left when you turn
up the discharge terminal and that's clearly not manageable whether at a technical level you or at a project economics level yeah wow I mean that's certainly sounds like a a pretty significant obstacle and those those are figures that definitely leave an impression what are you seeing and hearing in terms of ways that the hydrogen industry might look to solve for the boil off issue so we're aware of a number of proposed solutions for dealing with the increased boil off challenges for lh2 the Kawasaki project is looking at ways to increase insulation efficiency and they're doing
this by adding a layer of vacuum insulation around the lh2 tank effectively a tank within a tank with a vacuum layer in between to try and prevent heat transfer this technology has only been used you know in very small scales so far th000 cubic meter range and it's never been used on a ship so there's a number of engineering challenges that need to be overcome and proved up that said you know if the pilot project successful we may see Kawasaki begin to scale up the technology so that larger volumes can be transported by ship another
solution that's being explored is is pressurized lh2 storage you know we're special reinforced tanks used that can tolerate sign ific L higher tank pressures you would say five or 10 bar instead of one bar basically instead of the heat being released for want of a better word it's boil off gas it's stored in the in the liquid and the tank becomes increasingly pressurized we don't know too much about the timelines for this one though it' be an interesting solution for keeping the product in liquid form until delivery that's really interesting I can't wait to see
what the developments are in that space um I have one other question for you Josh and I I almost hesitate to ask it because I think we could probably spend several podcast episodes talking about it but I'm curious what are just a few of of the examples of commercial terms that you see emerging for lh2 that are either reminiscent of LG or strongly Divergent from LNG and and why okay you're right there's a lot that we could cover here but but let's pick a few examples maybe if we start with Contracting in supply chain I
think like LNG projects especially the early LNG projects we expect that lh2 projects are going to need to be underpinned by long-term offtake contracts with minimum take or pay volumes these will help get investors and lenders comfortable that the project revenues can pay back the substantial capex costs of developing and building you know the lh2 supply chain similarly we'd expect that projects will want to have a pretty clear picture of the whole export supply chain before they'll make their final investment decisions again the focus here is on making sure that money will flow back through
the system longterm to pay off those upfront capex costs okay so what about pricing pricing is challenging at the moment there's a there's a pretty sizable gap between buyers and sellers buyers don't want to pay more than the cost of their competing fuels in their local market this might be coal diesel LNG depending on what the target industry is but those prices are very challenging to to achieve at the moment for sellers you know they're more likely to be wanting to sell on a Cost Plus basis to make sure that they're always kept whole there's
external factors that might help to bridge this Gap you know things like increased carbon taxes in the destination Market they'll bring up the cost of competing fuels and make that Gap a bit smaller um we might see government grants you know to reduce capex costs for the production facilities or the transport or maybe incentives from government to absorb some of the hydrogen price at the moment these haven't been developed yet so it's a bit of a wait and see I think for the time being to see what develops exactly for the first export projects we
may well see mechanisms like alternative index pricing linking to oil or other Commodities you know maybe price review mechanisms which are common place in the l& industry you know and see them being adapted for hydrogen contracts as as well another feature of LG contracts is how they deal with cover you know this is where a party fails to deliver or fails to receive the LG that they're supposed to take modern LG contracts will frequently manage this scenario by requiring the other party to Source alternative Supply from the market in the case of a supply failure
or requiring the party to try and sell the cargo in the market in the case of a receipt failure take or pay Arrangements will continue to apply in the background but the idea is to try and keep volumes moving and minimize take pay damages now the structure probably is going to work straight out of the box for lh2 though and there's a few reasons for this firstly there'll be a reduced pool of alternative buyers and sellers that's just not going to be that open market similarly there'll be reduced numbers of unloading facilities you know alternative
liquefaction facilities to buy and and receive the lh2 from add to that that different projects might use a different transport solution we've already talked about pressurized versus unpressurized liquid H2 compressed hydrogen ammonia you and things get even more complicated so producers and buyers need to give some careful thought both at a Contracting level and at a commercial level to make sure that their cover structure works and that it's practical you know in the early stage lh2 Market maybe a final example of analoges to the LNG industry is scheduling so we talked a bit about vessel
sizes earlier for for lh2 on top of those you know smaller sizes so far lht only contains about 40% of the energy content the same volume of LG contains so even assuming that we can match vessel sizes in the future this difference in energy density means that we still need about 2 and a half times as many ships carrying the same energy content from production country to destination markets so you scheduling matters that are already pretty complicated for LNG things like birth constraints Inventory management delivery programs 90-day schedules that's going to take on an even
greater level of importance with lh2 that's great that's certainly a lot of things to think about and I know that's only scratching the surface of the list that you you probably could have ticked through I guess we'll kind of leave it there because I think we're probably at our normal time for our podcast and I want to thank you both for joining me today to help scratch the surface on hydrogen exports thank you also to our listeners for joining us if you have questions about any of the topics that we talked about in today's episode
please don't hesitate to reach out and of course stay tuned for our next episode of hydrogen Rising which will be coming your way in just two weeks thank you for listening to this episode of hydrogen Rising be sure to subscribe to receive timely notifications of future episodes and check out our Market leading publication the hydrogen handbook on our website at www.k gates.com