[Music] [Music] okay thanks thanks all right so the state of mental Healthcare delivery in this country is right now I would say inadequate and also at times inappropriate so right now we've got about 46 million Americans who are diagnosed with a mental health disorder um so that's one in 17 adults one in 10 children um but only 38% of them are getting treatment right now and that's a problem so you might ask why is that well some researchers have asked that question and they found that there are sort of two broad categories that explain why
people aren't getting the help that they need and those two categories are access and stigma so when you see up there as over 50% of respondents um said that you know the main reason why they can't get help is because they can't afford help that's an access issue when people say they don't know where to go to get help that's an access issue when people say on the other hand that they're worried about their neighbor judging them or they're worried about getting fired from their job or being committed to a hospital those are what we
call sort of stigma reasons um for not getting help so you then might ask well okay well what are the states doing to address this unmet need well unfortunately we're doing the exact opposite of what I think we should be doing which is to say we're making dramatic budget cuts so in the current political climate of fiscal austerity we've cut $ 1.8 billion from 2009 to 2011 for treating mental health problems so on a state-by-state level that looks like $587 million at California cut $132 million that New York State cut um and I want to
emphatically state that when you make these kinds of cuts you're not actually saving any money right because you're just transferring the burden of care to a different venue so what's that different venue well if you can't get treatment at a hospital or treatment at a Community Mental Health Center um a lot of folks wind up in prison people wind up in homeless shelters or they wind up going to emergency rooms and those venues are actually more expensive than if you were to just pay for helping people um in hospitals or Community Healthcare settings so it's
actually these cuts are not saving us any money I would argue um so you might say if you're a sort of staunch capitalist well maybe the market is determining um you know the level of supply and demand um and maybe these Cuts make sense because there's not as much demand as there used to be but that also is not the case we're seeing more than half of the states reporting increased demand for services so you've got increased demand and our response has been to cut services so I think we can do better and you might
ask well what's one way that we could do better better and I would argue that we could Institute what's called a steep care model of Mental Health Care delivery all right what's that steep care model is just saying that we provide um graduated levels of care uh according to need so graduated levels of increasing care according to need so what does that mean practically so let's say you're feeling really depressed really anxious um you go to your doctor that's where most people go when they're feeling depressed and anxious maybe a psychiatrist and the doctor says
you know the first treatment we want to give you we want it to be the least stigmatizing the least restrictive which is just another way of saying the most accessible and also the most costeffective treatment first right that's not really what we're doing right now but in order to address unmet need in order to address problems of not having enough funding a step care model can um redress those issues so you go to your doctor feeling depressed the weather is not changing it's still really really cold out this is getting insane what can I do
and doctor says well the first thing I want you to do right so there the most accessible least stigmatizing most cost effective is hey why don't you go for a run why don't you try exercise there's actually a lot of great data that shows exercise is a great treatment for depression and anxiety um why don't you try changing your diet a lot of research that shows changing Diet also really effective maybe you could try dropping in on these classes anger management classes things like that and the idea is you're reserving the most expensive most um
intensive care for people that need it the most so you could think of it as sort of like a mental health care triage right so um the way in which a step care model is really self-correcting is that you don't just say go for a run and if you don't get better too bad right you say let's measure how you're doing and if you Institute some regular aerobic exercise and you're still not getting better then let's try something else let's try something more intensive maybe a little more expensive maybe a little less accessible maybe a
little more stigmatizing but the idea is the first approach first line of defense didn't work so let's try something else that's all a step care model is right it's pretty simple really straightforward um so you might ask yourself well is that what we're doing right now and and when it comes to physical health sometimes we do that when it comes to mental health that's not really what we do we usually provide um doctors and psychiatrists the first line of defense that they usually provide is what we call pharmacotherapy and that's drugs right um the evidence
of that is pretty substantial so 10% of Americans currently take anti-depressants um 11% of children are diagnosed with ADHD and taking pretty powerful stimulant medication as a result and um really powerful antipsychotics such as cakil which used to be used to treat people who are having psychotic breaks from reality are now um prescribed for children to help them sleep and for people to address their sort of average Garden variety mild and moderate depression and anxiety and also you know just recently the day doesn't go by that there's not new evidence that um prescription of medications
is really Rising exponentially so um in the last two years the VA and um military has increased prescriptions of psychoactive drugs by 700% so why is this going on why are we having all these prescriptions being written at ever increasing rates as our first line of defense well one is the sort of Rise of the chemical imbalance Theory which just argues that you know the reason why people are depressed and anxious and this is a a mindset that's taken over um Psychiatry and c and certainly medicine too is that there's a sort of chemical imbalance
you don't have enough neurotransmitters enough serotonin in the brain to function appropriately and so if you take these medications you will address these sort of chemical imbalance and when you look at the neuroimaging of people who are depressed or really anxious there's no question that there are substantial chemical and neuroanatomical differences between people who are depressed and anxious and folks who who aren't right but there I would argue there's been a misattribution of the cause for those neurochemical and um anatomical differences so whereas now we say the reason you're depressed and the reason you're anxious
is because there's something wrong with you there's something broken in your brain that you were born with right that's what we say now we used to say um and that's the sort of attribution or cause that we list is why people are depressed now we used to say things like well you know actually external circumstances are the things that caused you to feel depressed and anxious right like we used to say the reason you get you're really depressed might be because you got fired from your job or you can't find work or you can't find
work that provides a living wage or you're in a terrible abusive relationship or you were raped or you live in a place that's environmentally degraded and and difficult to live in so now we've turned the almost the blame or the reason or the explanation for why people are um not feeling great um and we've said well maybe it's you and not the society you live in so we've kind of ignored these external circumstances also drugs and medication are really inexpensive so um insurance companies love to provide medications as opposed to uh face to-face talk therapy
because it's cheaper and also you know we live in a capitalist Society so of course for-profit um organizations want to maximize profits and so they aggressively Market these medications even when they might not be um when their use might not be warranted so um what is the cost incurred by pharmacotherapy being the first line of defense well they're pretty substantial I would argue so a lot of new data coming out about the long-term effects of prolonged anti-depressant and anxiolytic use and they include sort of prefrontal Cortex atrophy overall shrinkage of the brain um also when
you go off the medications often the symptoms that you have um worsen so they're worse than they were before you began the medications as your brain readjusts to its original natural sort of um chemical makeup um also unfortunately doctors and psychiatrists wind up prescribing drugs and medications to treat other drugs and medications that you're on so you might come in um getting a medication for depression and then but that depression makes it really difficult for you to sleep causes insomnia so then you need a medication to help you sleep but then that causes sexual dysfunction
right so then you need a medication to treat that and before long you've entered this like long Cascade of um drugs to treat drugs and when you came in with just a single problem now you've got six or seven problems um six of which came from the first medication that you began taking so we're all from so maybe were not familiar with these sort of long-term side effects I think we probably have heard lots of ads um on the radio and TV like the following that discuss the shortterm side effects so this one's amazing so
just listen to this may cause serious orer reaction that may requ hospitalization and be lifethreatening if you develop rash hives mouth sister swelling peeling Skinner eyes trouble swall or breathing dark urine or fever stop vigil and get emergency help vigil is not for children Vig doesn't replace SLE and has risk of abuse or dependence news is directed common side effects are headache nausea dizziness and trouble sleeping stop new VI and call your doctor for depression anuc exity ofal that's awesome right so this is a Okay so we've all heard that before on TV you know
um and these side effects are really you know for a lot of people painful and not well tolerated now you might say well you know what maybe that's true you have these sort of long-term short-term side effects and they make it really difficult to take these medications but if the medications work really well then it's worth it right so what's interesting is that the medications don't work very well and this is something that's not really known um by the public very much because of all the sort of aggressive marketing that goes on but there's also
an interesting story behind this too which is to say that so when these drugs are sort of marketed or when they're sort of first um submitted to the FDA for approval um pharmaceutical companies have to conduct these Rand control trials they have to submit the studies to the FDA for review the review looks at the studies and if they see evidence that the drugs are well tolerated and effective then they approve it so a couple researchers looked at this evidence and it was pretty convincing that these medications were really working well um but then they
were sort of suspicious and they asked the uh pharmaceutical companies did you um submit to the FDA all the studies that you conducted and they said no um and so the researcher said well we want to see all the studies not just the ones that suspect you submitted because they showed a positive effect and the pharmaceutical company said no we're not going to give those to you and so the researchers led by Irving Kur and some others filed the Freedom of Information Act and forced the pharmaceutical companies to submit all the studies that um were
conducted and when you look at all the studies and what we call a metaanalysis which is not just looking at one study it's looking at all of them together they actually found that um medications for the most commonly prescrib commonly diagnosed disorders were no more effective than taking a sugar pill so these medications for commonly diagnosed Garden variety depression anxiety no more effective than taking nothing now this is not to say that medications don't have an really important vital role to play in mental healthare of course they do um there's no question that if you
have a severe uh disorder like schizophrenia or bipolar or panic disorder or even really severe depression medications save lives they change lives for the better unquestion unquestioningly that's true um but the issue I think is whether um medication should really be the first line of defense should it be the first thing that we give people and I argue that we shouldn't so all right well that's what you say what should we provide as a first level well I'm already mentioned like diet and exercise another thing that you can provide which is something that I've been
working on with my adviser Pat Frasier and counseling psychology department is developing online interventions and so one that we came up with I won't go into a lot of the details about the actual intervention but just really quickly we found that when people feel like they have some control over their life when they feel like they have some agency over the things that are stressing them out they don't get as depressed they don't get as anxious as folks who don't feel any sense of control so we thought well how can we increase the sense of
control among um college students who are feeling stressed out and really anxious and it turns out that it's really easy to do it so we came up with an online intervention where people just identify the things that are stressing them out they write down on an online form what's stressing them out then they decide okay you've identified these stressors which which ones are controllable which ones aren't for the ones that are controllable write down some specific actions you can take to help yourself right um and that's it that's all it is identify the stressor determine
if it's controllable write down what you can do about it okay so that's all our online intervention did and what are the advantages of internet-based interventions well one they address that unmet need that we were talking about um so in terms of access it's free right you don't have to travel anywhere to get it so in terms of stigma you can do it in the privacy of your own home no one knows about it you're not going to be committed to a hospital you're not going to have to worry about getting fired from your job
I work at the VA a lot of veterans are worried they'll an active duty Personnel are worried that they'll get fired from active duty if they get help for being depressed or anxious um and lastly a huge meta analysis similar to the one conducted um on pharmace on um pharmacotherapy was conducted and they found there was a pretty substantial effect that online interventions work um so what about the one that I came up with and with my adviser in our lab what about that intervention well that also works really well so if you look at
the Blue uh bar there that's the control intervention that's just giving people info so not much of an effect but when you look at the yellow and um gray bars those are just variations on the intervention we came up with you can see the effect size right after treatment ended was about. 35 um. 36 and then a few weeks later the effect size went up so you should know just in terms of basic statistics this is considered a moderate effect size not as high as maybe you would get from face tof face therapy but it
doesn't need to be right because it's a level one intervention but still very very effective um and super cheap and super easy to do students would spend 5 10 minutes a day and that's all it took to get this effect needless to say when you use an internet intervention of this sort you don't have any side effects right you also don't ignore the external circumstances that are making people depressed so we don't have to ignore the social and political um inequalities that are making our society I would argue unhealthy and Ill um so a lot
of advantages to internet interventions in a step care model the first line of defense really simple way to help people in need so again I just want to emphasize this isn't to say you know pharmacotherapy doesn't have a role to play it absolutely does it saves lives but we just think and I think that in a step care model which would increase um the number of people that that need help so it would address access issues it would address stigma issues and it would save us a lot of money right that's the advantage of a
step care model it would additionally relegate phaco therapy to um sort of a later level of treatment so first thing you would try exercise diet classes internet interventions then you can try face-to-face therapy if that doesn't work then maybe pharmacotherapy is appropriate so I think it's step care model it's really um could be the way of the future if we're sort of brave enough to implement it um it's a really Common Sense idea and it's you can think of it in terms of like Mental Health Care triage that's all it is really so okay hope
hopefully that was interesting for you thank you very much [Music] [Applause]