[Music] uh hi everybody good morning now that uh john's put the pressure on uh that this isn't supposed to be built um bear with me because i haven't done one of these in three years as a matter of fact the last one i did was uh for john in uh april and chicago in 2012 so uh it might take me a while to get going So hopefully it won't be dull but anyway um i think the way i want to start out is uh by answering a question that a lot of you guys not a
lot the few people i've talked to yesterday and um and a few people i talked to last night were asking me that uh i'm writing a third book and i guess i should ask you for have a lot of you read trading in the zone of this One trader and so you're probably wondering well why am i writing a third book right would that something become your mind yeah okay like why am i doing that well okay here's the reason why i'm doing it um [Music] about uh eight years ago i was asked to um
speak at a at a trading conference that was going to be quite large maybe about five Or six thousand people were expected to attend the conference it was going to be in texas and uh you know a few people have been in this business for a while you'll know that there's a lot of a lot of people that um uh just just aren't that ethical i mean there's there's a lot of ways that people can be taken advantage of in this business and there's a lot of a lot of People that understand that a lot
of people that exploit trade people who want to become traders and so as a result they didn't want to be associated with somebody or an organization that fell into that category and i asked them to and i knew they had user groups all over the country and so i asked them if i could uh attend uh some of their user group meetings to see just how well they lived up to their uh claims of customer Service and and the kind of products that they offered and so they had a pretty substantial user group in the
phoenix area and um and i attended there were probably a little over a hundred people made 10 20 people and i was just kind of taken back one i mean by everyone was really enthused with this company they really loved the product they love the customer service that they're providing and uh but the other thing i was taking back by Was just how absolutely totally clueless they were and um because i was i was used to working i started coaching in uh really around 1982 or 1983 and and most of the people that i worked
with were uh like floor traders you know the chicago board trade chicago broker deal exchange and then later on a lot of hedge fund managers and uh you know people who fill in the category of what i call Professional traders i mean people who are die hard traders and so so actually my coaching client kind of fell into two broad two categories with nobody in between in that i had the professionals people who'd been in the business for a long time and they understood just based on their experience the importance of their state of mind
and their psychology played on their results so there wasn't a convincing them you know that this was the direction they needed to go and then At the other end of the extreme was the person who had been in the business for probably quite a while lost usually a lot of money you lost their account several times and they're at the point of what i call total and complete exasperation where you might want to you might want to think of someone uh being on an alcoholic bender and they wake up with their head in the gutter
literally literally their head in the Gutter and they look up and they say okay god i'm ready i'll do anything and they mean it it's not lift service it's not they really mean it i'll do anything and so i didn't have anybody in between because they didn't realize what they were getting into okay so basically this group of people in the user group they were all these inbetweeners and not only they were just in between there none of them were professionals they were like you know just really what I call nice people but not that
not the professional traders can't be nice people but they're breed apart they really are they're uh uh i'm not gonna get into that but any case uh they're different but um so i'm thinking you know what i i have to write a book for these people i just you know because the disciplined trader and trading in the zone did not really address the issues in a way that someone just Starting out in the business could relate to i made a lot of assumptions writing those books made a lot of assumptions based on my experiences of
doing these kind of presentations and speaking at trading conferences back in the you know in the early 80s like the first conference i spoke at was in 1984 and and i spoke you know several years later he went you know you went on a world tour for dow jones in 1987 i literally went around the world for dow Jones and wright reuters out of a 36 36 city tour i could have done all 36 cities they didn't want to be gone that long but i did 18 out of 36 cities and went all the way
around the world so you know it's like i have you know i have this this basic experience of you know you know the way people think about trading but yet like i said i didn't write these books in a way that that the novice trader could relate to and it Shocked me literally shocked me because the discipline trader was published in 1990 and trading in the zone was published in 2000 and when the internet started getting big and you know you got a lot we had a lot of people doing chat rooms all that sort
of stuff and and people were recommending you know that hey retraining in the zone and a lot of the people that were that were reading it were just novice traders because i'm getting this feedback and emails it's Like well this book wasn't meant for you and i didn't even really know how you were relating to it so i thought you know what i i gotta write another book i gotta write it from the perspective and i gotta write it from the perspective uh of someone who really doesn't know anything about this business the people in
that room in phoenix where people who basically have watched like a half an hour infomercial on how trading how you can take financial control of your life By being a trader okay you know secure your retirement go into trading okay with this particular methodology you know and you should be able to do it well the reality of it is a lot of these methodologies people aren't lying to you about the fact that if you can actually follow the methodology you can you can secure your financial future the whole idea is being able to do it
Just like for example the very first workshop that i ever attended was in bermuda like i think in 1981 and um at the time it was being put on by three of you at that time you know people were considered market gurus and uh you know and at the very first morning of the conference i mean i'm really excited you know what am i going to learn oh i just can't wait and and uh you know i sit down in the room and the speaker you know he gets going and he's Going for about 10
minutes and uh someone in the audience raises her hand and he and he stood up and jake is the guy the guy his name was jake and and and he stood up it's not effective it was jake bernstein you probably he's written a lot of books you probably heard of them anyway uh so jake acknowledges the guy in the audience and the guy stood up and and he said uh and the speakers of course we're talking to talk about their their trading systems And and how people use them that's sort of thing and uh the
guy stood up and he's in in in kind of an indignant tone that really surprised me and i think it also surprised jake he said jake your system's so good why are you selling it and you know i think the whole thing kind of took jake by surprise like i said and jake you just stood there and thought for a second they said you know what house sales medium is you want to Buy because out of all the hundreds of people this room there probably isn't one of you that could go back and execute it
now i'm sitting there listening to this i think you know you know he didn't he he didn't say this in a way that i thought he was kidding you know so you know i'm thinking what's going on here and nobody asked him to elaborate so it's like you know it's like i'm just hoping this didn't apply To me okay i'm just like you know i don't know what he's saying i don't know why he's saying it i just hope it isn't me he's talking about okay and it was of course it was you know it
was definitely me as probably as well as everyone else in the room so um anyway like i said i i really felt i had to write something from ground zero in other words if you don't know anything about this business if you don't know anything about the nature Trading and especially if you don't know anything about the nature of price movement that you can actually go through understand what you need to go through and go through a process of changing the way that you think because this is what this is all about everybody you're gonna
have to get used to the idea that if you're gonna do this successfully you are probably going to Have to change some major assumptions some major beliefs you have about their nature market trading to do it successfully i'm not saying you're not going to have winning trades i'm saying that if you want to create a consistently rising equity curve and assure yourself of an income you're going to have to think differently than what you think right now there's no way around it like for example most of you in this Room just real just quick example
most in this room would think that because i'm a trader and because i put on trades i'm a risk taker that makes sense because we know that trading is risky right come on i'm gonna have to get some feedback guys okay you can't you can't sit there stone face no you really can't seriously you can but it's going to make Things hard for me i don't want to be heartbroken i want to enjoy myself okay so come on just give me some feedback yes or no yes okay thank you remember i haven't done this in
three years so give me a break i'm asking you nice so yeah we're risk takers right and yet when you think about it everything that you do or let's say i used to do as a trader with respect to analysis was to try to eliminate the risk Once i tried to make the risk go away was to try to make sure that the trade i'm getting into right now this trade was going to be a winner not maybe a winner but going to be a winner oh why would i do it why would i get
into a trade if i didn't think it was going to win does that make sense to everybody is that the kind of logic that makes sense that's exactly the kind of logic that's Going to make sure you're not going to be successful in this business it's exactly the kind of logic that is going to be going to assure you that you will not make it in this business this business has nothing to do with winning on a trade by trade basis on a trade by trade basis what you're going to learn today is that your
technical systems okay what they give you is an edge everyone you heard the word probability said a hundred times Probabilities edges edge is nothing more than a higher probability of one thing happening over another there's a huge difference between understanding that concept and actually believing it in a way that you can execute your traits properly you actually have to believe in the nature of probabilities at the very core of your trading personality which means you're going to have to give up on the idea that each individual Trade is going to be successful what your system
does is give you an edge over a series of trades where the outcome of each individual trade is unknown and unknowable not just unknown unknowable the more you think you got to know this business the less successful you're going to be this isn't a business about knowing what's going to happen next it's a business of getting your mind to the Point where you're completely detached from your outcomes very different than the way we live our lives gino was talking to geno last night what did you gino's been an attorney for how many years 43 years
what what did you learn when you became a trader in relationship to the kind of strategies that you worked that you used as a trader that i used Absolutely do you hear what he said everything he used to be a successful lawyer is completely opposite of the strategies and thinking methodologies that we have to use to be traders if i'm a lawyer am i detached from my outcome you are yeah if i'm a lawyer am i detached from my outcome oh no no no if i'm a lawyer am i attached to my outcome absolutely not
i'm going to make sure That i get the outcome i want if i'm a doctor am i detached from my outcome if i'm an engineer am i detached from my outcome so if i'm saying to you to be successful in this business you're going to have to become detached from your outcomes just how in the world you're going to get to the point where you can do that you don't know i you're right you probably don't thank you [Laughter] trade for somebody else that's that that not everybody that you know they're the groups following people
that they can trade for somebody else and be detached and trade with somebody else and actually they're even more attached than what they would be normally i work with both ways there are people who can actually trade their own money once they learn the right methodology in the right mindset They can trade their own money much easier than they can trade somebody else's because they're more concerned about you know losing money for other people somebody you don't know how you don't even get still there's a lot of variables in there yeah yeah that's you know
so so so basically yeah i had i had to write this book from like i said from the perspective of going from the ground Up and having two books under my belt which i thought were really tough books to write i mean they don't i i'm not yeah they were very very difficult for me to write and um i'm thinking you know and here's this is my own bias that i'm going into this this whole project with like okay you know i've got i wrote the discipline trader took me eight years or trading the zone
took me five years you know Come on i should be able to knock this out a couple years right anybody right should be able to knock this out in a couple years yeah eight years i'm still not done way harder than trading in the zone way over the top part of them trading the zone or the discipline trader i just i can't even begin to tell you how difficult it's been and how challenging it's been for me and and and how this just the impact that it's not in my life Even it's just really been
very very difficult but in any case um i found that breaking these concepts down to a core level where someone who doesn't know the business can understand it was not easy and i made a lot and over the years you know doing presentations i've made a lot of assumptions see it's one thing to know how to trade to break through a certain certain what i call the threshold of consistency you know like like if this if over here this is Like a mental threshold okay like if you're down here and you're booming and busting okay
your equity is you know you go up you go down you go up go down and and you want an equity curve that looks like this you're gonna have to break through what i call the threshold of consistency and this is the mindset it has nothing to do with your methodology i'd say nothing but you're gonna have to have a good edge all i'm saying is that but there are a lot of good edges out There okay but so so this is a mindset yeah yeah breaking breaking breaking these concepts down in that way was
just you know i i made a lot of assumptions and breaking through my own assumptions was was really a difficult process you know because because what i was getting at is that that it's one thing to learn how to trade for yourself and however however however way you manage to break through this threshold of consistency it's another to actually learn how to Teach people how to do it the process of doing it and teaching people how to do it are worlds apart there's almost no connection there's almost no connection at all because there are a
lot of people who teach trading because they become successful traders legitimately successful traders and they teach it from their perspective without realizing that their audience is nowhere near their mindset and and and Cannot cannot do what they do when i was you know coaching in the early you know the mid 80s mid 80s to early 90s you know they're i'm not going to mention names but there are some you know trading gurus out there that had huge followings and uh you know brilliant people very successful traders but absolutely did not know how to teach it
did not know understand you know where where the common guy was coming from and most of most of uh you know Like my really serious suicidal clients were as a result of listening to these people you know the ones that ended up you know waking up in the gutter saying oh my god you know i'll do anything [Music] just because they know how to teach it that's all and because the process of learning how to teach it is just not just completely different than the process of learning how to do it so like i said
i made assumptions and those Assumptions uh resulted in um you know making it really difficult for people reading the discipline traitor and trading the zone to get what they needed out of it to break through this threshold of consistency and i didn't really know that until you know i got almost to the end of the book where you know it's like the exercise and trading in the zone you know when i finished that book in Like 1999 it's like i thought i thought i explained it i really did i thought i explained it i'm going
to apologize to now realizing that i didn't i really didn't explain it because in this new book i've devoted thirty single site to the single space type written pages to just the exercise because what i because the big assumption that i made was that all the all the background all the all the Material that that i wrote to to uh as foundation to do the exercise that somehow people would find a way to assimilate it and realize the connection on their own and then when i started actually getting to the point where i had to
write about the exercise i realized that that just wasn't that wasn't going to happen and the reason and the reason why i i know it didn't happen is because i would do presentations And um but like for example in 2008 2009 2010 whatever and like because i did several for john in a row like you know where i did like i said eight nine ten eleven and twelve last night he was in 2012. and so like in 2010 i go through the whole presentation you know and and and uh you know and explain what i
felt people needed to get and and and the exercise itself but pretty much explained it within the Context of trading in the zone and uh and then the next year you know some people would you know a lot of the same people with 100 people in the room but there's a percentage of them that were there the year before and it's like how many of you did the exercise nobody not only that i was wondering you know like okay everyone in the audience pretty much let's say the large percentage of people in the audience have
great trading in the zone and right Off the bat i mean i say okay you've read trading in the zone a lot of people said they've read it multiple times so i'm thinking how many did the exercise nobody and it's like so in so in 2011 uh we're going through this this is this mystified me now i was truly perplexed i really was i did not get it i really didn't get it and uh so in 2011 somebody in the audience just happened to say after Closing getting to the point where the presentation is you
know is completed there's as much time as we have and uh someone said well how many of how many of you how many of us do you think are going to do the exercise and i said no buddy they're all taken back by that you know because i was just flat out none of you are going to do it and um and then the next year in 2012 There were a few people that actually did it and they got the results that that that they were looking for now we're going to talk about this we're
going to talk about in great length mostly tomorrow but it's like you know i want you you know i want you to leave understanding the process understanding what it is that you have to do and the process that you're going to have to go through To get to the point where you can you can acquire the kind of psychological skills because because all the skills there isn't anything about training that's physical what are you interacting with you're interacting with information there isn't anything physical other than just you know if you've got the ability to uh
you use your mouse pad or use a mouse you've got the eye hand coordination to put your mouse in a Certain spot on your training platform you've got the skills down pat you're you're golden on the skills the physical skills it's mental skills it's how we interact with information the state of mind that we're in people don't realize that you know that this is this is like a a just to really do training at a really high level in what i call a subjective or the discretionary mode as opposed to mechanical training where you've got
a a Particular set of criteria that define your entry and exit and it's rigid so the market has to conform the market has to conform to your rules and you do nothing okay that's i'm just going to cursor give you a cursive explanation in the mechanical mode the market has to conform to your entry and exit rules or you do nothing there's nothing to do there's nothing to think about you're just supposed to do you know Enter when it says put your stop where it says put your objective where it says and either happens or
it doesn't okay in the subjective mode basically discretionary mode you can do whatever you want whenever you want based on whatever information you expose yourself to and the way you want to combine that information in the brain to come up with an entry or exit signal and where to put your stop and where to put your profit objective To be in that mode and do it successfully you better be in a real high a real like elevated state of mind because what you're gonna find is that it's your attitude it's your it's a quality of
state of mind like are you confident are you fearful are you in a carefree state of mind are you agitated are you angry you feel like you know do you feel like like getting revenge if you're going through personal Emotional trauma if someone said you know if someone you knew was trading was a full-time trader and they're going through a real traumatic experience in their life would you advise them not to trade makes sense right just makes sense and yet what people don't realize is that there are degrees of states of mind in other words
you've got on a continuum at one end you've got you know got Positive you've got confidence okay you got confidence and here you got fear and there are degrees of confidence and fear and until you become aware of where you're at on that continuum you have to adjust the way you trade based on your awareness of where your state of mind is because your results are going to reflect that the way you pick the what information you pick or you choose to uh uh to Utilize and where you where you were your trade location your
size your stock your objective all gonna be reflected in your state of mind [Music] it would be i'll give you an example you got you got you you had just had the ncaa uh uh you know college basketball championship right okay now you got now you now you know if i said that at a professional or even a College level that that some of these kids or some of these guys they can hit 25 or 50 free throws in a row would anybody dispute that that they can practice they practice thousands of shots and they
get at the free throw line while they're in practice and just and hit 25 in a row 30 in a row there are people who can do that so so if you can do that you have got your muscle memory in place your muscles Are chained to the foot like as if you're like there's little these little memory cells and each of our muscles it's like they're completely in place so that you know and you step all the physical variables are exactly the same no matter where you're doing it the bottom line is right here
the basket's so many feet away the basket's a certain height the rim is a certain diameter that's it all the variables are the same now pull one of these kids who can do 25 In a row in a situation where there's about two seconds left in the game the national championships on the line and with uh two shots he can win the game with one shot he can tie two shots he can win the game for himself his college you know all the fans and his team one shot he ties what is going to be
the determining factor is whether or not he wins that game well when you stay controlled out there You might not have any fear all i'm saying what's going to be just at a general level what's going to be the determining factor what mental state of mind yeah this state of mind why do you think you know everyone knows like for example field goal kickers who are in a position where they can take a field goal and win the game the opposing coach calls the timeout they put him on ice okay everyone knows but what is
putting him on ice mean it means you know what These guys are pros you give them the opportunity to get up to that tee and kick the ball without thinking their muscle memory is going to come in to come into play and this is going to be automatic now give the guy the opportunity to start rolling some negative thoughts through his brain and he might choke same thing with the kid on the phone line if he can keep his thoughts positively Focused on the process of doing what he needs to do he'll probably make both
shots if he starts thinking how his life's going to go to complete and absolute if he misses those shots chances are he's going to miss him if if some thoughts start rolling through his brains you threw his brain about coaches who have berated them parents who have berated him throughout his life and being in these kinds of Situations chances are he's going to miss those shots and choke and this will go right along here here we have just normal confidence there's what's called a threshold of euphoria okay you can cross from normal confidence into a
threshold of euphoria which is just as bad as being in a state of fear for a traitor but same way with this kid let's say he's standing at the foul line And he's starting to think about what a hero he's going to be in a couple of seconds and he starts celebrating in his brain before he actually takes the shots that extra degree of excitement just might have enough of an impact on the way the ball leaves his fingers for him to miss the shots so it can't be too much it can't be fearful he
just has to have the right amount of confidence flowing through his brain and the right amount and be Focused in just the right way before he actually for the ball leaves his fingers and he'll make the shot because the muscle memory is there anybody anybody have a problem with this when we're training in the discretionary mode these are the things we've got to be aware of we're interacting with information it's like like the it's like the analogy would be the kids muscle memory to shoot the free throw would be Our memory of all the different
patterns we've learned about how to define an edge the patterns are in our brain we can we can we can when we see them in the market how we utilize those patterns are going to be a function of the state of mind that we're in now you don't have to get to that level of awareness to be a successful trader if you stay in the mechanical mode In other words once you learn one how to how to identify an edge you learn how to think in probabilities you get rid of what what i'm going to
just refer to as the four primary trading fears the fear of being wrong the fear of losing money the fear of missing out will fear leaving money on the table when you neutralize those four fears and you can trade in a carefree state of mind carefree detached state of mind you can stay in the mechanical mode for Your whole trading career and and don't really have to address a lot of these state of mind issues not that they won't come into play not that they will come into play because they will if they're there they
will but at least in the mechanical mode you know exactly what you need to do and when you need to do it so any any thought of deviating from that you know there's a problem We'll get the i'm going to think it's a perfectly fine i'm gonna go into all this detail i'll just give you an overview here okay so don't get too don't get too perplexed go ahead oh yeah the fear of being wrong uh the fear of losing missing out leaving mine on the table so you don't have to reach that level of
awareness that let's say heightened love that heightened level of awareness To to be able to be successful but you better be at that height level of awareness if you don't want to create disastrous results in the subjective mode most people are trading outside their skill level meaning they should be trading mechanically and they're trading subjectively they're trading discrete in the discretionary mode and they have nowhere near the skills to be able to do it Because in that mode you can do whatever you want see in the mechanical mode i would say you wouldn't even even
to think about pulling a stop even to think about moving a stop as a trading error in the subjective discretionary mode you want to move a stop movement you want to pull a stop pull it because the assumption is you you don't you're not doing it from a state of fear you're not doing it because of what what you're afraid of the results are you're Doing it because that's what you that's what the market's telling you to do in this moment based on your ability to read the market from an objective perspective because every mistake
just about every mistake that you can make as a trader will be the result of i'm afraid of being wrong i'm afraid of losing money i'm afraid of missing out i'm afraid of leaving money on the table You're going to get in too soon you're going to get in too late you're not going to define your risk because you're thinking hey why define the risk i know we can get in this trade and i think it was going to be a winner so there is no risk yeah oh yeah okay yeah yeah or you or
you or you say you know you read all the books and you go to the conference and say hey don't do this Without free without determining what your risk is before you get into a trade and so you think okay well i've gotta you know everyone says i gotta do it so i'll do it so basically it's lip service lip service in the sense that okay you'll put a stop in the market and that's where usually people use percentage stops as opposed to scroll what i call structure stops structure stops where you're actually reading the
market in a way where you know where's The best place from the structure perspective that tells you this trade isn't working or the likelihood of it working working is so diminished in relationship to the profit objective it's not worth staying in anymore did you guys get what i just said okay that's a structure stop when you pick an arbitrary percentage stop like one or two percent that's the people that do that usually doing that's risk that's a lift service risk Management they don't really don't believe they're gonna get stopped out but they're they're you know
they've been turned over and over again you got you got to do something like that and so they put their percentage stop in the market and thinking well it's never going to get hit anyway and of course when it starts to you know start to look like it's going to get hit they'll either pull it and you know put somewhere else or if they're coming out Of a state of basically pain where they've lost three four trades in a row you know if it starts even getting close they'll pull up thinking you know what i'm
gonna save myself some money nobody in this room done that good oh okay yeah today yeah right it could be anything yes the structure stock could be you could the question is the structure stopped like a two bar Stop well instructor stop is is based on on your definition of an edge we have edges for getting in we have edges for getting out whether it's where the edge is defined as a profit objective or a place where where the market's telling us that the likelihood of this trade not working is so great it's not worth
spending any more money on or not or not worth uh the likelihood of even hitting the profit objective is so diminished that It's not worth spending any more money on go ahead no not in this business zero fear absolutely zero fear absolutely zero fear i want to be emphatic about that i don't know there is no no absolutely zero fear you have got to try this good question thank you very much you don't have to trust yourself because what you're going to find when i get into this example is That that fear acts on our
perception of information in a way that we actually create the very experience we're trying to avoid okay i'm gonna i'm gonna explain that how that works but fear will act on our perception of information how we perceive it the way we filter the information and how we behave in a way where we will actually create the very experience we're trying to avoid so if i'm trying to avoid being wrong that's Exactly what i'm going to end up doing i'm going to i'm going to act and see things in a way that create a situation where
i end up being wrong if i'm afraid of losing money that's exactly what i'm going to create for myself zero fear not only that you have to it because fear and trust are are are uh opposite of each other you've got to be able to trust yourself you have to be able to completely and absolutely trust yourself that you can do act in your own Best interest and do the right thing without experiencing pain first how can you be successful in this business if you have to experience pain to get out of a losing trade
that if it takes that much if you know the market has to go so far against us that we can't stand it anymore that we eventually get out go ahead no no anxiety no fear no completely carefree state of mind you're going to Have to get to the point where a completely objective carefree state of mind you cannot care about the outcome remember i started it wasn't even that long ago detached from the outcome you got to get your expectations in line with the reality of the environment you are operating in you are operating in
a probabilistic environment that really means not lip service that really means probabilistic maybe Maybe maybe i'm going to get the outcome that might that my edge says or my edge is predicting will happen maybe i'm going to prove this to you he said one of the reasons why i wrote this third book is because because i came to the realization that that my personal experiences as a trader starting out because i started trading in 1978 so my personal experience as a trader and then going to work for merrill lynch and the chicago board of Trade
as a retail broker you know it's like it's like i ended up learning things about how the market works that ordinarily without being on the inside of the industry people just wouldn't get so i also took that for granted and what people don't get is how when they don't understand overflow when they don't really understand the nature of overflow and how prices move from an order flow perspective it's very hard to learn how to think how to very hard it'd be very Hard to let's say extrapolate what you know watching prices move on a screen
in a way where you could think you know i need to think like this i need to think like this when you don't when you don't understand overflow that that really screws you up because when you really do everything that i'm saying will become self-evident when you understand order flow all the things that i'm saying will just like yeah okay yeah that makes sense So if i say to you that if you operate you've got to get your expectations in line with the reality of the environment that you're operating in that means you don't know
what your outcomes are going to be there's no way you can know what your outcomes are going to be i'm also going to say that you don't also know why you're winning or losing when you understand order flow you will know that there is no way that you can Know why you're winning or losing or even find out think about that one for a second you don't know why you're winning or losing and there's no way to find out do you understand how prices move to the extent where you can you can think yourself yeah
okay that makes sense to me i'll explain it to you it doesn't make sense now and the implications of what i just said Is that every prediction your methodology makes and in essence is a guess and if it's a guess the implications are guess what you're gambling what's that if you're guessing you're gambling that is the reality of our situation we have no assured outcomes and we cannot make a connection between the reasons why we put on a trade and the reasons why the market went into when in Our favor or win against us if
we can't make that connection then we don't know why we're winning or losing and it isn't any different than sitting down at a blackjack table or playing a slot machine because there's no way to know we are gambling regardless of the fact that you're using analysis regardless of how good your analysis is i don't care how sophisticated it is there is no analysis that can take the gambling element out of trading listen to me There is no analysis that can take the gambling element out of trading there is no analysis that can eliminate the risk
there is no analysis that can say assure us that this trade is going to be a winner when you understand overflow you will agree with what i'm saying and then you'll start thinking about this whole thing differently so instead of trying to avoid the risk instead of trying to use your analysis to avoid the Unavoidable to do the impossible you will accept the risk and understand it from a probabilistic perspective and then everything will change everything will change you'll even see a different market you'll see the same bars but you'll be interpreting it in a
way where it's like oh yeah okay that makes sense yeah it's like one second it's like it's like We're here in las vegas out of casino you heard john say or somebody uh maybe yesterday or i think somebody said you know uh about even trading his own it's like you know like be the casino well here's what this means like when casinos know that they have the law of probabilities working in their favor the law of probabilities is like magic see the casinos really aren't gambling Because they are gambling in one sense and gambling from
one perspective but not in another on an event by event basis you know this blackjack hand this blackjack hand this back to every individual hand that's dealt they don't know the outcome to and in essence they are gambling on the outcome of each individual hand but since they have the law of probabilities working in their favor what that means is that over a large Series of events they will always come out net winners so in essence they're not gambling we can do the same thing as traders exact same thing we have an edge our edge
gives us a higher probability of one thing happening over another over a series of trades but each individual trade the outcome is not known nor knowable all i have to do is execute that edge Flawlessly every time and i will come out in that winter and in essence over a series of trades i'm not gambling on each individual trade i am are you guys with me on this i'll explain in more detail later on there is nothing you can do to take away the risk burn that in your brain there's nothing you can do to
take away the risk any effort that you put towards taking away the risk is going to assure you of failing To whatever degree you're going to try to take away the risk of being wrong the risk of losing money the risk of being leaving money on the table the risk of missing out all these four fears will detract from your ability to create a consistently rising equity curve and cause you to make mistakes okay ahead who had the question back well i don't know how you define a program good poker player i have no idea
i don't know how you define a good poker Player so be hard for me to answer that question what's that well yeah see winning winning one night or you know and getting out getting on a winning streak is different than someone who can someone who can gamble and make consistent income you know people people who can make consistent income gambling you know work basically about the same kind of mindset and they also there There's a lot of other facts a lot of other variables involved it's like it's like people who are you know are immersed
in gambling i mean you know there's a lot of dynamics in play that are you know not so much different from a psychological perspective but for example if if and i don't gamble i mean i don't i don't you know i don't play black deck anymore or anything else like that but anyway um it's like if i were what i would do for The first thing i would do is i'd walk through a casino and i tried to find i tried to find a dealer who was having a bad night in other words he could
a dealer who's busting on a consistent basis you know or if i was playing craps i would i would peruse the table until i found somebody who was hot with the dice because i do believe in streaks i believe in winning and losing streaks and if you can you know if i'm playing My cards right you know if i got a basic strategy and how i'm going to play my cards or or or how i'm going to bet at craps uh what i'm going to want to do is i'm going to want to you know
find somebody who's already on a streak or looks like they're gonna be on the street in what way if we hold on we could flip the coin a thousand times in a row okay we would come up with a pattern a discernible Pattern where there would be very little difference between heads and tails if the coin is evenly weighted right this is the pattern that would that would come up over and over and over again and you could actually bet on it you could actually bet on the fact that if i put the coin enough
times like a thousand a thousand flips that that that the uh that the relationship between heads and tails would be within a percent right let's see but within that thousand flip Sequence can you have winning you could have heads could cast come up ten times in a row yeah okay i didn't say it was predictive i said what i'm saying well i would say what i'm saying is i'm just looking for people i'm looking for situations where it's likely that this is what's if someone's on a winning streak they're on a winning streak i don't
hold on to the last Or why i don't care i'm just looking for i'm looking for edges that's all i'm saying look so the answer is question about gambling it's not a good correlation because there's too many other factors involved so but otherwise i'm just looking for that that kind of edge go ahead yeah i will now but i'll the whole rest of the time is going to be pretty much elaborating On it but when i say if you come if you say you you say be comfortable i say that that you accept the risk
at such a core level of your trading personality of your trading and belief system that there is no other part of your mental environment that would argue for anything different in other words what what i mean is that when you've accepted that that i could put this trade on i do not know what the outcome is going to be I don't care what the outcome is going to be because i've adopted i've adopted a series of trades perspective meaning that that i don't know what i want basically what am i expecting i'm expecting wins and
losses over a series of trades and i don't know the sequence of wins and losses but i do know that my edge in the past has produced let's say a 60 win loss ratio or 70 win loss ratio again i don't know what the sequence the Wins and losses are and i don't care i just need to execute properly and when i get to the point where i really have accepted these principles accepted them at the very core of my being i will be able to do this without fear i'm gonna show you how to
do it tomorrow but what i'm saying is that this is where we're getting to we're getting to the point where if you're gonna do this right you gotta you gotta transcend your fears and to Transcend your fears you're gonna have to learn how to think differently it's that simple if you're not willing to learn how to think differently you might as well walk out of the room now it's not going to happen for you it really isn't go ahead and there's enough there's enough back case of of of people who've been in this business for
years who have lost one or more fortunes have lost one or more fortunes until they get to the point where they come to the Realization that you know what my strength my life strategies don't work in this business why do you think there's this there's a theme in all you know all you know really good traders that this theme that that most of them had lost one or more fortunes before they finally broke through the threshold of being able to create consistent results because that's what it took it took losing all that money to break
down the resistance of Their their dysfunctional beliefs about the nature of this business or their erroneous assumptions about what this is about and most of those erroneous assumptions have to do with analysis which is which is normal because when you think about the way we define analysis in our normal everyday life if i step into and engage in an analytical process and and i really believe that that process has validity Then when i come to a conclusion i should think that i'm going to get the outcome i expect wrong in trading that's not the case
you don't open up a trading account at a brokerage firm and they tell you that you know what whatever you think the way you define analysis doesn't work here does not work you're only using analysis to get an edge and an edge is a higher probability of one thing happening over another and If there's no way to assure myself that this trade i'm going to get into is a winner i'm guessing and if i'm guessing i'm gambling they tell you that anybody ever tell you that john john yeah okay john john's a good guy okay
i'm sorry [Music] you're never eliminating the risk you're accepting it you're never eliminating it there's there's nothing just you have to Get to the point where you're just like i said there's no question in your mind that the risk always exists now there's when you say eliminating risk by by scaling out a pro yeah well but see there's a difference between between what you say is reducing risk from a money manager's perspective and actually accepting the risk when you reduce risk from money management perspectives because the market's telling you with one that's that's your Strategy
okay and two the market's saying this is a good place to take some profits that has nothing to do i mean you can say the vernacular is you can say yes i'm reducing risk but that's not what i'm talking about i'm gonna talk about from a psychological perspective actually accepting the risk okay so that yeah yeah there's a difference but these are subtle differences this is the kind of thing that gets us in trouble see we don't understand these Subtleties we get into a lot of trouble go ahead do i walk yes please no i
actually i don't really know what this reason is so uh i i have been trading a long time you know i as a matter of fact i turned my training i used transportation i turned my training platform off really just about three years ago right around this time thinking that you know what i don't want to be distracted with the market i'm Going to be done in three months yeah i'm still not done and i haven't turned it back on so uh i don't even watch markets right now anyway it doesn't matter just to tell
you what just maybe maybe i shouldn't say i'm not saying anyway uh now give me an example of what i'm talking about where i'm at right now in the book is is is uh the last chapter and i'm actually writing about Subjective discretionary training um it's taking taking me like 26 27 days just to get the first three paragraphs what's the name i know you're gonna ask i've got about 20 names when i'm done i'll pick one okay when the name comes i write it down and if i can find the file because i didn't
follow the name in a long time i'm gonna have to find the classes like thousands of files but anyway uh yeah it's like And when i say i've worked it's not like i haven't been writing i've got pages and pages and pages it's just that it's just that the words have to be come together in just the right way for people to really get it and it's like it's not until it resonates you know it resonates with me that yeah okay i've got the suitcase sequence of the words just right and like i said the
25 26 days just to get just to get three Paragraphs and if you asked me a month ago i'd have said hey i'm almost done with it i'll be done a few days [Music] and what really scares me is the next part is intuitive now i've already got a lot of stuff on intuitive written so all i gotta do is find it but then again one no seriously i'm not kidding because i've written it years ago so you know so you know i'm gonna have to find What i've read i'll find it it's not like
it's lost but you know i don't want to get into it anyway so where are we yeah right no exactly so you know yes it's my own problems with the whole writing process that you know creates all the difficulty to get right down to it i never you know because i never i didn't go out to be asked with aspirations being a writer do you really or an author or have any idea What that was like or here when i almost finished my third book spent most of my adult life writing books and i'm like
huh you know it's like i just wanted to be a professional hockey player i said i'm not kidding i'm really not i've got i grew up in the in the 60s or the 50s you know and uh you know you've got because i'm 66 years old so it's like i grew up in the 50s and back then they're only six nhl teams And there and everyone there weren't any american players any american hockey players in the nhl there wasn't not one american hockey player in the nhl so my chance of becoming a professional hockey player
was zero but while all i'm saying is that my aspirations would be to be a professional hockey player that's what then to be a writer it's like come on i used to and this honestly got true when uh the term i went to michigan State and the term would start and i go into a class and the professor said we're gonna have a term paper i'm out build my advisor drop the class writing forget it i just i you know i avoided writing at all costs now i know why my life purpose was to be
devoted as a writer and i was just avoiding what i was going to end up doing i didn't why started back you know why started when i'm in my late teens and early 20s i'm going to end up spending my whole life Doing it you know but anyway go ahead you know what there's these are all personal individual variables and it could be it could be any anything i mean just even is john here john okay we were talking last night you know in the cocktail thing and uh john brought up that um he made
a connection you want the connection about uh being a hero oh god um we were talking and if i was going Through this kind of yeah when you're on the other side of it yeah when you're on the other side of it yeah and as i thought about it really and then the logical explanation in my mind was well done i mean and the first [Music] right and so um um so eight thousand dollars and this was like in 1995 nice downtrend uh two markets there and then um at one point the premium dropped in
for the yesterday and if is great to work um when we come back down to have a gap built within the iphone together I'm like you know let's learn i was never going to do that but now i've got the sideways i've never seen the sideways and i woke up [Music] to me that you know i did not go tell them right now money closing the money account everything's going to mind but the last minute you know the latest people said you know you Said that you're going to put 30 um wow it's worse than
i thought you know what i watched him get to though okay okay yeah i'm having a really hard time is that there is something naturally below it and surviving and somehow i was i i really believe sometimes and how heroic is it to lose every day Out is you know it's kind of hard to like you know it's almost like it's the heart you're part of the point of you know you know yes that's what happened but i'm like once i realized that it's not happening yeah yeah thank you that's exactly what i wanted i
wanted he was he was he was applying his own agenda and that was he had another agenda other than just being A successful trader so that's why i couldn't answer your question about you know well what's happening with with people because because of all kinds of agendas that we have and when we trade in mechanical mode it's it's at least a lot easier to be successful until because we know exactly what we need to do when we need to do it any deviation we're making a training error in the Discretionary mode there's no such thing
as a training error you do anything you want but then what you have is you have all these personal agendas that can really start to assert themselves you can have personal agendas asserting themselves when you're in mechanical mode but again at least you know something is going on because i'm not executing properly i want to make an i'm do i'm about ready to do something that that is defined Explicitly as an error and so at least if you've got enough presence of mind to say you know what i'm going to step through that that compulsive
behavior and do what i need to do anyway you'll be all right but when you're in the discretionary mode these agendas can assert themselves in a way that unless you have a really high level of awareness you don't even know what's Going on making sense okay that was that was the like the introduction as a matter of fact you know what before we get going again let me take a five minute break a bathroom break is that all right again