please state your name Debbie Debbie in your phone uh Deborah C whack and where do you live ah Live Oak and how many children do you have um I have four children and how many grandchildren uh 12 . Debbie how do you know Aiden ah he's my grandson and how long have you known him since he was born and how often would you see Aiden over the years all the time and when you say all the time how is that all right we're always together we're a big family we do everything together just we're always
together we're just you know I stayed with them too because I work here in Jacksonville so it saved me a drive um to not have to drive home all the time so I would stay with my daughter and her family so a lot of dinners and breakfasts you would see Aiden oh yeah all the time who did Aiden live with uh primary with his mom but his dad and his mom shared you know custody so how often would he spend days or weekends with his father are they alternate um you know they I think Jason
I think his dad got him Tuesday and Thursdays and every other weekend so that's how they worked it they were really adamant on having their days nobody wanted to miss their time both parents wanted to spend time with them yes ma'am and how many brothers or how many children does sorry Aiden's your grandson by your daughter yeah okay and how many children does she have she has five okay and where is Aiden in that group of five children uh he's in the middle now did the five kids get along yeah they get along just like
normal kids yeah I've never seen any fight you know arguing or any problems at all it was a pretty happy home okay how would you describe Aiden in that home with the other five kids it's always been silly and funny and the jokester of the kids he um he was always happy every pitcher I have he smiles he's now what's your daughter Aiden's mother like the person's good-hearted and kind and sweet and I mean my daughter I love her and his father was Aiden's father like oh he's a good man he's always been in our
lives and you don't see that often and when people split up they usually there's always one that leaves that stays out of their life but he's always stayed in his son's life from the beginning now what holidays would you share with David all of them and especially birthdays because my youngest daughter their birthdays were like a few days apart and so we always celebrate them together meaning Aiden you're your daughter yes my youngest daughter all right and but sometimes those celebrations be at your daughter's home and sometimes in life a lot of times on my
property because you know it's country you know they like to ride four-wheelers and go to Springs and river and it was just I have a lot of family out there and you know everybody kind of came together there so where do the kids spend the summer um well some in Jacksonville and some out there with me you know they like to uh like I said they like the country I like being out there but it's just more peaceful out there and happy and just the four-wheelers kids all the four-wheelers and we good Springs a lot
in the summer and cookouts and fires and we had it's took me a lot um the other part of that question sorry so in the summer now sometimes would Aiden come with you and the family if was there any other activities say the Bible is in the summer yeah they like to come uh we have vacation bible school once you know every summer so him and his older seven would come for that and they like to go to the church with me and church always had little events and activities so they'd come do that with
me too now Tristan Aiden's responsible for taking Tristan's Life on Sunday May 9th but what was the plan for the night before that Saturday night for Aiden well he was supposed to go with his cousins because they were going to spend the night at my other daughter's house and so the boys were supposed to come pick them up and they picked up his older brother but he wasn't there yet I get to see what his friend so he had called them to please come back and pick me up but they said I didn't have any
gas so that's why he never made it over there and and then another seven so that night the plan was for Aiden and his brother to go out with some cousins yeah they were going to spend the night over there in my other daughter's house and his oldest brother made it but he wasn't there yet they said he was still with his friends and they didn't want to wait around so when he had called him to come back and pick him up they said they didn't have gas money and so he ended up staying home
so there wasn't enough gas money to come back and get eaten right that's what they said now what mental illness do you know of in your family well the only thing I've experienced with any of that was I mean my son goes through a lot of depression he still does he always has even since he was a teenager um my ex which is my kid's dad has a lot of mental issues I mean he has things going on he still has things going on he's in and out in jail so but I loved him when
my kids were real little so I didn't want to put them through any kind of stuff like that so your son Aiden's uncle when was he first Baker acted or how old was he was like 14. so his first Baker Act he was 14. right he started getting a little bit of trouble but you know we pulled through it you know I mean counseling and help you pull through it and but he's still depressed he has his moments you know he falls so you understand what Aiden's here for yes all right um is that the
boy you knew he's not the boy that I knew I don't know what happened I mean he's always been good and I mean so sorry wow this is so hard I'm so suffering he has a good family we don't condone what happened and um we're very sorry we lost he's always been such a good kid and we don't I don't even know where that came from I mean he doesn't have any bad in his family or around him or ah I don't know I don't I can't explain I just don't know now in terms of
Aiden around the family that included hamsters animals was he ever harmful harmful to any of the pets no I mean we all have animals and um no he's never been any animals and then there's younger siblings so he's got a little sister you 'd interact with her um well they were very close besties little sister they always played around he was real close to her and she still asks for him all the time and uh and she still doesn't know it's gone and she wonders why she can't see her brother but they miss him very
much and I think I'm pretty much the voice for the family and I know I'm probably the first that y'all seen and probably one of those darts at me but I mean I'm sorry I don't you know we have a good family very good Christian family and we're loving people and we just don't know what happened I think we're all trying to wonder what happened now you've seen the the newsreels with Aiden in the car again is that the boy you knew no and I've seen that with him in there it's like you designed something
I could tell you just know okay you're around them all the time and I he just looked like he was high in some kind of drugs you know I don't know it wasn't the same person that I know and see every day so I mean how has um how is the agent's arrest affected your family well we haven't had a family event since you know you um we're sad all the time you know I mean this is something you don't plan for you just it happens and you just you just don't know why and you
just I pray every day for both families and I try to stay strong for my children and my grandchildren because I'm pretty much been their mother their father and their grandmother and grandfather she always cries my daughter always cries and then I cry and they all cry and you know I just wish I could have changed nothing's going to happen if I could have been there you know and what would you like to say to the court um so I want to say it is about emphasis sorry I wish I could change what happened and
um we pray for you every day I pray for my family every day and um I just find hope that you find me somewhere in and uh just know that he has a good family and we miss him and we lost a child too you know he's I know there's not physically here he's here and I just we just miss him and which just didn't happen I don't know you know I had work I had a letter ready because you know I knew I wouldn't speak right when I got up here and I could just
leave the letters and or I can read the letters or no you want me try to read the letters go ahead I had I had to plan my mind what I would say but when you get up here and you're sober one you just don't know what to say because it's just a very tragic situation you know it's just tragic um do you you want me to read these okay um this is the family for me I just wanted to tell you you um that I'm feeling very deep sadness for loss of your beautiful daughter
and and I know the heartache you must be going through it's just terrible and I will pray for you every day I promise and I just hope you find peace you know sometime you know enclosure for what happened um I love these are I can't see it real good I'm sorry if I look a mess I just wanted to tell you um I know he has to be punished and um for his actions and I love him and his family love him very much too you know I know we're a very large Christian family and
we pray all the time and I just hope you consider it a little bit and please don't take him out of our lives forever you know that I've died and not be able to spend time with him sometime before I go I don't know I'm not good at this I'm so sorry I know there's some good in Aiden I don't know what happened to him that that this cause but I know there's some good in him and uh and I think if we find that out what caused him to do this you know maybe we'll
have more understanding of what happened I don't know I can't I can't think I just can't think sorry I'm sorry sorry no further questions your honor I'm sorry so sorry afternoon I think it is now in the spywack um just so the court understands you you live outside of Jacksonville but you spend like the weekdays Monday through Friday ish in the home of Crystal Smith and her family yes ma'am okay and you've been doing that for a long time right yes for years you did that um when she was with Jason fucci you lived with
them as a unit is that right yes and then um she is now with or married to Michael akel correct yes ma'am and were you also visiting and living at that house on Casa Dale Drive during the week leading up into when this happened in 21. yes I was there okay were you even there the week before this happened I was there that Thursday okay and then you kind of go home for the weekends and then come back is that right when I had said I wish I was there I wish I had like stayed
and not gone home or something maybe I could yes ma'am So You observe this family a lot correct yes I do and you've never seen any um we didn't talk about uh Mr Ackle a lot but even from Mr acre as a stepfather treated his family well no abusive Aiden that you ever observed I've never seen I've been in the house a long time and I don't never see that now okay um I believe you said that those kids had it all right yeah they I thought so yeah and they were spoiled and never went
without because I never went without you didn't see anybody excessively use alcohol or drugs is that right no they they weren't really drinkers now home you know it's a good thing and I believe you said Jason fucci never missed a weekend he prioritized uh Aiden even though they were separated it's not fair yeah no he's always there you know pick up the kids those Summers that you talked about that he would come he and some of his brothers would come spend with you and maybe attend BBS was that when he was younger like seven eight
yeah she uh she wouldn't let him come when he was too young because she's always worried about him getting hurt you know so I think it was like seven eight years old when she finally realized okay I can he'll be all right you know he's old enough to not get hurt and have to worry so much so I was allowed to take him okay um but that stopped in the teenage years right VBS is something for like Elementary age the teenagers how many Summers did he do that with you Lots I don't know again well
I mean it's once a year so you have to think of like seven or eight nine ten eleven twelve up meaning all the way up until he was fourteen so okay and you talked about some mental illness in your son and your ex is that right yeah that's great okay um but you're not aware of any uh or observe anything in Crystal Smith your daughter right no no she's a good girl okay and you never observed anything living with Aiden that caused you concerns no no never observe I'm sorry go ahead no okay you never
observed him like responding to stimuli hearing voices anything that you needed to report well all the kids talked about the house being haunted and I think I told you that and I thought myself I would hear things in this house whenever people were gone it would just be me and my one older grandsons and the boys would always say that there was somebody in this house you know but outside of thinking their house was haunted you didn't see anything that you felt was a mental health concern what Mr Fuji would need to be Baker acted
anything like that oh no no all right and Mr fucci never reported to you you know you guys were close right yeah we're real close yeah he never came to you and said Mr akel is doing this my dad is hurting me nothing like that well I mean he'd get in trouble he would you know he would just say I'm gonna get in trouble with my dad you know but I mean that's any kid you're gonna get insured by your parents right but nothing above um disciplining him if he were to get in trouble at
school or something like that no oh no if they got punished they would pretty much just go to the room get their phone taken away or whatever it wouldn't be able to go down to the lunch court food court that they have down there okay all right I appreciate it nothing further judge all right thank you very much if you'd like