[Music] Hello friends I'm Dr Raman mitl I work at the faculty of law University of Delhi in this module we shall be talking about assignments and licenses of intellectual property that is how intellectual property rights could be transferred by the owner to other persons how the owner of intellectual property can invite others in participating in the exploitation of The Works in which he has intellectual property rights now where do you find licenses and assignments what are the instances of it we find them all around do we find it here in the bottle of a Coke
yes the bottle of the coke that we consume comes to us only through the process of Licensing of intellectual property there are various licenses or assignments involved in the whole process of manufacturing bottling and consumption of these soft dring portles then the t-shirt that we wear carrying the logo of our famous of a famous character that comes to us through licensing activity only then software that we consume is also subjected to Licensing in fact we consume softwares as as lenses rather than as buyers in case of films how the film comes to us whether through
broadcasting or through a cinema Hall it also involves the case of intellectual property licensing the books that we read is also involving the case of Licensing or assignment of copyright so we say licensing is ubiquitous we find it everywhere first in order to understand the aspect of Licensing and assignment let us look at it from the angle of a lawyer what are the tasks of an intellectual property lawyer the first task is obtaining rights the second task is after obtaining rights protecting those rights and the third task is exploiting rights so obtaining rights and protecting
rights cannot be ends in themselves because what for are you obtaining rights what for have you protected those rights you have done so only with the aim of exploiting those rights so the fundamental task of an IP lawyer is to Aid or to maximize or to monetize through the utilization or exploitation of intellectual property rights of his clients now exploitation could be of two types self- exploitation and exploitation through others if the owner of intellectual property utilizes his own intellectual property himself then is the case of self exploitation of intellectual property if the owner invites
others or gives away his intellectual property to others for exploitation then it is the case of exploitation through others which is normally done through licenses and sometimes through assignments as well now both licensing and assignments are transfers of intellectual property so let us go a step earlier and understand what is meant by transfer of intellectual property is intellectual property transferable yes intellectual property rights most of the we can see the intellectual property rights are transferable in nature these transfers could take place either by the mechanism of a contract or a mechanism which is apart from
the contract which is for example by operation of law for example the owner of intellectual property dies so his legal heers will get the intellectual property which was owned by the dead person so but the most important one for our purposes is the contractual transfer of intellectual property contractual transfer transfer of intellectual property could be achieved in the form of assignments lease license mortgage or sale all these are legally different and significant aspects and concepts of Law and they have they convey very different rights and very different meanings and very different consequences now most important
types of contractual transfer of Ip or intellectual property is through assignments and licenses so licensing activity gets impetus from three fundamental aspects of law first is the rights which are contained within intellectual property they are of exclusive nature this exclusivity of Rights AIDS the activity of Licensing what is understood by exclusivity of rights now the rights exclusivity means that the owner alone has the right to exploit his intellectual property so we can look at this aspect of exclusivity from one angle that means the restrictive angle that gives the owner a right to exclude others but
the other aspect of this exclusivity is that the owner has the Liberty has the freedom to invite all others to partake in the exploitation of his intellectual property thereby he'll be allowing others permitting others to participate in the exploitation process and also earning for himself some remuneration so this aspect of exclusivity really AIDS the licensing activity the second aspect is the intangibility of intellectual property intellectual property we understand is intangible in nature now the enjoyment or the utilization of this intellectual property being intangible property does not detract the use of one person does not detract
from its use by the other person potentially the in any intellectual property could could be utilized by any number of persons it is contad distinction with a physical property for example some a owns a house in case he wants to part allow B to utilize his house then the house has to be divided between A and B so that is not the case with intellectual property both A and B can have the same and any number of persons can have the same property for its exploitation so this intangibility or intangible nature of the intellectual property
also AIDS the licensing activity because the owner can invite n number of persons for its exploitation the third aspect is that gives impetus to the licensing activity is the freedom of contract the law permits the owner to freely contract out his property this freedom of contract also AIDS in the in in the licensing activity intellectual property as we have seen has three limbs first is creation of property then second is protection of intellectual property and third is its exploitation so one question is fundamental to this circle of intellectual property should a property be created first
and then protected and then exploited in other words is it always the case that intellectual property is created first and then exploited well that is not always the case that may be the case in sometimes but the modern practices of the market they if we peep into those modern practices we find that exploitation of the property takes first and then the property is created only upon its exploitation for example a person there is a person who wants to make a film he's a film producer so first thing he needs he requires is a script so
he commissions Mr a to write a script for his film so for that he already pays Mr a upfront a particular sum of money so can we say that the property intellectual property copyright was created first and then exploited in this case no because it was the property was subject to sale first and then it was created because only upon an assurance of money and actual payment of some Advanced money that the author was ready to create it for the producer so in this sense we can also say see the modern practices in which uh
inventions are made employees are first people are employed in business undertakings they are given certain tasks and before before they create something they already have assigned by virtue of their Employment contract to the employer the rights in all their creativity so exploitation many a time comes before creativity and protection in case of intellectual property now what is the role of Licensing in business and economy the first question is is intellectual property wealth in itself well we say that in the knowledge economy intellectual property is wealth but intellectual property is not wealth in itself it can
be converted into wealth by its exploitation and Licensing is the major way in which intellectual property is exploited is it really the second question is is it really possible for the Creator to utilize his property himself well that may be the case in many cases but in most of the situations the intellectual property is utilized by somebody who is not the owner that means the owner invites somebody or permit somebody to utilize his intellectual property and that permission is known as a license the third question is is it possible or feasible for businesses to create
everything inhouse in the modern economy well no mostly businesses depend its business these days is a collaborative Venture so you cannot create all the intellectual property that you want or that you require for your business many times you create some properties some intellectual properties and license in in the others that you require we know it as a fact that the greatest economic value of intellectual property in the modern economy comes from licensing so licensing is indispensable to the modern economy that is the role licensing plays in the modern business and economy licensing is also strategic
tool for innovation in various ways first like licensing allows the owner of intellectual property to concentrate on his core competence for example there is a research institution now the core competence of that institution is to do research is to do fundamental research and make new inventions that research institution may not be and is not usually competent to take the invention to the industry and thereby thereafter to the market for that we have industrial houses and marketeers so licensing allows This research institution to concentrate on its core competence that is creativity that is invention so once
they invent they can utilize this instrument of Licensing to transfer their invention to the market entities to the industrial entities thereby earning through in the form of royalty income now licensing further allows you to access new markets in the throughout the world for example there is a owner of intellectual property he has his markets in India but then he wants to expand to Europe now he has no presence in Europe he has never done business in Europe it would it may not be possible for him to directly take his property to Europe for marketing thereby
he can use therefore he can use the instrument of Licensing and license an entity a business entity or a marketing entity in Europe to take and sell his property intellectual property in Europe there licensing allows you to grow allows you to access new markets licensing also allows you to test new markets for example the same businessman wants to expand in Africa but he doesn't know about the business climate the business environment of Africa so before he Ventures himself out in Africa he can he can test the market through a lensy he can first license his
property to somebody a business entity in Africa and if that Venture is successful then he can think of going to Africa himself and doing business himself well licensing is an instrument of turning an infringement infringer into an ally normally infringers are seen as opponents or as seen as enemies of any intellectual property holder but that is a very very very very um impr magmatic View and very primitive view who is an infringer normally an infringer if I'm the owner of an intellectual property an infringer is is a person who needs my property in the first
place two who knows how to exploit it so if I can shake hand with the infringer or compel him to shake hands with me and try to sell him a license then then he can do whatever he was doing before he can do it just by paying me my share of his earnings that is my royalty thereby licensing allows the conversion of an infringer into a friend licensing allows the utiliz ation of intellectual property that the owner doesn't use himself in the course of its business a business entity might create a lot of intellectual property
might generate a lot of intellectual property like copyright like trademarks like patents like inventions Etc so all those properties are not needed may not be needed by that business for all the times so what to do with the intellectual property that is still current that is still called an intellectual property which is not passed in public domain but it is not utilizable by the owner himself so he can invite others and Grant them licenses over the Redundant intellectual property which is of no use to him but which can be of use to many other persons
then licensing also allows you through spin-offs to take the technology or invention which was made for a particular cause to be utilized for a totally different cause for example our past president Dr AP J Abdul Kalam invented carbon carbon material which was invented for space vehicle program because they wanted to make the weight of certain components be very less so this carbon carbon material really reduced the weight of the component space Parts space components significantly so the same technology was used for making artificial limbs of persons who had no limbs for example a person has
no legs so uh we were in search of such a material which was lessen weight and at the same time very sturdy so this material which was invented for space technology was ultimately utilized also for making artificial limbs so all this through the instrument of Licensing licensing is a strategic business tool is sort of a partnership is sort of a joint venture so it is a joint venture between the owner of intellectual property and the person who has the ability to exploit it so the owner himself may or may not have the ability or willingness
to exploit his property so he can invite the person who specializes in exploitation of the property and thereby make a joint venture with him for example take the case of the author of a book the author of the book knows how to write the book but then he doesn't know how to print and publish the book he may not have any Market presence to Market his book to sell his book to take the book to the consumer for that if he utilizes the instrument of licenses and allows a publisher to take over this aspect of
um the distribution publication and distribution of the book then he can concentrate on his core competence that is creation of the book writing of the book thereby there's a division of labor and through this joint venture the book is ultimately taken to its audience now what exactly is licensing licensing legally speaking is converence of intellectual property and contracts primarily law of contract and IP combined to form the body of law that is known as licensing law professor Lon nimmer who has authored one of the most important books on licensing of intellectual property stated I quote
thinking of contract and intellectual property as isolated and discret boxes of principles is an empowered idea law as a practical discipline relates to human activity which defies being boxed so if we see if we dissect licensing law what do we find first it is comprised of law of contract because every license has to be a contract first where is this law of contract contained this law of contract is primarily contained in a statute in India which is known as the Indian contract Act of 1872 further this law of contract in case of licenses is also
contained within intellectual property statute statutes most of the intellectual property statutes like Copyright Act 1957 patents act 1970 and trademarks act 1999 they contain elaborate Provisions as to Contracting activity in case of the respective intellectual properties whether it is copyright patent or trademark so contract law is contained within the contract act as well as within the intellectual property statutes then licensing law is also comprised by intellectual comprised of intellectual property law further competition law has a lot of bearing on licensing activity and most of the issues regarding most of the competition law issues that arise
in case of intellectual property arise in case of its licensing only then Consumer Protection Law is also called in in LC within licensing law fold because many times the consumers are licenses for example we consume computer software by becoming LIC lenses and the provider of the computer software is the licenser so the provider of computer software say Microsoft Windows is not the seller of computer software he's only a licenser and when we buy Windows we become lenses of the Microsoft Corporation then taxation law also has a lot of bearing on licensing law the treatment of
royalties how royalties are to be distributed what to believe the taxation upon those royalty income etc etc they are all governed by taxation law so licensing law basically is an amalgam of all these different doctrines of law next we come to the influence of intellectual property law on license contracts first intellectual property law defines the scope of the rights that means the consideration part when A and B agree whereby a agrees A and B agree to form a contract whereby a agrees to Grant his intellectual property to B and B to pay in return for
that Grant what has happened a transfer of intellectual property so the scope of that intellectual property the scope of that transfer is to be moed in accordance with the law of intellectual property because it's the law of intellectual property which defines the exact scope of the property and thereby defining the exact scope of law of exact scope of Grant intellectual property law May provide for requirements over and above the requirements of General contracts many times the the journal contract law may not provide some requirements for example writing or signatures whereas intellectual property law may go
above the general law of contracts and provide for such requirements it delineates the scope of the license by laying down the Contour or establishing the Contour of the exact rights the scope of rights that are available it determines the scope of a license intellectual property law many times also provide the default or background rules for a license the parties to a license may assert certain rights against third parties who are strangers to contract for example the law of contract says that only the parties to a contract can sue and be sued upon the contract but
in case of intellectual property law there are exceptions made to this fundamental rule of contract law which is also known as the doctrine of privity of contract intellectual property law may also provide for compulsory licenses normally contracts are free we have the theory of freedom of contract if the party owns something he is free to contract it out but in certain cases of regarding intellectual property the law has Provisions for the grant of compulsory license that means the if the person wants a license he is not required to go to the owner of the intellectual
property instead he he may go to the state and obtain a license from the state which is known as the compulsory license apart from compulsory license there is also a provision for statutory licenses in various statutes like copyright statute Copyright Act of India 1957 so it contains Provisions for statutory license now what is a statutory license statutory license is a gener of compulsory license where the statute itself has granted a license to everybody whosoever is willing to comply with the conditions laid down in the statute itself so intellectual property may also provide that certain intellectual
property are or certain intellectual property rights are not transferable or not licensable or not assignable that is for example we can say that in case of section 18 which was recently amended in the 2012 amendments to copyright law of India whereby certain rights of the author are not assignable intellectual property May provide for additional non-contractual remedies as well which we shall see during the course of this presentation now if we see licensing as a subject of study we can see it as a limb of intellectual property system we can also see it as a limb
of commercial law and if you adopt a unified approach licensing has also become a unique discipline in itself because there are certain legal professionals who identify today as licensing professionals only so licensing has become quite complex in the modern context and there are organizations like licensing executive Society International which enrolls members who are licensing professionals who practice this discipline of Licensing worldwide now we come to the contractual aspect of a license contract is the vehicle of license contract is the only means to affect an intellectual property license there's no other way it has to be
a contract now all the essentials that are the required that are required to be complied with in case of a normal contract in case of an ordinary contract are also required in case of a license now there are certain aspects which need a little more scrutiny for example writing is a contract required to be written down to be enforceable to become valid no as far as the journal contract law is concerned writing is not the requirement an oral contract is as enforceable and as valid as a written contract but certain intellectual property statutes for example
the Copyright Act and the patents act require that the contract should be in writing contract of the license intellectual property license has to be in writing to be enforceable that means if the contract relating to intellectual property is not in writing then it may not be enforceable certain statutes also require in addition to writing the requirement of signatures normally no notice of the contract is required to be given to any party further as far as registration is concerned some intellectual property statutes require registration and some make it optional even if the a particular intellectual property
statute has no mechanism for the registration of a particular license as a legal document it can always be registered under the registration Act of 198 now what is the relationship between lenser and ly first the relationship is contractual further there is no Assumption of fiduciary character between or Fu relationship between the lenser and the lensey it's a contract between a principal and a principal the lensey is not necessarily an agent of the lenser the contract is between principal and principal rights of lensy flow from intellectual property law as well as the contract law now what
are the types of licenses first license could be exclusive an exclusive license is very similar to assignment now what is an exclusive license exclusive license is a situation whereby the owner of intellectual property agrees with the other to Grant a license exclusively that means the owner of the property says that I shall not Grant any other license to anybody else further the owner promises that he himself shall not be exploiting that intellectual property which is the subject of an exclusive license so that means the leny becomes the only person entitled to exploit the licensed intellectual
property in case of an exclusive license opposite of it is non-exclusive license non-exclusive license is only a promise is just a promise by the owner not to sue the lensey there is no promise that he will not not Grant any other license to anybody else or he himself will not be utilizing his property in future so non-exclusive is the opposite of exclusive soul soul license is somewhere in between Soul license is a gener of non-exclusive license only so license means that the owner of intellectual property says that you shall be says to the licy that
you shall be my only leny that means the owner cannot issue any other license to anybody else but he himself remains free to exploit his property now statutory license we have already seen where the statute itself grants you a license on return of fulfillment of certain conditions which it it is lays down we have also seen what is a compulsory license for example the patent law allows or creates a mechanism for the issuance of compulsory license in case of Public Health emergencies Etc these are the important aspects or types of licenses now the division of
license rights it could be divided in four any license could be divided in four ways one is geographical that means you can divide the licenses over the same property geographically for example you have a product and you can allow somebody to sell it in one particular geographical area and the other to sell it in another geographical area so for example I am the author of a book I can allow one publisher to publish it for America and another publisher to publish it in India in the same language the division of license rights could also be
temporal for example I can allow I have a new technology and I obtain a patent on it I can grant a license to a manufacturing entity to manufacture and Market the technology that I had invented for five years and thereafter that entity will not be entitled to do the same so it can be divisible on temporal basis then substantive I can divide because intellectual property is divisible the rights that are granted under intellectual property are divisible for example I write a book I can allow X to make a film on the book I can allow
y to translate the book I can allow Zed to adapt the book so different aspects of the rights can be a portion differently then field of use I can if I am the inventor of a technology and obtain a patent on this then I can allow I can license X to utilize it in the field of medicine I can allow y to utilize it in a field which is something very different from medicine so field of use could be different and it could be a portion or divided on the basis of field of use now
what is the difference between license and assignment now the nature of transfer is very different assignment can be analogized with sale and license can be analogized with rental for example I have a house if I sell it it would be called an assignment in in relation to intellectual property and if I allow somebody to make use of it it'll be like hiring giving the house on hire the title The lensy of intellectual property gets no title to intellectual property whereas the assign gets the same title as the owner he himself becomes the owner the right
to sue normally a leny has no right to sue the infringer of intellectual property but some statutes like copyright and patents act have granted limited rights of suing to of pursuing the infringes those limited rights are available with certain kinds of licenses like exclusive licenses otherwise the licenses have no rights no independent right to sue the infringer or pursue the infringer whereas the assign always gets the right to sue the infringer now breach and infringement in case of breach and infringement the rights and responsibilities of the breaching parties are quite different if he's a lensy
or an assigning the consideration for license is usually in the form of periodical payments known as royalties and the consideration for assignment is usually in the form of a lumpsum payment now how to know whether a contract is a license or an assignment what is the importance of a label for example a contract is styled or lab labeled as a license would it always be a license well no it is not necessarily so it is the substance of the contract that determines whether it is a whether it is a license or an assignment it is
not the talismanic phrase by which it is styled or described that would always be determinative of its nature as a license or assignment it is the content it's the substance of the contract it is the rights that that are transferred that would determine whether the contract is a license or aign the manner of transfer and the intent of parties importance of label is there but label itself cannot in itself decide whether a contract was a license or an assignment now we come to trademark licensing certain examples from trademark licensing now in the beginning of trademark
law if we trace the history of trademark law licensing was not permitted because at that time we went by the theory of single Source function that means a trademark was required to identify the source of the product um so if the product was emanating from a and henceforth a licenses the his trademark to B then the consuming public would always think that the product is coming from a thereby it will consume it will confuse the consuming public this is why licensing was not permitted and specifically prohibited in the trademark statutes before 1930s but then then
with the development of trademark law the consumers of were more concerned with the quality of product than with the source of product if I want to consume a bottle of a soft drink I'm more concerned about the quality as long as I get the same quality which is which is made by the Coca-Cola Company I satisfied whether it comes from any other source with the authorization of Coca-Cola company so this shift in the nature of consumer behavior and shift or development in trademark law allowed licensing for the first time in 1930s so thereby it was
stated that as long as the quality of the lenses goods are controlled or regulated by the licenser licensing is permitted now that means the licenser was required by law and is still required by law to maintain the quality of the products or the services of the license that means what should the product or Services of the license be of the higher quality or the highest quality no the mayor of the quality should be the same as that of the licenser if the licenser is providing X quality then law expects the lcy also to provide X
quality because in this case the consuming public will not be confused and then with the merizing function of trademarks licensing of trademarks has come full circle in the modern world what is merchandising for example when I take my kids to the market to buy a t-shirt they are specifically interested in a t-shirt which contains the logo of their favorite cartoon character so what has happened for example they want a t-shirt with Mickey Mouse printed on the T-shirt has wild Disney company which owns rights over Mickey Mouse produce that t-shirt no certainly not wal Disney Company
produces films not t-shirts so what has happened in this case is that Walt Disney Company has authorized or has licensed an independent manufacturer of t-shir to put that label on the T-shirt to put that logo on the T-shirt now this happens only because of Licensing now we have moved away from Quality Control Function because in this case because Quality Function stated that the the quality of the licenses lenses Goods should be similar to that of lenser in order for licensing to be permitted now in this case wal Disney company has never produced t-shirts so how
can we measor the quality of the t-shirts with the quality of the film so we are going beyond the Quality Function in trademark law now licensing of registered and unregistered trademark both is permissible the trademark acts of Act of 99 in India contains elaborate Provisions regarding the registered trademark being licensed whereas the licensing of unregistered trademarks is mostly governed by the common law of passing off now in case of registered Trade trademarks the statute the trademarks act provides elaborate mechanism of its registration and there are various advantages that flow from registration whereas it is not
the statute has not made it compulsory for a license to be registered there's another fundamental principle in case of uh a trademark license it is that the use made of the mark made by the license he always URS to the benefit of the licenser section 48 subsection 2 states that the permitted use of a trademark shall be deemed to be used by the proprietor thereof and shall be deemed not to be used by a person other than the proprietor for the purposes of section 47 or for any other purpose for which such uses material under
this act or any other law now what is the meaning of this legally speaking we say that what if a is the owner of a trademark X and A allows B to use x for its own purpose then who shall have the rights on the basis of that use of the trademark the law says it is a and b shall not amass any trademark rights on the basis of his use of the mark x by virtue of being a lensy so in order to summarize we can say that licensing is the most important activity that
happens in case of any intellectual property an intellectual property is created ultimately for its exploitation and one of the most important means of exploitation of intellectual property is licensing licensing is of various kinds like exclusive license non-exclusive license Soul license statutory license compulsory license or cross license now there are fundamental differences between assignments and licenses both assignment and licenses are contracts but they entail very different legal consequences a license can be analogized to rent of a car whereas an uh an assignment can be analogized to a sale of the car thank you very much