I think you need really high pain tolerance if it's uncomfortable to you to hear pain tolerance that means you don't have a high pain tolerance welcome to the Logan Bartlet show on this episode with you're going to hear is a conversation I have with co-founder and CEO of frame IO Emory Wells now Emory sold frame to Adobe at the end of 2021 for nearly $1.3 billion emry and I talk about his journey to founding frame Which included moving to New York without knowing anyone in technology industry working as a bartender for a number of years
before founding a digital agency that worked alongside SNL to make their digital shorts this led to Em's recognition of the pain point that ultimately led to frame we talk about a number of different things related to operating a startup including why Emory categorically rejects The Lean Startup concept and why he thinks it's done far More harm than good for businesses I fully reject Lean Startup it's equivalent to like teaching an artist how to paint by numbers we also talk about his near jobian obsession with design and getting into the details of almost everything he cared
about while operating the team is doing the demo of the thing they're going to ship but there's like always a caveat there's like 10 caveats what Pixel Perfect meant was not 99.9% accurate but 100% accurate so that meant if one pixel was misaligned or not centered or whatever the case may be we actually would cancel the meeting after those 3 four months I don't think I've ever seen a pixel off we also talk about what culture really is including a near fatal experience that led to a cultural reset within frame and ultimately set it on
its course to its sale to Adobe you'll hear that discussion with emry here now Emry thanks for doing this yeah thanks for having me so uh maybe for people that don't know can you describe uh what frame does sure so frame iio is a video review and collaboration platform at least that's where we started we've we've expanded a little bit since then but essentially um you know if you're a team working on video like this podcast here you're recording a video you go through a editorial and review process after we're done recording and frame is
The platform that that teams use to do that so you can upload the work in progress edit leave comments at different points in the video you can draw an annotate on the frame so um you really kind of everyone from Hollywood Studios down to teams that are doing podcasts like this we use it all the time we were just talking before I think slack maybe is the thing we're in the most but Rashad on our team uh he said this would be the single tool if it went Down it would ruin his week most so
uh I think that's a good place to be that means there responsibility stickiness to it that's funny cuz I remember in the early days of pitching you know the the common thing that you know investors ask or think about or talk about is you know are you building are you building a vitamin or a painkiller yeah and um and I you know I think early days people were I think there was a consensus with a lot of the early people I spoke to That it was you know was a nice to have vitamin and then
it gets embedded in the workflow and probably in the early days too I'd be interested who are your initial customers I assume VC's doing podcasts weren't in the Tam analysis originally it was probably a lot of media and yeah like agencies yeah I mean I think our earliest customers were well our our our very earliest customers were a lot of kind of individuals and small teams that were making that were making Video a lot of you know small boutique post- production companies and um but but yeah I think that media focused companies were our first
Enterprise customers and it's expanded to kind of like all sorts of people that make video you evolved this out of SNL in some ways uh like I mean I realize the through line it's not perfect but maybe talk about the uh the SNL digital shorts and how that came to be a part of uh frames founding Journey yeah sure so I mean I Had a post-production company prior to frame so it was a um a boutique agency that that did all kinds of post- production did visual effects and color grading and finishing mostly for broadcast
advertising like commercials and uh one of our clients was SNL and so I used to do all the the digital shorts for SNL did a you know for I don't know four years or something every thing that was pre-recorded for SNL is what they called their digital Shorts and that's their movie trailers and you know fake commercials and music videos and things like that so my company did the post- production for those and um we were I know I was working on those while building frame incubating frame in my post- production company amongst other amongst
other things as well but sure people remember a lot of those like Andy Samberg and Lonely Island and all that stuff what was the biggest one that you you it was Already kind of going before your production got in right so what was the biggest one you guys worked on that was kind of viral on the internet um so we I started working with SNL you know the tail end tail end of Andy samberg's time so they had already done like you know the the big viral like dick Sunday I'm on a boat those were
like the like three early viral hits they did but um but we did start working on them for like so dick and a box wind Up being a trilogy there were three of them so there was two more after that with Dick and box say it was uh I think the names were um uh it was it was one was called Mother Lover another one called I remember that another one called not gay in a three-way yeah yeah um and then uh yeah there were some other big ones there was uh um oh gosh there
was uh there was one with Kristen wig called red flag that Was a really a really big one yeah I remember all these yeah yeah that was like a dating one about like signs of red flags or something in the in the yeah was she was like in a beautiful Ballroom it was like a perfume commercial and perfume was called red flag and and they were talking about like I don't know you know what different red flags red flags yeah I remember all that you like her her pinky fingernail is longer than all the rest
Red flag did you uh did you get in with that group at all like did you get to do after parties or go to any of the shows or anything um yeah a little bit yeah I mean there was uh yeah it was a it was like it was a tight tight group and um yeah I was always invited to like the the um I usually I mean so so generally the way that it worked is I mean when the show was on airing we were usually still working so the whole nature of SNL is
like so live it's so last minute um The digital shorts you think well they're pre-recorded like we they probably do those well in advance no they don't they're um the schedule for those is they they would um they would shoot them on Thursday so they would have uh sorry they would shoot them on on Friday so they would they would have their I forget the exact schedule like they would have their rer pitch meeting on I think Wednesdays was the was the pitch meeting um they would have one day And that's when they would decide
like what they were going to shoot like of the things that were pitched and then they would have one day of pre-production on Thursday they would shoot on Friday and they would air on Saturday which means that we were working on them usually uh usually you know we were still you know putting the final touches on them when they when the show had already begun airing so often times like you know you're delivering The final piece sometimes 10 minutes 20 minutes 30 minutes before were you on site cuz I'm just thinking f file transfer times
and all that like how are you actually getting them the files yeah so no we were um I had I had a I had a you know my post- production company office which was you know 15 blocks from from uh from where they were from you know for messl and uh no I would I would I would upload stuff I would like FTP stuff to them And then uh sometimes we would have like random slow internet days and I would have an assistant that would like literally just like be running up the street with USB
with like with like a hard drive and stuff so we would ship hard drives I would messenger hard drives but then I would messenger hard drives and then you know for like for the the main delivery and then we would up FTP stuff like last minute for like replacement shots or whatever and then Sometimes somebody would just you know have to like Sprint up the street so we were building frame while we were doing all that work I mean that's the thing I think frame you know was very very classic founding story of we we
built what we needed and there was no question there was like zero question in my mind what needed to be built um I knew that you know the how we made video and our experience working with clients and back and forth I knew that was completely Universal even though we were doing you know broadcast advertising so um very much a product that was was built from you know a deep Insight of doing the work and and needing the product ourselves so so uh normally I don't like to go linear in this but you have an
interesting uh I guess story to New York so you grew up in Miami moved to New York didn't didn't do college you originally going to goip college skip college and did you always have interest In media and entertainment movies that's what I moved to New York with the intention of trying to be a filmmaker okay got it so so that was the intention and um you bartended for a while when you were initially here I guess any interesting things you learned about um the service industry or like that frame to frame from bartending actually I
I think that that being in the service industry uh I bartended for three years when I first moved here so From like 20 to 20 I moved here when I was 20 so from like 20 to 23 I was bartending and uh yeah I think you learn a lot in the service industry I mean you know I worked at um I mean a lot I'm sure you know it I bartended at at Bond Street sushi so I was you know in the lounge bartending this was over 20 years ago and um you know you in
the in the in the service industry um you learn to be of service you know you say yes a lot and You you have to you know kind of you cater to the to the people who you're serving and that ABS that that that absolutely stayed with me for years I mean when I started my first post-production company um you know I went from being a bartender to starting my first company and I had never worked in a company in fact I've still never basically worked in anyone else's company oh I'm at Adobe now but
I I brought that mentality into you know Starting my postproduction company and doing doing a post-production company is a service business and I I would you know I think the thing that made me successful in the early days is I said yes to everything all the time like just like there was I don't I can't remember a time i' I'd say no to to a client you know whatever they asked me for I said yes and and I don't I don't think that's common I think a lot of people are you know they they I
don't know they they Are they bring their ego or their I don't know I just I always said yes no matter what it was I said yes and I did that for years and years and years which meant you know my life was was was pretty tough for those years I mean I slept in that office I don't know thousands of nights really thousands of nights over the years I mean I had that company for almost 10 years for eight years I guess so post production you know it's a it's A very 24-hour business so
the big post- production companies if the big post production companies basically do run 247 because people are shooting they drop stuff off late at night it's like I don't know these things the postp production companies literally do run on a 24-hour schedule there's a there's a you know there's a morning shift a day shift a night shift and overnight shift at all these at all these companies and you know I was in the beginning a Company of one trying to compete with that stuff so I mean I lived in that office I slept because people
would call hey we we got this shoe can we drop off at 10: p.m. you know they'd call me at like 5:00 p.m. and I'm like yeah yeah sure no problem and I'm there till 10 p.m. and they needed something the next morning and I would just you know I would stay up all night and do it and I did that hundreds and hundreds of nights did you have an inkling of being a Software entrepreneur while you were doing this or like when did that start entering the consideration set yeah I always did um I
cuz you know one of the things so one of the the the areas of postproduction that I got really into was visual effect and the thing that I love about visual effects which I think is very similar to software is visual effects is deeply Technical and deeply creative it lives at the intersection depending on what Type of visual effects you can do eventually visual effects by the way becomes programming I mean you know if you really get into like complex stuff uh and so that was my entry point into into into coding I mean you
know you start by doing you know python scripting and then you have to build you know kind of more complex workflow so so my entry point into software was through visual effects it is not full scale I mean at least what I was doing back then was Certainly not fullscale software engineering um but uh but that was my entry point and I always wanted to do software I always always always wanted to do software um I never really I mean eventually I think the opportunity arrived when I met my co-founder and I hire I hired
my co-founder as an employee at my post- production company and he had um he minored in in computer science I hired him right out of right out of college it Was his first job so he likes to tell people that his his first interview ever was with me at my post-production company and I hired him and he never did another interview and has never worked anywhere else so it's he likes telling that story but um but he haded a a minor in computer science and and together we started tinkering on software uh which ultimately led
to to doing frame but we did other stuff before that was there a unique why now for frame like in the Moment In Time time or could it have been started a couple years before could it have worked a couple years later was there something special about when you actually got going I don't think I think a couple of years before would have been tricky I think even you might argue that maybe a couple years later maybe would have been better for frame uh but I think it was about the right moment in time and
it was um I think bandwidth played a role like you needed you needed Better B like video on the internet's gotten you now it's it's common place but but just being able to like upload move files watch high resolution video like all of that stuff um we launched frame in 2015 so it was about the right time to you know to build a product like this you needed you you know you also needed um I I mean you basically Needed You Know video like high bandwidth video to work on the internet which it was pretty
much working at that time and um You needed cheap storage and so like for the workflows that we were doing and and how much we needed to charge per month to make this a service that people would pay for and offered them enough storage to actually utilize it that it was probably around the right time but I I think that the first couple years of frame I guess the only reason it would have maybe been better a few years later and and this might have only been true if of some other players had come into
The space but we spent years kind of educating people about the problem and back to the uh thing earlier about whether frame was a painkiller or or vitamin um it absolutely is a painkiller and has proven to be to to to be a painkiller but you know sometimes people don't realize the pain that they're living in until they take the painkiller right like if youve just done things a certain way for a certain amount of time um because there literally was no other Solution you just sort of don't don't know that you're living in the
pain and then you know when the solution comes along you realize that so it took it took years of kind of educating the market at one point you had tweeted a bunch of different lessons that you had learned or some things that were maybe contrary to popular opinion and one of the the ones that stood out to me was uh CEO shouldn't get caught up in the details and you had said this is a myth And if you consider leaders like uh Steve Jobs Elon Musk Mark Zuckerberg Brian chesky and the cison brothers all are
slw deeply involved in the in intricacies of their businesses can you can you speak to that point and how um how you were able to do that within frame yeah I mean I think we we we we kind of touched on this but I think people the they people have the idea that a CEO is supposed to do business stuff and like I honestly don't even Know what that means it is the the most important thing that your company does is is build a product that your customers buy and I think that you know it
is your it is your it is it is the leader's job to you know to be deeply involved in creating that that outcome and I I you know I think the the the people who I think do you know incredible work and build the best products are the ones who are uh who who know every single Detail of what they're building and are deeply involved in it yeah I mean my experience of of scaling frame was that a lot of people around me told me I was doing it wrong you know because I was I
would if I would look at a design like what you know CEOs don't like CEOs aren't involved in designs and or they're not involved what whatever it is that I was that I was looking at and um you know and I think in those days I also I I was trying to because I never I Never built a software company I never really scaled a like a a large company I was trying to listen and be like maybe I shouldn't be like am I like is it weird and everyone tells me like I shouldn't really
be so involved and um I would you know would listen to an extent but then but instinctively I knew that I just knew there was no other there was no other job that was more important than than manifesting the outcome that you give to your customers and that comes Through that only comes through details there's not really there not really a high way of of doing that I've read that uh you've said something about lean startups doing more harm than than like that methodology maybe can you speak to that and I guess the derivative of
how it informed uh your philosophy around frame I read Lean Startup when everyone else did and I you know this was before I had uh ever built any software and I remember leading reading the book and Thinking at the end of the book like wow there's a magic formula that you you can just like sort of like mathematically find your way you know to success AB test your way AB test your way to success and um and you know I mean I subscribed to like part of it for for some time but but when I
really started getting into um building the company you know I think a lot of the people that we hired early on were we were all young I was young I was inexperienced we were Hiring young inexperienced people and I think what Young inexperienced people do is they sort of like you know they like want read what the internet's saying and sort of follow those those formulas we had a lot of people that were you know really trying to kind of Follow That That Lean Startup methodology which now you know sort of 10 years into building
software and and and having an exit and everything I uh yeah I I fully reject Lean Startup as a as a methodology and It doesn't mean that you shouldn't like use data as you know one input into um the decisions that you're making but uh I think it really has done a lot of harm I mean here's here's my my realization about startup is years later I went back and I I looked at um by by the way I think Eric Reese is you know a really brilliant guy um I don't agree with his his
framework but I went back years later after reading the book and I was like man I wonder what I wonder what Product Eric was building because he used his whole experience of of Lean Startup was this this game he was building and I went back and looked at the product he was building and it was I it was an Abomination I mean it was a Terri it was clearly something that was built by people that have absolutely no idea how to build a product and Lean Startup was you know sort of like their mathematical approach
to trying to build a product and that was not their skill Set so you know it's equivalent to like teaching an artist how to paint by numbers like you can you can do that you can try to like you know learn how to paint by numbers or you can learn how to be an artist and I think that product I think there I think product is an art you know I think that if you're going to if you're a founder or a product person and you have this you know company that you want to build
I think you have to have really strong internal conviction And you have to be able to see the world more clearly than everyone else and yeah like along the way like you should have data kind of start you kind of bump you you know two degrees this way and bump you two degrees that way but if you have to use that sort of um that sort of approach to to building software I don't I don't think you're going to make it and I think that I've seen a lot of the industry kind of turn and
and start to kind of evolve their thinking um because What happened was we started Lean Startup just built tons of really bad products they were too early that was the other problem you know this whole idea of like getting the MVP out and we've evolved since I think the market in general the industry in general has evolved past like like what a lot of I think a lot of people maybe were misinterpreting you know the the MVP approach the Min minimum viable product because people were just putting out Products that were just not good you
know and they're like well I guess it doesn't work and it's like well no it's just the product's not good it's not fully baked you know needs other things for people to um to love it and and think that it's it's valuable so um yeah I mean internal E frame we spent we did spend a couple years building it before we released it but that I mean I don't know that that was int I wasn't even thinking about it back then that was Just me and my co-founder because we were the only two people who
who built the first version and we spent about two and a half years building it before we we launched it did you pick some point in time in the future of what you needed the product to look like and just build to that was that the journey or were you getting feedback uh incrementally from other people from the outside as you were going along we actually got no Feedback really yeah so it's just it just hey I know this is what the Market's going to need based on my experience and let's go from there yeah
I we we actually really I mean we you know a couple friends here and there we would show it but we didn't have any any formal feedback for the first initial launch it was like two and a half years of building and and I don't think that I'm not saying you shouldn't do that you you certain should uh I think it depends On what kind of like who you know what your what Your founder market fit is you know I was building a product for myself of a in a problem space that I deeply understood
um which I think by the way is a very valid way of building I think that building a product for yourself is is a great way to build like let you you let let yourself be customer number one and and I still I I would still do that U if I were to do another company maybe in a space I didn't understand as deeply I probably would incorporate you know more more customer feedback along the way but no matter what product I build I would try to make sure that I was customer number one even
if I wasn't the real customer I think that you can try to like psychologically shift your mind and say I'm going to be the customer now and there's a real there's a real mind shift and I even did this with frame even building frame there's a difference between a builder mindset and a user Mindset and even as the designer and the Builder and the product thinker of frame I would have to very intentionally shift my mind and say now I'm going to use it now I'm going to experience it and I want to and I
want to you know experience it from the mindset of a of a user um so no matter what I did I would always put myself as customer number one and I would have to be personally satisfied and sort of you know do I like using this product does it solve you Know my problem when I'm in that in that user mindset I I I heard you say uh something to the effect of um as a company scales it's inevitable that Founders spend less time focusing on what really matters which is the product and get more
involved in process and all that um was that something that you made the mistake of getting more bogged down or were you able to to focus on product as number one throughout the journey oh I definitely got bogged down and I think That you know one of the things that also I was I would hear a lot from kind of my own internal Echo chamber and I think that a lot of Founders experienced this is that you know my own I think that that a lot of the company and again I think we were all
pretty young and inexperienced but everyone thinks the founder should be this like business business guy or or or girl right like as the founder you have all these executive things that you have to that you should Be doing right I don't even know what those things are the only reason that a company exists is to build the product that it sells to its customers and so I think that that should be the time that a Founder spends you know the the most amount of time on um and I I I would I definitely always stayed
close but you know it it got it got harder and harder to um I stayed close but I think what got harder to do is Is um maybe be a be a driver of of the vision as you know the company scales there's more people involved and this gets to you know like how do you how do you set up like a culture around decision-making and what's the founders role in decision- making um because you know people think that distributed decision- making is another thing that should happen as you scale I I don't believe that
I think that as you scale um distributed decision- making is Really just going to make everything substantially slower and worse it doesn't mean that people don't have lots of responsibility but you know you you need Clarity of decision making and Clarity of vision if you think about all the best products out there the ones that people universally love the ones that's like no question everybody loves these products whether it's software or Hardware or whatever the case may be there's probably a very good chance that Those are the companies that are led by uh Founders who
really drive like that singular vision and the companies that do distributed decision- making probably less so and I and I think this is you know I'll just say one one other thing about this is like I'm not saying that there's one right way to to run a company or build a company or whatever and this was a key insight for me I think that you know to build like a really world-class product It requires you know a founder or a small group of people to be directly driving and and uh and and making decisions but
there's obviously lots of companies that are not run that way that are incredibly successful and um and there's just not one right way to do anything you know there's just like lots of paths up the mountain the most the most important thing is that you build a company where everyone knows and Understands what your path up the mountain is because if you know you have a group of people that think no we should do it this way no we should do it that way and there's there's disagreement that's that's when that that definitely doesn't work
do you think that that the the point about um having more centralized decisioning leading to better products is it what do you think that is is it the consistency of the design and the experience is it Uh just the the more opinionated nature that you get from having a a more narrow subset driving the vision yeah I think it's a couple things one I think that you know I I mean first of all some people are better at making decisions than others right I mean there's people that have like you you need to find um
ra rather than Distributing decision-making you need to find the people who are who have proven over over time that they are best equipped to make A lot you know that they're they're best equipped to make decisions and be right a lot and I think that's one of the Jeff bezos's like leadership principles is that executives are right a lot and the idea that everyone does that is just not is just not true right we'd all have if people were like oh you just just distribute decision- making and um you'll have a lot of great outcomes
uh I think some people are better so you got to find those people it doesn't Necessarily mean that that's always the founder certainly not uh but you got to find the people who are who are best equipped to make decisions and then yeah I mean when you have one person who's really thinking holistically and again this doesn't always have to be the founder but somebody has to be thinking holistically with deep ownership uh about what every part of the product is is going to do and how it works together and inevitably you know When you
distribute decision-making everyone has squads and they all have their areas of responsibility and they you know they're they're trying to you know uh make great decisions for their areas but they absolutely have a gazillion blind spots of you know every other product's uh respons every other team's responsibilities and then how it all fits together as a whole so yeah um and and then just generally somebody that Has a really Clear Vision of what the future is supposed to be and someone that can be thinking about the micro decision that you're making today on one small
team and how that's going to evolve three years from that decision into you know wherever you're trying to get to implicit all this is an element of culture and how you define you know what it is that your business stands for you guys went through a period of time where there was a little bit of a I Don't know cultural crisis is the right way of articulating it but if if if my research was correct you you had to fire your VP of engineering and then three directors of engineering like all resigned in the same
day we had yeah we had um we did we did have some cultural crisis and it was it was over a short period of time but I mean basically um yeah we had we had three directors avenge which by the way you shouldn't have three directors I'm not exactly Sure how that happened no no we had three directors of that that all left within a couple days of each other um you know partially because we had some cultural crisis partially because I had already hired a VP avenge and and that person didn't work out out
and so you know there's there that is a a risk often as you hire you know when you bring in an outside leader sometimes the people who are doing the job don't like that new leader and that can drive them Out um I think there was there was there was definitely an element there but but overall yeah we we were we did have um some some cultural crisis and um and really was you know kind of a reset moment where um that was a big turning point in in the company's how far into the business
or how many people were you around then we were probably 60-ish people and so a couple years in Yeah couple years in and had you had you not been explicit about values and Definitely had not been explicit about values but here's the thing is you know um the the to me now what like what culture is is is very very very clear and I it was very it was something that I didn't understand for a long time um and I would always listen to people talk about it and even still I hear people talk about
culture and I don't think they describe culture in the right way culture is the is the political affiliation of your company or the Religion of your company you know when you think about I like to think about it that way because it's it's much clearer right it's like you think about a political affiliation you're like oh it's a group of people that all have these like strong convictions and values about you know a certain way of thinking and and and what we know is that you know two different political affiliations like they cannot work together
and I don't know I'm not I'm Not saying one is right or wrong but like you have to get a group of people that share the same you know political affiliation or religion the same thing with religions I mean there's some very you know uh strong shared ideas in one religion which would be not okay in another religion um so it's has nothing to do with like you know what do you guys do for fun and do you hang out after blah blah like that that's not culture culture is you know what are the What
is the shared belief system uh about how you build how you make decisions etc etc um and I you know I just in the first couple years of building frame um well in the very in the very beginning I had never even thought about this never never even crossed my mind that you know like this was something I had to care about and I thought well you know you hire people and you're the boss and they'll sort of like follow your lead and um I didn't Even understand that there was such a wide range of
of ways to like I don't know make this it sounds silly thinking back on it I didn't even understand there was such a wide range of ways to to make decisions that could you know lead to that could lead to so many disagreements um and so I W up just you know hiring also I was you know I was hiring kind of whoever I could get this was you know 2015 2016 2017 I'd say kind of Early in the you know sort of Zer cycle um but but you know very hard to hire I didn't
have a network I was you know you're hiring who you can get and um but anyway yeah we W up hiring people that just a large group it wasn't like there was just one sort of cultural ideology that existed at the company at that time there was just a lot of different ideas and it just led to a lot of internal debate you know in an unhealthy way and um and so we yeah We did wind up having three directors that left in in the course of a couple days and then you know maybe like
a month or two later I I let go of of the VP avenge and so at that point it was kind of like a big a big reset moment where I had have taken everything that I had learned and say okay how do we want to move forward and and there was three people I brought in at that time I brought in a new head ofe a new head of product and I brought in a chief of Staff and um and and a and then well later a new head of design but really those three
people at that time came in and and you know we really sat down and intentionally started kind of working on kind of repairing you know the the culture the team that was still there most we didn't we didn't really have that many people leave it was actually you know those three directors left and most most everyone stayed it wasn't really like a big Exodus Um uh and that and that was the beginning of a of a new chapter did you all was that the group that ended up defining what the cultural values were yeah and
and what and that was essentially my leadership group through acquisition and so what what did you find I guess in in going through that process uh and coming up with the values was it was it things that you think everyone mostly agreed with within the company and you just needed to codify it And make it more explicit or were these more aspirational traits like how how did you kind of um go about actually assessing what the culture was yeah I don't think that culture oh I think similar to I I I think that I think
that um I think values need to be potent and come from you know one one or a small group of people I think with any type of you know decisions that you sort of like lay on people you want to make people feel like they were part of the Process I think that's one of the you know that's like the magic is if you're going to set values you want to set them yourself but somehow make people feel like they set them or they were part of it and so the way that we went about
it is and I I had gone through actually this is we we had gone through a few so yes we we did sort of officially set values as as part of this exercise and um I had previously tried to do like a a a value setting exercise where you know Like we had you know we had pulled like that we'd sent out surveys and asked people like what they thought the values were and and blah blah blah um it done it a couple different times we never we never had rolled we never finished it because
it was such a like I don't know it seemed one it seemed unimportant and two the process that we were running to try to like set the values we were just getting such watered down stuff if you do if you send out a survey to your Company you ask them for values I promise you you're not going to get platitudes you get plaud you get platitudes back so uh the process that I wound up going through was uh we didn't have any there's no values committee there's certainly no commit first of all there's ever a
committee for almost anything it's probably a bad idea but there was no values committee but what I did do is I reached out to like 15 or so people that were um you know who had Been at the company for a while and and uh I thought were kind of you know important figures in the company and I asked them to to just overs slack I just said like hey like I'm I'm we're working on values again can you please tell me like the one only one the one most important value to you personally or
like you know an idea or a principal or whatever that's most important to you and when you ask oneon-one there was no no nobody could see what these you Know what uh someone else was thinking and you said just for that one most kind of potent idea I actually started getting some some some better stuff so I I think I wind up asking even more people maybe asked like 25 people and then um and I I took all that and I I sort of word smithed it and distilled it and actually had a lot of
good ideas in that um but I could shape it into kind of you know what I wanted the values to be and Then I would go back to that person and say hey I interpreted it this way or I shifted it this way does this still kind of align with you know the the core idea of what of what you were thinking and they say yeah yeah and say okay well I want can will you be you know the the kind of the spokesperson of this value and so when we rolled it out um I
didn't roll out the values I had I had a group I'd have like three people that would speak to Each value that they that they had selected it this was the mo this was the most important idea to them and so they got up in front of the company and said you know this is the value this is an example this is what it means so really it was delivered you know uh as if it was all from the company um and if I'm being honest it really was all from me but but you know
I think that's like a really important part of leadership is you have to make You know you you have to have like clear potent ideas and it doesn't mean that people they they they legitimately did inform inform you know those ideas but I ultimately got to like shape that and and have it be what I wanted the identity of of our culture and values to be um and and it was it was really I mean it was really successful roll out it took time you know like it took time to you know kind of work
those into the fabric of of the company uh but um but But we got there how many uh how many values did you end up Landing with nine was there anything you did in the hiring process then subsequent to that to make sure you were like did you have someone that was responsible for assessing singularly in an interview did this person map to those uh those values or kind of I don't think I ever perfected that to be honest you know we we tried I I would um I think I would I would continue Experimenting
with with better ways of of sussing that stuff out but we did we know we did we did culture you know we certainly did like culture value interviews the the number one thing that I would do personally is you know over time you learn like what your more controversial ideas are you know the things that you get more push back on and whatever and I certainly had learned them a couple years in and I when I would interview people I would Just unsell them I would just say like these are I would just I would
unsell them based on all the most controversial idea you know controversial things I'd learned about the way we operate myself and and and I would just unsell them on it and and make sure that they're signing throw it all on the table and say hey throw it on the table yeah like one of the things that was just you know I'd say that I probably had A I'm not comparing myself but I had a job Zan obsession with design I am insane about design I'm a maniac I didn't know that about myself until I really
got into it uh and I have that maniacal you know obsession with wanting to have great Des I don't even know I'm not saying I get there but I certainly have the the pursuit right I have the the goal and the desire of getting there and how does that manifest itself for an individual employee in this case is it Just constant iteration difference yeah it's just it I mean it's it's uh it's a lot of iteration I mean I think the difference between um look I let's let's start with like there's if you want to
have the world's best design it starts with you need some people that are at least capable of reaching there from like a hard skills you know perspective but let's just say that you have those People still getting to that you know kind of apple level of execution creates you know requires a culture of of um of of deeply caring and what deeply caring means is really it's probably just iterating more than other people and and not stopping when I this is actually the key difference it's the hardest thing about getting to like 11 out of
10 it's not even the work it's pushing through the emotional boundaries of People thinking they've put in the work and we've hit the we've we've reached the point where we're done and it's it's pushing it's pushing past those uncomfortable moments and and doing it again and then it's doing that 5 to 10 to 15 to 20 more times where people they're like you're you push people to their limits right and there's an art to that as well um because there's a way of doing that where people just burn out and and you know don't like
you at the End of the day and there's a way of doing that where people get to the other side and say wow I didn't know I I we were going to get there yeah because you can get you can do half the effort and get to some to get to 95 % of the outcome or something but then you need that other half to get to the last 5% or whatever which is unnatural most people say this is will this actually will the customer actually ever notice this or will they ever care on it
so in an Interview process did you was there any way of um teasing that out or yeah I would tell people I would tell people especially with leaders because I think I could be a little bit more open and direct with leaders but I told people one of the things that I would that I would that I would battle with is that you know I I would hire people who would be really interested in frame and think it was like a cool exciting company to work at they would one of the things You'd always say
oh yeah we you love the brand and the attention to detail and the design and everything and then they would come in and be at be in opposition to the very things that that created those those outcomes and often had the experience of like why would somebody come in and say we want to make the company worse we want to pull it down you know and so I I would tell leaders and this is something I I did you know only kind of a few years in but I'd say The one thing that you can
never ever do and I just want to be really clear is that if you ever lower my standards we're not working together your job is to come in and raise my standards I want you to pull me up like you you should be pulling us you know getting getting us getting us higher um and my you know my was was hard because my standards are really high but um that was one of the things that I would that I would tell leaders and it it is probably one of the Things that is like you know
where I I I get um probably would make you would make someone incompatible to work with me if if they try to lower the standards the the the best employees at frame if you were to go run it back and start another company was there a shared characteristic that stood out uh for the people that you had the most success with yeah I like working with people that have high pain tolerance and um you Know I think that's I think that like on the journey to Great you know and doing like doing great things um
I think I think you need I think you need really high pain tolerance um yeah I remember that tweet I shared about pain tolerance I I deeply believe that I mean I want to work with people that have a high tolerance for pain and I remember when I tweeted that I people said yeah well like pain tolerance sounds painful you could you could say like you why don't You say uh uh I don't know what were people trying to rephrase it as cuz it sounds like it's like rephrasing willingness to do their best or yeah
yeah and I'm like I'm like if it's uncomfortable to you to hear pain tolerance that this that you know that that's one of the things we look for that means you don't have a high pain tolerance like if you have to like soften it to to to make it okay then I'm sorry to say you don't have a high pain Some some of the most important things about values uh that I found is the opposite also if if the opposite also isn't true it's a platitude it's everyone will agree for uh it if you can't
frame the the the counterbalancing thing in a positive way then what you're saying is probably Hollow in in some way so having high pain tolerance there's probably like there's an opposite version of that of you know being inclusive or or Empathetic to other people's feel there's some version of that that's probably also true and you want people to opt into your way of doing things if it's true for every person or the majority of people in the population then you're not discerning or you're not getting people to opt in in some specific way yeah is
the design side of doing uh Building Product was that when you think about what motivates you and what drives drove you through the ups And downs of it was a how long was the journey seven years before selling to Adobe and now you're nineish is that right yeah was design what you came back to as the thing that most motivated you and most drove you through it or was there some element other element of building a company uh it was probably definitely design yeah yeah as you got more and more senior within the organiz or
as the company got bigger you stayed the same uh but your responsibility Started to become more disperse um was there a structural way that you maintained responsibility for design so that it didn't like start to be decentralized no I think it was something I struggled with I mean I did wind up you know hiring some really good people in the design organization um which you know which they brought a lot of intensity to uh to design and so yeah I mean naturally like naturally when you scale I mean you you just it's it's Impossible to
be like involved in you know every minute little detail but the thing that um so so this was the big so so one of the big turning points that we did and something that was really critical for my continued involvement in in not just design but product and just kind of overall high quality execution um a cou so like after we had the big reset moment and we brought in these new leaders and then shortly after that we brought in aead of design so we had this New leadership team and you know my you know
my objective with them was like we want to really Elevate the the the quality of of our execution and so we set up um we set up a a pretty simple a pretty simple framework um where we would have on on Fridays we would have what we called uh stakeholder reviews which were you know sessions to kind of review the work but um let me if if I back up like when if there's if there's ever a problem within A company um you know and this is super common right you're like you know you you
sort of expect something of the team and they deliver something else right that's just like one of the most common things you can experience as a leader I have I have developed what I think is a pretty straightforward simple framework and these are ideas that are not new they probably exist in every management framework it's just that management Frameworks have a lot more steps that I Don't think about so I just use three things which is um the key to changing anything is is you first you just have to sort of align on expectations like
what does success mean what are what if we were to all say yeah we knocked it out of the park what does that look like and the more detailed you can be the better right like write it down in excruciating detail and then get everyone to sign up you know sign up for it and say yep we all understand that This is what success looks like because now you have this thing you can all point to if you ever stray from it you have this shared understanding of expectations um so so expectations is one um
the the second is accountability like how do you hold people accountable uh or how do you how do you ensure that uh that people are aligning to those expectations you have to do check-ins you have to do inspections a favorite quote of mine that I did not come up With is that people do what you inspect not what you expect and so if you're not inspecting the expectations I don't think you're I mean through some process in the organization I don't I don't think you're ever going to get there and then the third thing is
um is actually the the accountability or the action like what happens if somebody is not meeting those expectations right you you've aligned on them you set you you check in to to make sure that they're Happening Now what happens when they're not happening and obviously like you know firing somebody is the most extreme thing you can do but usually that's not the right tool in you know that's a last resort to and so for us what we did is we set up these uh stakeholder reviews they were held every Friday we every we basically took
all of Friday and it was we had every single team had a slot on Friday they could use to present work but you Know sometimes they weren't ready to present and so they didn't have to use the slot but when they did have a piece of work that was ready to present they would use these slots and um and so as we were trying to change the kind of internal expectations of what we were delivering um one of the things I did is is uh when we we rolled out this program is at prior to
the Friday presentations the teams would come in and they would present their work I I would have my Leadership team do like a pre-inspection of the of the presentation and um in this case let me just clarify we had we had two types of meetings we had what we call a stakeholder review and that was they could present you know uh work in progress design or kind of anything to get feedback and then we had some called the build review which was like this was a finished unit of work and it had to meet every
expectation um that are you know that meets kind of our shipping Criteria and what customers would experience and so importantly for this build riew you know I don't know how many times you've been in in a meeting and I'm sure Founders can relate to this you're you're you're sort of the team is doing the demo of the thing they're going to ship but there's like always a caveat there's like 10 caveats it's like okay well yeah so there's this we're still working on this one thing it's like this meeting was to say no caveat At
what point do we have the thing that's going to be the thing that our customers use and that's what this meeting was for and so our my my leadership team would do a pre-inspection of the work to make sure that it met the criteria and one of those criteria among many was that you know we uh need that the that the execute the build the execution of the build had to be Pixel Perfect and so that what Pixel Perfect meant was you Know not 99.9% accurate but 100% accurate so that meant if one pixel was
was misaligned or not centered or whatever the case may be um we actually would cancel the meeting and that seems like kind of like not a big deal right like it's not like you're certainly not the same as firing somebody but it actually was a really big deal and because what it meant is when we when we rolled out these you know kind of the The expectations and this new program the build reviews we canceled these meetings for months I wouldn't look at the work for months and months and months the meetings were canceled and
it created a lot of tension on the teams a lot of tension internally um but eventually you know we we uh the team had to build the muscle and all collectively we had to build the muscle and which ultimately kind of became part of our our you know culture I'd say um that this is what it meant to ship product at at frame and uh and after those you know sort of three four months of of pain I mean I'd say that we won just like a cross the board radically shifted our quality of execution
up and I think after those 3 four months I don't think I've ever seen a pixel off I don't think like in like years I don't think you just you know it's one of those things like you experience with with apple and it's not To say that Apple's perfect but one thing that you know you'll get with apple is like shit's going to be like 100% po you're it's going to be polished right and now maybe there's other things they didn't get ride or idea but like there is a quality of execution that is just
fundamental like they can they there nothing will ever come out of that company that doesn't have that veneer of Polish and that's even just that forget about like all the foundational Decisions underneath that that's really really really hard to do culturally and at scale um and so we you know we we got there and um and that and that whole kind of Builder view I I think um it was cumbersome on the teams I don't think the teams always loved it um would imagine getting their meetings canceled was was it the yeah but just overall
the the the pro like I think you know it was cumbersome on the teams there was we we actually wound up getting rid of them as We were trying to accelerate our speed of execution after after working on quality of execution then we worked on speed of execution and and one of the things we tried um when we were trying to accelerate our speed of execution was to get rid of those meetings because PE teams wound up putting a lot of prep time you know it's one of those things like when you're when when a
team is presenting to a leader an executive or the CEO you know even if you don't want Them to put a lot of prep time you're like hey just show me what you're doing it's impossible yeah they will spend days and days they spend so much time and I've experienced this like now being at Adobe and I'm not the CEO and I'm not the boss and you know I and I and I and I have to go and present you know to to the senior leadership or to Sean T the CEO and you're just like
gosh I can't just roll in even if their expectations are different you feel like You're not doing your job if you you don't show up like but buttoned up professional presentation it's designed well the whole thing and like you know sometimes that's necessary but a lot of times it's not and um anyway we tried we tried uh we tried getting rid of our our kind of review process and I don't think it really accelerated us is that right yeah I don't think it accelerated us and I think that there was a hit in like that
that was like that was like these Gates that ensured we were always shipping the Quality quality wanted yeah um brand is an interesting uh thing for B2B companies I think you guys were pretty purposeful about the brand of frame how did you think about going about building a uh a brand in the B2B world you know I didn't think about it a lot other than the fact that I Pro you know I think I probably just instinctually built frame I wanted to make it cool number one like I just want I wanted to make it
cool I wanted to make it a desirable brand um I had never worked in Enterprise software prior prior to prior to launching frame I had really never bought enterprise software cuz I had a small boutique agency any software I ever bought was just you know something I could sign up with a credit card myself and um I think I built frame overall from the from the brand to the product and everything I I we started by building frame in the way that like I Don't know I would use it buy it Etc and so we
had this kind of very kind of more consumer looking motion you know from sign up with a credit card selfs serve focused on brand but I've come to EV you know I've come to evolve my thinking and I think there's people who think you know maybe brand is not a worthwhile effort in Enterprise software design is not a worthwhile effort in Enterprise software I mean I've I've shared tweets around you know how there's such an Opportunity in Enterprise software if you just come in like just like do like high quality execution you can basically just
win in any vertical and there's people that are just like hundreds of comments of people say nobody cares about the product nobody cares about quality nobody cares about design like that's not going to matter to the buyer and I'm like guys this is why enterprise software sucks you know because this is there's a belief system that whether you Know a brand doesn't matter design doesn't matter you know quality of execution doesn't matter and enterprise software and I and I think that that might have been true trer you know earlier but I think today where um
one we've seen this this big shift in the consumerization of enterprise software and what does that mean it means that like I think people's expectations of what software is is just different right like We all use much more high quality software and whether you're using software at work or using you know Instagram on your phone you just have like an expectation of what good software is and I think the end user within organizations has a bigger voice than they've had you know than they've had before like whether it's it or you know whoever's making the
buying decision they're much more careful about buying something that their users are Going to hate or not use and uh and so I think there's just been this big kind of consumerization of of enterprise software um anyway you originally asked me about brand we built a brand because I love I mean this just fun for me really and I I don't know if it's like this is what I'd say I think that anecdotally I think that our brand both our go to market motion and our our brand probably made it a lot easier to start
Enterprise conversations was it Just an outgrowth of your own style and personality or were there Frameworks or methodologies that you used of how to actually actionized people to to feel or was that just more innate to you I think it was probably more innate and um you know my background was in postproduction and and and uh production and post-production and film making and and so I just you know I'd want to use that tool set as well like we we were able to do stuff That you know maybe less expensively than it would you know
than someone else could do it because we you know I just literally had done that work for for years and knew the Freelancers and the people to hire and things like that so um yeah I think it was more inate you have a uh uh a methodology or style of launching twice uh doing a pre-announcement and then an announcement can you talk about that and what the benefits of it are yeah I think That um you just basically want to milk a launch for everything that you know for as much as you can and um
for most of our launches we would always do we would do a uh you know like a a teaser so you want to let people know that it's coming and a lot of people do this but I think I think we would you know maybe mil it a little bit more um so you do you know you do some kind of teaser where you get people excited and and let them know that it's coming um and There's lots of ways to sort of maximize you know that experience I'd say like if I go back all
the way back to our like actually launching frame for the first time and we use the same framework for subsequent launches but uh we would do a uh we yeah we do this sort of like an announcement launch and um and you know build a landing page and experience and a teaser video and then you know we' build you know lots of kind of gamification Around um you know like if I go all the way back to the to the original launch this is before anybody had access to frame and I'm sure we've all seen
like these gamified launches I guess you see less of them now to be honest but you know back in 2015 it was like the era of gamified launches and uh and so what we did is we um you we had a we had a landing page that wasn't just any landing page like we put a lot of effort into creating like an experience of a Landing page and most people you know when they're launching something it's like hey drop your email in right and then you to get notified when it's going to be ready and
that's sort of the end of the journey but I think that's a missed opportunity because when people are interested and engaged and excited and wanting access to something you can usually get them sort of do more things on your behalf so uh in the in the earliest launch we had this landing page Where you could drop your email get notified when it's ready but then as soon as you put your email in we kind of took you through this whole gamify journey where we had like a point system and we said you can do this
for five points and this for five points and this for five points and the more points you gain the earlier you know kind of you raise your ranks in terms of getting access some of them were like if you send this email and share with five Other people that sign up it was it was it was um it was shared on social I think we had I think we had back then uh Twitter and Facebook so we got you got points for sharing it on social you got points for um I think you could add
friends email addresses in uh you got bonus points for oh you had to answer survey it was like five questions and then um you got bonus points for following us on social and um we had like 15,000 people go through that go Through that flow this was when we were literally zero no one I mean you know it was just me and my this was our earliest launch it was me and my co-founder had no one else that were helping us and um and that early launch got like 15,000 people to sign up um uh
and then and what do you think I mean was it were you previewing on the land page what frame was and so we were pring what what what made it what made it work what made sort of the the viral Loop work was um we one We seated it with uh we did just like kind of Grassroots marketing like you know we were we come from the industry so our my previous industry was in post production so knew all you know knew all those people in the industry and identified you know people that were kind
of influencers that word didn't exist in 2015 I don't think like commonly but you know that we I identifi people that you know had a following and asked we just asked them hey will you I Mean like people I don't think people were getting paid to do kind of influencer stuff in 2015 I think so we just like asked people hey would you you know we're launching this thing would love your support would you share this um and so we kind of seated we seed the the the sharing with I don't know 50 75 people
that um that would you know share the announcement on on Twitter and uh and then um and obviously we did trade press and uh We were on the front we actually were on the front page of Hacker News because we were using a we were using a frontend framework that was new at the time for the landing page called famous it was just like front end framework JavaScript framework That was supposed to like their their their mission was to sort of build once run anywhere and do like you know iOS level animation on the web
uh we wound up using it for the for the landing page not for the whole product But just because we were using that that that framework we were front page on Hacker News and I think that you know that got some actually probably got more like um Silicon Valley types investors potential investors that's where they found us on on Hacker News um we were also in an early version of product hunt like when it was back as a an email distribution list um but it was all just through these like organic seating and then the
social um sharing flows and and It just kind of worked right so like somebody would would tweet it and then another person would see it they go they'd sign up they tweet it and we got that Loop going um so we had 15,000 people sign up for uh for that initial launch and you also did a personal touch like automated follow-ups you would reach out after 15 minutes or something to someone yeah that was that was really uh important as well so you'd sign up and then you would get an automated Email from me 15
minutes after and I think a lot of people do this now um but the email that you got from me 15 minutes after signing up was totally plain text there was no unsubscribed which I know technically is you know not you're not supposed to do that but it I was really trying to make it look like it was an email that I wrote and it was super plain language it was like two sentences I think it was like hey I just noticed you signed up You know um you know what interested you in in frame
what pain points do you have and I got thousands and thousands of responses um which I went through every single one of them and I uh I I went through and read every single one of them and that was and in them there were like you you know there were there were potential future Enterprise customers there were there were uh investors um and the one of those emails was uh from bellagi at at Andre he was At Andre Horwitz at the time and that was my that was like first contact with Silicon Valley I was
a total Outsider I didn't know a soul like not I didn't know an engineer I didn't know a Founder I didn't know a venture capitalist I knew zero people and sort of like my first contact with Silicon Valley was was this email from BAGI and I remember getting that first email and I'm I'm pretty mellow guy I don't really like show a lot of visible Excitement but I was you know it was I I couldn't believe that I one it was you know it was an investor who was voicing interest and it was from Andre
Horwitz it was like oh like Bingo um and that uh anyway you know of course I responded and that led to an introduction to somebody he introduced me to Steven sinowski but those those were responded those that that automatic response email um you really kind of like opened up these conversations with uh with VCS What uh what did you learn about fundraising so you went in and met Andre in the early days pre product fully launched we had an the announ yeah so this this this this launch that I just told you the story about
that was an announcement launch the product was not ready to use and I um yeah so I so BAGI you know responded to that email from BAGI and he you know he said you know not really my space but I think um but I'd like you know to meet my colleague Which was Steven sinowski and so I went in uh my very my first first first like contact in person or really I guess at that point other than that conversation with bellagi you know my second conversation with anyone in Silicon Valley was was stepen sinowski
for those listening I think most people know but you know stepen was the president of windows at Microsoft he had left Microsoft and he was now uh at andreon so that was I came in and I you know had A had a conversation with uh with with Stephen um which did lead to a board pitch at Andre you know some weeks after that but I uh uh they did not invest but you asked me what I learned about about about pitching um there was a really important thing I learned about pitching which was you know
when I came in first conversation with Steven I mean I don't he kind of knew a little bit about the industry in the space so he he he did get it but Um I mean my original pitches I think were all were just all were all bad and one of the things I noticed is that if you were to sit down and ask me hey tell me about frame tell me about the story like on a phone call or just like casually whatever I would I would tell you a story of who I am what
I'm doing and why it matters and when I but then I looked at my pitch and it's like well this the pitch looked very looked very different and so uh basically my Realization was if somebody just asks me about frame when I'm not doing like a pitch with a deck I I'm able to tell a really compelling story but my my pitch isn't there so um one of the one of the conversations I I had upcoming with a an investor who had reached out um you know typically and when you make first Contact you're like
oh so tell me the story right you're just like tell me about what you're doing um and I knew that my storytelling that I just would Do off the cuff I couldn't like recreate I couldn't sit down and think about it and recreate it like you just have to do it there's something about I have a job where I'm communicating to a human this thing that I need to tell and your brain just like Works differently so I recorded my conversation with this investor just my side of me pitching my story and then I took
that recording and I'm like okay this is the this is the narrative this is the framework so I Took the story and then I made the I I put slides to the story which I think other people it's just I've done this a lot now like I always just want to first like let me just let me just like talk and tell a story if I'm doing a presentation I try to just talk and tell a story and some I would do that you know with my chief of staff I would you know just sort
of or you know dictate and talk about what thing I wanted to tell and then go back after I had that Story and start working on how the pitch and the slide deck sort of Lins to it and then that made my pitch like infinitely better rather than uh people inevitably speak to slides and they just kind of go Slide by slide through it and ultimately often times slides are a uh an amalgamation of a bunch of people's thoughts and feedback all going into some version of it versus what you naturally want to want to
communicate um did uh in the early days you got an Acquisition offer for like 10 million bucks oh this is a great story yeah why uh what made you say no uh to doing that the first two people I ever made contact with was was first was the bellagi that that got introduced to Steven sinowski and the and the third or second person was um uh was Aaron Levy from box and he had also responded to that autoresponder he saw it you know wherever he saw it he responded he was like hey Aaron Levy here
like you know think what you're Doing is really cool so when I flew out to uh San Francisco which you know by the way when I flew out to meet Steven when I flew out to meet Aaron they weren't like hey come out to meet I you know you're I'm just like Hey I'm going to be out there these dates if you want to meet and I'm like I'm no reason to be out there they're like I'm not here and I'm like actually it's these other dates I'm going to be here I spoke right so
I went Out and um I think actually I'm trying to think if I what was it was did I meet Aaron first or did I meet Stephen sinowski first I forget which one but I went out same trip and um anyway you know Aaron was interested in what we were what we were building and uh uh I met him for dinner at Fuki Sushi on El Camino uh near the Fox headquarters back then I think they moved um and he brought like his whole executive team team too and um we had This like long my
first contact with I think I maybe had a phone call with him prior I don't remember but we had this like long dinner and then after dinner we went back to uh box HQ and I gave him a demo of uh what we had this was all pre-launch we hadn't launched anything it was pre-launch gave him a demo of what um of what we had built and um and that kicked off a series of of Sation uh with with Aaron who you know um I think was really kind of interest you know Aaron's background I
think he you know famously was like an intern at like a movie studio I forget like Universal or somewhere and he had always had this interest in film making and I think saw the angle for kind of what we were doing and had that fit fit into to box so it kicked off a series of conversations and um you know uh I I loved getting to know to know Aaron he's a he's a great great dude and someone I've I've stayed in touch with over the years uh but it did Ultimately culminate like I knew
that there was a I knew you know the nature of the conversations were like leading towards some conversation around around an acquisition and we had met you know I don't know four or five times um different scenarios um and I kept thinking you know it's actually funny is I think back about this this these conversations with Aaron I really only had two I call I guess kind of serious acquisition dances I had interest along The way the years but nothing that was like really real it's funny as I think back about these con these conversations
with Aaron it was similar to um acquisition conversations with Scott bsky where there is a dance you know like Scott Tad DOI who ultimately acquired Scott bki is out aob he ultimately acquired there's there's a dance where you're getting to know someone and you know thinking back to those early conversations with Aaron we Had met like you know four or five times and I'm like you know I remember thinking that I'm like gosh the next conversation's got to it's got to there's got to be like a serious there's got to be like it's got to
lead to an offer right because the the first year you kind of getting to know each other and all these things uh and so I remember after you know several several meetings with with Aaron we had a meeting scheduled I was back in New York I'd met him a couple times in San Francisco he was in New York we met uh somewhere in New York um we had a call scheduled it was like late my time it was I don't know 10 11:00 p.m. my time and I'm like okay there's only one thing we could
possibly talk about on this call it's got to be an offer and prior to prior to that call I called my co-founder and I said okay look I you know Aaron's going to call me I think There's got to be an offer right so like let's we I want I want you and me to be aligned on like what's our what's our Buy It Now price and by the way are you dual processing with VCS at this point are you self-funding as this is uh going on I mean I was just self funding I mean
I was just self funding I was dual proc processing with VCS um we didn't wind up actually getting we were not able to raise until after we had actually launched the product and then we had a Lot of early traction and everything but um but yeah I called my co-founder before the call with Aaron I was like what I just want to be aligned like what's our what's our buy at now price and I think uh honestly I don't remember what our buy at now price was but it was something like north of $20 million
or something like that and and mind you this was it's pre-launch you know like we were it was just he and I and yeah I Had a company that was doing well but like that would have been yeah that would have been a lot of money for me for me back then for all of us for anybody um and so Aaron called and you know we're having our back and forth we're talking and like okay let just got to get to the thing like when is it GNA come out and I think uh I think
he had sort of off I think he had offered like you know a uh a million dollars um was the opening bid Um and you know I I told this story before and so like I I want to be consistent as I tell this story I think I've told it like on an interview before but I don't remember what number I countered with but it was an absurdly high number like it was a number that you know he was just inappropriate to like 30 or I think it was like 50 or something like that you
know like something stupid uh And you know I think I remember his his his response was like his response was funny cuz he's you know he's a very funny guy tot he always always got a great joke and he was like his response was like God damn it you really are a founder and uh yeah so it um I think that uh yeah he in that conversation he was you know he was pretty I I think we got in that on that phone call he got up to a verbal like he's like look there's there's
the Highest number that we could ever acquire a company for that's like a pre-launched company with two people um is $10 million like the board never allow me to do anything above that and it's just probably wouldn't you know and so we and I don't even think I don't even know that that was like an offer for 10 it was just basically like kind of setting a just so you know demarcation of yeah but you used that and that was the anchor for the seed Round right that was the I used that I used I
used that and I I yeah so that was my anchor for the seed round when I when I um when I pitched andreon and then later Excel and and that was our valuation so we did our you know we raised 2.2 million in a seed round and uh a 10 million pre so I use that as our as our anchor for for the valuation Flash Forward all the way uh to the actual acquisition uh so how did uh how did all that come to be With Adobe uh it started off with the DM on X
then Twitter still the Twitter back then from uh from Scott bsky who uh yeah he just he just sent me a DM on Twitter like saying hey um you know been following you guys would be would be great to connect and I and I knew getting the the DM from him already was uh you know I think I think I sort of right off the bat kind of knew like okay This this is this is probably going to lead to some kind of interest in in a conversation around acquisition because I is this the end
of 2020 beginning of 21 it is the beginning of 2021 so I think it was um March of 2021 when he reached out uh the first the first uh kind of surpris you guys didn't know each other well that that's what I was going to say is that you know I mean one is Scott is you know really prolific investor he's you know really prominent You know figure in in in uh the industry you guys are both in New York both in New York both in the same space but yeah so I had I there
15 people along you know over the years had offered to introduce me to Scott and I always said yes I was like yeah yeah because every person I would talk to every VC I would talk to like y you know who you should talk to yeah he like do you know Scott you should talk to Scott I'm like great I'll talk to Scott but then it would Always just go silent so you know I think on the other side Scott was like no you know because he was at Adobe and and they basically you know
they were competitive right so he didn't Scott doesn't invest in competitive companies and things like that right so I I never um I I never met him but uh but then he reached out over over DM and uh and that that kicked off you know a series of Conversations similarly to the Aaron conversation you know series of conversations where it was like lots of getting to know each other lots of walks in the park lot you know there's a lot of um you know over a period of a couple months um before we got to
maybe not a couple months it was like uh probably six weeks from initial contact to a uh negotiating a veral offer mentally at that point in time you're running a business uh and you're Planning for a subsequent fundraise and IPO whatever the the things are and then there's this uh orthogonal well we were actually um we were actually uh closing our series D so it was like a it was close to $100 million series D that was all being done by our our insiders um our existing investors when the conversations started and Scott actually convinced
me to pause the closing to see if there was a a path to Acquisition that would have been a very unnecessary delu uh amount of capital takeen think to you know uh one my board was supportive you know they were like they were um they were supportive of pausing the round so we did pause it and um we did we did pause it for a little bit but we reached a point in the negotiation where we felt like we were probably too far apart on on valuation and so you know I had um basically thanked
Scott and you know just kind of Said hey like after we eventually did get to that first offer I I um you know said hey I think just IND indicative I think I think the the offer is indicative that we just have more work to do and so I'm going to close the round and um you know maybe we'll you know there'll be an opportunity to speak in the future and um and I and that and that was my true intention I I was like I because I talked about it with the board and you
know we I needed to Capitalize the business like we we needed to get this this round done and i' had been holding it for for a while so I reached out to uh my uh lawyers at the time was Gunderson was the team we worked with and I told them like we're going to go like send out the wire information and I think this was um it was Friday it was a Friday and I and I told Gunderson to send out the wire information but then I got another I got like another follow-up call from
Scott And he was like he's like em don't do it he like just give me one give me 24 hours give me one more day and uh and so I I called you know I called the lawyer back I was like hey did did did you send the wire information out yet like just no don't don't don't send it he's like I was just about to send the email I like don't don't send it so paused it for one more day and then it was that next day that we wound up uh uh having our
our verbal agreement was it hard uh through That period of time to to have these two things going on oh it sucks it's I mean it's really hard yeah it's really hard I mean because you know the full the full acquisition took um from first Contact in April to closing in October um um and during that time you know you're I I was spending 90% I I was spending 95% of my time on the acquisition and you know 5% on the business and then as as things progressed and it and it actually we got To
the LOI and we signed it then you have to pull in more people and like you know diligence is intense diligence for an acquisition I mean I've only gone through one so I don't know what other Acquisitions are but you know it's it's like a venture capital diligence uh you know but like times 100 I mean it's just like it it was it was intense we also as part of our as part of the acquisition we had never done an audit and you know Adobe being a publicly traded company uh They required that we complete
a three-year audit um and and and to do a three-year audit in the course of like a six weeks diligence period um which normally a three-year audit you know I'm told would take you could spend like six eight months even longer just depends on like how much you want to how much time you want to spend on it like we we did a three-year audit in in about I think it wind up to taking about 8 weeks um which was intense I Mean like it is you know you are digging up I mean the amount
of crap you got to dig up like some random receipt that like you know the Auditors pull out some random charge and you're like trying to find some receipt because you know in the early days you have like people are just spending on credit cards and whatever whatever um anyway yeah it's intense um I mean those that was that was by far the most intense period of the entire Journey was trying To do the acquisition uh while continuing to run the business also the business was going through its deepest growth inflection point at that time
um uh but yeah it was I mean I would start I would start I would do like a you know because because we were trying to run the business and the exec my my my leadership team had all their normal responsibilities we would start um with a exact team morning huddle at 8: am. and then of course we're in New York Adobe's in in San Francisco and um our we our Bankers we were using Catalyst they who were based in San Francisco and a lot of times Adobe would have like their acquisition update meeting around
like six you know 6 7 p.m. or something like that usually late and then so that was already even later in New York and then you know my my team at Catalyst would usually like have dinner with their family anyway I would be my I would talk to Catalyst in the evenings At like 11:00 p.m. midnight and and then we were just dealing with all of the diligence stuff like throughout the whole day so and I did that for you know six months it was intense is there anything you would have done differently in the
process or if you advising a Founder to be prepared for something that could be I mean this is the outcome for 99.9999% of companies uh maybe audit sooner I don't know what what yeah yeah I think there's a lot of stuff you can do just hygiene wise that you know if I were doing differently I would just know to you know have a little bit of better hygiene about yeah you should do an audit you should probably do you know a yearly audit um I I think that um I me trying to honestly like I've
sort of purged a lot of this from my from my mind there's some trauma compartment in there put you on a couch over here lat yeah yeah yeah But no there there is I I'd have to sit down and think about it there's there's a number of things from from a hygiene perspective like um just keep you know like the how you you know keep all your just like your Enterprise contracts keeping those like making making sure that you actually have like every executed signed like you know signed both sides the final executed contract like
you know in your Salesforce database along with the blah BL just Like you just got to have good hygiene like you got to I mean our we you know we're a little messy like we some like we're like a startup your startup yeah like we couldn't like we couldn't find like our fully execute some of our fully executed contracts you know like their side signed but then like we didn't have like our counter signed and blah blah blah yeah just a lot of little stuff a lot of little stuff on the way was there something
unique at that Moment in time that you felt like uh it was going to be a good partnership with Adobe versus going uh on your own or did they just end up making the compelling offer that made it worthwhile for everyone involved no it was definitely I mean I think I think a big part of moving forward was was Scott you know Scott uh belly is is a really um he's just first of all he's just like a really good he like good dude and anybody that knows him would all say That he's like a
good kind like honest like he's the type of person you're like oh I want to work with Scott you know like he's super likable um and he's a start you know he's a startup guy he he was his company uh behance was acquired by Adobe and so he was able to really relate and tell me about his journey of bance being acquired by Adobe he was also really transparent about the things he was trying to change at Adobe the things That he was like hey these are the things that you know I think we're not
good at and you know we we're trying to we're trying to change and you know would love your help with it and blah blah blah so I think a big part of the deal happen I mean no first first of all like the reason the deal happened was Scott I mean he sponsored the deal sold me on it sold it internally um and so yeah I mean the deal happened because of Scott in a lot of way in in more ways Than one um but uh for me personally he really he really sold me on
it and I you know I think also I looked at it as Adobe was Adobe was the natural home for for frame we didn't have a lot of like natural acquirers you know there's always like a random like oh Amazon somehow thinks they should be involved but uh in terms of a company that's like this is in their wheelhouse what they do like Adobe was the the company yeah so it just made sense that Makes sense like maybe Autodesk a little bit you know like they were they were sort of in and they were they
were kind of sniffing around around the same time um um but it was I really like and then but Adobe was the more natural fit so you've been within Adobe now for about two and a half years a little more than little more than two and a half years uh what have you um taken from adobe's culture way of operating that um I don't know if you Were to run it back with another startup in the future just something that you've uniquely learned from working within it yeah well you know I think that I'm super
great f for the experience of you know of working at Adobe I think it's it's a really uh it's a really great company but you know I think that I think the key takeaway is and granted I'm not running Adobe so you know it's not like I have the same The same purview of of running frame versus running Adobe but you know I got a seat at the table I'm in a lot of the important meetings and a lot of the uh exec meetings I was reporting I was reporting directly into Scott um you know
who's the I was reporting into the into the the E team the executive team um so point being i' I've had some prview and my experience is that it's not that Different and if anything it is it's like it's it's all the it's all the same stuff it's a lot of the same problems like of course like you know the bigger the company grows like the the nature of them change a little bit but the problem solving is is kind of the same and and that's funny something Scott sent to me during our our early
walks is you know he's like you know Do's a giant company it's over 20,000 people but at the end of the day like It's still just like five people in a room making decisions and that's true you know um so if anything I think it's given me maybe more Comfort or confidence that like I don't know I guess I I I think I could do that yeah it doesn't seem that different what's that Steve Jobs quote that like you look around the world and like anything you see is created by people no smarter than you
or something when you get into these big companies or You meet these people it's uh yeah and I think they're normal people yeah I think they're they're they're normal people and I think what I'm about to say is not it's not indicative it's you know in many ways the jobs that people have at startups are a lot harder there's a lot more responsibility and you know at startups I think that you know just naturally the scope of responsibility can be much more narrow at big companies at big companies Sorry at big companies the scope of
responsibility can be much much more narrow and um and you know so I I think that like I don't know I'd like to maybe have somebody have the opportunity I'll come back on and tell you after I've run a 20,000 person company like is it any harder but you know know from I think in some ways startups can be a lot a lot harder uh Adobe spent a lot of time thinking about AI I'm sure you have as Well there's been a number of different tools that have come out uh related to video generative video
um uh there's there's so rare from uh open AI Runway there's a bunch of stuff related to to that category that seems to be coming out um what's your any highle thoughts I know you've tweeted a little bit about uh different things Rel ated to to AI um being in the creative world working with design tooling it sort of feels like you're in the the eye of the the storm To some extent what's your what's your perview or perspective on like how it's going to impact the creative world yeah just in general any thoughts observations
um I think predicting the future is really hard and I don't I don't I don't Proclaim to be able to do it but you know I think we're a couple Generations away from seeing how truly impactful you know kind of video generation uh you know can be for the for the creative industry you know you You it's certainly potent enough to be involved in like a creative process and you can you know sort of do a a shot you know you can generate a clip and use it as a b-roll or or whatever but it's
still you know it's it's still tricky to kind of guide it um and when you get into really like what you know like professional creative workflows I mean there's a a lot of intention around what they're trying to create and I think that you know AI is it's hard to I think Everyone's trying to work on controlability like how do you how do you sort of steer this thing because it's obviously incredibly powerful but I mean I you know not not speaking for Adobe I I think of like over the next few years um it's
like I don't know if it's two years 3 years 10 years but there's clearly going to be a day where it's probably not so far off that you can really just like input a script And output a movie and probably be as good as like great great movies um and how does that change the landscap landscape of creativity I don't know does it lend itself to more I mean I guess inevitably it will lend itself to more taste in some ways and more like back to the original Point around what motivates you design and some
of those considerations as the functional skills maybe get up leveled in a more meaningful way yeah I mean I think Absolutely ta taste is you know I think in a in an AI in a kind of a gen ey World taste becomes you know a more important um skills than than creation there's a lot of people that have the technical skill to create but you know maybe their their taste is lacking and if you can put these tools in the hands of people who have great taste um you know I think that'll be it'll be
fun to watch and and you know back to like Great I think great things in general come from a framework where you have one person driving really Clear Vision and then you know lots of contribution for from other people and you know movies are movies are really really hard to make I mean if you it it is it is a shocking number of people that have to collaborate and you know movies do have like like culturally it's about like a director driving a vision but still there's just so many people that have to You know
come in and be part of that to make a movie happen um and it's so expensive that your ability to iterate or fix something that didn't work well like just doesn't really exist you can't really do that so when you get to the point where you have a tool that one person's mind can can guide and you know create a story around and iterate and iterate and iterate basically for free until they can find what they love I you know maybe the you know maybe we'll have Some of the best content we we've ever had
because you'll have absolute Clarity of vision it'll cost nothing to iterate and explore different ideas and um I think we're going to see a ton of cool stuff is there anyone from the outside end that was particularly influential uh to the business for the outcome anyone you would want to shout out or give credit to I will say that I had a really awesome board you know I think that startups go through tons of problems and For many startups board problems are one of them and I just never had board problems I had you had
Voss from Excel Vos from Excel Amish from first Mark and uh itai who was a board partner on behalf of insight but now has his own fund lgbp eai sidone um but those were my those were my three board members and um for a long time it was just Vos and Amish um and I also had um Chris from signal fire he was a board Observer he was uh also involved from but all all of Them you know I think that I really heavily leaned on on my board and I think there a lot of
conversations around like how much value add to investors bring and I don't know I thought they brought a ton of value because for me as a first-time founder they really had just like didn't know a lot about business especially when it came to really thinking about like how do we you know how do we think about capitalizing the business setting you Know success milestone you know scaling a sales organization thinking about like I mean I think a lot of I think a lot of the stuff I did wind up talking to the board with was
was on the you know kind of the business side the product side I always drove instinctually but I mean I thought they were invaluable was there anything you did in selecting them that was purposeful or lucky I was lucky yeah I was lucky I Think I was lucky yeah I I mean I'd say that that I for our seed round we had a competitive seed round and I wound up choosing Voss for Miel and I think I chose Voss because he um he did seem to like just truly get the frame iio value proposition the
best there's you know there's the the term founder market fit I think there's also like investor company fit you know in terms of like who really understand like he just he he He really understood it he was an investor in Envision yep um which was envision was similar to frame they were kind of like you know frame for design and Invision was ahead of us U by a few years and so M was as well right and M was as well so so I you know I I Invision was a great company that kind of
like set a path for us it can be so much easier when there's a company that's kind of like proven something out you know and I think we had a lot to Prove in our Market because you know there wasn't you know video collaboration like didn't exist and um kind of the review and approval Market was like pretty nent but but Envision had at least chartered a path for us and proven like this space can be valuable so yeah um Voss and Amish were both on the Invision board and they were on on our board
and but I think that what it what it meant was when I would speak to them they they really they really got it They really understood it so um and they're both great SAS investors both great B2B investors they work well together that's important too is like you know there's like the board dynamics of like do your board like each other because because you might like all of them but they don't like each other and that can create you know tension so I never I never had any any board problems the only time I had
a little bit of tension with my board was during Acquisition and that was because there was one board member that was really playing his fiduciary responsibility to like you know maximize the outcome and and I where was a little bit of disagreement on like when we should like continue to push on the negotiation where I felt I had pushed like I was on the front line of negotiating so I had all the you know kind of easy for their quarterback to say you should push harder yeah and I but like I felt like You know
I really knew what the limit was of the pushing and I and and so anyway but in retrospect I guess but it was fine we had there was I mean that was just like little moment in time small little moment in time so if nothing purposeful in retrospect uh if you were giving advice to someone and picking a board member picking an investor um would you Probe on how deep they can go into the space and how unique their actual interest is in the Space would you just spend more time with them and get the
vibe check and really pin that down yeah that's a good question I mean I think that um yeah I mean I think that especially you know especially for I guess for all board members um it's not dissimilar to hiring you know an executive like I think it's super important that you like each other yeah you know like if you don't if you don't want to hang if you don't want to go to dinner with that person uh this is Actually both this this very much applies to hiring Executives and it's something that I kind of
came around to uh a little bit later cuz you think that like n you don't have to be friends like that's not what it's about to like work with someone I think you kind of do yeah I think you have to like each other enough where like you there's some level of enjoyment of spending time with each other and I call that a friend you know Um and I'm not super I'm not like I don't I don't like hang with my employees a lot I'm not like friends but you do have to like each other
and I think that's important for the board like you got to like each other I think they're their conviction in the spa in your space their understanding of the space I think really really does matter and then and then I think you want to understand you know like talk to other Founders and found hopefully Founders That have it's probably much more valuable to talk to Founders that you know of companies that did not succeed or went through some moment of Crisis and understand how uh how how the board would you know respond to that we
did go through one moment of Crisis where I had to like I think was a you know the wrong board maybe would have led to I can't talk about the moment of Crisis but it was I think the wrong board what would have maybe led to a different outcome And it all turned out to be totally fine because um because we had a good board so you know it it it is a marriage marriage with uh not necessarily the recourse of divorce I guess it's hard to divorce your board yeah also I think you know
I've heard like other Founders where you have like a board member they're at of they're out of you know they're out of fund and like you sort of don't think about it but like they leave the fund they're at and then you're sort Of like giving over to somebody else or whatever I mean I think kind of understanding where they're at in their careers and you know their intentions of I I don't know you can really like learn that much by asking because whatever's going to happen is going to happen but I think it's good
to sort of maybe have a conversation around that and think about it um uh I think the seniority of the person kind of does matter uh it it it matters I think the seniority of the Person matters there's probably some people that are not as senior that are just as helpful running the business but the seniority matters in terms of like let's leverage on being able to get stuff done for future rounds whether it's them doing a round or helping you do you know around with somebody else or however you construct that um Voss was
particularly he you know Voss was actually kind of early in his career when we started working together um he Was he was he was pretty young but um one of the things that Voss did do is we work together on every single fundraising round we worked together on every single pitch deck we built every pitch deck together um every single one I mean I would go to his house and we'd sit down at his table and you know and and and go through the pitch and rewrite the pitch and practice the pitch he was he
was particularly helpful on uh on on Pitching well good well Emory thanks for doing this yeah this was fun yeah thanks for having me thank you for joining this episode of Logan Bart show with co-founder and CEO of frame Emory Wells if you enjoyed this discussion we'd like for you to subscribe on whatever platform you're listening to us on as well as share with anyone else that you think might find it interesting we look forward to seeing you here next week on another great Episode of the Logan Bartlett show have a good weekend everyone [Music]
[Applause] [Music]