about 30 years ago the landscape architecture industry began feeling the pressure to move from hand drawing to computer aided design or CAD they did so for better collaboration more efficient documentation and space-saving archives as we fast forward to today our industry is once again feeling pressure or maybe just being inspired to make a similar conversion to a more robust building information modeling or Bim workflow I'm Eric gilby I'm a landscape architect and the product marketing manager for the landscape Industries at vectorworks in this presentation I'm going to share strategies for your organization to consider When
developing a transition plan for Bim implementation from assessing your firm's current use of design and modeling software to meet Bim collaboration requirements and identifying where support is most needed I'll provide a series of questions to ask yourself as you carry out this assessment and determine how to make office-wide changes for Bim integration so with as much content as we have planned in this presentation I thought it might be best to divide it into two major sections the strategy in approaching Bim and then a section about the implementation of Bim so this first section is going
to address your firm's understanding of them your understanding of Bim for landscape bringing Bim to your organization and also managing a successful change so let's jump in and establish or confirm the fundamental understanding of what Bim is and what it is not and though you may already think you know what Bim is it can still be helpful for each firm to take time to revisit this and make sure everyone in the firm is on the same page this is especially true for firm members who have been along for the ride when they evolved from hand
drawing to CAD and now we're looking to move from CAD to Bim and it's going to be good to recognize the conventions which are similar and how they relate to the new representation in Bim so defining Bim whether it's for Architects Structural Engineers Landscape Architects it's all going to be seen as a holistic design approach it's not just about buildings it's not just about information and it's not just about 3D modeling but probably most important to note it's really not about one application and most firms are looking to move to Bim today are doing so
because others have been suggesting or requested that they do so so it's important to know why any of these preceding firms have moved to Bim and as you're going to find there are benefits that they found will be the same for your firm as well so from this image that we see on this slide you're going to note that projects designed in a typical CAD workflow is typically done in the time spent when the file creation takes place in a less convenient time to help projects change when needed without costing the stakeholders for these changes
but Bim on the other hand purposely moves firms to recognize conflicts and challenges earlier on and this helps the project development to move forward with less risk of changing direction when at least can afford such a change yeah so of course firms can and should expect other benefits when moving to Bim for example an earlier adopting firm Perkins and will noted several of these after they switched many years ago of those shared with us by Michael Lipscomb I'm going to point out just a few that I think are echoed through other firms the improved coordination
and collaboration sometimes we recognize that documentation in a cad workflow has a lot of efforts being made to make sure that a change in one place is coordinated and and recognized in another place and so in this case they see that that process had been improved reduced errors and Emissions this is actually interesting because sometimes the contractors get a little bit nervous about using Bim because there isn't a lot of wiggle room because they've gotten so accurate in how the the project and materials are being specified multiple people working on the same file this is
one of those things that we're not also used to unless we're using several files that are assembled together or referenced together but in them you have the ability to see other people working on the exact same file they just check out certain portions and changes Rippling throughout the project area so this kind of comes back to that coordination and collaboration but really this idea that a change Mage in one place actually changes in other places really pulls that coordination altogether and making sure that the referencing is really doing its its work as well so I
often get asked what Bim for the landscape is and do we actually call it limb or landscape information modeling or do we call it SIM for site information modeling and I'm going to suggest that for most people I think they recognize that the B and Bim which is building is more about a process than a noun and with this I think I'm going to agree so let's just continue with the phrase Bim for landscape for Bim specific to landscape there are site-specific features which I think firms can enjoy efficiencies by in this first example I'm
going to show here is a plan object and in Bim specific Landscapes you'll note that these plane objects have a 2D and 3D representation they have things called parameters which note their height their spread and even spacing so we're getting to know this term parameters as well because we're not used to designing by parameters or design used to designing by line shapes and texts and symbols and things like that but objects that have parameters that can be changed by you know changing the the factors that you're entering in or maybe it's just the the scaling
of the parameters but they they have these things that kind of control how they look and operate and data pertinent to the height such as performance tolerances sourcing this is usually part of the information associated with these objects and so this is going to be used to help make plant scheduling even easier so another Bim object in the landscape is surfacing so objects like hardscapes or landscape areas they bring similar benefits as well and so whether you're using built-in 2D hatching or maybe you're using 3D texturing layering components such as Stone over setting base which
is over compacted aggregate as you can imagine you're starting to build these layers up and this can all be included in a Bim Hardscape so documenting is made even easier by reporting your building area your perimeter and your volume calculations so another favorite Bim object for site designers is the digital terrain model showing both 2D Contours 3D surfaces these objects are more easily created modified and analyzed which makes site grading even easier to do in-house and we're going to recommend that you do that in-house instead of sending others to do it but still shareable when
collaborating with other design team members so if someone else has already created some form of surfacing or contouring being able to collaborate with them and work with what you're proposing versus what's been existing and vice versa so there's really several other examples that I could have shown for landscape specific Bim objects but you know I think you get the idea about what landscape Bim means and so one important aspect about Bim that can't be missed is a reporting so objects included in Bim workflows are intelligent so this fulfills the eye of information in the acronym
Bim and unlike tables and many General CAD applications you're going to find that worksheets are reports and they and within Bim applications are designed to harvest the data from those objects that are already in your Bim model so imagine having Excel or number of spreadsheets built within your design application and they're pulling that needed data or that related calculation and with that you have an idea of what Bim worksheets are and what they're doing okay so this is definitely a different mindset than most firms are using in a conventional CAD workflow and so you might
be asking well why and how should I bring this to our firm and I would imagine that the Y is more known than the how for example I think your firm is feeling the pressure or requirement from collaborating Architects or clients then maybe the jurisdiction that you're designing in is requiring you or mandating that you complete your project in Bim so the why is really not necessarily as much of a question because I think you're already feeling that need to do so or that you're going to be providing your project in a Bim format you
know maybe some of these are perspectives that you're already starting to feel so as we covered before there are a number of benefits to moving to Bim but we also need to admit that there's going to be some hurdles to consider as well and so I think it's good for us to note what firms have noted about these hurdles as they've done so uh or in the past for example time and money learning a new interface or software solution isn't billable so in the fact that a team is being trained on this new software they
have to be pulled off of billable work to be able to get this new workflow learned another example is investing in your hardware and software especially if you just upgraded or signed on to another multi-year subscription training we've just talked about some of this but usually the biggest reason for firms to delay the move aside from the time mentioned it's necessary training is not usually without its cost either so you're paying for the cost of people not being billable you're also paying for the cost of the training and then commitment wise does your firm really
have a clear expectation and goal on how to make this a successful change so you might actually be thinking of other hurdles too but those are the ones that we've typically heard of most frequently so once you have a chance to address how your firm is going to overcome those hurdles it's time to plan for the new Bim workflows and just like my advice to those who transition from hand drawing to CAD or to 3D modeling your firms should seek to know how the expected product is going to be similar or different than your current
workflow and note that the similarities will help to build quicker confidence about how the team is going to work and this should also bolster them in the new workflows as opposed to thinking that everything is going to be new and just like a real site design project this transition is a project worthy of planning because it's not going to happen overnight and you know just like other projects it's going to need some proper project management to be successful so it's true firms have made the switch to Bim and then quickly realized either they weren't ready
for Bim and then they reverted back to their traditional workflows or maybe they realized that their projects weren't really ready for Bim or that their approach to them wasn't really completely thought through so probably several factors that we could get into that have been the cause for an unsuccessful change but this action is going to offer some insight from successes that firms have found because I think you're going to find that these are going to be a value to you and your firm as you begin your planning so in speaking with firms who have successfully
made this switch to Bim we've kind of boiled this down to six essential elements that we've noted which directly Aid you in this success these are going to be Vision skills incentives resources action plan and evaluation so let's take a more detailed look at each of these elements so vision and it's true that without Vision it's going to be hard to implement much of anything because if you can't see forward to what you're aiming towards you won't know if your efforts are going to be successful so with that in mind you need to establish a
clear goal that everyone can work towards and this is crucial and clearly communicate those expectations especially the ones for the use of Bim and how that many of the projects were there previously not ready and then noting projects that potentially are smart goals I think many of us have used these in other strategic planning efforts and moving to Bim isn't really any much different it's still going to be viable to establish those specific measurable achievable relevant and time-bound goals so in fact documenting these smart goals will help establish a firm's Bim vision statement so examples
of Bim vision statement goals may be your firm's expectations for Bim projects or maybe how many Bim projects you expect to accomplish in a year maybe it's going to be expected or required level of detail because you know maybe the amount of information that you're providing can be flexible and depending on what you expect needs to be that level of detail your leadership's commitment to provide proper support and resources and then implementation timeline for one year two year five years you can kind of establish what you think that that expectation is for implementation so our
next element skills can undermine the best intended plan if you're not properly assessing it so aside from your proper skills firms should ensure that their team's passion and motivation are there too especially if the skills have room for development and one of the things we recognize is that sometimes firms can hire in this expertise which is good because your old man automatically getting that expertise but it's also a risk if that skilled hire doesn't share the team's passion or motivation so consider what training might be available for the Bim software that you are prospecting and
establish how best that your existing team learns new technology because everyone learns differently so often software companies and professional trainers can offer different varieties of this such as you know coming to your firm to help you virtual or instructor-led training maybe it's on the web maybe it's in a classroom setting and web-based also known as self-paced tutorials so sometimes you'll see videos or recorded steps that are being recognized by either that company or maybe even users of the product have created their own tutorials ah and then there's the incentives so part of that passion and
motivation we just talked about can come from incentivizing your team because we all know that without incentives we will probably work slower and so considering these options for your first few projects are probably something you should take a look at you know seeking longer deadlines uh you know if you're working in something that you're kind of unfamiliar with making sure that you're not necessarily expected to accomplish everything you don't know that you're doing in a tight deadline so you should also plan to expect that there's going to be challenges and that a project could fall
behind so with this extra time your team's stress will be lessened and then also you know only abandon Bim as a last resort you know the thing that I think that most firms are starting to think of is that it's easy to just get into it a little bit and then and then determine that it wasn't meant to be and they just move on with their regular Cad workflows and maybe that's true but in some cases I think it's it's a commitment you have to really kind of have to find that way to to stick
with it as much as you can and try to only abandon it if it's really your last resort and so reward your team when you've actually met the goals that you've established maybe you have something like a happy hour or everybody goes out on a specific outing whatever your team agrees will be that rewarding incentive and then there's securing supportive resources you know part of the planning should also include the production of resources that the current team and maybe those who are going to be added after the switch will get to use to get to
know that your firm's standards for the project work I've seen firms create their own onboarding manual and maybe even sample project workflows to help their new employees get to know their workflows well some of this could also be helpful for your existing team members as well but ultimately this is going to be beneficial as you onboard new employees also making template files and libraries you know we've already been doing this in a cad workflow so this isn't any different here but it's really going to be necessary for your Bim workflows to do those template files
and libraries and so hold them so that other projects will continue to build upon them and then you know I think it goes without saying that there's probably going to need to be a look at purchasing Hardware to make sure that the software or the Bim workflows that you're planning to go through are supported so if there's any kind of need for boosted performance in your Hardware definitely consider that you know another essential element is the action plan sometimes we refer to this as the Vim implementation plan and in this plan I think you'll find
that it helps to identify a project in its early stage for its first Bim exercise so early on your firm could also team up with your Consultants that you expect to collaborate with and then determine if you need additional software for example class detection and model validation we're not used to using these in our typical workflows but these can be helpful for landscape projects that are built on structure or co-mingled with other site infrastructure work so I think you can kind of visualize the reason for some of these detectors so software that we're not used
to using I think is something you should look at and again plan for that necessary training and then be sure to create your own internal Bim requirements because this plan will help your firm prepare for future Bim project requests anytime you have some of these things already kind of figured out when your approach to do Bim you can say well this is how we typically or how we expect to do or Bim so this brings us to the last of the six elements which is evaluation and just like Vision if you don't plan to evaluate
how things worked in your each sequential project are you really going to be able to measure for the success so we recommend an evaluative assessment as you progress in a Bim project so this helps because you're going to be adjusting it as you go along now this brings us to the second part of our major sections planning the implementation of Bim in your office so we'll cover strategies to help Define your new goals assessing your current tools as well as assessing your required skills and training and then ultimately the part about moving forward and so
when it comes to defining your new goals we recognize that this can be a moving Target which can be expected in your initial transition so let's take a look at some recommended steps to consider when you're defining new workflow goals to utilize Bim and so one of the first things firms usually try to identify in setting their new goals is how far into Bim do they want to go we've already discussed the holistic nature of bimin design and to take a brief glimpse into what landscape Bim means but it has to be decided about what
Bim or landscape Bim means to the individual to the firm and this is really relative because when you think about the overall firm's expectations if you're not coming back to each individual person and understanding their role in how Bim is going to be affected the whole team approach is not going to be consistent so the firm should start out at a lower level Bim should they work up is the firm committed to fulfilling a mandate requires a higher level of Bim no matter what the The Firm thinks that they should be doing all of these
should be things that you consider the firm scope will work in its design philosophy and its business practices should drive this new goal setting process as well so putting these into a chart or table form I think can really help frame those goals if you know from the chart that I'm showing here there could be more than one description of what Bim means which can then correlate to the organization's vision statement and then eventually offering a distinct opportunity to recognize where the move the Bim will align with or maybe even alter these processes or your
services so here are some sample goals which other landscape architecture firms have identified that help them in their move to Bim they expect to find improved landscape performance they expected to lower the maintenance cost and duration of maintenance they found that efficiency in producing specific tasks like estimates or material takeoffs or even making plant lists uh they found the idea or the goal of meeting jurisdictional codes obviously that's a requirement like site use tree preservation and water budgets but using Bim to do that so I think when you're looking at this idea of defining new
goals uh start thinking about the project itself the implementation of the project the project after it's been installed you know as we've discussed about the improved or the lowering of Maintenance costs even after the Project's been installed how it's going to be affected because you can make better decisions about what's being specified based on how it's going to get maintained or how it might not get maintained and how you should plan and Bim can certainly help you with all of these goals and as you get used to this idea of tables planning and goal setting
here's another example that I think can help once you're establishing your Bim goals then you can determine a measurable objective to meet and then provide a place to document if those objectives were met and if there are any lessons that you're learning from that so consider some goals that could be scalable you know maybe the size of the project maybe the not necessarily the size but the expectations of the Mandate expected from that project um later projects could represent a stretch goal so this is another way of scaling so knowing each project is enabling to
grow as you continue with each project knowing that perhaps your goals are going to continue to grow as well and where goals are seen to be unrealistic revise them to become more attainable and then plan for new goals as you experience or identify the chance to do so you know it's not crazy to think that some of the tools you're already using could be of some help in the firm's new Bim workflow so assessing for these will certainly help at least for people to understand where they stand and then where changes are needed and so
in this next step by assessing your firm's current technology use and design workflows to determine how to move forward with payment implementation and we see an example here from pcld which is Pacific Coast Land Design they're out of California and they noted their initial primary workflow and then what adding secondary might look like and then recognizing what a preferred new workflow would look like so you will need to assess the use of additional software evaluating the firm's existing skills and those still needed and then to ramp up the Bim planning for necessary training you're going
to hear me say this over and over again but it really is part of that planning process and then the resources and it's ease to move to Bim so as you see from these diagrams it was very explicit about how this firm expected you know from the design stage getting into primary workflows secondary workflows how they expected to accomplish their deliverables they really didn't want that second realm what we see in the second figure to get as convoluted as we see so they were starting to think about how Bim would actually kind of help them
streamline and become a little bit more vertical and a little bit more linear in a more descriptive way instead of more of that Matrix than webbed view so I think it's helpful to see what some other firms have done the same firm this is a diagram of pcld's pre-transition workflow assessment so noting earlier on that the collection of software here varied greatly from lesscad or Bim Centric applications but then that changed at the project matured so you see from the Genesis the conceptual the schematic each of those phases there was a different level of each
of these applications being used all the way up to contract Administration so their new tool assessment reveals that their Bim application dominates their technology use from the beginning through the end so from the very beginning stages even through the very end stages they're still using their Bim application but you see that there's still some other collaborative applications being used or some amending or some pending going on there's some visualization elements going on but they've really kind of Taken control of much of the work in the project with their Bim application so we can assume that
most firms are like pcld and that they utilize more than one application to accomplish all of their design and documentation processes so it's not likely that a firm could or even would want to put all of these specialized workflows into one application not even trying to pretend like that's viable since each application is specialized to enable and support each part of the desired workflow it really can be essential to make sure you know which ones you must have and with the transition to landscape Bim I think you'll find that in some cases it's an inclusive
nature of integrating 2D and 3D geometry its cite specific data the reporting the coordinated documentation and Analysis would mean that there are going to be some applications that could be relied on less and you know maybe even altogether removed from you know your overall workflow scheme or even gaining your firm efficiency so that can be considered you know maybe it's something that we start to figure out as we go through each project that we're going to rely less and less and then maybe in that year or two year down the road we understand that we're
probably going to be dropping some software so creating a chart like we see here enables your firm to be very explicit about the existing workflow details so that the new workflow is considered and then each portion of that workflow is not missed all right so similar to the tools assessment assessing your firm's current skill set is just as essential as the trend in the transitioning process and we're going to understand that most firms have indicated that the biggest reason why they resist moving to Bim is the need to train the firm on the new workflows
so they see training as a non-billable use of their firm's time but eventually they realize that the projects are awarded to other firms they're going to find out that oh if we're not getting into this Bim workflow we're going to start losing those projects and that's lost income as well so you have to determine whether that lost income is going to be through training so that you can secure more projects or is that lost income going to be coming from firms turning you away because you're not participating in a workflow that's required so with that
said I think it's important to note that in Bim modeling and in site designing firms need to separate from terrain and 3D modeling that they have different skill sets they are different skill sets because Bim modeling requires an understanding of your basic site amount elements and how they get constructed or installed it should also be acknowledged that having a team member that is proficient at 2D Drive crafting and or 3D modeling doesn't automatically make them the perfect or proficient person at Bim but those skill sets are certainly going to be critical when planning for training
because that team member who is proficient at those objects will probably be proficient at the others they just have to continue to learn those new processes in the new role so to be trained in a new role you know how does that get worked in and should that new role be deemed necessary so what we need to understand is what you currently have Proficiency in can those proficiencies be extended in a new tactic and a new role and then understand where maybe some people are going to be from scratch they're going to be trained from
scratch they're able to accomplish their new task or their new role and then based upon your organization's skills assessment and your Bim goals you may determine changes are needed maybe it's even in the staff maybe it's in the titles and the roles need to shift around maybe you need to figure out how this can help you with a more efficient Bim workflow and then think about who's going to lead this effort in the office as a Bim manager who can lead each project because they need to be asking these kind of questions too like how
will these roles vary from the existing ones and is there a need for additional training or additional team members you know because we've we've see what we have we see what we need to meet and we still need help in certain areas so maybe that means additional team members uh what types of training might be necessary for example you know your software your workflow your it um resources you know things like that and then who's going to perform the training and who's going to attend there are two prominent roles that we find for firms that
are working with Bim it's the office Bim manager and the project model manager so maybe in a small organization one person might have to assume the responsibility of both of those roles but really the office Bim manager's role is going to be similar to that of what you now have in the role of a cad manager they both oversee the development of standards and the workflows in the entire office the project model manager is responsible for implementing those standards and then the workflows on specific projects so the model manager also takes on the responsibility of
the model coordination and then with that of the consultants and then the quality assurance and quality control of the drawing output so in many instances a Project's team lead will serve as the the model manager too so as we approach the conclusion of this presentation it shouldn't be any surprise to know that one of the most key strategies in implementing a successful transition to Bim workflows is training I think you've heard me say this almost every other slide and fortunately there exists several methods for firms to consider as well as their team members and along
with any initial classroom or on-site training your organization should also have an ongoing continue education effort this is going to include onboarding program we talked about before to ensure that all new employees are familiar with the Bim processes their office standards and how to adhere to them so to begin developing an in-house training program you need to compile a list of available resources so so far we've walked you through all of the major considerations involved in establishing a Bim strategy for your site design organization and so the information presented serves as a guide for drafting
your initial or your further developing an existing Bim implementation or execution plan so as you Embark into the move to Bim we thought you might appreciate some other recommendations of firms like yours have been offering based on their successful experiences one recommendation is to implement Bim on a pilot project you know a somewhat simple to moderate complexity firms have also found that it's much easier to start a project in Bim than to convert one here's another one medium to larger firms acknowledge that their transition couldn't be done all at once they needed to manage both
a 2d workflow and a landscape Bim workflow until completing those that were pre-bim were completed another recommendation is to use the pilot project to develop a Bim implementation or execution plan so they use this first project to help them make that VIP or be EP dep depending on how you want to refer to it and then they use those Project Specific information to help inform that plan and then from there you can also extract a template for adapting for future projects another thing remember your Bim workflow is specific to your practice it will continue to
evolve and you're going to learn much through that experience it doesn't mean that another firm using their own execution or Implement implementation plan is going to be exactly the same and helpful for your firm so just recognizing that this implementation is going to be kind of firm by firm it's going to be Case by case it's going to be project by project and a lot of which comes down to trial and error and so it's important to document what your processes are uh what the results were that they yielded and then also conducting a Bim
debrief upon completing each project so much of the content included in this presentation came about from the strategic planning guide for adopting Bim and as you consider moving your landscape architecture or landscape design firm into a Bim process I'm going to recommend that you use this document to support your implementation so at this time if you think of questions even after the presentation is done feel free to email us at Landmark vectorworks.net