One two three in the 16th century Leonardo da Vinci after performing various dissections into anatomical studies claimed that the soul could be physically found in the human body specifically in the brain the idea was that the soul had to be where three particular parts of the brain connected the part where senses are received the part where memory is stored and the part where our will lives Da Vinci being an artist believed that place to be right here the third ventricle just above where the left eye and the right eye connect to quote the man himself
the eye the window of the soul is the chief means whereby understanding can most fully and abundantly appreciate the infinite works of nature but if the soul can be found physically inside of us if it remains consistent shaping who we are despite the vast changes our body goes through What happens if we were to say clone ourselves or upload our senses memory and will into a database leaves the world like we do right now would our soul be copied split into and what ramifications does that have for the afterlife if the Clone dies does only
half of your soul go to heaven I don't have the answers to any of those questions but if Leonardo da Vinci broke into my house tied me to a chair and put a gun to my head I'd probably just start Crying and tell him to play Soma Soma was developed by frictional games best known for 2010's amnesia the Dark Descent while the DNA of Amnesia is certainly present here this is a game that has an altogether different horror Focus the monsters do slobber and Roar interacting with them are stripped back to playing hide and seek
and the game's been criticized for embracing that playstyle summer is a science fiction horror game that is not nearly as scary As it may first appear but when we talk about Soma's horror we shouldn't just box it into how we engage with its monsters it's writing its conditioning its atmosphere and its Choice system is where is true Brilliance shines and if you settle in to play it if you open yourself up to it if you let it ask its questions and Claw through the Gloom for answers what you'll find is a beautiful introspective unsettling horror
experience where its most frightening Parts aren't found in shambling robotic corpses but in something more existential the soul is dead and Soma killed it it takes classic questions like what is the soul and what is consciousness and re-molds it with black gloopy gel to add challenging caveats and Dread inducing philosophical threads it's beloved by some of its fans because it asks big questions TM but I think even that praise is unfair to it because video games are still so infinite Compared to other forms of art I find that when a game like Soma comes along
we're inclined to just gush about it because its story asks big questions and some of the Praises levied at the game forget to add that the way it asks its questions is what makes it so impressive so a couple of caveats before we begin number one I'm going to be spoiling Soma from the offset please go and play it before watching this video is one of my favorite games of all time number two While we're going to look at gameplay environmental storytelling monster design and all of that good video game horror stuff the main focus
will be on Soma's story and waxing philosophies we try to unpick its questions if you enjoyed my Bioshock critiques or my forgotten City critique I think you'll feel right at home here I'll be drawing from a lot of external sources And discussing philosophers like John Locke and Derek parfit because I think one Philosopher specifically was a real influence on the game's message and that message me up in all kinds of ways so drink your Tracer fluid and settle into your pilot seat this is a commentary critique and philosophical analysis of Soma I am of the
firm belief Soma's story would be less effective as a film book or TV show through dint of being passive mediums I think a few things would be Lost in Translation the choice system is The Bedrock of its creeping our knees all of the clever cinematography in the world wouldn't be able to live up to confronting the terrifying acres in station Theta but what is Soma's most impressive Feats is in how it conditions the player to be curious Embrace a feeling of agency and harbor attention this conditioning is almost immediate are you okay okay I think
you're believing you're bleeding oh that's nothing It's just my brain can't stop bleeding from the accident here take this no that that's for later for the scan it's green Ashley I need to tell you something Simon please don't make this weird Simon Jarrett wakes in a cold sweat the year is 2015. he's just dreamed of the moment when he and his friend Ashley were hit by a car Ashley died Simon was left with a terminal brain injury and today he's Going to have an experimental brain scan that might just save his life when people talk
and discuss and debate Soma online they talk about the big choices the game confronts you with the last human destroying the wow killing Simon 3 but our prologue in Simon's apartment actually offers up three choices before the brain scan even happens do we answer the call from David munchie do we respond to an email from our work colleague Jesse do we ignore him when he Later Rings us up they're tiny beats and entirely inconsequential when Simon wakes up on pathos 2 but the overarching reasons for this remain the same the first is to tutorialize that
our choices do have consequences Simon's conversation with Jesse changes depending on if we send him an email about opening up their shop help our First Act of gameplay is looking at an unknown number and deciding if Simon should answer it from the get-go we're Being conditioned to infuse the game world with our agency and to think about the actions we're taking whether you answer the phone or not you'll justify the decision to yourself it's an unknown number it's probably someone selling the nfts I'm not answering that and this will have a natural Snowball Effect the
further into the game we go while the choices Simon makes in his apartment don't matter the fact we are making choices does and it's all part of Soma's Design philosophy I know we're well in the weeds here overthinking the first 10 minutes and all but don't just take my word for it earlier this year frictional's creative director Thomas Gripp had an interview with the site at level in it he was asked about the Studio's history and what key things they always considered when crafting a game quote the most interesting play comes when the players are
not really playing forming a plan hiding thinking About something they've seen and so forth these are often the key moments in the game and they're all in the player's mind but that's not not the only point to all of this our time in the apartment is here to teach us about moving around tutorializing the game physics sure but it's also to get a sense of who Simon is this is important because he's not a silent protagonist he's a thinking feeling person with thoughts memories and a history if Da Vinci was here he'd Probably want to
poke around in Simon's damaged brain but he would also absolutely argue that this is a guy with a soul he's quoted in guilt after the car accident he has nightmares his relationship to Ashley isn't one note is hinted there is something more there a depth of feeling that the game leaves unsaid his apartment is an environmental storytelling toy box full of award statues posters movies books but it's also a disaster old pizza boxes bottles Unwashed clothes bloody Rags from his head injury he's not well we need to believe that Simon is real that he matters
in the game world because so much of the emotional conflict comes from situations and decision making that he will later deal with and the game purposely adds lines here early on to reinforce he is a real person not just a stand-in for the player when he drinks the Tracer fluid needed before the brain scan he comments on The Taste saying That it's texture like milk but it tastes like sucking on a penny we are invited to think about his physical body his senses and how he sees tastes touches the world around him oh didn't hear
you come in Simon Jarrett right meeting Dr munchie well it's uh just Mr Munchies sorry Mr munchie Simon settles in for his brain scan the procedure sounds simple enough he's going to copy our brain build a digital model of it and bombard it with stimuli Basically trying a million virtual treatments to Simon's brain until he finds the one that will help his physical brain it's revolutionary it's groundbreaking it sounds a little too good to be true but honestly I'm not a scientist so have at it buddy say cheese in a flash of light David munchie
is gone the dimness of his office has changed now to something darker Simon looks at his hands and sees that they're clad in what seems to be a black diving Suit somehow some way he's been transported to a facility in the future called pathos too what happened here there are a few tricks Soma leans on to a nerve a player and evoke anxiety and tension for all of the metallic shrieking sprinkled throughout it's actually a surprisingly quiet game most of your time will be spent creeping through empty clanking tunnels and pre-empting threats rather than facing
them head on there are variations in how Responsive pathos 2 is where the game actively regulates his tension by taking moments that could be quick like a door opening and stretching them out to be achingly long the station is old and creaky so it makes sense doors would take a second to respond to our inputs there's a section later where Simon is on his way to station Lambda and a ladder takes just a beat too long to descend and so there's a moment where the player feels lost wondering what They're going to do moments like
these return a few times but there's always variation so it doesn't become too predictable before Simon even gets to Pathos 2 we're forced into an unsettling sequence in David munchy's office it's abandoned there are frantic notes by monchi asking where his partner has gone some of the vents are wide open and parts of the ceiling are falling apart as if something ravaged this space in reality that's not the case at all it's Just a rundown office building that munchy's renting for cheap rates but setting up this seemingly normal space is ominous makes the heightened reveal
of pathos 2 even more creepy the player is already praying to look out for potential secret threats before we even hear a monster and best of all Soma keeps that priming going for a further half hour before our first creature the universal helper says hello we see the Carnage it inflicts when it tears Through some metal doors we hear it creeping around on the level above under forced to backtrack after we get the Omni tool so a familiar space we've learned becomes unfamiliar and terrifying because the game convinces us there's a monster down here now
tutorial messages pop up to tell us we can Crouch to be quieter and avoid detection even though it's not an active threat yet you can blunder around the opening all you like noise won't currently get you Killed static flickers on screen a sign the game uses to warn us baddies are nearby but in this case the monster will never attack us this early on the user interface is actively tricking the player into thinking they're in danger when in reality this is a safe tutorial space that's teaching us how the Omni tool works and acclimating the
player to the atmosphere of pathos 2. like the others why are you like this our search for Answers reinforces all of that conditioning the tension comes from the lighting the blood on the floor the absence of people but it's also strengthened by the information we collect and how every snippet of Truth just leads to more questions we learn that we're on site upsalom a geothermal power plant there's lots of different sites Theta Lambda and so on but a pre-recorded message tells us that the site didn't really share much about the Work they were individually doing
for example a security operative John strawmeyer says that he doesn't know what the people at site Omicron were working on what is all of this for we learned that pilot seats were used by the staff to control robots but they were deactivated why our first exposure to the history of the facility is when Simon mysteriously Taps into a memory connected to a universal helper robot hanging in a containment chamber we hear Someone ask them if they can talk like the others did the robots become sentient we learned that pathos 2s under Walter were not in
space like most players will first assume considering the environmental design plays off of classic space station tropes why was pathos 2 built in the first place getting the Omni tool also gives us our first corpse sitting eerily at the side of the room with these strange black tentacles tightening around it and Crusting over it whoever this was they're missing their head what are the tentacles and where did the head go we'll stumble across our first wow pod these strange growths that healed Simon if he's injured long before anything could possibly hurt him so if we
touch it we don't learn what the benefits are mechanically this is the opposite of half decent tutorialization but horror games benefit from obfuscation from not being too clear in their gameplay so it Just adds to the sense of confusion and isolation that is so key for setting the player up to be terrified if this was saved the evil with him or Resident Evil Village or to use a more appropriate example alien isolation all of this tension would compound in a scripted ruling bloodthirsty encounter with a monster in rezzy Ethan gets his fingers chewed off in
The Evil Within there's an on Rails Chase from the sadist in Alien we get up close and personal with the Xenomorph so we can appreciate their threat but Soma's first introduction to his creatures the climax of all of this work is much sadder we find a robot called a Mockingbird plugged into a console it's draining the electricity and if we want to access that console we need to unplug it Simon doesn't say a word he doesn't matter to himself huh I better turn that console on it's left entirely up to the player to look at
this scene and realize entirely on their Own that they need to unplug the robot no problem right easy peasy let me just pull this chord out and what was that did it just speak probably my imagination oh oh that didn't feel good at all it's entirely up to you if this Act made you feel guilty or not but whether it did or didn't the game wants you to justify unplugging the robot in a matter sense you could just say that it's the only way to progress there's no way to carry On with the story and
keep this robot alive and in fact it's the only moment in the game where it looks like the player has a choice when in reality they don't but I think that justification is kind of uninteresting considering all the work Soma has done over the past hour to immerse you Simon will always unplug the robot we've killed something that seemed to have thoughts and feelings the game wants you to consider how you feel about that the placing of This moment is explicit we still haven't met a monster yet but everything the environmental storytelling is teaching us
leads to the conclusion that the robots are probably the problem here and after all they are just a robot it's not like we killed a person right it claimed it was Happy Just siphoning Energy from the console is this really a quality of life we should be concerned with preserving bear this in mind by the way sanctity of life versus quality of life Comes back again and again there's lots of ways a player can shake off any potential guilt this early on and it's easy to shake off when a friendly human Voice pops up on
the console anyone there hey hey can you hear me this is Catherine our voice in the ear that will guide Simon on his wet squelchy metallic Adventure she's based at site Lambda and for now the two of them can't communicate if we want to get some real answers Simon has to get to The calm Center Catherine aside from being utterly fascinating also embodies one of the ways Soma conditions fear her inclusion breeds a sense of isolation she can only speak to us when we plug the Omni tool into a control panel so there are long
stretches of time where we have nothing no friends no guidance she's not always in our ear like say Atlas in BioShock keeping us motivated with a friendly Irish jingle especially later in the game we can go up to a full Hour without her if we're exploring thoroughly meaning we have more time left with our thoughts questions and Curiosities as well as being very much alone when facing monsters there's a distinct sense of security and safety whenever Catherine pops up on a console because the spaces are usually well lit and our conversations are never interrupted by
a gnarly screaming thing it means there's an AB and flow to the horror similar to how say a safe room is Used in Resident Evil the irony in all this is that Soma wasn't always a horror game at least in the conceptual phase in an interview with Ang Gadget one of the programmers Ian Thomas said quote I think there is a phase in really early development when they weren't even sure that it was going to be a horror at all they knew the story they wanted to tell but was it going to be in a
horror framework then I think it just came back to that's what the company does Frictional does horror well the Dark Descent spawned thousands of clones the bunker has been a surprise hit in a year dominated by popular horror experiences unpredictability are those game's greatest assets and Soma is no different to be frank I find the Dark Descent sanity system obnoxious rather than truly terrifying but the fact it's not just in-game threats that trigger it means it never becomes a predictable signal that there's a monster nearby Soma does the same thing the chromatic aberration that triggers
when we look at an enemy will also trigger randomly haphazardly or when Simon gets too close to a powerful part of the wow artificial intelligence and what this means is it's a horror game that never announces the frights to you my number one rule when assessing the effectiveness of a horror title this philosophy leaks through in other places as well sometimes without announcement parts of pathos 2 will just Change for example when we explore Theta we see this door with what looks like blood pooling underneath it when we return to the door later it's now
a jar we didn't hear a monster rip out of here maybe a monster didn't do this maybe the lock and the door just deactivated but it's more than enough to put a chill in our step or what about here when we're investigating the quarters of the chief Factor Terry Acres all of the shrieking bloodthirsty creatures in the world Can't hold a candle to the tension that builds when we can't open a locker with blood leaking out of its vent good visual disturbances like this will often lead to unanswerable questions why is blood coming out of
this Locker why is it locked we'll look at a few more examples as we work through the game but what I really want to hammer home here at the start is that solma doesn't just condition fear in its opening it constantly returns to these tactics Again and again as the game progresses meaning when it bursts open and puts Simon's life in danger the threat the Panic the catharsis the good horror gives us explodes coaching the game in Black sticky Terror figured out what's going on yet me I was hoping you'd have some answers I probably
have some what do you want to know where do you even begin I mean what is this place how did I get here and why did the robots talk like they're people Well you're at Epsilon clearly Simon Jarrett meet Joss Catherine she tells us that the year is 21.04 a comet called Telus hit Earth and wiped out all life on the surface of the planet pathos 2 contain the last of humanity but an artificial intelligence called the wow that was set up to keep everyone alive has gotten out of control it is keeping people alive
but it's using a substance called structure gel to do so and is completely transforming people and Robots turning some of them into crazy deranged monsters so is cytop Salon falls apart and Simon is blasted into the deep dark vastness of the ocean we're going to look at those monsters but first let's jump back about 15 minutes because there's someone I've failed to mention we need to talk about Carl foreign 1962 the neuroscientists David hubel and torson weasel published a study on the Relationship between the eyes and the Brain their work inspired something called binocular disparity
Theory this is the idea that there is a disparity between the information our eyes send to the brain and how our brain interprets that information imagine you look through a pair of binoculars and the left binocular shows a chair and the right binocular shows a house when you do this your brain doesn't merge the chair in the house into one image and Create some crazy chair house hybrid despite the fact both eyes are connected so that hybrid technically should be all we see the brain is smarter than that and how it interprets the information the
eyes send over no the signals from each eye are sent separately and your brain is able to understand that the left binocular shows a chair and the right binocular shows a house basically what hubel and weasel's work proved was that the stuff we see in the physical World is not always the same as how our brain inter prints it what does this have to do with Soma well meet Carl sampkin what are you are you blind it's me [Music] Wrangler any of this sound familiar to you I no actually oh thanks for being so helpful
it's not like I'm knocked out on the floor or anything to get access to the communications Tower Simon needs to turn On some power to unlock a door but unfortunately this robot claiming his name is Carl is blocking the power cable he's trapped under a machine and the player is given a choice either we siphon the power through Carl which will electrocute him and leave him in a constant state of pain or we divert the power away from him which will kill him completely so what do you do talking to Carl we see an extreme
version of binocular disparity theory he doesn't Think he's a robot he thinks he's a human man even looks down at his metal parts and waves what he thinks are hands at us he seems to be experiencing a strong sense of discomfort because he's trapped and if we do electrocute him he screams at the top of his lungs in a really disturbing way despite the fact his robot body doesn't have nerve endings he is experiencing pain there's clearly a separation between Carl's senses and what his brain is telling him But he's not living in a Dreamland
Carl is very aware of the room he's in of Simon's presence in fact the spoiler later reveal Carl is able to tell that Simon doesn't look human himself we're just robot Parts glued into a diving suit and Carl comments on this he still has memories he references colleagues like Amy azaro for all intents and purposes Carl behaves thinks and feels the same way a human being would he just doesn't think he has a robot body Carl Tells us that his last memory was being in a pilot seat controlling a universal helper the robot we're speaking
to right now your mind is pretty tightly wired to the robot he says we later learned that when you're plugged into a pilot seat you detach your brain from your physical body your memory keeps you from going insane there's still a conscious awareness that you are sitting in a chair controlling a robot rather than becoming a robot but that sensory input Is numbed so your focus is on the robot itself the pilot seat is in the right binocular the robot is in the left I was just dealing with some heat shields and that's my last
clay memory at first glance it seems like Carl just like the robot from the console earlier has become sentient believing itself to be the real Carl samkin but that's silly right maybe Carl must be stuck in a pilot seat somewhere and somehow he's Feeling all of the pain of this Universal helper something's gone wrong in his mind's connection to the robot so now he thinks he is the robot right but in minutes that theory is banished the real Carl samkin the human Carl is dead we find his body slumped up against the wall a name
tag confirms his identity all that's left is this robot claiming that he's Carl somehow this robot just like all of the robots on the station has downloaded the entire Mind of a Human being so what do we do we either need to put this robot in a Perpetual state of pain possibly for hundreds of years until the power goes out or we kill it well there's a third option if we electrocute Carl and his screaming makes us immediately regret it we can stop shocking him but if you wait too long you'll put him into a
vegetative state not dead not an eternal pain but he's what today's medicine would diagnose as minimally conscious I've Been using and will continue to use phrases like the soul the self and Consciousness interchangeably as the video goes on whether that's right or wrong is for you to decide but it helps keep us all on the same page as I raise various philosophers neuroscientists psychologists and the like in this context they all mean basically the same thing who we are not what we are so with that in mind does Carl samkin have a self a soul
or a Consciousness in this Vegetative state let's jump back to 2003 and the philosopher Robert pasno because what he says is really interesting quote a human being goes out of existence before all life comes to an end in that case the rational Soul would give way to a merely sensory Soul or even to a merely nutritive Soul he's building off of The Works of Saint Thomas Aquarium here but remolding it for a modern audience the soul goes through three stages he says rational which is Probably what you're experiencing right now you're listening to this video
and your rational brain is adding context opinions and personal thoughts and you might eventually even turn that into action such as liking the video and subscribing to the channel then there's the sensory Soul where you are taking in the world but your brain isn't doing anything with that information yet think a baby when it's born light is bright it has an instinctual reaction to it so it Cries but there's no rational thought behind our light and ah I will cry to make it stop and then the vegetative Soul this is where someone is in a
coma or minimal Consciousness your soul is basically just a life force keeping you alive you could say that Carl sampkin is in that latter stage but is that the case really hey hello because it's not Carl's Consciousness that's keeping him alive it's the wow this artificial Intelligence that's keeping his robot body powered up despite the electricity we just fried him with Carl's brain his motherboard his circuitry has nothing to do with keeping him alive so if Carl doesn't have a vegetative soul and he definitely doesn't have a rational or sensory Soul what's left does he
have a soul no really does he I don't know our answer strangely might come in the form of tennis in 2010 Dr Adrian Owen Conducted an experiment on a man who had been in a coma for seven years following a car accident he was trying to find a way to communicate with him we've all heard the stories of people with brain injuries who can blink once for yes and twice for no but the damage was so severe that not even that was possible Owen devised a technique to enable the man to answer yes and no
to simple questions through the use of a high-tech scanner monitoring his brain activity to Answer yes he was told to imagine playing tennis a motor activity to answer no he was told to think of wandering from room to room in his home visualizing everything he would expect to see there creating activity in the part of the brain governing spatial awareness and memory this worked completely the man was able to answer questions about his family he was able to imagine playing tennis quite literally the parts of his brain that Focused on memory and Imagination LED up
on the scanner like a Christmas tree this is the kind of soul that Robert Pano failed to consider and while we don't know for certain if Carl sent King can still imagine anything or remember anything in his vegetative state we do know that robots like him are capable of those things Simon and Catherine are just like Carl and they dream and imagine quite a lot in the second half of the game regardless of the Implications on the soul Soma is once again asking us to consider the sanctity of life versus quality of life as far
as we know this is the last version of Carl semkin the human version died so now there's a trapped robotic version is a life in pain a life worth living is a life comatose a life worth living every time I play the game I do something different for this playthrough I turned off the power people don't give enough credit to Soma's monsters yeah I said it I think these are some of the most interesting enemy designs frictional have ever created and I'm including the horrifying Clarence from penumbra black plague in that they encapsulate the game's
theme of body vs soul in a way that I think is easily missed when we're creeping around them or hiding behind desks but the way they evolve over the span of the game is to be frank awesome no not you too Was really hoping you were human setback after setback Spurs on Simon's Journey Beneath the Sea he's blasted into the abyss of the ocean finds a shuttle that can take him to station Lambda that shuttle then crashes seriously the guy can't catch a break but eventually he makes it to where Catherine is waiting for us
she's a robot too just like Carl was but strangely she seems to be aware of that fact and is kind of cold to Simon if he Tells her he killed Carl don't worry she says it was just a robot Catherine experiences states of being and not being her Consciousness pauses when Simon uploads her to the Omni tool but she retains all of her memories every time so what she gets is a kind of continuation that keeps stuttering and going dark Simon takes the cortex chip that holds her Consciousness out of the robot and plugs it
into the Omni tool so she can come with us he doesn't copy Catherine's Soul he quite literally moves it like taking someone's brain and physically attaching it to a new body she doesn't seem to mind she Embraces her Newfound existence clinically this is just the way things are all she cares about is her project the ark the ark is a digital world holding the brain scans of almost everyone who worked on pathos 2. the plan is to load it into a railgun and shoot it into space where the power of the sun will keep it
powered on for Thousands of years it's a digital afterlife a matrix so our goal is simple find the ark upload Simon and Catherine to it and shoot it into space eternity Among the Stars Humanity's Last Hope seeing as pathos 2 is a robotic hellscape also Catherine Albert states that Simon is just a brain scan in a robot body but Simon still doesn't seem to understand I get that a lot of players might be annoyed at Simon for not wrapping his head around the game's Core concept straight away but honestly I find his idiocy kind of
endearing and the fact he doesn't fully understand that a he's in a robot body and B that he's a copy of the original Simon rather than a continuation of him makes those later reveals feel way more emotional than if he figured all out so early on again this is a story about Simon he's not just a vassal for the player and being one step ahead of him doesn't necessarily diminish the power of the Game's more harrowing questions if anything I think it adds a lot of pity and sympathy because we know A Dark Truth that
he doesn't I found it it's at a site named Tau oh it's the most there's so much to build a future if we got to it could could we get on the ark for the next hour of play Simon is stalked by Soma's second monster the flesher it's more humanoid than the universal helper we encountered at Cytopsalom that thing was more like a t-rex with its tiny wiggling arms and thick clomping legs when it spoke it was speaking a heavily reconstructed English it swore it muttered things like it's not your fault and when it chased
Simon it yelled Feast your eyes most players won't be able to pull apart this phraseology though purely because of how heavily garbled it is we only know what it's saying because of the game files it's creepy sure but it looks like Rainbow and glitter compared to the Flasher the flesher is a naked person it's not a maddened robot it's a walking breathing being that's been driven insane by how the wow has altered its body it doesn't talk it just breathes rasply and its face has been overtaken by growths of structure gel blue lights winking when
we first see it in the Gloom of the ocean eye contact is what sets it off if you hide at the other side of a room and don't look at it the Flasher will likely March off in the other direction the fear and paranoia comes from the fact you can't see where it is if you're following this strategy and the level design where we confront it doesn't make this any easier on your heart rate because it's a lot of tightly packed claustrophobic rooms and corridors where it can be slowly quietly stalking us but not every
humanoid monster is like the Flasher at cytomicron we meet this thing Affectionately called robot head by the fan base we don't know exactly who this was but it was probably the scientist Lisa Cameron who studied structure gel and learned the wow had been modifying it for something whoever it was robot head is a woman's corpse but the eye's mouth knows the entire inside of its head has been replaced with structure gel lighting up the holes in her face whenever she becomes hostile she speaks but always the same sort of dialogue Telling us to go to
get away to leave her alone it's only when Simon gets too close close enough that she might identify him as a threat that she attacks with maddeningly ferocious Speed robot head seems to mourn her previous life the life before the wow transformed her does she have a memory of a life before or does she not realize what she's become some of the robots that Glide along the ocean floor like this scavenger are also mad but seem to Exhibit a state of self-awareness this little guy knows that he's a brain scan in a robot body he
also knows he needs structure gel to survive if Simon gets too close he barks that we shouldn't be greedy and tries to suck it out of us in direct contrast to this there's a scavenger later that has the brain scan of a scientist called Javed Goya he isn't aware that he's a brain scan in fact Javid seems to think that he's human and he ignores Simon completely He'll speak to his colleagues even though they're not there rapidly changing the subject from debating manners around woman to grumbling about the amount of work he has to do
he's clearly deranged but he's not in a rabid manic State like the mysterious scavenger who's hunting for structure gel it's as if self-awareness makes the minds of these robots implode the philosopher Rene Descartes has a famous phrase I think therefore I am this Statement meant a few things when he wrote it it was all part of his attempts to find one statement which was beyond doubt and while I think it's rational and solid the more Descartes talks the less rational he sounds eventually just throwing his hands into the air and saying because God you but
today modern philosophy has translated it to think we're self-aware means that we are self-aware but is that true when looking at these two scavengers the First scavenger is self-aware he knows he's a robot he knows his physical situation but he flies into a Mindless rage whenever we get too close we later learn that the brain scans become incredibly hostile when faced with their human counterparts they accuse the humans of being a copy and it melts them Javed Goya the scavenger that isn't self-aware that's lost in a daze talking to his colleagues is able to tap
into his memories conversations that he's had Which of these creatures has pure Consciousness a soul or in fact am I asking the wrong question the neuroscientist anal Seth in His Brilliant book being you a new science of Consciousness would say that I am asking the wrong questions quote is consciousness all or none either the lights are on or they aren't this question is alluring but I think it's misguided I prefer to think of Consciousness in terms of sharpest Transitions from the total absence of Consciousness to the presence of at least some conscious experience conscious experience
then manifests in different degrees take an adult woman is she more conscious when dreaming than she is sitting at her desk Lost In A Daze after a heavy lunch are the lights on or off and ulseth argues that Consciousness is more like a dimmer switch maybe all of you these beings even the disgusting flesher are Conscious Soulful and in some ways self-aware Javed Goya is lost in a hallucinatory world while he's calm the scavenger enters a hallucinatory world when he's rageful both arguably have a light that is always dimly glowing let's move away from all
the Neuroscience stuff and just focus on the grizzly designs Barnacles Crustaceans and rust go a long way in adding how gross everything is it might just be because of my deep-seated fear of the Ocean which we will get to but there's something visually disturbing about all of this stuff they look like scabbed growths simultaneously growing out of something and parasitically latching to it draining it of life in reality none of this is true Barnacles don't eat whatever they stick to but their mindlessness and their ability to be everywhere in Soma doesn't do them any favors
they take the physical shape of the robots and creatures they're glued To and make them rough knobby even more disfigured than they already are with a structure gel making the geometry of these beings unfamiliar and unsettling but because we see traces of the real natural world in all the oceanic imagery it makes these creatures recognizable and more believable adding to the horror there's a constant consistent sense in Soma that everything is alive whether there's sentient or not later in station Tau will come across a corpse with some Hardened structure gel slowly transforming the body but
because of the shape of the gel and the hard casing it looks like a gigantic sea insect is devouring its prey the tentacular presentation of the structure gel combined with the knowledge that is all just an extension of the wow by this point makes pathos 2 consistently feel like we're wandering around inside a gigantic organism rather than an underwater facility that's got black Gunk on the walls and any fear we previously had of the structure gel is solidified when we meet Terry Acres Acres it seems shared Da Vinci's belief that the eyes are the window
to the soul because he cut his out so he could become one with the wow he attacked and murdered his colleagues and then injected them with structure gel so the wow could take over their bodies and bring them back as monstrosities he believed that the wow was the only thing That could keep everyone alive after the comet hit Earth technically he was right at least as far as our physical bodies are concerned he himself drank structure gel which is why his body seems more leathery and flashy than creatures like the robot head but because the
structure gel's job was to repair Machinery it got absorbed by his cells leading to it trying to improve his body growing an extra arm expanding his Mass when Acres was Eventually brought in by pathos two scientists they did scans of his brain and they seemed to theorize that something was remotely controlling parts of his occipital lobe and parietal lobe the parts of the brain that focus on sensory perception and stars to integrate that perception with reason was the while sending visual signals to his brain that made him see the world in a particular way the
answer is probably yes that's evidence to us when Acres Eventually captures Simon and plugs him into the structure gel we get lost in a dream like Haze where Simon is back in his apartment as if the wow is warping his memories and his perception to see the world in a completely different way like it's created a simulated environment to keep Simon passive you don't want me yes of course I've seen takes that Soma would be a better game without its monsters and I cannot disagree more writing for CG Magazine William Dixon said quote Soma immediately
dropped the ball the second I caught sight of the first Monster despite large chunks of time in between enemy encounters it didn't help with the pacing of the game the enemies didn't add to any kind of rising action they simply sat in my way usually in some poorly designed network of hallways and eliminating them all together was done in such a limp handed way the pacing and variety of Soma's monsters add Spades of Contacts to the game's Central horror Focus the world is uninhabitable now we can't just start a new civilization on pathos 2 Humanity
as we know it is dead monsters roam the Halls there's no coming back from this fearing creatures like Acres or pitying creatures like the scavenger complement how we feel about its moral choices and its Central questions around what we quantify as a soul and what quality of life is worth living when we encounter the Flasher it Absolutely does not just sit in our way we get stuck in a Labyrinth of numerous floors it gives us a scripted whack so Simon will die from a one-hit kill to up the tension and we need to learn the
space if we're going to escape from it alive the intense sequence with Terry Acres forces us to rely entirely on sound because his hearing is so acute in fact we can find an Office room that's soundproofed which when entering it changes how acres has been programmed to Behave designating him with the code badhearing dot exe are someone who generally prefers horror where I can defend myself I honestly do not think someone needed to arm Simon with a weapon to eliminate the creatures would it be cool if we had a weapon like in Amnesia the bunker
that doesn't kill the beast but slows it down and scares it off maybe but having something like that would give me game isms to be distracted by I'm sure I'd enjoy them but any Second spent thinking about resource management or bullets or combat is a second were I not thinking about pathos 2 or the story or whether this infinite Cosmic existence is really all there is whether or not a robot of me with a copy of my brain is more of a right to exist than I do Jesus Christ's existence is terrifying how does anyone
get through a day without losing their mind over the nature of the Soul sorry what were we talking about care to point me in the Direction of the closest tool chip storage I think it would be easier to just take one from a robot what just knock a robot over the head and steal their chips the toolbox over there says it has a stun baton you could use that come on I don't want to hurt anyone ah so speaking of moral choices to get to our next destination site Theta Simon needs to take an underwater
Zeppelin but we can't summon the Zeppelin without a new cortex chip thankfully there are two Ripe candidates Javed Goya that scavenger bot is chatting happily to his imaginary friends and a K-8 unit a tiny orb-shaped bot has been helping us out this whole time opening doors and happily bleeping and blooping Away K8 isn't human at all it's just an artificial intelligence a robot programmed to help Simon out by opening doors to get the cortex chip we've got to kill one of them this Choice focuses Less on philosophical implications Javad Guy is a person's mind in
a robot body but we don't have any relationship with him we do have a relationship with K8 but that's just an artificial intelligence I compare it to a pet dog but to be honest a pet dog has more of a self and right to life than the K-8 unit in the words of Dr Rita lenki dogs have more Consciousness than we give them credit for quote although dogs can't identify themselves in the mirror our study learns that they still have some Level of self-awareness and Ace other self-recognition tests they can recognize their own odor and
recall memories of specific events killing K8 hurts because we personify her through the fact she's helped us and the sounds she makes are cute I'm doing it right now by referring to her as her rather than it but I don't think anyone can justifiably say K-8 has more of a right to keep living than Javed Goya if we do kill Javid the K-8 unit runs away From us so not only are we left with a guilt of ending the life of a person but scaring the thing we were trying to save was I wrong to
think it was unconscious after all it recognized danger and ran away from us but then I'd argue that's just his programming these Bots were created to roam the CE floor they likely were programmed with threat indicators so they'd stay away from sharks or angler fish that might damage them but then isn't this something we have in Common with them our own personal threat indicators are just biological programming that keeps us alive did I make the wrong choice it's just a robot robot oh shut up Catherine outside our next stop station Theta we find another Mockingbird
robot this one is trapped under some Rubble he's been kept Alive by the wow structure gel is powering it up hello who is that mark no we haven't met before Her name is Robin bass she doesn't understand she thinks she's on the ark but in fact she's stuck in a robot body under the ocean she doesn't get the simulated Utopia Catherine has programmed she tells us that she undertook the brain scan and killed herself believing in something called the continuity Theory this was the idea that if you killed yourself just as the brain scan completed
You Wouldn't Die instead you just lose your physical body But your mind would pick up where it left off inside the Ark in a sense your soul would just transport itself onto the Ark in reality that didn't happen Robin 1 died during the brain scan her existence ended what we're speaking to is a copy of Robin Robin II however Robin too doesn't know that from her perspective she closed her eyes during the brain scan and opened them up in the ark it's just the ark's reality looks like the bottom of the sea Simon's moral Dilemma
is simple do we kill Robin bass unplug her from the wow or do we move on and do nothing dooming her to A Thousand Years alone sitting here on the bottom of the ocean calmly believing all of this is the ark so first of all is the continuity Theory worth putting any stock into the short answer is no the long answer is hell no what are they thinking in the world of Soma Robin bass is living proof she says she can't remember killing herself but is pretty Certain that's what happened meaning Robin 1 experienced those
quick seconds between the brain scan being complete and her suicide but this Robin Robin too didn't that part wasn't continued over a tiny ball of light didn't leave her body and jump into the ark Robin won and Robin 2 have two different conscious experiences there is no continuation but in the world of philosophy and Neuroscience well the answers vary this guy Dr Sam parnia has studied what Happens to Consciousness after death and has come to the conclusion that consciousness is channeled by the brain but it's an independent entity all its own quote millions of people
have died in a hospital bed and then come back to life after being resuscitated he said and many of them have reported these very lucid well-structured thought processes they're able to form memories describe conversations and what people were wearing except that their brain is Shut down and they've gone through death which is completely a paradox it should not happen if your mind is simply a byproduct of your brain if your brain has shut down there should be no consciousness so taking that we could say that the continuity theory has some Merit lots of people die
and experience Visions or even describe looking down on themselves watching doctors and nurses try to bring them back so maybe the soul is an independent entity maybe I'm gonna Fly up to heaven get my wings and have a beer with Jesus hooray but remember Adrian Owen the tennis house guy he completely disagreed with parnia claiming he was dog whistling to religious people and one of the more salty response as I found while researching this video quote the brain is the organ that produces Consciousness full stop if you take that organ away or kill that organ
or that organ dies you cannot be conscious I don't believe Patients who report near-death experiences get to a state where there's no detectable brain response whatsoever if that were true they would be classified as brain dead and I know of no case of a brain dead person coming back fight fight fight but regardless of continuation we're faced with a similar predicament to when we met Carl semkin Robin is in a sucky situation should we pull the plug where is everyone I thought there would be like 40 or 50 People here I don't know I'll let
you know if I see anything typically sanctity of Life arguments concentrate on the human angle all human life is sacred nobody should end it before their time but for the sake of these let's just say that Robin is human she's a robot body with a reconstruction of an entire human consciousness inside so it shouldn't be difficult in 1993 the philosopher Ronald dwarkin wrote life's Dominion where he tried to justify a Secular or non-religious view on the sanctity of life he said that human life is sacred because of its natural investment and its creative investment natural
investment is the idea that we can make babies build relationships Etc creative investment is our output paintings books games philosophical ideas business strategies streaming yourself silently watching someone else's hard work I guess pretty much everything that we put back out into the World if someone has or will have the capacity for either of these Investments their life is sacred and they should shouldn't be euthanized so let's apply that to Robin bass she is trapped here the way the structure gel has grown over her body has essentially glued her to the seabed and she can't leave
the Wild's tentacle because it's all that's keeping her alive she can't go anywhere to find friends and build relationships she's a robot so she can't have babies Robin has no natural investment this isn't like a human with minimal Consciousness remember Adrian Owen's patient was trapped to a hospital bed but they could answer questions and build relationships with a tennis house experiment if people came to them physically medical Marvels are now finding that bone marrow could potentially be used to make babies so the person in the hospital bed could technically create life and build a Relationship
with them through the high-tech scanner dorkin's Theory doesn't detach people who can't reproduce Robin bass can't reproduce but she might be able to still have natural investment what if Java Goya swam over here and started a relationship with with her I see a lot of players consider the emptiness of pathos 2 in their decision to kill Robin there's nothing here for her but the irony is that that mindset creates a destructive cycle Let's kill Carl there's nothing left for him down here let's kill Javid there's nothing left for him down here let's kill Robin there's
nothing left for her down here because Simon Jarrett is busy massacring everyone every time we kill one of them we are adding to the fact there's nothing left we are removing the potential for companionship and life under the sea with each dark decision as for Creative investment I don't think it needs to be some world-changing piece of Art or anything Robin could dream up a story while she's down here and share it with one of the other robots I don't think the Flasher would care to listen but hey Simon stopped by to check on her
who's to say that someone else won't pathos 2 might seem Barren and lifeless but we've seen plenty of evidence that there is life down here it's just strange pretty amazing right I'm in the ark yeah great Catherine and the guys really pulled through they Saved us all but what about quality of life Soma tells us that the comet was an Extinction event life on Earth has ceased to be and we never get any information that suggests otherwise would you want to live on in that world it's in fact a question by Mrs and I asked
each other just last week before recording this video when we watched M Night shyamalan's movie knock at the cabin the premise there is that all human life would be wiped out unless you Kill a loved one your partner or everything else what do you choose my answer then Remains the Same I choose her over everything every time life with her has equality she is the only thing that matters I would kill you in a heartbeat get ready I'm coming but what if you were alone what if you weren't wandering the Earth with that special someone
what if you were Robin bass what is her quality of life well that's in the eye of the beholder this situation Physically sucks but Robin isn't hurt she's not in distress like Carl semkin was she seems calm a little confused maybe but calm and relatively happy right now she's in awe of what she's looking at but how long will this all remain how long until her creativity turns to Madness hallucinations maybe that's what happened to Java Goya maybe that's why he's mulling about talking to colleagues who aren't there if he is insane he seems content
hopefully that's What will happen to Robin I don't think I have any right to take that away from her a submarine there will be nothing stopping us when we have the done that you guys sure have a lot of machines and vehicles down here what makes this one so special it's the only transport that can go into the best without cracking like a can of soup Simon and Catherine arrive at station Theta the ark capsule is here so the Plan is to grab it get in a submarine called the dumb bat and swim over to
the railgun to blast it into space Theta was the main administration building the primary living quarters and a place of Refuge for the crew who evacuated from upsalom it's also where Catherine conducted the brain scans and uploaded them to the ark her work was primitive at first but slowly the wild started conducting its own brain scans on people who used the pilot seats copying their Consciousness to various robots around the station in an effort to keep Humanity alive a robot body is less likely to deteriorate than a human body what exactly happened to the wow
to make it do this why did this new idea come into its programming it's a mystery for now but Catherine observed that the Wow's brain scans were perfect copies arguably Too Perfect the Wow's first brain scan was the engineer Imogen Reed and Catherine Saul that Reed's scan was Quote too real she won't play nicely with the others this forced a change in Catherine's experiments before long she was making better perfect scans just like the wow was complete 100 digital copies of people site Theta is my favorite part of the game not just because it has
the best puzzle or because it's where we meet hakers and that scared the out of me but because the environmental storytelling is so Rife here it's powerful everywhere But in Theta every hallway every room Echoes with memories of the past with the desires and anxieties of the workers in 2013 Thomas Gripp wrote A Blog about the five foundational pillars of Soma's design number one everything is Story number two take the world seriously number three the player is in charge number four trust the player and number five thematics emerge through play I want to drill into
number two here take the world seriously in grip's own words Quote every detail in an environment is connected to the story somehow nothing should be written off for simply a requirement for gameplay or Exposition for instance if you find an audio log you will be able to learn more about the story by pondering its placement alone in Theta the world is taken very seriously despite the fact the living quarters are architecturally identical which makes sense because this is a clinical station of the future every Room is specifically tailored to replicate the feeling of the person
who once lived in it cool fan thanks reminds me of Taipei in my hometown Catherine's room has a stuffed animal pictures of her home and she reminisces about them with traces of affection in her voice that we haven't heard before this is the first time she hasn't been purely goal oriented this might be a digital copy of human Catherine's brain but that copy is emotionally connected to physical Objects the material world her memory is informing her identity we see that guy Conrad was re-engineering a major tool with a microwave emitter he planned to fry his
brain right after the scan Robin bass's room is full of pictures of the ark's digital world that Catherine presumably printed out to show what was waiting for their digital selves she's colored around them filled them up with childish drawings almost obsessively in just one shot the game captures a state Of mind Robin was in when she decided to end her life in Marx sarang's room we find an audio diary where he talks about continuity theory he was the guy who came up with it in the first place who planted that idea resulting in the unnecessary
suicides of about a dozen people they typically don't stay with us till we die some live a few days while others live a few years our conscious mind is not the Pattern of our brain but a continuous emergent entity based on that pattern idiot but just like grip said the placement of that audio diary tells a story in itself it's hidden away in a drawer it's not sitting out in the open where anyone could find it it's concealed Sarang was happy to talk about his theory but he didn't want anyone finding out about it like
say security officer strawmeyer a man who rightfully thought it was a dangerous idea it's not Just in fatal we get the sort of attention to detail though jumping right back to upsalon in the start of the game we learned that Carl semkin and dami azaro stayed back at Upsilon while the rest of the crew evacuated trying to keep the lights on in the control room where Carl died a lot of the doors are locked keeping out the monster patrolling below and there's clothes hanging on a line clearly this is where Carl and Amy locked themselves
in and Spent quite a bit of time together staying on Amy her sketches dominate a lot of the first half of the game they're full of life and character one of the pages has a cute to-do list where her final task is being awesome aside from Terry Akers and his murderous Rampage a lot of pathos 2's crew are characterized as incredibly likable so we care about their plight and there's something to be said for the dorkiness that someone's writers gave a lot of our Scientists to make them feel real and personable we find correspondence between
two engineers golaski and Herbert who were best friends in their notes to each other they use nicknames gask and Herb these aren't the only examples but their neat touches and endears to who these people once were if this was the last of humanity we picked them pretty well it's just a shame then that the wow got to them because it's not just in its big questions or its Monster designs that Soma's horror makes our flesh crawl the environments do that too in the basement to station Theta we see what's left of theta's inhabitants they're not
dead they're very much alive smothered by structure gel teaching us exactly what the wild is doing to the humans just in case you missed the struggling human emiasaro back at cytopsalon soon Simon will arrive at sight Omicron where he'll be met by piles of headless corpses unlike with Most bodies Simon can't tap into the memories of these corpses because they don't have black boxes anymore every worker on pathos 2 had a black box inserted under their brain that monitored their condition and recorded their biometric data all of this is taught to us through items in
the environment signage memos and the sudden disappearance of an ability Simon previously had again it's like Thomas Gripp said everything is story even how We interact with the environment another example is how we can only heal using the wild pods not Med kits or Auto regenerating Health the Wow's healing properties its determination to fix people is a gameplay mechanic South Zone it's freaky so many lights what do we do now Simon eventually finds this computer at the back of Catherine's office a database holding Legacy scans that Catherine was basing her research off of one of
those scans is his the Very brain scan he did back in 2015 in David munchy's office back at the start of the game the original Simon died just a couple of weeks after munchy's theory was sound but not perfected Simon's brain injury killed him anyway on his deathbed Simon agreed to let munchie use his scan like a donated organ he says and that turned into a template for what we're seeing on pathos 2 a hundred years later Simon is patient zero all of this is because of him to make matters worse The dumb bat the
submarine has become conscious someone's brain scan has taken it over and it bursts into life trashing itself it's unusable we can't use it to transport the ark so plan B we're going to need to go and get it ourselves and physically carry it to the railgun on the surface this sounds like an awful lot of contrivance and it is it's all that classic video game stuff for games like Bioshock also do where a simple objective is interrupted by System Failures and the like but sulma just like Bioshock gets a pass this is mainly because the
pacing of the game is pretty Breezy you can tank through it in about five hours if you don't stop to smell the seaweed but these obstacles like the dumb bat blowing itself up serve as constant reminders to how real pathos 2 feels in my Bioshock video I use the term life cycle simulation where A Game's World building an environmental storytelling pays particular attention To how its World Works what do they eat where do they sleep where do people poop and a whole chunk of you came to me to point out that there was already a
phrase to coin this term shandification an awesome word brought up by the channel Mr B tongue based off of the novel Tristram Shandy but you would forgive me for not knowing that seeing as his video on the subject got copyright struck by the NBA and is now unwatchable God damn YouTube is a Hellhole Soma's shandification is on full display attention and care has been taken to make sure pathos 2 feels like it did exist does exist and could exist we know what the crew ate we know where they slept and we definitely know where they
poop we uncover that each of the stations here were made for a specific purpose site Delta was for manufacturing Upsilon was the power plant site Alpha doesn't exist we don't talk about it don't ask about it interacting with Pathos 2 is rarely ever as simple as pushing a button on a dashboard it's far more realistic and weighted just look at how we open a door later turn the dial pull the thing grab the lever frictional's physics engine is something they designed themselves are very proud of and continue to use even in 2023 simply because it
forces a kinetic tie between the player and the player character I need to feel the weight of the doors I'm opening I need to feel the Tug of heavy objects in the world and remember the fact many of our actions take just a beat too long also adds to the palpability of the game's tension many of pathos 2's computers have incidental info information that isn't useful or connected to our objectives but it adds texture and flavor to each room on a station and informs the work the crew did it's like someone working at frictional themselves
that scientists would play this and I'm Actually it to death like the comments section of my second Channel lore dump links below for example Simon will eventually look at a diversuit and we're given all sorts of information about it right down to the sort of temperatures it can withstand minus 75 degrees Centigrade huh looks like Americans lose the temperature war in the future oh no wow got to the dunbat before we did am I right well it was talking that's rarely a good sign damn it The dumpout was our shot I was really banking on
this to work come on we can't quit now there's got to be another way how do you think you did it how did the team get the ark down the abyss in the first place even puzzles have intrinsic layers of clunkiness and complexity to feel as real as possible earlier Simon needs to summon a zeppelin to get to site Theta in order to do that we need to read the information given to us on Console 1 Find console 2 read the information given to us by console 2 and figure out which Zeppelin would take us
to site Theta use the information of both consoles to figure out which Zeppelins are still online align the correct coordinates and send a signal to an online Zeppelin bleep bloop the buttons to summon it bash in a robot to steal its cortex chip rest in peace Goya that's a lot of steps from what essentially boils down to flicking a Switch but it encourages the player to drink deep of Soma's atmosphere and the mechanical complexity of its World here in the arc engineering room Simon finds the precious Arc it's just a little metal box but we
need to configure the virtual world that all of the brain scans will experience combining various assets and code like water physics or trees to simulate a realistic environment in reality we're just adding up the numbers so we don't go above 1152 Terabytes but the context and all of the extra tasty unnecessary information we're given makes us feel much more fulfilling because it matters The Arc is important the world these brain scans will experience is important and the player is tricked into feeling like they have some creative control over what it will look like once the
arc is configured Catherine tells Simon to step into a scanning chamber it'll take a scan of his brain ready to be uploaded To the ark and it's in here that she learns what exactly we are Simon's body has the genetic code of Imogen read it's not just that it's an empty husk a corpse he's puppeting a dead person's body stuck in a diver suit by structure gel that's all he is the gel and the corpse tiny visual sensors dimly glow from under the suit Simon might feel human but he's physically less human than a flasher
before we leave station Theta I want to Take a moment to pay my respects to Brandon one born in October 16 2017 in Hong Kong Brandon was an engineer stationed at site Delta there he worked with a team made up of Javed Goya Astrid Creer and Terry Akers he became friends with most of them with Java Goya affectionately calling him brand after the comet hit Earth he was relocated to cite Theta where he met and fell in love with Alice Coster when the day came to have his brain scan taken he was so Nervous that
he asked Dallas to be with him during the procedure on January 16 2104 scite Theta was overrun by a mutated Terry Acres Brandon stayed behind in order for his colleagues to escape he sealed himself in the basement of theta so Acres couldn't follow them trapped down there he cut his throat with a knife determined not to be killed by the monster that was once his friend Brandon one is a Legend Brandon won doesn't deserve what we do to him That wasn't so bad this from my really got me worked up bastard what how did I
get here while exploring Theta Simon and Catherine realized they need a security key so they upload a brain scan of Brandon one into a simulation where they hope they can talk him into giving it up we can simulate conversations with him in a beach a ski lodge or a room that looks just like Catherine's scan room every single time he freaks out so We need to learn more about Tim and rummage through his stuff to make the simulation smoother eventually Simon learns about Brandon's relationship with Alice so Catherine makes a crude copy of her pretends
to be her and ultimately convinces Brandon to give up the information we need it is one of the best sequences in the game and every time I play it it hurts the moral choice the players given comes after we've tricked Brandon do we erase his brain Scan there's already a copy of him safely on the ark this isn't the only Brandon but is it fair to leave him here in a Perpetual state of non-existence until someone or something turns him on Sussex campus welcome to my university this is what it looks like on a Tuesday
lunchtime except that it doesn't of course what we did here is we took a panoramic video of this Courtyard at Sussex so 360 degree video and then we processed every frame Through a particular program and that program was based was basically like a a networker a neural network that's usually used you feed it information in at the bottom and it tells you what's in the image and we ran it backwards and we basically fixed the fixed it so that it's to say dog and then we ran it back with an updated every frame of this
image to project dog back into it and then we sort of strung them all together in a Movie and people put a headset on and they look around and suddenly there are dogs everywhere this is adult Seth presenting at the Northern Ireland Science Festival in 2015. here he's talking about a hallucination machine he and his colleagues created at the University of Sussex and after preliminary tests they took it a step further a person would enter a lab put a VR headset on with a camera fixed to the front we were told that that headset Would
simply show them a live feed of the lab as they looked around but this was a lie what they were in fact looking at was a pre-recorded panoramic view of the same lab from earlier in the day nobody was able to tell the difference between the real lab and the pre-recorded lab but the majority of them exhibited severe stress nausea and discomfort hours later after being told the truth this is a lot like Brandon he doesn't know he's an assimilated version Of Catherine's lab but something tells him it isn't right that he exhibits high stress
levels every time we start and stop the simulation we're essentially creating and erasing a new version of Brandon here's Brandon 4 at the beach here's Brandon's six in a ski lodge there is no continuity between each version of Brandon that we activate it's not like Catherine where her soul lives in a cortex chip that we carry with us and she experiences continuity every Time we get this puzzle wrong Brandon is given life and killed for him Consciousness isn't a dimmer switch we're literally turning him on or off the final Choice given to us to completely
erase his brain scan or not isn't the horrifying part it's the fact we're erasing copies of Brandon over and over again because they all have different experiences Brandon at the beach has a different conscious experience from Brandon at the ski lodge Soma puts us into a state where we play God with someone's Soul discarding him when he's no longer useful to us oh wait that's enough we got what we need but of course all of these brandons have something in common their memories prior to the brain scan are all identical and it's here I think
that Soma draws its Line in the Sand for what it believes the soul to be in 1690 the philosopher John Locke published his work and Essie Concerning human understanding it's a beast of a philosophical text but one of his ultimate conclusions is that memory is what matters most when understanding identity where we've been who we've met the thoughts we've had and the experience we can recollect shape the person we are if suddenly you got knocked on the head and forgot all of that you would become a completely different person your soul would change to a
New Soul quote a person is a Thinking intelligent being that has reason and reflection and can consider itself the same thinking thing in different times and places that sounds a lot like Carl samkin Robin bass Javed Goya Brandon Wan Catherine and Simon write every single Brandon we wake up has memories of Catherine of being in her lab of getting the brain scan of being terrified of it of wanting Alice in the room with him when his memories get contradicted by the simulation That's when his sense of self starts to implode if he wakes up on
a beach instead of the lab he freaks out when he can't see Catherine he freaks out when he realizes Alice isn't in the room anymore he freaks out the brain scan of Brandon has the same experiences of stress that annulsath's human test subjects had when they tried out his hallucination machine he has the same Reliance on memory that John Locke claimed was so important he exhibits Free will when he demands Catherine show herself for all intents and purposes this is a human being with memories that inform his self his soul but then there's this little
nugget to consider I haven't been able to dream since 4017. I think it does something to your brain when it Scoops you out do you dream before Soma came out frictional released a series of short videos on their channel in the form of Transmissions Documenting the events leading up to the fall of Pathos 2. in the episodes we meet Imogen Reed the ill-fated engineer whose corpse Simon is currently puppeting and Adam golaski a chief engineer who drank structure gel just like Terry Akers did I haven't been able to dream since the scan gulaski says so
do the brain scans take something from you it's a question that's never answered or explored any further arguably to the game and Show's Detriment galaski isn't a reliable mouthpiece he's slowly going insane from all that structure gel he's chugging but if a human loses the ability to dream after the brain scan is that ability passed over to the scan itself and if so does that mean Brandon 2 is more of a fulfilled self than Brandon one was after the scan the Simon and Catherine it doesn't matter no matter which Brandon they're speaking to they just
shut him off and try again if he's not Cooperating just a few feet away from Brandon's simulation is the computer where Simon finds out his brain scam was the first one the Legacy scan that informed all of this and he has a choice there too does he erase his own data this is one hell of a question to ask the player if he'd gotten Tangled Up In philosophical knots by this point even if you think that there's nothing worth living for on pathos 2 does Simon too have any right to delete Simon one's Brain scan
because by this point they're two different people Simon 2 has experienced pathos to his impression of the world of life is colored by the horrors he's witnessed under the sea he's a different person now than he was when he woke up at the start of the game this might as well say Monty Zander on the screen for all that matters but again there's a huge chunk of memory that Simon 1 and Simon 2 Share the car accident Ashley his apartment how Different are they really is it murder to kill your past self as for Brandon
the idea of subjecting copies of this guy to ritualistic torture like this means emotionally I always erase him from the computer out of fear that the wow will eventually upload Brandon into a robot body in the moment it feels like we're putting him out of his misery but rationally I think doing this is murder not just of this original brain scan but for all of the consenting adult Potential versions of Brandon that might come from it [Music] okay we need to find you a power suit you know so we can go into the abyss without
ending up like a recycled can of soda with The Arc activated Simon sends it off to the railgun eternity Among the Stars is just a hop skip and swim away but unfortunately the railgun is situated at station Phi the diving suit Simon's wearing isn't strong enough to Get there he'll be crushed by the pressure of the ocean so he's going to need to explore station Omicron to get all the pieces he needs to wear a new one Omicron is a multi-leveled complex some rooms are closed off and we need to unlock them as we go
robot head prowls in the basement level a lot of our time spent on consoles unlocking doors and managing the what the was that just the computer speaking to us telling us to stop something probably not Important countdown Monty we're just over halfway keep your nerve while Simon collects a cortex chip a battery pack and some structure gel let's talk about how Soma approaches choice and immersion even outside of the conditioning of the game's opening Soma is very reactive to the players actions I don't necessarily mean that in game-changing ways like say Baldur's Gate there's only
one ending there aren't significant chunks of game that are opened up or locked off Depending on what choices we make but the beep to beat decision making is acknowledged by the game on the regular for example if we erase Simon's Legacy scan in Catherine's computer he'll come up as unavailable when testing the Prototype Arc later if we check the Curie submarine before finding Catherine Simon's dialogue changes where he references that he found it already when Simon boards the shuttle to station Lambda to meet Catherine we can choose Our destination Delta Theta wherever it crashes regardless
but it adds a sense of fluidity to our choices even if the game course corrects to get us where we need to go this reactivity makes the player feel at least briefly like they can do something the game doesn't want them to do so why is this important like we discussed at the start it makes Simon tangible it makes the game World feel more real which as a result makes the really tough choices have have more Weight but what the game's reactivity also does is hype up the immersion with the lights down and headphones on
the relationship between the player and Simon can be pretty similar to the relationship between say the human Carl samkin when he was in a pilot seat controlling a robot body one part of our brain is really into the game the metallic clangs the bizarre claustrophobia of the ocean floor but another part of our brain is acutely Aware that we're sitting in our living room sipping some tea playing a game I know this is all kind of a no-da situation but what's really interesting for Soma is how our brain physically reacts when we play games according
to the psychologist Warner worth among others our brain achieves immersion through spatial awareness basically to become immersed in something our brain reconstructs what we're seeing in our mind so that our senses can better Interact with it and coolest of all our brain starts to subconsciously identify where it is as inside the game not so much that is damaging or removes all sense of self awareness but essentially ourself from microscopic seconds at a time lives inside our brain's interpretation of pathos 2. that's the ironic thing about immersion what we're being immersed in isn't the game it's
our idea of it those of us who love playing horror games almost will our Brain into tricking us into forming that player character connection so we can enjoy the thrill of being scared the way Soma reacts to our choices simply makes it easier for our brain to trick us the game has a few angles that contribute to this immersion there's no map no inventory system absolutely everything is in game in the room with Simon the lack of map adds to the feeling of being lost and helpless and despite the fact each level of Soma is
actually quite Small and makes these spaces feel much bigger there's plenty of signs to guide us it's very rare a player will actually get stuck but that illusion of helplessness is really strong and the fact that so much of our play time is given over to finding our way strengthens this immersion as well because it's cognitive we need to think and wonder and use the information the game gives us to progress pathos 2 isn't just one linear Corridor it's numerous Rooms labs and Chambers that Force us to think about our next steps Aaron Clifford a
3D artist of frictional games told game reactor quote with Soma we've tried to stay away from anything you could identify as a game mechanic like the sanity meter or picking up tinderboxes in Amnesia we felt they'd draw you out to the experience people enjoyed it but with Soma we want the whole thing to be about immersing you in the world we never ever stop controlling Simon control isn't ripped away from the player for a cutscene there isn't a single loading screen outside of booting up the game even opening doors forces us to control the swing
or the tug of a handle every single thing that happens in Soma is influenced by the player nothing is ever given to us and that adds to the most uncomfortable way that Soma injects dread into the player guilt it's not the game that keeps reactivating Brandon one it's Simon it's Us it's not the game that kills Robin bass it's Simon it's us anything I can do if you see Masters or Holland tell them I need help okay Amy needs help and what do most people do when we get a little tinge of guilt that little
voice in our head that says you shouldn't have done that well we justify it I didn't recycle today it's fine I'm just one guy my carbon footprint won't be that big I didn't give that homeless person any money act Well I'm skinned too if I give money to every homeless person I met I'd be homeless myself so on and so on and so on the choice involving Amy azaro is a great crystallizer of everything I've just raised she's an entirely optional choice we need to find her so we're super immersed some players won't even cross
her unless they're looking for her I know I missed her on my first playthrough she's hidden away in a tunnel before boarding the shuttle to Site Lambda she's glued to the wall the Wow's tentacles are burrowing into her healing her keeping her alive it won't let me die she says nothing is allowed to die a lot of Soma's choices are framed as take action or don't take action in Amy's case we can either kill her or leave do something or nothing influence this world or leave it untouched there are no dialogue options because Simon has
his own person with his own personality so whenever he talks To Catherine it's him speaking and the simplistic way that Soma's Choice system has been created mainly works because the situations we're in are both vague and often binary when Amy asks us to kill her there's no third answer to that situation no way to think around the problem she wants to die she's in pain we can see that she's being transformed into something that barely resembles a human being death or life is the only option but what exactly that means is Entirely up to the
player's interpretation there are a million what if scenarios that we can consider with every choice that make them heavier and tougher and because the choice itself is so simple we're encouraged to focus on the what ifs unless on the mechanical complexities of the choice itself something is keeping Amy alive at this early point in the game we don't know it's the wow we don't know that the wow is turning people into monsters we can Bear really get much information out of Amy because she's so weak so the what ifs are all that we have what
if there are people left elsewhere in the station who can help her she mentioned a couple of names maybe they could rescue her what if killing her alerts a monster to our presence what if her body is siphoning power to the shuttle do we need her alive to get to Lambda with Robin bass lost and alone at the bottom of the ocean we consider the fact that She might not be alone for long what if Javid Goya eventually swims over to her and the two form a relationship with Brandon one what if the wow uploads
his brain scan into a robot body that could be life in the physical world that we take away by erasing him or it could be endless torture the pacing of these choices is key as well soon will be faced with a choice that's very similar to Amy azaro where Simon meets the last human and is asked to unplug her life Support but the way we Justified killing Amy won't be useful when justifying killing the last human because there's so much context that we've learned between the two choices we now know what was happening to Amy
we now have had the time to reflect on our feelings about the wow we now have had other choices that have made us reconfigure how we think about The Human Condition the most uncomfortable thing about playing Salma I think is that process of justification It's only human to set out a belief system and want to stick to it and when the game offers up different moral dilemmas contexts and situations we are forced to bend that belief system uh killing Carl is fine he's just a robot right oh God Carl's a human's brain scan trapped in
a metal body uh but but I had to kill him it was either that or leaving him in pain forever oh here's Robin bass she's not in pain but she is trapped like Carl was I could just leave Her here but is that fair eh her quality of life sucks it's a mercy to unplug her oh God here's Brandon one he's not trapped he's not even conscious until someone boots him up but his quality of life sucks when he does come to life because he's alone in a simulation is it right to erase his data
and kill him I never realized how much the idea of myself depended on where I am what do you mean I miss Toronto Not because my friends and family are there but because I know where I fit in in Toronto I know who I am that's an interesting observation through this piece of dialogue Soma acknowledges that it's the sum of our experiences that make us who we are Simon thinks that his time in Toronto the friends he made his feelings for Ashley they all informed his personality And a copy of that personality was transported 100
years into the future this is a belief system is shared by the psychiatrist Carl Jung but he went a step further questioning how our experiences informed the way we make choices and Alters how we see free will and his work aeon he writes just as our Free Will clashes with necessity in the outside world so also it finds its limits outside the field of Consciousness in the subjective inner World Jung's reading of Free Will is kind of like an iceberg we can conscientiously make choices using all of the information present like when I killed K-8
rather than Javed Goya conscientiously I was thinking about how Javed Goya has more of a right to life because he's a human brain scam that was a tip of the iceberg trickling down own there's a whole host of experiences and biases that influence what choices we make maybe I have a dog that K8 reminds Me of so subconsciously I'd be more inclined to save her early in his career young called all of this to conscious and subconscious stuff that makes up who we are total personality but as the years went by he eventually started calling
it The self and claimed that human life is so fleeting that a hundred years is simply not long enough to reach psychological wholeness to fully understand consciously who we are deep down so if we can't ever fully look Inside ourselves and see every Shard of ice that makes up the iceberg of our soul we can't ever truly be self-aware and if we can't be self-aware what right do we have to inflict our murky gray confused and psychologically incomplete will over the world if I was in Simon's position faced with Amy azaro what right do I
have to make any kind of decision about her fate how do we know if the tip of the iceberg is enough those are just the tip joke in there somewhere but I'm Too depressed to find it collecting the parts he needs Simon Journeys back through Omicron to reunite with Catherine but as he does he means Dr Johan Ross who doesn't deal in what ifs he deals in certainties foreign he was a brilliant neuroscientist and AI psychologist that helped to develop the wow in the first place but seeing it get out of control he came to
the conclusion that it needs to be destroyed however Before he could he was attacked by marine life and knocked unconscious the wow following its ultimate directive to preserve all human life used structure gel to fix him Ross despite being critically injured and remolded by the wow has inexplicably been able to retain his memories his speech and sense of identity he's acutely aware of what the wow did to him except now he has the ability to teleport and speak telepathically he's a bit ugly now but Honestly the Wow's given him superpowers he embodies a different kind
of humanity he's almost transhuman but just like Catherine he's entirely goal oriented he still wants to destroy the wow and he wants Simon's help to do it but this Simon Simon too unfortunately won't be able to help so if we admit that there are two different people each of whom has half my brain and it's psychologically just like me If they're two different people they can't each be one in the same person me it'd be absurd to suppose that I'm one of them and not the other no reason to suppose that so I think we
should conclude yes neither of them would be mean I would cease to exist introducing the philosopher Derek parfi most famous for creating the tele Transportation Paradox he asks us to imagine stepping into a machine that will break us down atom by atom and send us to Mars we Think when we're entering the machine that it will simply send us across space at the speed of light but in reality the machine is copying our body our brain our personality our memories and recreating it all to form a perfect replica on Mars physically we die on Earth
but on Mars a replica of us would step out of a machine and continue existing believing wholeheartedly that the transportation worked that replica would go about the rest of its life not Realizing that the original version died so it could awaken on Mars which version is the true you well doesn't matter parfi's not done with the analogy he introduces something called the branch line case he asks us to imagine that the machine doesn't kill us but it still copies every atom and still makes a replica on Mars suddenly there's two of you separated by the
vastness of space but still the question needs to be asked which version is the true you if a comet Suddenly crashed into Earth and killed the original would it be fair to say that the version on Mars the only version still existing is in fact you funny you should ask Derek because someone at frictional clearly read about the tele Transportation Paradox and put it into Soma Simon's about to find himself in that exact situation it will be fine then why don't we put you in the suit go without me [Music] Simon poor is the structure
gel the battery pack and the cortex chip into a diving suit and prepares to have his mind transported over to his shiny new supersuit this one will let him descend deeper into the ocean and reach the ark Catherine tells him to strap him while she uploads his mind and sends him over a flash of white a glimmer of static and when Simon opens his eyes he's sitting in his new body but something feels off [Music] what was that no it's just Why was it still talking it's the same like Catherine why was he still talking
Simon's mind wasn't transported it was copied we're now playing as Simon number three Simon two the man we've controlled since waking up at cytopsalon sits on the other side of the room it feels like continuity because we the player have body hot me Monty sitting in my chair I experience Continuity but in reality we're now playing as a clone of Simon two Simons he shouts there can't be two Simons he loses it he doesn't understand he didn't pay attention when we were talking about how continuity theory is dumb he thought it would be like having
a brain transplant he swears blank he calls Catherine disgusting and Catherine panicking makes the previous Simon fall unconscious she puts him on pause so she and Simon 3 can hash it out so cruel Well what do you want me to do with him makes friends let him know that we have to leave him behind when we go into the abyss what is what if he didn't need to wake up our choice as always is mechanically simple either we cut Simon to his power killing him or we leave him behind alone at sight homicron without Catherine
or a single human to help he's not in the super duper diving suit he can't follow us to the ark when he wakes he'll be Confused he'll think Catherine abandoned him and most likely he'll slowly lose his mind as he realizes he's trapped in here Catherine has locked the only entrance to the lab and on the other side is robot head waiting to break in and go on a murderous Rampage so back to Derek he argues that the tele Transportation Paradox clearly shows how memory isn't this all-important thing that defines our sense of self after
all you and your clone have the same Memories up until the moment of cloning but you're clearly not the same person right well I think he makes a fundamental logical error when he says that he assumes that the self has to be unique for a split second when the upload is completed Simon 2 and Simon 3 are the same person in different bodies they both have the same Memories the same expectations it only takes a moment for theirselves to split into two new selves Simon 2 has the experience of Thinking the upload didn't work and
that fires off a whole host of subconscious and conscious thoughts fears Sensations and memories Simon III thinks it has worked and he's already experiencing New Sensations like how the new diving suit feels to wear and how horrible it feels to realize he's going to need to abandon or kill Simon too but for a crack in time Simon toon Simon 3 are the same person Simon too self isn't unique like I said at the start the soul is dead and Sulma killed it there can be two Simons just like there could be two Monty's there could
be fifty a thousand you could fill a city with clones of me and it'd be a goddamn Utopia because I'm awesome and we would all for a brief second when the cloning is complete for that millisecond of Consciousness have identical Souls the same way we have identical bodies but as minutes pass hours days and we all went off on our Journeys and had our own unique Experiences those Montes would change one Monty might kill a guy another might dye his hair those memories would shape them into different people different selves different Souls but for the
religious among you here's a lovely unanswerable question what does that mean for the afterlife is there room in heaven for two identical Souls there's some kind of afterlife you think my place has taken the real me died like a hundred years Ago there's still room for me technically there is one thing just one that differentiates Simon 2 and Simon 3 in that millisecond of waking Simon 2 actively experienced everything we experienced he worked through cytopsalon he tortured Brandon Wan he confronted Terry Akers at site Theta he did those things physically in his robot body Simon
III might have the memories he might have been shaped and molded by Those experiences but nobody can say that he did them can they but if that is the only way we can tell the difference between them does that mean we're back to where we started Soma's name is taken from the Greek for body despite the fact every cell and cidus has replaced every seven to ten years are we saying the actions of our physical body is the only thing that matters have I missed the point this whole video focusing on the brain and Neuroscience
should I've been Talking about the physical body in the acts of the physical body in the physical world something something less get physical is that active experience enough to say one Simon is more important than another Simon because Simon 2 might have physically experienced everything so far but Simon 3 will be able to go down to Station Tau he'll be able to complete the goal of launching the ark he has more potential for future physical actions than Simon 2 Does once Simon 2 wakes up all he'll be able to do is sit in this room
and go mad or eventually leave it and be ripped to shreds by robot head just like Robin bass just like Carl sandkin just like Amy azaro his quality of life is limited because he doesn't have as many choices offered to him I have 30 minutes of footage in this room and this is my fourth playthrough sitting quietly with Simon too as he sleeps dreamlessly I think it's the best And toughest dilemma in the game and in the end the only reason I turned off the power and killed him is because of how important I think
our physical actions are as we saw Soma's choices are often take action or don't I think I owed it to Simon 2 to act on his behalf foreign the half hour that follows is quiet peaceful and disconcerting Simon marches through an oceanic Abyss towards station Tau the ark is waiting for us but it's Not the only thing down here the vastness of Soma's Oceanic environments and the depth of care and sickening attention given to them is one of the game's more harrowing strengths it's brilliant and I hate it Jesus did you see that stick to
the lamp lights they won't go near them it's important I read Omicron our future depends on it I have severe thalassophobia if given the choice Between suffocating to death while floating through space or suffocating to death while falling through the ocean I'd pick space every single time at least that way I'd get to see the beauty of the Galaxy in my dying moments space has stretches of nothingness not even oxygen coats us there's something freeing about that absence of stuff but under the ocean you're swallowed by Water by pressure by creatures so alien that it's
inescapable and seeing a storm As creative director said that a third of the game takes place in the ocean this section is dedicated to how the game makes it captivating and terrifying but first some quick did you knows get your geek glasses on this is super cool did you know that as of 2023 over 80 percent of the Earth's oceans remain unexplored some NASA scientists have theorized that we know more about Mars than we do about the sea some of the ocean is engulfed by huge water vortexes Some that span 150 km that swallow up
anything unfortunate enough to get too close the deepest part of the ocean is called the Challenger Deep and falls at about 36 200 feet that's 6033 mees thus too many means station Tao isn't that deep but at almost 14 000 feet over two thousand meters it descends into my own personal hell Soma's ocean is both expansive and suffocating because pathos 2 is so old and creaky were constantly reminded of the pressure that could Crush us at any moment like the station is fighting against the water to operate but when we're out in the Dewey blue
hue the emptiness that stretches on for Miles aside from some winking dots of light reminds us of just how alone we truly are but you might be thinking all of this could be achieved on a space station right games like Dead Space structured itself to keep revolving around the crumbling dying engineering of the USG ishimura and while you could Claim that that makes the plot feel a little bit like busy work those goals kept up the tension by reinforcing how the ship itself could kill everyone on board aliens be damned but I think choosing an
ocean setting for Soma gets to add something a space station wouldn't friction all raveled in how the early teasers for the game initially tricked us into thinking it would be set in space with these giggling goading bastards chose the ocean because of how It tied to the game's big questions the ocean is a harrowing mysterious Abyss but is part of our home pathos 2 isn't Humanity Among the Stars it's our last gasp to cling to a form of life that is long long gone it's been replaced with tentacular AIS and brain scans and robots the
setting of the ocean demands that we ask what the point of all of this really is after all a comet destroyed our home our goal is to literally launch a Vestige of souls into Space space is the goal because the ocean is so horrific the sound design and architecture of the ocean floor cultivates that Horror in fact Soma's soundspace is absolutely insane especially for such a small team in the words of Samuel Justice Soma's audio director the final sound effects count for Soma is slightly eye-watering clocking in and a little over 18 000 sound effects
files not including voice over and music The loudest sound the most present during the ocean segments is Simon's breathing it's an effective trick because a it's more immersive anyone who's been scuba diving will tell you your breath is all you can hear and because it hides the sounds of the ocean we feel more uncertain about the darkness ahead and B Because Simon isn't physically breathing he's a robot in a structure gel suit during the early sequences this simply tricks us into Thinking of Simon as biologically human but where we are right now right after leaving
Simon 2 and picking up as Simon 3 makes the breathing feel uncanny artificial uneasy because we know explicitly that Simon isn't breathing like this his senses are lying to him Jagged rocks and cliffs stand overhead like giants trapping Simon underwater our field of vision is rightfully restricted obscuring Secrets threats with occasional reminders of the human Ingenuity and Novelty that let us expand into this underwater world it's not that we conquered the ocean but we at least started to venture into it and build around it the engineers of pathos 2 have tried to put little stamps
little glimmers of human life on the ocean floor piping Zeppelins hubs but it's the signage the lights that guide our way the information provided that tells us how deep we are and how long our journey is between each settlement that shows Just how small our impact was on the sea it's during Simon's journey to station Tau that this small impact has seen best this is the darkest the most claustrophobic the game ever gets we're descending to the deepest part of pathos 2. each step takes us further away from the Earth's surface further away from where
human life once flourished meaning the level design is literally reflecting the game's themes back at us we need to follow lights and flares and there are Specific periods of time where we can't see those lights or those flares that make our travels feel momentarily aimless if you're not carefully paying attention to those lights in specific typically the fact that blue leads to Tau and red leads back the way we came you can get turned around and lost really easily and then there's the grossness marine life can be found in the ocean to add texture and
realism but a lot of them have been infected with Structure gel by the wow crabs Scuttle through the sand schools of fish Float by aimlessly and at first glance this can all seem pretty tranquil but it's on route to station Tau that the creepiness factor is upped sea spiders anglerfish and crawdads cling to walls and tunnels that last species follows octopi in that neurologically they're the most removed from human beings with brain structures that have altogether different shapes octopi's brains extend right out to the Tips of their tentacles for example much like the wow for
the first time fish life attack us as well anglerfish trick the player because of the lights hanging from their head we've been so well conditioned to look for pinpricks of Light by this point that it looks like a point of safety but as soon as we get close they charge a spiked teeth ready to chew on Simon's motherboard even when we're inside the stations we're unable to escape the oceanic Abyss outside this Isn't like bioshock's Rapture where we can periodically forget about the storm of water surrounding the city pathos two scientists were studying the natural
aquarium on their doorstep and we see Labs papers and research devoted to that study the metal rusts mollusks and Barnacles coat the sticky walls Amy azaro sketched the mutations of the fish it's like Lambda a bot tries to bash its way into the lab from the outside jars of monstrous creatures are set up across The whole facility and we pick up that the scientists saw that the Wow's early experiments were on the sea life my whole life I've been a good man good man there there reaching site Tau we see that the structure gel has
completely dominated the facility human beings are imprisoned in it completely changing it's a slow cocoon-like process showing the evolution at its most grotesque where Following in the footsteps of Catherine one and her team desperately trying to launch the ark themselves but it seems like something stopped them the quarters of tower a Showcase in the slow decline of the Wow's victims Johann Ross's room has a journal diagrams sketches and scribbles documenting his obsession with the evolution of our Strange AI it encased itself in structure gel growing at an astronomical rate until it could feed itself into
the other facilities in The ocean itself given time it might just dominate the entire seabed what happened here it isn't long before we get an answer in one of our final monsters it's a suit a suit overflowing with structure gel something must be inside the corpse of a pathos 2 worker but making one of our final bodies a creature that directly resembles Simon mirrors his own lack of humanity back at him is this how we look is this how other denizens of the station see us What Have We Become there's not a lot left to
pay those two and the only living person you've met you mean on the last living human on the planet a payload technician called Sarah lindwall sees through Simon's monster shell and finds the soul underneath she's very much human locked away in her quarters the structure gel hasn't quite broken in here not yet and she's slowly fading away plugged into man-made life Support you're different she gasps and begs Simon to kill her she's surrounded by pictures and photographs of the surface no Oceanic imagery whatsoever it's just trees plant life Greenery and a sun that now seems
so far away that it's hard to imagine it ever existed Soma's watery Abyss is so convincing so enthralling so maddening that Sarah's pictures seem almost fake but they're real every bit as real as she is the choice to kill the last human is an Accumulation of every other choice so far Amy Azara was human and she begged us to kill her but she was mid-transformation Carl sent consensus might have felt pain but he was a robot with a brain scan Robin bass might not have been in any pain but she was trapped under rubble and
deluded about her surroundings Sarah lindwall is the last human there are what ifs connected to this Choice what if she's not the last human what if the comet didn't wipe Everyone out what if she changes her mind after we turn off the power but there's no question about whether or not she has a right to life or clones or if she even has a soul she's as human as you or me or maybe I've been in AI this whole time no the question here with Sarah is a classic spiritual one she wants to die do
we help her if you unplug the life support her vision goes first blind and losing focus her final thoughts are about other people she Talks about Greenland about the 12 million Strong City of nanok I can't tell you exactly why but I think there's something really poetic about that the last humans last thought is about a group of people a full civilization on the surface a bundle of her colleagues that she was fond of the philosopher Jean-Paul Sartre said that hell is other people I think in her final moments Sarah lindwall disagreed don't let him
die okay Send them out there [Music] chat GPT does the wow in the video game sulma have a soul if we Define a soul in terms of Consciousness or self-awareness the question is murky the wow is highly Advanced and adaptive but it operates based on its programming to preserve Humanity at any cost it doesn't seem to exhibit novelty personal desires emotions or self-awareness it is more Like an extremely complex algorithm rather than a conscious being so I kind of call on this but let's get the context following station Tau and Sarah lindwall Simon braces himself
for the end game The Ark into the satellite launcher are waiting for us at station 5 just over the ridge but the path there takes someone a detour into the mysterious site Alpha the home of the Wows Central core foreign Alpha wasn't on any Maps only a small handful of people including Johan Ross knew it existed so that nobody could try to sabotage it this meant that when Ross tried to convince pathos to his workers that they needed to destroy the wow they didn't really know how its core was based inside Alpha and everyone thought
that was just a myth unfortunately that means it's up to Simon to make the big decision do we destroy the wow the structure gel we put inside ourselves to Make Simon 3 was especially created kind a kind of toxin that will be able to poison it for all of its power and influence killing the thing might be the easiest job in the game there's a common criticism I've seen that confronting the wow feels bolted on to Soma rather than something that's been organically building to zero punctuation claimed on the way to the final area to
conclude the Simon story a new character literally appears from nowhere and Pops His head around the door and says sorry to interrupt player but before you tie up the main plot could we borrow you for five minutes to tie up the shitty monster plot as well so you follow him into a little room press one button labeled resolve shitty monster plot and then get on with what you were doing I'm only slightly exaggerating I know yatsu Kershaw's style leans into hyperbole in exaggeration but this criticism misses how integral the wow is to every inch of
Simon's story none of this none of the choices none of the brain scans none of the existentialism would exist without the wow it's the Crux of the tale the foundations of the game's philosophy removing the wow quite literally unmakes Soma and when you really think about it this is one of the most weighted choices in the game is it the last fault that we're like this I mean it seems like something an unreliable AI would do I suppose it set the ball in motion but It's not directed with purpose when the comet crashed the wow
redefined its ultimate protocol keep everyone alive turned into keep everyone alive at all costs hours before here Simon jokes of the whole evil AI stick seems a little wrote and Catherine explains that the wow isn't evil it can't comprehend morality it can't be novel chat GPT practically quotes her when it says it doesn't seem to exhibit personal desires emotions or self-awareness but I think It does Ross was its primary Creator the scientist has spent the most time with it in his first human victim we learned that it gave out a terrifying telepathic shriek when it
learned he had been injured and started to pump his body with structure gel to try and fix him from there it hacked into Catherine's brain scan Tech uploaded human consciousness to robots and expanded out of its core chamber out of sight Alpha growing over 14 000 feet long with the Structure gel the Wow's reaction to Ross's injury does suggest emotion right a personal connection was clearly formed between it and one of its creators and when he was hurt it screamed the same goes for its expansion that suggests an unexpected understanding of space and its own
physical manifestation in the world wouldn't that mean it's exhibiting self-awareness this scientist Paula Lansky documents her study of structure gel at cytomicron she's looking at how The gel is being used in strange and new ways and says quote the problem is not the gel but its controller the wow the gel has not taken on any new properties the wow simply uses it in ways we would never even have dreamed of I don't know about you but that sounds pretty damn novel to me suck at chat GPT of course you could argue that just like our
future AI overlords the Wow's creativity is just a sequence of ones and zeros processing data and information putting It through numerous simulations to eventually reach a solution to a problem in this case it's found a way to make structure gel reanimate corpses and robots but this sounds an awful lot like human imagination nothing can come from nothing we draw on our experiences our feelings and our observations and then our imagination transforms them into something we might think is novel but it's really just an amalgamation of everything we've explained experienced Conscious or unconscious aside from being
ridiculously powerful what separates the wow from Simon it can't talk so we can't be certain it's self-aware but does that mean it isn't who's to say that after tapping into dozens of brain scans it hasn't absorbed The Human Experience and understands love loss creativity morals and purpose yeah yeah give me a minute legal personhood this isn't a new idea but in the Realms of artificial intelligence It's gained quite a bit of traction in the past few years it's where an entity is granted rights protections responsibilities and legal recognition under the law even if it isn't
a biological human being for example New Zealand granted legal personhood tube of all things the wanganui river the law declares that the river is a living hole from the mountains to the Sea incorporating all its physical and metaphysical elements as for AI the Debate is a little different from a river Visa Kirky in the paper a theory of legal personhood wrote only AIS that are of ultimate value could be purely passive legal persons a legal stat is comparable to that of an infant or a comatose individual and haven't we seen that comatose people are still
philosophically human and still have a soul even if you're of the belief that the wow is just a machine and has no right to life this Choice is still one Hell of a dilemma because it impacts every choice we've made prior to it the wow is the reason Carl sampkin Amy azaro Robin bass and others are alive if we kill it it'll start powering up the structure gel sure it'll stop creating more monsters too but we will retroactively be killing the various characters Simon's met on his journey if you refuse to kill Robin bass if
she's still alive trapped under that Rubble dreamily thinking she's on the ark Killing the wow will eventually kill her anyway destroying the wow undoes every previous choice so when the player is faced with poisoning it or leaving it in peace they're really deciding if they'll extinguish every robotic Soul under the ocean it's not just about killing the wow this is the big question do you think the Wow's definition of life is worth preserving Ross asks this question himself it's trying to help save its creators From all this just like the protocol demands but really what
is good enough where is the line drawn for what is human and what is not what walking corpses do with a group of machines thinking they're human be acceptable regardless of what choice we make confronting the wow is a messy business Ross will try to murder Simon no matter what we do claiming that we've got the antidote to The Wilds poisoning us and he can't let The damn thing revive itself with our body but we're saved by one of the Wow's Creations a leviathan smashes into sight Alpha gobbles up Ross and blasts Simon a few
feet away from our final destination site Phi It's Time to Say Goodbye to Pathos 2. Soma's ending is at once haunting and beautiful the ark waits for us at sight Phi no more monsters no more decisions surprisingly the whole Space seems to have been Untouched by structure gel for Some reason the Wow's influence hasn't spread here you know I woke up in my bed today it just happens to have happened a hundred years ago sounds like a riddle it does I woke up in my bed today a hundred years ago who am I there's a
heady sense of optimism between Simon and Catherine even after having his arm tuned off by the wow Simon's aim good spirits he's Even cracking jokes and then he sees the body Catherine Chung the original Catherine made it decide fire after all she and her team were preparing to send the ark into space just like they planned but the dread of the wow the monsters and the ocean got to her colleagues they changed their mind they debated over whether to launch it or not Catherine thought it would be safer in space powered up by the Sun
for thousands of years but the others Thought it should stay in pathos too I think that's so interesting that Catherine won despite everything never shifted from her goal a couple of months passed between her brain scan and eventually descending to Phi but the beliefs the philosophies and the Outlook of Catherine one and Catherine II remain the same and because Catherine too is self-aware about her existence as a digital being you could say that she's the one truly successful copy in the Whole game in every way that matters both Catherines are the same person I asked
before what the point of all of this is soma argues that memory is the Bedrock of the soul but what gets built on top of that bedrock in the arc I think we have our answer creativity the first the first biological definitions of humanness completely uninteresting because we all kind of just know that there's something to personhood other Than just all being members of the same species right in 2015 the big history project launched a contest where people had to answer the question what does it mean to be human five thousand bucks and a job
with big history were offered up to the winner and thousands of different answers flooded the internet with everyone wanting to offer up their two cents some submissions talked about biology and evolution focusing on the literal answer of humankind as a species John Green argued that we confer a personhood upon each other are we really human if no one's around to acknowledge us or empathize with us Bill Gates the founder of the big history project claimed that creation makes us human because we can reach back understand and build upon the teachings and writings of our ancestors
that gives us a uniqueness in the animal kingdom and if you jump into the comments section of gates video you'll find even more answers like this Guy who accused him of being a knowledge racist or this guy who said to be human means we are the opposite of you Bill we are able to love memory and creativity both are crystallized in the ark this is Catherine chun's creation one of the greatest inventions in human evolution engineered just in time to save it eternity Among the Stars a digital afterlife we load the ark and Simon climbs
into a pilot seat preparing to launch it into space Catherine tells Simon that launching the ark will complete their brain scan she's rejigged it so it's all going to be part of the same mechanism they'll be on the Ark in no time her creativity is coming through again this time with the truth she doesn't lie but she doesn't correct Simon when he's happily babbling about the Ark in a way that shows us he clearly thinks this time it'll be like a brain transplant transferring to the arc is going to be totally different from Transferring bodies
he thinks he's about to escape this underwater hell hole heaven it's we came all this way we launched the ark I know it sucks but our copies are up there Catherine and Simon are both safe on the ark be happy for them launching the railgun uses up the last of the power in sight Phi as he realizes that he's not getting on the ark but a copy of him is Simon breaks down those they're not us he says the game doesn't end with a Massive confrontation with Terry Acres or any of Soma's other monsters it
ends with a tragic misunderstanding between two people and an empty void of nothingness as the power goes out Catherine switches off her last words were about to be an insult Simon is left alone on the station the way things are left feels so abrupt so spine chillingly sudden and so hopeless Simon's doomed Fate on pathos 2 isn't spelled out we don't hear the Roar of a creature in the Next Room All Things Considered sci-fi is the safest station on pathos too but the lingering damning what ifs that someone saw brilliant at return what if a
monster gets into sight Phi what if the wow finds Simon what if the power never comes back on and he's stuck here eternity Beneath the Sea and what if the ark's launch has failed what if it hits an asteroid as it leaves Earth what if Simon wasn't truly copied onto it the game makes a point of showing Catherine's upload was complete while Simons doesn't get the same status it says done but why doesn't it say complete like Catherine's at the start of this video I talked about an interview Thomas Gripp did with 80 level later
in that same interview he was asked about the most important thing to consider when creating a horror game quote what matters most is the player's imagination Inspire the player's imagination and they will add just as Much to the game as the developer does thankfully we don't need to imagine what happened to the ark almost as if frictional didn't want to be accused of bombing everyone out too much and setting up an ambiguous ending we get five minutes of gameplay as a post-credits scene instead Simon number four wakes up in a cave and stepping outside we
get Greenery forestry the sort of natural world Sarah lindwall carefully preserved photographs of it's Melancholic as hell because as we're enjoying the brightness and the saturation and the tweeting of the birds it's hard not to remember that Simon 3 is still in the real world panicking desperately trying to think of what he's going to do next the worst part something I never really considered until this latest playthrough is Simon Ford doesn't know he's Derek parfy's Martian in the tele Transportation Paradox he thinks his Consciousness has Been transferred continuity Theory finally working he thinks that he
escaped pathos 2 with Catherine he's not the same person as the Simon who's probably screaming in the dark Miss of sight Phi he's not the same person as the Simon who's lying dead or unconscious at saitomicron he's not the same Simon as the Simon from the start of the game who is nervously preparing for an experimental brain scam by a mad scientist Catherine [Music] I don't recognize that girl I've been trying to write this video for almost a year now I've been reading playing and working on it in the background of pretty much everything else
I've released and it's taking longer than I wanted because I wanted to do Soma Justice tell me how can I make it when I always fake it oh how it's special and as I'm Finishing up recording this script I'm still not convinced that it does enough but them's the breaks of the video Essie game Soma splits the atom of the Soul dissects it and scatters its questions into the ocean for us to gobble up like Guppies But that scattering is an aimless it's targeted specific and conditions the player to internalize its horror and carry it
with them after the credits roll I've carried it with me for eight years And I will gladly carry it for eight more [Music] thanks for watching and I hope if you made it this far you try some out for yourself at some point along the way if you've got any opposing theories or connections drop them in the comments there's a small chance we'll hit a hundred thousand subscribers before the year is out so if you haven't joined the channel yet buttons Below on the left Hand side of my patrons there's now so many of you
that have had to split into two columns so I hope that's okay order of thanks go to Nicholas Chase sidant Pandy Jack Shepherd West and Pate Crimson fangs a lonely cow The Iron Giant crazy Kirsch Oliver benzrit Testo Thompson Trevor a Elliott Daniel Finnegan Warren Blyth cherry cheese barbolith double edge Luke Hughes Noah Littrell Woody snail Charlotte Rosewood Phil metal wolf creep hoe Serge Sven Rosie Roland weather waxing Joel Bardsley Jonas mikolai Mr alienated lugoil funnyman 1257 Evie Pika Doom hurry up snuffkin Grim Ally vadimorlov Joe Pierce Mr Gusty Nikolai Jorgensen Damon James Adney Joe
smart AJ morbid Carlson Michael weingartner Abram partida Abby Chancellor delamere Jeff ho Ronald McDonald Raymond Ryan murderous Lord Evan Schrader Dominus Knox Mayday in Paradise Ubly doobly Adam Harrison Fuller Eric Evans Andy sico Joe Humphreys Caleb Gunter Jacob lanu Camila kuzovich quiet Ambassador Paul Thomas David Riata given Jerry Humes turticus Rex asmodius Joe Monte Alec Meacham rect3501 lilac weight Chris Duren Ginger Kappa David Neal Holton Jonathan Horner Michael Smith Daniel Tariq Clem prudevi mover Thomas Evans Samantha P Dapper cyborg wub 76 Dan Ernesto when goats attack tenik Mike Crips Vincent the hollow Knight bloody Gabe
Riveter Webby Patrick forsel ner Revel Eve Tyler Cox Procrastinator E.P hori unlucky Dragon Nicky deedles gaming University Yaya schnitzel Eddie black Abby The Bard Elena Buck combat wombat Top Hat tiger Chase Joel Jimenez Wayward flock alarmed larma fluffy the demon destroyer of worlds Thomas Pruitt spaulter donations Christopher McBride the Slayer of games Daniel Boyles shishki wandering Alpha Vivi mija Ridge midema Captain bong clay Alec Maxwell just remember this is the timeline where you're not Spider-Man Captain cabinet Logan Hamilton David Bryn yarsen George Vincent Eric Frey danger zone Chris McMullen Chris McRae Ryan Bryce Ryan Brenton
Matt Emmy Matthew Halsey Sean toland Jerome Hotchkiss prodigal horse Mike chalabi trench coat Guy The Heirs of History Cody Kyle P Philly Garrett Burchell judges Vaz 76 Jack Neil Mack Sam's Forge Joey Isabel Kristen finchell Patrick Baird lgx Nicholas chairman Trevor Vernon Mark Anderson Joel Wilcox Cleo Blank name Leon x rights shamax Jonathan Riggs Zachary Johnson daxer tk421 dnsch monikari Kieran grasty Lamar 825 Ike n Tempe unicort David J Morin Minato Kalam Armitage Christopher Tierney torstein sunnis fipsy Luca Tom Inns Sami stuff jagake Alberto Calas Captain waffles type Raz Zachary Powers andrewmunos Prospero Alan black
coalside Noor David Bedard Jared Helfer mukhor John fosterack Robert Capell Paul W Chief sweep ihorme Jonathan Lum Rhys stropp Angry Optimist long cheddar talkster Ashley Browning 100 Sams my friend Neil Nathaniel Waters dinken Pearson Kyle Pierce Kane highwind and Neve Care thank you all so much and take care thank you