hello everyone this is Tom Fox back for another episode and I'm absolutely thrilled today to have with me Bruna Vega Bruna first of all welcome to the podcast thank you ter thank for it's such a pleasure to be here to discuss about good not to compli Department were while and the importance of this department for the fin market so thank you so much for your time here to bring me at this space for networking and knowledge it and thanks for the audience or following up episode as you might have figured out Bruna is from South
Texas maybe a little south of Texas but we're going to have a great discussion today about compliance specifically or at least particularly in the financial Market in Brazil but also globally and she's got a lot of great ideas around both of these Geographic areas so we're going to start with Bruna if you could give us a little bit about your professional background yeah thank you I started at C PL Department 10 years ago by now uh I started as a traine and then I did a littleit my career to ad to the role of leg
compliance officer as I do right now and I work in a fund management so we have to take look at all the regulation enforce for the kind of product we serve for the clients really how is that how does that background help uh you have the perspective on combining the regulations that you and your clients are under with the compliance challenges that every financial institution has in a market whether it's in Brazil or the United States yeah Financial Market I think is one of the business that has most speculations in force to comine so it's
difficult to have o track you have to always take no look at what the Regulators are publishing and you have to become first responsible in the company for checking if what you're doing in your daily rtings are in accordance with what the regulation en Force requires you to do and besides that you have always accomplish with annual deadlines reports and have to answer for the regulators and you always s you be approving the parties I think that complies to the main importance to understanding all this regulations and making sure that the company is looking for
it so I'm always interested in people who can talk about the development of a compliance Department a compliance function compliance within a corporation I started coming to Brazil about 2015 and the first time I came I would have said at that time Brazil this was the start of laato and would have said compliance was about 5 years behind the United States the clean companies act had just come into force and then I came back in 20 uh the first year after the pandemic in 2021 I think and I would have said America's 1A and Brazil
is 1B uh meaning there had been a huge development of compliance internal compliance programs in Brazil in that time so I was wondering if I could ask you to give me your overview of how compliance functions developed in uh Brazil literally for the 10 years of your practice yeah sure uh I think that uh when I saw it at the department it was not even called compliance yet it was called risk management ear and we had to understand how to bring the standards to what we have right now I believe that for the past 10
years right now we had looked at a lot in EML especially and Brazil is one of the best refers in the whole world in in he we all the rules enforc Bel in the website of the Brazilian FCC and the Brazilian bank of the central bank so we have all of the groups totally for free for anybody that wants to access and wants to do a self study so uh if you want to become a good compliance officer it depends a lot of near to light on all these uh rules and making sure that your
company is doing exactly what the r uh requires to do and especially about the Fone management part we also have an organization called Aima which is quite similar to the we always have events that they provide to clarify Some Ds that the financial Market has and they also publish a lot of manuals trying to catch all the people's doubts lately about thees yeah in terms of financial Market we became Brazil one of the biggest reference in the whole world in terms of standards and in terms of how the rules are uh available for everybody to
access the uh development of compliance programs in response to those rules is equally interesting to me and what would you say are some of the factors that have driven the growth for instance you just talked about the rules and regulations but in America we saw businesses require companies they did business with to have compliance functions and then Banks and financial investors require compliance so it was actually a group Beyond regulations has that been your experience in Brazil or is it something different yeah definitely we are going to this PA that if you don't have a
good CLI Department develop it you will be approving in the decision so even if you somehow try to Fay for the regulator you won't last for a lot of time because you will be catching by down and you will also be catched by your three parties and you will be able to make her business grow because you'll feel the pressure from all the sides here make it happen but one thing that I recognize is that in the past 10 years I got some nail some people that are R company than they are more fashioned ways
you think oh we had we we had done a lot of money without accomplishing with all these things so I have right now the obligation to have a department that takes me money your investment Department it doesn't get me directly any Investments at all because comp Department doesn't have you bring clients and so there are few people that still think that c L is not there Neary and it's quite expensive to make it but this culture is St in a way because we can see that if you are not going to you all the sides
will be pressing you to your failing in the financial Market because you will be approved by your to pars you will be approved by The Regulators as well we always receive a lot of requirements from the The Regulators along the year asking for f es we have to pass through the status so if we don't have a good Department always catching there your role as a compliance officer Does it include responding to other companies request to either look at or assess your compliance program is that something you have had to do personally yeah we do
have to REM more for du for out in procedures we have to report for all the requirements on behalf of The Regulators we sometimes receive requ for Brazilian ACC the Central Bank are from our Thea which call AO we always receive the kind of questions about how a specific activity will is going on and the Ence is to Pro and if for some reason the F doesn't respect the limits of investment that it was supposed to accomplish with we also receiving time a lot of requirements to prove that we try and to do how we
try and to solve the problem when we are doing everything ride we always rece this kind of questions and we are for some reason sing most strong all so we'll receive it as well so the let me go back to something you said very early which I think was when you began your career these departments were not called compliance but were called risk or risk management yep why that intrigued me so much is in America where actually complian is moving towards that towards thinking about compliance as one one type of risk obviously any company has
risks whatever their business is and certainly in the financial markets or financial industry there's types of risks but here's the question why this is such a challenge in America is compliance professionals tend to be people like me who are lawyers by professional training risk management is not always something they are familiar with particularly in financial markets uh has that been your experience or do you find that with your professional background you've been able to sort of wed those two concepts one risk in the financial industry but compliance as well yeah I think that since our
rules developed a little bit uh later than the American ones and in America we had earlier some cases that help it to develop the compliance Department as we know nowadays the USA was one some steps forward comparing to us in a few years uh ago but now right now we are getting a lot closer we are getting to the fact that we are always looking for the same subjects that need use it's a part of CLI agend uh review all the policies to reveal arum to review cyber security and uh accomplishing with all the that
we have to do to guarantee that the data that uh the company holds will will not suffer any kind of ATT so uh all the subjects that uh an American Financial company has to accomplish with no day is basically the same subject that we do in pursu but it was not the reality a few years ago because we had to pass through the same process of mes that America did but it did earlier than us about having scandals and cases that help it us to understand how the compliance Department was important and how to build
the r stands and guidelines to use so that really leads to the next area I wanted to visit with you about which is balancing multiple regulation regulations simultaneously and you talked about the American regulations and you talked about Brazilian the Brazilian framework so I guess question one is what are some strategies you might suggest for navigating the various regulatory Landscapes and then the followup would be are there Frameworks that a financial institution could think about which would comply with both or do you need a separate framework that's an important question especially because I haven't working
in companies that have you accomplished with at the same time American and Brazilian regulations I always trying C looking for the more standard so if I were complying with the more of one basically I would be in accomplish with the eest one as well for bringing an example here in America you have to provide a backup of all documents for 10 years in Brazil the deadline is five years so I always try to reach the the most typical standard with which would be 10 years because I would be of a level play also in accordance
with the Brazilian one another example that I passed passed through was when uh we already had the AML rule in America and we didn't have the safe standards in Brazil we started to implement all the procedures you a risk based approach and that sign were already looks for all our relationships all employees third parties and uh clients in a risk based approach putting down in high medum and low risk and we doing a is analyze for the frequency of The RK that reestablish to reach relationship that's s that for a while it was a reality
for the American regulation but it wasn't for Brazilian yet so I already because we had to comply with both but few mosts later it so now to be as well an obligation here so we have the same standards for amm Brazil that we do in America I'd like to maybe turn the focus to some of the Hot Topics in compliance and I want to start with moneya laundering and I say that with the following introduction there was a multi-billion dollar enforcement action in the United States against a Canadian bank called TD Bank which had a
US bran so that's that's sort of on everyone's mind right now is money laundering what are some of the key challenges you seeing from where you sit in Brazil on moneya laundering these days I think there a big challenge sometimes as to in terms of the sign the fun management is to to know about the evidence before turning out to be uh real risk sometimes you prove a client in the time that it didn't it didn't show any risk so you put us in at low risk and you would only get you analyed this again
years later if you keep all this time not refreshing this analyzed it can happen anything that could change your concern about this risk and can change as well how you are comfortable with continue with this relationship so I think that the most difficult Park Val do in is refreshing this analyze your year and getting to know the risk before it turned out to be a real Scandal the perhaps the most ubiquitous topic right now in compliance is ai ai governance use of AI and compliance policies and procedures around Ai and I guess I wanted to
just ask from your perspective what are some of the key issues you're either seeing or you're advising companies on we hear that's good question s uh European Union just publish a new act about a system and I believe that next step will be having a rule in America and having a rule in Brazil totally dedicated only about how AI systems must uh behave and how they must provide so reports to guarantee that the AI system counts with human intelligence as well to guarantee that data won't be uh attact in any way because for example I
if I put all the AI system some questions in my from my rtin any accounts with client data I am not quite sure yet if we are totally secure that it won't be attacked in any way I believe that the next St about the subject is having rules for each country about the subject and obligating the financial companies to have manuals about how and in which moments we are supposed or not supposed to use AI system in our daily routines so I think that by this year from 2026 probably the companies will be lying on
to have uh internal manuals to to use AI systems internally so BR I wanted to maybe turn towards the topic of compliance considerations and marketing but I want to pair it with how do you help or how do you continually communicate to the business unit employees their obligations around compliance without causing compliance burnout without causing compliance fatigue without causing oh my God another email from Runa okay delete H how do you keep them engaged yet give them the information they need with the ever evolving regulations around truth and transparency and Communications yeah it's important because
his compliance has sped through years trying to understand how to deal dealing with the business so isn't tricky situations not being the person that is look at as already go she's trying to you to stop the business word I think it's an obligation for the compliance sub you from one side being friendly enough for people trusting on him or on her and uh when something happens don't be afraid to talk with your compliance officer so a part of these relationship comes from the complaints of guarantee that people knows that he's trying the best to being
close to people and helping the business to grow but on the other hand you just can't like hide any inance you just can't agree with anything that is wrong because you are personally responsible for this it's important I think when you are going to be hiring a company to to guarantee that everybody that is uh leading the company knows that you are doing things right and you're are not going to agree with anything that is not in accomplish with the rules and one one other topic that it's important is time to time you have to
refresh with people about the compling subjects in uh in a good way you have to do a training that people feels interested to you listen to you you have to do a training that people W really understand the importance of uh accomplishing with the rules and understand deeply B def Fin and all the risk that we are taking if we are not going to do the things in accordance with the rules I think that the best feedback that I ever received in my career is that I really know that I can count on you and
I really know that you try your best to make the the business deelow but you won't do it in such a way that I'll be in a risky situation this best feedback I ever had but uh will have to make it difficult wait you still have like the bad cop you have to guarantee that people really understand your concerns so people will be Pro compliant as well not only you will be Pro business so it's important for both sides you have this relationship always develop and for the company best thing that can happen is if
you GoLine Sofer never creats from the job because the worst thing that can happen is having you change such a person that must be from your loyalty and a person that you have to really trust on so if this role is always coming and going with different people there is USS like there Bruna let me end by asking you the following question given the evolution you have seen in compliance in your professional career what would you say to the university student uh about having a career in compliance and if you think it's a valid career
or a good career path what skill set would you suggest they learn as I mentioned I'm a lawyer so I have that professional background but there are other skills that could be useful for Mir perspective how would you advise a a university student or someone else who may be thinking about compliance as a career yeah it's quite difficult because the compliance Department always have to count with people there are more develop it in professional ways because everything that we do in our daily routine is so sens sensitive and if something goes wrong the risk and
the damage is so huge always we all we never say small small damages the mostal part for a person to start at this department right now is getting an opportunity in understanding how the department works an advice that I would give is join every event that you can join every podcast that you can listen to join every different book releating that you can read you because every Network and every knowledge that we will get year by year is so important and even if you are already in the compliance Department working it's so much important to
keep dating yourself talking to different people and understanding if you are doing the rice tenders or if for some reason you didn't rule quite well and you have to refresh your rtin so we have to keep studying for the rest of our lives we it's like an Unstoppable highway it's important to highlight that this department requires people that are really curious and really wants to always keep upating themselves and this department requires people that lien you things are the right way and doing things at the right way is not always doing things when everybody's watching
is also doing the things that was supposed to be done even if nobody's watching you have to be eal you have to accomplish with your personal values but if you are this person in your daily life as a human being there this Ro will fit with you because you have to fit this values in your professional career and what a most passion about complains is this is that I can't leave in my career the same values that I really in my personal life I think that this devices would be good and definitely trying to look
for opportunity that are in Good Financial Market standards and in a it would be a good path because working in Brazil is turned out to be a place that you can do compliance well and you have like your standards globally comparing but it's giv you only if you are going for an opportunities you always guarantee that you're going to an opportunity with a a company and with employers and partners with that will support the compliance Department you just can't be in a place that nobody wants to you but was supposed to you have to be
in the compl in a company that will want that wants to being in compliance with all the standards such as you want here BR unfortunately we are now at the end of our time but before we leave I wanted to ask you if any of our listeners wanted to connect with you what might be the best way for them to do oh so thank you if you can make my link available for everybody to reach out is the best way that you can cont with me because there be my publishing in my professional career there
BR I wanted to thank you again for taking the time to visit with me it's been a fascinating exploration of financial industry compliance in Brazil with a little American compliance thrown in I hope we can continue this conversation hope so thank you so much for the space for your time talk I hope we can Contin here in M tou