[Music] hello and welcome to philosophy vibe the channel where we discuss and debate different philosophical ideas today we're going to be discussing solipsism and the problem of other minds well fascinating now we have covered solipsism in our philosophy of mind series but we thought it would be worthwhile to have a soul video on the subject yes in short solipsism is the idea that the only thing we have direct access to is our own minds our own thoughts our own consciousness and our own experiences because of this we can only be sure uncertain that our own
minds exist which means we cannot in fact be certain that any other minds exist it could be quite possible that I am the only mine that exists a truly radical theory indeed I think it's worth looking at the history behind solipsism first and the steps that has led certain philosophers to take this ellipses standpoint sure it is fair to say that the roots of solipsism began in the 16th century with rene descartes in his meditations on the first philosophy they caught goes through a process of doubt they caught reasons that he has often found himself
in a dream that was indistinguishable from reality he was fully in a dream but had no idea and believed everything was real if it is possible for one senses to deceive them sometimes then it is possible for one senses to deceive them all the time and so they caught agreed that he could in fact be permanently in a dream world that does not physically exist I see from there they caught doubts the existence of everything he has come to know by his senses everything in reality except his own mind he knows that he exists he
coins the famous phrase I think therefore I am they caught knows that if he is able to doubt it means he is conscious and therefore alive so was they caught the First's ellipsis not really during the meditations he reasons that God exists and that God cannot be a deceiver and so he rejects masterson and accepts the existence of the material world and of other minds I see now fast forward to the 17th century and we have the philosopher John Locke who made a distinction between primary and secondary qualities Locke believed that the things like shape
extensions size all existed in an external physical world these are primary qualities however things like colour taste and smell all exist in the mind these are secondary qualities and these are created by the powers of the primary qualities so effectively half of reality solely belongs in the mind and not in the external world yes understand and from there we reached the philosopher George Berkeley who rejected the external world altogether he took John Locke's theory even further and said even the primary qualities are in the mind all of reality is just mental ideas there is no
material world no external reality to the mind all of reality was mind dependent truly fascinating and just to let you know we have full videos covering Descartes Locke and Berkeley the links will be in the description so please check them out if you want to go deeper into their theories so by the 18th century the complete rejection of a material world was a prominent theory among philosophers so now we are just one step away from solipsism let's look at the reasoning in reaching a syllabuses position you would agree that your mental states are completely private
and unobservable to anyone else yes I suppose no one can see my thoughts or ideas directly correct and so you agree you cannot have direct access to anyone else's thoughts or ideas yes I agree so all you can be sure of is your own thoughts your own ideas and your own mind and as you do not have direct access to anyone else's thoughts or ideas you cannot definitively say anything else exists outside of your own mind and so you cannot definitively say that anyone else has thoughts or ideas you cannot any certainty say that anyone
else has consciousness other than you this is known as the problem of other minds I must doubt the existence of all other minds I am quite possibly the only conscious being in reality okay okay I agree we cannot have direct access to someone else's consciousness but you can say you have indirect access and so it puts us in a good position to infer that other minds exist and what is this indirect access I would say behavior we know how our own mental states correlate to our own body so when we see bodies behaving in a
certain way we can infer they must also be having certain mental states when you for example cut your finger you feel pain and you scream so if you see someone else cut their finger and scream you can infer that the sensation of pain took place and so they have consciousness they have a mind it does exist and it does feel this is known as inference is the best explanation but this is still an inference it is not concrete proof it is not certain knowledge so behavior does not solve the issue every other person in my
life can be what is known as a philosophical zombie on the outside they are indistinguishable from a normal human being but inside they lack conscious experience and sentience so if I cut my finger I feel the pain and I scream if I was to see someone else cut that finger and then scream there is a huge bit of data missing for me namely the sensation of pain I have no idea that the other person felt this pain all Feltz anything at all it could be just a simple input/output these zombie caught their finger and the
zombie screamed but no feeling or sensation actually took place whatever was felt cannot be accessed by me it cannot be proven by me and cannot be known by me and so I have no evidence that this actually took place and that the consciousness exists I have every reason to doubt it exists it could be that I am the only being that feels that thinks that is conscious I am the only mine that exists but we can see thoughts and conscious feelings the breakthroughs we have made in neuroscience means we can measure thought processes would this
not be proof measuring is not direct access with all the breakthroughs in neuroscience we cannot actually see a thought and we definitely cannot experience someone else's mental state so no this is not proof ok fine behavior may not be enough to definitely prove the existence of other Minds but what about language what about language does the existence of a shared language with mutual understanding not prove that other Minds exist how so let's look at Vick in Stein's private language argument bacon Stein explained that it would make no sense for someone to speak a language that
no one else understood what would be the points in uttering words that only you understood no one else in the entire world could make any sense of the words you were saying speaking this private language would be meaningless right right so in a world where you are the only mind that exists any mention of a mental states you have would be meaningless as no other mind is conscious so they would not have any mental states so words like pain pleasure happy sad these would effectively be a private language a language so that's only you understood
because the words of this language refer to they logically private states of your mind yes I can agree with that well if there were no other minds how could you attach feelings with words if they are solely privates in order to do this they need to be public they need to be understood and recognized by other minds but you do talk about your feelings and sensations we all do we attach words to them so that we can discuss them with other people and other people can know what we are talking about hmm this was Vicki
in Stein's points he denied the possibility of a private language he use that language is necessarily public in nature it would not be possible to engage in conversation were it not for the existence of common meanings and so unlike a private language we can share our thoughts and feelings and mental ideas we may not directly perceive other people's mental states but we have a common language where we can discuss them proving that other people have the same or similar mental ideas I can talk about my mental ideas and other Minds can understand and respond to
this proving there are other thinking Minds experiencing mental ideas I'm sorry but I do not think this proves other Minds exist why not I would like you to imagine a dream which is somewhere along the lines of what these ellipses can imagine reality to be now I often meet people in my dreams and I have conversations with them but they are not conscious minds yes they are using language I am using language and everything seems to function I am the only conscious mind in my dream yet there is a public language you would not say
this is proof that the characters in my dream are conscious Minds you could say they are they are part of your mind created by your consciousness exactly and so is everyone and everything else in this reality mm-hmm okay okay so explain how would this work if you are the only conscious being that exists what does this mean did you create reality and everything and everyone in it well one idea is that yes I did create everything I create and perceive simultaneously just like a dream so you were saying you can pick up and read a
book on quantum mechanics something you do not understand yet you created the character that wrote the book how then do you have this knowledge yet to not understand it this is the case with anything I can ask you about the architecture of simples Cathedral you have no idea of architecture yet somehow you built simples Cathedral are you saying you also painted the Mona Lisa created Beethoven symphonies yet you have no idea how to or play an instrument this seems logically inconsistent now we are getting into the metaphysics of this but yes I did create all
of these things just like I do with all the details of my dreams not the same thing your dreams are your subconscious projections of things you have seen in the real world if for example you dream of a beach you have seen a beach in the real world and this is projected onto your dreams you did not create the beach in the first instance but if I am the only conscious mind then I am basically good it's like I've created my own video game and I've put myself in as a character this is starting to
sound absurd I mean if you are good why are you not all-powerful why would you create yourself as an average everyday person why not give yourself the most amazing life possible riches fame power etc the same way I am NOT all-powerful when every dream I have I give myself limitations for a richer experience oh come on in dreams most of the time you do not know you were dreaming you are saying that you believe to be the only mind and the creator of reality this is then comparable to a lucid dream so go on then
fly turn into a giant manipulate reality if you are a creator fully aware that you are a creator you could well perhaps I am NOT God but there is a God that has created everything and plugged my mind and my mind alone into this reality for the experience see this just sounds like the most self-centered and narcissistic theory possible you are saying either you are God or that God has created reality just for you this is not an attractive theory to espouse also no two people could ever agree to solipsism as in theory only one
person could be rights also if you truly believe this why are you talking to me why do you talk to anyone if we are just figments of your imagination I am continuing to play the game I am just interacting with the reality that I am in I think that sounds absurd well there you go just a reminder the script video is part of the philosophy of perception ebook available on Amazon if you want to read over this debate and support the channel please get yourself a copy it really is a great ebook by the way
we have the scripts to loccs primary and secondary qualities Barclays idealism and Hume skepticism definitely worth a read the link will be in the description but that's all the time we have for now thank you for watching we hope you enjoyed the vibe and what are your thoughts are there any syllabus up there if there are you're actually wrong as I am the only conscious mind there is but still let us know in the comments below if you enjoyed the video please like and share and make sure you subscribe for more philosophical debates take care
until next time