hello everyone i hope all of you are well and having a wonderful day for this module i will be talking about the different models of clep or clinical legal education programs i am carlo vistan a professor at the u.p college of law i am also the director of the u.p office of legal aid or upola as it is often called i hope you find this module informative and useful should you have any questions about the presentation please feel free to get in touch with me through up hola before proceeding further let me outline the flow
of this presentation so you will have an idea of what's in store i will start by explaining the significance of thinking in terms of models of clinical legal education programs i will then explain the basis of the typology or classification of the models to be presented after these preliminary remarks we will go through the different models we will then end with some points on how best to use the information from this module now that you have an idea of the topics to be discussed let's proceed as already mentioned this module is about models of clinical
legal education or cle programs this begs the question why think in terms of models we have to go back to the reason for this module and for the entire series for some clues to understanding the significance of thinking in terms of models you are going through this module to learn about cle programs that last word programs is the key to appreciating the significance of thinking in terms of models a program is a concept that involves multiple components functioning or working together to achieve a goal or set of goals speaking in terms of academic programs for
example we do not think only of one particular course or even the entire listing of courses that the student must complete we think first about what the objectives or learning outcomes that the program seeks to achieve we then think of the various aspects of the implementation of the program like the subject matter coverage of each course how the courses of the program are arranged when during the program should each of the courses be taken how they complement or build on each other how the subject matter or instruction is delivered how the student's performance is assessed
and then how the other actors in the program like professors the courses and the program itself are assessed in terms of their contribution to achieving the program goals now that's a lot and it should be the same with clinical legal education programs even if a cle program involves just one course in the law school's curriculum that course the program itself must be planned built and then implemented with the same dimensions outlined above the goals content processes methods of instruction student assessment and then the assessment of the course are aspects of the program that must be
conceived and planned so that the benefits of clinical legal education may be fully realized thinking about programs in this sense makes the use of models crucial if not indispensable modeling after all includes discerning not only components and structures but also goals and functions and then the interrelations of all these dimensions there are many parallels in how i have so far described programs and models and that is no accident for to be thinking about designing or planning a program is in fact creating a model of it in our minds the significance then of thinking in terms
of models is this being aware of the various models already out there and understanding and comparing their features would allow us not only to adopt or choose the model we want but also to adapt or modify the model for our peculiar context and needs being aware of models contributes directly to planning building and implementing cle programs in a systematic way that is the significance of thinking in terms of models and of course knowing the models themselves so why not dive into the models already we will do that in a while but before that some explanation
of the typology or classification to be presented must be given the discussion of the models presented here is based on experience and information gathered about the different ways in which law schools go about giving their students practical training in the law the information is based on my experience with and exposure to different environments that allow learning through practice of the law as well as documented anecdotal information the classifications made in cern are based on the observed distinguishing features of the various models most of the models to be presented here were adopted without any law requiring
them having said that some rules such as the old and the amended rule 138a of the rules of court or what we call the law student practice rule seek to regulate cle programs at any rate the main point here is that the emergence and evolution of these models is due to practice and not legislation the typology or classification adopted is based on an analysis of empirical data at various levels or perspectives to be able to discuss the different models observed in a logical manner it is often observed that actual cle programs exhibit distinguishing features that
could serve as the basis of two different models it should therefore be noted that while a particular model presented here could on its own be the basis of or dominate a particular law school's it is often the case that law schools adopted and combined various models to reap the advantages of each of them another effect of this reality is that some of the features of the models overlap to an extent but the models are still distinguishable because of other distinct dominant features these preliminary remarks on the significance of thinking in terms of models and the
basis of classification of the models to be discussed we can now survey the different models and their distinguishing features the first level of classification i will present stems from the type of practical experience in the law that the students may gain based on the type of experience they offer there are two general types or models a government service model and a private practice model the government service model involves the student working at the government office or agency to help handle its legal services in general then the experience and insights gained by the student is that
of a lawyer in the government service the particular experience offered however is dictated by the mandate and functions of the government office involved typical examples of this model are the internships or student clerkships in the judiciary as well as in offices such as the office of the solicitor general the office of the government corporate council and other government offices involved in litigation or legal advising on the other hand the private practice model simply put involves the student getting some lawyering experience outside the government service this description does not offer much details but this is because
the model accommodates a diverse set of experience that even evolves as the legal practice evolves from typical litigation involving private parties to public interest lawyering that offer opportunities to handle human rights cases environmental litigation and issues affecting indigenous and other marginalized communities the types of lawyering experience that could fall under this model is indeed the most diverse this diversity allows for further classification of the private practice model into the following subtypes or models the public interest lawyering model and practice for compensation model public interest lawyering involves the rendition of legal services to marginalized sectors as
well as advocacies to promote objectives or causes that are considered of public interest but are usually not in the mainstream of society or while in the mainstream are actually underserved this subtype is also broad enough to accommodate further classification or models one is the indigent litigation model and the other is the public advocacy model indigent litigation appears to be the primary service that many law clinics of law schools offer including the office i had the up office of legal aid this model offers a diverse set of experience that overlaps with the experience that could be
gained in the practice for compensation model only that the service is rendered without compensation for indigent parties students here could be exposed to the handing of criminal civil labor and other administrative cases of all sorts which diversity i believe is why this model is popular among law schools and students also falling under the public interest lawyering model is the public advocacy model this type of clinical experience involves taking on a particular cause or the interest of a marginalized or underserved community or sector of society and then helping them by employing the methods usually associated with
public interest lawyering this kind of lawyering seeks to advance the communities or sectors welfare by increasing public awareness advocating for more attention or resource allocation from the government or even defending them or winning a claim for them in the courts perhaps equally broad as the public interest lawyering model is the practice for compensation model the best way to describe this model is that it exposes students to the cases were in clients pay compensation or fees for legal services which could therefore be any kind of case or legal matter this model would be the best way
to gain significant experience in the work lawyers do for corporations and other business ventures as well as in specialized practice areas such as intellectual property law banking and finance law and competition law that caps the discussion of the models based on the types of experience they offer to recap there are two larger models in this typology the government service model and a private practice model under the last mentioned private practice model are two subtypes the public interest lawyering model and the practice for compensation model the public interest lawyering model in turn has two distinguishable subtypes
the indigent litigation model and the public advocacy model in truth classifying based on the experience the students may gain could result in as many models as there are law practice areas or specializations i only present in this module what should be useful for our anticipated audience who i presume is looking for information on how to plan establish improve or maximize the benefits of a clinical legal education program for these purposes knowledge of the general models presented so far would suffice the discussion so far has been about the models classified according to the lawyering experience they
offer a classification of models could also be made based on who mentors the student viewed from the perspective of the law school to be more specific this classification is based on whether the supervising lawyer is someone who works for the law school and the program itself or someone who does not work for but rather works with the law school in mentoring the student under this classification system we could identify two models an internship model and an externship model an internship model is one wherein the mentor or supervising lawyer as we call them is one engaged
by the law school itself under the clinical legal education program as such the mentoring and experience are delivered directly by the law school usually through a law clinic traditionally the student who undertakes a practicum course in a law clinic is called an intern hence the designation of the model as one of internship in fact the law student practice rule refers to this model as a law clinic in this presentation the term internship model is used to emphasize the direct supervision of the student by the law school through its own mentors or supervising lawyers the externship
model on the other hand is one wherein the mentoring is provided by lawyers not engaged by the law school in such programs the law school allows the student to complete the practicum requirement working for a partner entity outside the law school organization such as a law firm or government office in such a model this the law school sets parameters for the externship that the partner entity agrees to observe the supervising lawyer employed by the partner entity is the one directly supervising and interacting with the student while there is some coordination with the partner entity in
the law school the law school usually does not direct how such supervision or mentoring is actually given the law student practice rule allows for and actually defines an externship as follows externship is part of the clinical legal education program if it allows students to engage in legal work for the marginalized sectors or for the promotion of social justice and public interest and it is undertaken with any of the following the courts the integrated bar of the philippines government offices and law school recognized non-governmental organizations we leave this classification of models into internships and externships to
discuss the next category of models for this category the distinguishing feature is the location where the students work in the course of completing their clinical legal education experience there are four models observed under this category the first is the office based model the second is the community-based model the third is the classroom-based model and the fourth being the remote clinic model as with the other classification systems a combination of these models could be observed and could be adopted in cle programs as the label implies an office based model would be one wherein the law school
provides a permanent physical office that would serve as the base of operations and primary workstation of its students in this model the student could go to work in the office and do his or her student lawyering there regularly reporting to the office and staying there for a set amount of time could be required by the program this physical office is usually considered as synonymous with the term law clinic this identification of the law clinic with the physical office is reflected in section 2 subparagraph c of the law student practice rule which defines a law clinic
as follows law clinic refers to an office or center which is a component of the law school's clinical legal education program that renders legal assistance and services as hearing provided to eligible persons groups and or communities the community-based model on the other hand is one wherein the student goes out of the confines of the law school to do the student lawyering work in the place where the people or community to be served is located the student goes to the community regularly and sometimes even stays there or in nearby accommodations for a number of days the
important features of this model are the frequent visits to and rendition of services in the community's location itself the classroom based model is one wherein the base of operations is not a permanent office dedicated by the program for the work of the student but the law school itself in general with classrooms and other facilities of the school being used for case conferences and other activities despite the absence of an office this is actually a viable model especially for those programs that would take in a special project or set of related cases and create a course
based on that subject matter the subject matter is usually expected to culminate in the short term which is why an office is not needed case conferences interviews of clients and other work to be performed by the student may be done in the classroom or any other suitable place for that matter files and other resources are kept either by the supervising lawyer the student or the law school itself but this location is often not the place where the work is done the remote clinic model is one wherein the student stays and does the work required by
the program at home or any place outside the law school supervision and many communicative aspects of the work are done remotely through video conferences voice calls and email or messaging correspondence for the up office of legal aid for example we had to prepare for such a model during the enhanced community quarantine imposed by the government beginning march of 2020 and we eventually implemented this model as soon as quarantine restrictions were lifted last year to allow offices to open people who seek legal advice could go to our physical offices where video conference interviews are set up
with law interns who are at home or even at their work case conferences with supervising lawyers are also done remotely through video conferencing the authorization given by the supreme court for video conference hearings made the remote clinic model a more robust one eventually interns who can and prefer to do so are allowed to go to our office to attend video conference hearings and use the offices facilities for this purpose this often happens when the client is required to appear and the client has poor internet connection at home or otherwise has limited means to communicate through
video conferencing in such instances our law interns would have to assist and attend with the client at our office to use the facilities there to safeguard the health of all concerned protective measures such as the installation of tabletop acrylic shields and the observance of social distancing were implemented we have so far discussed models based on the kind of lawyering experiences they offer on whether the supervising lawyer works for or works with the law school in supervising the student and the location where the student performs most of his or her work to complete the program a
final set of models is discussed here which is classified based on the range of lawyering services or the types of cases that the program or a particular law clinic in the program handles for this classification we observe two models that we can call the general practice model and the specialized practice model as the name suggests the general practice model would allow its students to experience handling all kinds of cases and legal matters such a model would usually be in the form of a law clinic whose range of services is much like a full service law
firm or in the form of an externship with such a law firm there is room for this model for having policies that would decline the handling of certain types of cases for as long as such exclusions are exceptions rather than the rule on the other hand the specialized practice model is one wherein the students get to handle only certain types of cases often within a narrow specialization for example a law school may have a law clinic that caters only to children's rights cases while another law clinic may only accept women's abuse in similar cases in
such situations the mentor or supervising lawyer would be a lawyer specializing in these areas the models we just surveyed are the more useful ones to consider in planning establishing and operating a clinical legal education program as previously mentioned while there may be more nuanced or specific models to identify and describe the information to be gained do not add much to the discussion when making preparations at the program level it must again be said that the models described are not mutually exclusive in reality the models often overlap and are consciously combined to reap their aggregate benefits
and advantages in line with the law school's goals for the program after completing the survey of models of cle programs i now move on to the last section of this module on how best to use the information you gained about the different models from this module i already mentioned the key to using the information and i repeat it here for emphasis the significance of thinking in terms of models is this being aware of the various models and their features would allow the adoption for the program of the models best suited to the law school in
light of its peculiar context and needs based on this statement knowing the different cle models is just one part of the equation to determine which models are well suited for the program the law school must first be clear about its program goals and the expected learning outcomes these are best developed after an assessment of the needs of the institution its students and other stakeholders equally important is factoring into the assessment the needs of the community where the law school is situated as the community would likely be the main source of the program's clientele there have
been instances in fact where the needs of the community were the driving force that led to the establishment of a law clinic in a clinical legal education program in law schools our office of legal aid in up for example is said to have started because indigents living in the community sought legal assistance from a faculty member for a property dispute and the professor enlisted the aid of student volunteers in lawyering for the said individuals in deciding on these points it is indispensable that administrators factor into the plan the following the number of students that would
avail of the program and the resources of the law school such as office space and available personnel particularly the availability of supervising lawyers and their practice areas based on the points for consideration outlined above it is recommended that the following initial series of practical questions be answered in developing a clinical legal education program or even in assessing an existing program number one would the number of students be enough to justify the use of resources to establish a law clinic or would it be more feasible to partner with a government office or non-governmental organization for an
externship and number two if a law clinic is to be established or already operational a would there be enough demand for its services from the community to ensure ample learning experience for the students b where would the students be expected to report to work and work from as they complete the program and see what kinds of cases would it accept it must be emphasized that the answers to these questions should be guided by the circumstances of the law school outlined previously when considered and studied properly the answers to these questions will provide a good start
for developing or improving a clinical legal education program in a manner appropriate to the needs and resources of the law school its stakeholders and the community in general with that i end my presentation as i said in the beginning please feel free to contact me through the up office of legal aid should you have any questions about the things discussed in this module the contact details of the u.p office of legal aid are available at the official website of the u p college of law i hope that you will find the information shared in this
module useful thank you very much for your time