so i was wondering if we can talk about mindfulness of breathing in terms of what the venerable arita has said mindfulness breathing is the mindfulness of breathing that he does in the suitors so on one occasion the blessed one asked monks do you develop mindfulness of in and out breathing and when this was said venable arita replied to the blessed one i developed mindfulness of in and out breathing lord but how do you develop such mindfulness and arita replies having abandoned sensual desire for past sensual pleasures having done away with sensual desire for future sensual
pleasures and having thoroughly subdued perceptions of resistance with regard to internal and external events i breathe in mindfully and i breathe out mindfully so the buddha says that there is that kind of there is that mindfulness of breathing i don't say that there isn't but as to how mindfulness of in and out breathing is brought in detail to its condemnation listen and pay close attention i will speak and then he goes in the classic uh description right right but so what i'm interesting is is irita's mindfulness his description well i think the um the bit
to mention there is i think some people might think that arita was wrong with something that what he described is not correct mindfulness with reading and then the buddha gave him the right one but that's not what it says he says yeah what you said is right it is mindfulness of breathing but it's not complete venerable at it as mindfulness of reading can certainly well certainly helped him free himself from centrality factually because we just didn't say oh you're not free from centrality and that's not mindfulness of bleeding which you described he just said that's
fine but let me give you the detail that results in combination of that practice so it's just not enough for for our engines so like you need to go into a bit more detail which then also makes you realize that venerable arita described was is sufficient to make you onigami so if you practice mindfulness for breathing even in that simple sense that he described which is by the way how every mindfulness of breathing formulation does start mindful knowingly he breathes in knowingly he breathes out that's all you need to know and if you stick to
that as vulnerable editor did you will lose you will overcome any um desire those essential pleasures now of the past for the future in other words you you would have surmounted the entire domain of of um of central craving and most importantly you would have completely subdued that fatigue resistance or aversion towards your own senses and so on that we spoke in previous videos and that's obviously as venerable declared enough for the five love effects to be destroyed so for the complete arghantrip then the buddha gives a further description of where you get i don't
know like give specific descriptions because people are already way too much taking anapanasati to be a mechanical method so that's why i think it's actually better if people follow a venerable arita's instruction first because it will prevent you from falling into that mindless or whatever you've been doing uh and force you to to see things on the level of knowledge of an enduring breath underneath your experience like what we said before regardless of the mind state regardless of the emotional state regardless of the physical state that's why mindfulness of breeding come brings satipatanos to fulfillment
mind state emotional state physical state but if you start getting into these details how i will breathe in like this and i'll do this to the body formation and on the desk to the body formation that will all become apparent if you become what vanderbilt is there so if you overcome all the sensuality subdue all the fatigue you have towards your own senses have no your will towards anything or anyone in the world past the future then follow the rest of anapanasati then you will know exactly what it meant how er gladdening the body and
experience enjoyable while breathing in or breathing out you know exactly what it means but otherwise people would be doing it with sensuality uh with with pretty much as something i should do they will result in even greater pleasure for me greater experience any any greatness of anapanasati on that level can only be done or can only be developed on the basis of complete surmounting of centrality and the final over factors but that's for me in a way it's a very good news you don't need to worry about every single little step if you cultivate and
bring to fulfillment the knowledge of breathing in breathing out regardless of the posture regardless of the emotional state regardless of the mental state regardless of the specific thoughts you have it that is your anchor that is underneath your experience that is always enduring and you don't lose sight of it the breath the knowledge of the breath being there not i'm focusing on the physical side of it you can focus on the physical side of it if you want while you know that it's underneath you for what it is that's really what the anchor is so
using the the enduring breath it's already happening to you underneath your emotional states or mental states or physical states as an anchor and investing effort to not lose the sight of it peripherally to be aware i don't need to stop doing what i'm doing in order to breathe but i can certainly not allow myself to be too absorbed in what i'm doing so that i forget that i am breathing at the same time so it's learning how to not overly commit to your focusing attention and actually learn how to stretch your mind to see like
these both ends simultaneously enduring that's what it would refer to like you know you develop samadhi the mind becomes pliable and stretchy not not like a hard twisted knotted lump but so in his description he's he goes beyond century pleasures sensuality so if there's virtue and there's restraint and he's putting up with the pressure he's enjoying the pressure whether he's overcome the pressure or not you know but even if he's putting up with the pressure not giving into sensuality then he says subduing um those perceptions perceptions of resistance resistance conversion aversion so and as you're
saying you know so you give up all these um sensual exploits things calm down and what you're left with is uh clearly seeing reality the reality of your body yeah but see that reality would present itself first as this this sort of oxygen as the suits talk about in the sense of you're going to experience almost like physical physical resistance sickness like like a heroin addict withdrawing from the drugs or something you are withdrawing from the domain of the entire central being so it's going to be felt physically but actually it's not the physical aspect
of it the pain of that endurance is your aversion towards it towards the discomfort but discomfort in itself it's actually quite bearable if samadhi has been developed that's like if if monk doesn't have the samadhi in that coming in their proper sense to like to use all the calming of the endurance not to get rid of the endurance or to base pleasure over it no just to calm the aversion aspect off the same thing and then yeah my mind is absolutely can become absolutely boundless limitless in that sense as as light as you can imagine
the most agreeable form of experience within the same endurance because it was your aversion that was making it heavy and that's that's where the work is in subduing the aversion not in like psychologizing and trying to justify the purpose for endurance or why you shouldn't do it or you should do it or what you should give in or you shouldn't give in all of that means are you still revolving around basically rooted in a version no the pure version that you have towards the non-experience of non-centrality you have to abandon your version of it the
aversion towards your own senses that are not engaging with central distractions and that's why the central distractions are so powerful it's because the aversion underneath it it's it's it's extremely strong and the only mean of escape from it is towards sense desires and you're saying that's your your first thing so you born you you feel all right right you experience the body yeah and your first act yeah that's what's meant by underlying tendencies they're not there you know the baby is not doing anything the baby is not proliferating choosing sensuality but the baby its experience
its mind is paired with the senses with the five senses and they are uncomfortable however subtly but there is nothing else there except that discomfort for an undeveloped mind for a newborn mind and what an unenlightened mind does regardless of the type of discomfort and experience it wants to get rid of it so naturally on that fundamental level when the baby is experiencing the discomfort of its newborn body and senses is just naturally going in the direction towards objects not that he chooses to but the discomfort pushes it towards you and then and then everything
else it starts encountering in the world you know the mother breast feeding just becomes like a confirmation of that direction where it found safety from this discomfort that you yourself are this unsafety because if you just left with the census but there are five wild animals in the world and you realize that's what i am there is nothing else to me that's the reflections the buddha will encourage to review this body not for mechanically see what's anatomically made of it's just to see that even the images of yourself you have are images of this bag
of skin and it's always any memory you have and if it involves this bag of skin these five senses these organs existing there and that's very unsafe like other people have access to your senses more than you do and and that's why you're all subversed towards others as well through the same process of resistance but that's a seeing form or your body or the sixth senses or the elements for what they are means that you see them as uncomfortable or pressured pressured weight yeah you know pressure burden yeah you will see them practically speaking you
will see them as a pressure but actually they don't they don't only there is only pressure when there is when you're seeing them with ignorance which baby does underlying tendency to a vijay it's not if if there was no a vj in baby's mind it wouldn't have been a baby it would have been born that's the whole point so that pressure practically yes that's how you're going to see them but actually that pressure is completely gone in another hand so that pressure is the result of seeing them with with with well not clearly with a
version with any other thing that you have not uh abandoned but if you do see them clearly if you do see them clearly and if you sustain the the clarity you will be unable to to to appropriate them to own them to even resist them in that sense because even a version towards them it's kind of inconceivable if you clarify it sufficiently enough so the aversion will fade so in terms of okay elements sixth sense body there is a fundamental discomfort not that you reverse to it sure but there's a fundamental difference the body yeah
being of that form form like we would have said what is the nature of uh rupa is or however if you translate it as form or matter is nature of form is to deform yeah that's and that's that's just how it is that is the nature of the body which is the elements are constantly like changing and reshaping and your body is doing the same yeah and so that you cannot remove you cannot just and you can try and you can kill your body and that doesn't work okay still stay with the controller it doesn't
work so you have to kind of appease that that that creature pees those elements remember those the vipers yeah yeah the four great elements that you have to bathe and so on yeah well exactly you appease them by removing your aversion towards them and it was the same just you reminded me now when you said the elements and so on like when that uh when the monk or when the devil i think was talking to manko to the buddha it was about reaching the end of the world like travels across the universe to find the
end of the elements and would have said you you doesn't matter how far you go all you're going to find is elements like they're infinite in that sense the ending of the elements is in with this own body when there is no more footing found in your consciousness for them so when your consciousness sees but when you cease to appropriate them when you cease to have lust towards them or aversion towards them they will cease they will not pertain to you anymore so then truly you reach the end of the universe erita is doing subduing
all perceptions of how do you do that well by by uh thoroughly developing sense restraint and then being guarding the dose of the sense faculties doesn't mean refusing to see things or hear things but means never doing so without being on god and that's often where people conflate like they think guarding the sense faculties means saying no to everything i will not look at anything hear anything i will avoid i will run away if i start hearing things no no guarding means you you will have to see here smell this touch things so keeping the
the the close eye and the the doorways of your senses so god in the sense faculties that's the work so now we're talking you're you know i'm aware of what i'm seeing and so on say i hear something behind i don't just look without thinking you want to be aware of your like if you want to look of your faculty that you're looking in case of what you see might induce lust in you or a virgin in you and that's what would have said he he keeps the um the guard of his he got he
sent faculties and then he doesn't give attention to any signs and features that arise within that so say i heard something and i have an image of what that might be and based on that image i'll decide whether i should look or not and if i have to look then i'll be extra careful so that when i do look unwholesome states don't arise in me so it can sound like oh i have to do a lot but that's only because you haven't been guarding the senses properly people as i said people confuse gardening we're just
refusing to see refusing to look no you have to allow some degree of looking and seeing and smelling and tasting and touching but you just always want to be on guard in regard to that but my because if you were to uh kind of crush the body and keep it blind and not let it hear anything not let it eat what you know mm-hmm basic amount of food a little bit of food hurt the body yes torture it yeah yeah it's going to be agitated just as agitated as it would be if you were to
over-indulge exactly exactly so you want to calm these wild dogs well you won't do by giving them what they want all the time and you won't do by beating them and starving them either it will make them even wilder more often than not that level of torture so you need to balance it give them when needed not unguarded so they don't eat all of it or as much as they want but you know doesn't mean don't give them anything at all so i also read about this practice um it's it's it's called the the element
calming meditation so so for example it would say earth sun meditation earth calming meditations and summer means to bring it back to equilibrium whereby you're not agitating this element anymore there is nothing that you do that agitates this form these elements this this body so the practice of summer not summer as in the right right summer as in um tuned to the right note where is that practice it's in there when he's described when he's teaching uh rahula how to be right sure sure and he's teaching him how to subdue that fatigue really by calming
well yeah that's the suit about mindfulness for breeding isn't it wasn't yeah yeah right right to how to do mindfulness being in regard to the elements so you're not doing anything that agitates yeah practically speaking you can [Music] people can see that for themselves for example when the body is fatigued and you're tired you're literally irritable irritated yeah so there is no reason for you for example to be illiterate when when the body is fatigued when body is heavy tight with the solidity aspect where the element of earth is felt more heavier dragging you down
or whatever else but you are because the mind is not developed in regard to the body so that's why you can't just you can't just count these elements abstractly you can try but that's not what the elements are you are like the basis of elements the body they found the footing through your own misconceiving and so on so when these elements change when your body and i don't mean just change in terms of aging or something but even yeah sometimes your body feels light sometimes feels heavy sometimes feels tired sometimes feels energized sometimes we're sleepy
sometimes awake sometimes burning sometimes cold all of those um whatever those that's what elements are so you train in regard to that not in regard to what you perceive elements to be on account of your body like oh elements and elements you know that's you abstractly now just trying to go through the motions of that contemplation no no so mindfully breathing in knowingly you're breathing in or you're breathing out underneath this body what is that body that underneath with there is breath how is it felt is it tired is it heavy is it light is
it aching those are the elements those are literally the things you need to develop your mind in regard to another because tired i'm averse to that aching i'm averse to that called i'm average to that yeah restless guy restless too much i'm a verse oh that's what aversion is in regard to me and this body or my point of view in regards to this body that's what would have meant for as long as you're not developed in the body you will be attracted to sensuality not developed in the body meaning meaning you in regard to
the body are not developed but you still have a version in regard to the discomfort and by by extension of the same principle you're going to have lust by when you experience comfort but it's actually in regard to the way the elements are at the time and that's what it would have said though there are all those um acid was to be abandoned simply by enduring them correctly heat cold insects discomfort burning sun and so on words of others abuse of others all of that is on the level of you your body being factually assailed
because that's what body is devoured i mean they said even the five senses are attacked by agreeable and disagreeable ears are attacked by agreeable and disagreeable sounds that's the nature of it that's just between them that's not your problem but your problem is to have lost towards agreeable and aversion to disagreeable so you don't so you remove your last towards it you remove your aversion towards it and then it won't be a problem and that's the other hand he says everything that you know all the taints to be removed i have removed the being the
centrality the ignorance all that's left is the disturbances that can arise on account of this body until it breaks apart like these natural level of disturbances so that's you have to be careful if you want to be doing calming the elements to not just go into visualizations and so on you don't you can't calm the elements on your own terms because they cannot be yours you count them by finding what state they are in now your body your body is your element that's why it's often the same use the word same word rupa for the
body rupa for the elements that is your practical experience of the elements so bringing bringing the elements to equilibrium what does that mean that's what we're talking about now but right well it means that so if uh like say you might start with the fatigue naturally to that extent that's how elements present themselves but to you through your unrestrained senses you get tired even more unnecessarily so you sent the elements even further out of that what they were naturally arisen so you you disturb them you make it even worse or being too averse towards it
you feel even tired than you actually are and then you can even come to the point that you're so averse now that physically you cease to be tired yet mentally you're just naked because of your aversion not because the elements without bringing them back to the natural state seeing them for whatever reason and not interfering with it and enduring it without aversion removing a version towards the endurance of them that's their natural state but even though their natural state is not peace and bliss and lovely and wonderful it's not either yeah dukkha is your interference
duke is your aversion because your last duke is your craving so yeah that's important to understand it's not like natural state of the elements is this you know blissful mystical realm no i'm tired naturally the body is tired didn't eat enough work too much that is a currently natural state of these elements all i need to do is not interfere with it and endure it mindfully so then you're seeing the natural discomfort the natural state yes the natural uncomfortable state the natural uncomfortable state which is not but it's factually not nice but then you can
then a person can see the asuba there isn't it yes yes yeah then it becomes obvious for what it is you don't need to be lovely making effort to see it you recognize it for what it is so this is not this is not beautiful it's not worth because it's well in itself in its natural state it's it's a burden it's a it's a it's a weight and and that's already not nice not agreeable it was now if you had to stop there and stop working well you could be quite disgusted with that exactly and
that's and so you if you are quite disgusted with it means your aversion is taking over not the natural state because the natural state has no aversion nor lust yet here you are full of aversion towards that and that's the way he gave anapanasati because someone's got two of us thinking oh this body is truly like that and they couldn't bear it but actually no if you calm your mind you realize no the body is uncomfortable to that extent that's it that's where it ends here and now is pleasant it's very pleasant arahant arahant's recognition
of that discomfortable body in its clarity is the most pleasant experience you can imagine it's the enlightenment but if it's aver if it's if it's too disgusting means okay so you did probably remove that the central perception sufficiently but now you do need to remove your version of it as well because you that's not me that's not going to be anybody so the work there which i'm jumping and that's exactly where venus said that first it was the sensuality abandoned and what he was left was the disgust and aversion to his body these senses and
then he subdued that and now he's just mindfully breathing and building up and in i think this is where it goes into the subduing of uh perceptions of petiga is subduing that aversion in the rahula sutra where the buddhist teaching in mindfulness and breathing he goes i think from the asuba realizing the yasuba there then practicing brahmavihara which culminates in upeka which is for the overcoming of all batiga yeah sure that's the enlightenment so it's meta yeah contentment with the whole thing vegeta exactly because you don't need to be a verse that's what i'm saying
you realize the version is coming from me completely unnecessarily if i remove a version this discomfort will be blissful so it's like oh and that's already seen the mind of friendliness already um so so that's the again brahmavihara's another misconceived visualization practice starts with a thorough thorough thoroughfare watchfulness guarding of the sen's doors sense restraint and then that aversion you're left with of that endurance for what it is you just i'll be friendly to it that's where you'll start with yourself and then if through that state you think of others you'll be friendly to any
internal or external any shape or form any perception of a version that appears i'll be friendly to it i will sustain the mind of friendliness that's all i'm that unprotect that anything that comes to it and goes internally externally internally and externally i shall sustain the mind of friendliness that's my concern not to spread love to you just to not lose the mind of friendliness in regard to any patiga that comes my way and whenever you search the suitors you will see that how to deal with batiga loving kindness mata yeah essentially essentially but it's
not like sure uh ill will towards others is a form of fatigue but that's not particularly you you must have been well restrained before that your mind should have been withdrawn if you're particularly concerned with hating this person that person to do brahman hara properly they would culminate in opeca because like you the monk the diligent monk um sense restraint uh virtue sense restraining gaza sends those then he abandons he doesn't cultivate he doesn't welcome thoughts of sensuality or central desires doesn't entertain doesn't psychologize why i hate or why have these thoughts no he simply
does not give any attention to those thoughts until they are subdued so thoughts of sensuality thoughts of cruelty harm your will he subsumed then thoughts about his reputation concern about his reputation thoughts about his his home country or clans like these kind of higher extensions of self that everybody carries you know but that is hard to see me and what i think he he submutes that as well not how long he justifies it or he thinks about it he subdues that so he refuses to engage with these thoughts and then what he's left with is
the nature of things that's another suit that says that so it's not like all these things will fall off as no he makes the effort to not engage with them because they'll try to hook you you know thoughts of centrality we want you to think about it even in terms of asuba you still accepted sensuality as a desire of a fact they now try to get rid of it by thinking it's super thoughts of cruelty will try to hook you to take them so to practice your brahmavihara as in try to get rid of it
that's not hara so you need to be left with the clarity of that endurance that you inevitably going to be averse to how much to that depends on how much sensuality you had carried from before and then ah it's the pure fatigue of this experience internally externally that i should just be friendly towards and if you're friendly to the fatigue of your senses you'll be friendly to anybody that comes through it even if people come and beat you up and abuse you you cannot hate because you cannot abandon the doorway of friendliness towards this through
which all of this manifests for you so that's why truly like matter practice will free you from all the batiga and result in opaquer and if it's if it's on that level through sense restraint and watchfulness and guiding of the sense those you could just decide to be friendly towards that there was this aversion and sustain the friendliness regardless of the aversion and aversion will subdue be subdued in the same sense if you choose to sustain the knowledge of breeding underneath your experience so to speak breathing in breathing out uh your thoughts will be subdued
they will be calmed down you don't need to how do i know if i stick to this knowledge that i'm reading and reading out while it is happening or whatever else knowledge that breath is underneath there happening to me in and out in and out and i don't completely lose the sight of it thoughts will be subdued that's just the natural outcome of it same sustain the friendliness towards yourself in that sense of having been fully restrained experiencing fatigue of the sense restraint just friendly towards that nothing else and latiga will subdue i mean in
the in the rahula again that i was mentioning after that subduing of petiga he then says developed a nietzsche to get rid of well that's the declaration seeing things clearly you won't be seeing the clear true meaning of that in each of that thing because just to averse towards it so you subdue your aversion what you're left is neither of us certainly not no no central desire and then oh let me make the effort and see there's arisen on its own inaccessible not mine what is it to describe but the clarity is there clarity well
exactly on the kind of clarity that you're not interfering with your aversion now you get to specify aspects of it that you want to see such as a nietzsche dukkha and then the experience is fully going to be cessation of all the traces of conceit and then he's and then the buddha actually after that then he starts to teach the mindfulness of breathing the rest of the mindfulness of breathing here that's what i mean that's like the fulfillment if you just then stick to that as a practice if there are any traces of any appropriation
of any ignorance left that you are kind of unaware of that will also disappear if you stick to that practice of that right order breathing in in that impersonal sense being unable to experience a version anymore because you have subdued it no central desire and certainly no appropriation because then perception for nature has been fully developed um because there were you know many like like anagami's in case they had so like little traces of egypt left that even the buddha could not specifically say where and how he would just say if there is there might
be some residue and if there is there will be you know non-return and so on so that's why like even if you think you're an argument complete finished just stick to that practice because it's pleasant here and now cultivate dana panasanti to that fulfillment as he said to venerable arita and then if there were any traces that would be that they would have been dealt with by sticking to the practice of calming correctly so it's a win-win in other words even if you were even if you're not honey win because it's a pleasant abiding here
and now and if you're not an iron hunt you win because it's a pleasant buzzing here now and it frees you from anything that was preventing you to be another hunt and yeah but there's no breathing there all that work you know where's the breathing where's the breathing that you there's also other work that you're doing you know you're calming the fatigue you're contemplating this breathing is that just peripheral recollection the knowledge of the breath and during a beneath that's basically the reference point that prevents you from uh being uh to engage from your personal
point of view which you're contemplating because if you're rooted in a naturally occurring breath underneath your experience breathing and bringing out and refuse to give give up give that basis up basically you refuse to give and that's already an impersonal reference point that in personal reference points that's why you that's why eventually if you stick to it everything else will be seen through the impersonal reference point not mine that's exactly what not mine is in person so when you contemplate the elements where you can't play through the personal basis of breathing enduring there you're contemplating
it rightly on that one through that impersonal basis of that thing which is so personal so sure sure so close to you yes that's why it's a useful and suitable reference point because you could take other references reference points but they will be exactly sooner or later you end up appropriating them so then it ceases to be an impersonal reference point through which you get to see all this personality and so on that's going on emotions and moods and and that's principles in personal reference to which you will purify everything from your gratuitous sense of
personality that's why it's for the one way for purification of beings there's nothing else to result in stick to satipattanas and it would purify beings of personality i arranged in any in every shape or form no matter how lingering how subtle if you do it sufficiently enough and anapanasati is the fulfillment of for satipatanos nothing else that's not suitable