speculative fiction is a term that many fans of sci-fi and fantasy will no doubt have come across before but what exactly is it how is it different to science fiction and are you reading it without even knowing it the definition of speculative fiction has altered since it was first used making it quite a nebulous term that has often caused confusion and a bit of contention too the oxford dictionary definition states it is a genre of fiction that encompasses work in which the setting is other than the real world involving supernatural futuristic or other imagined elements
but it has also been defined as a subgenre of science fiction that deals with human rather than technological problems a genre distinct from and opposite to science fiction in its exclusive focus on possible futures and the definition of speculative fiction that is widely accepted today a super genre for all genres that include a speculative element to the story based on conjecture and supposition that do not already exist in the real world not really helping the nebulous nature of the issue under the widely accepted super genre definition speculative fiction encompasses an extensive number of genres that
are in themselves also split into subgenres including some but not all science fiction fantasy and horror in an attempt to clear up the issue somewhat often speculative fiction is referred to as what if stories because fundamentally they pose the question what if they ask what if this happened or what if the world was this way a story of speculative fiction sets out to change reality as we know it today considering the consequences of this change it can be applied to anything from society right through to technology in this respect it's used as an umbrella term
for fiction that doesn't quite belong to a single genre it can include literary fiction with fantastical components as well as sci-fi science fantasy and fantasy and horror but it's widely agreed that not all elements of genre writing such as horror or science fiction for example can be defined as speculative fiction which is something we'll look at later for now let's take a brief look at how speculative fiction emerged and what purpose the genre attempts to serve the term speculative fiction was reportedly used for the first time by science fiction writer robert heinlein in 1947 but
before the term was even coined however speculative fiction had firm roots in science fiction and fantasy some early examples of speculative fiction include the blazing world by margaret cavendish a utopian novel published in 1666 that speculated another world could be accessed via a portal located in the north pole another is frankenstein by mary shelley which speculated that life could be re-established to a creature created by several corpses this is reported to be one of the earliest speculative novels and shows how a story under this heading can also simultaneously sit under multiple genres such as in
this case science fiction and horror in the 19th century speculative fiction began to fuse into recognizable genres such as science fiction with the emergence of authors such as jules verne and h.g wells fantasy with authors such as lewis carroll and horror with authors such as bram stoker but writers have written about suppositious events for centuries before these were even published it could even be argued that the first speculative fiction dates back to ancient greece when playwrights explored alternative versions of the truth as early examples of old history stories william shakespeare's a midsummer's night dream and
tolkien's the lord of the rings are also considered speculative fiction even though the terms did not exist at the time for a long time the term was largely associated with science fiction as i've said specifically because the genre is so well known for containing speculative elements the term however expanded to encompass subgenres beyond science fiction including fantasy and dystopian literature popular modern literary works that are considered speculative fiction today include the handmaid's tale 1984 the man in the high castle the hunger games fahrenheit 451 brave new world station 11 never let me go dune the
road the left hand of darkness the power ender's game i am legend and machines like me just to name a few the handmaid's tale speculates a life in the dystopia of gilead a totalitarian society in what was the united states where women are treated as property of the state in the face of environmental disasters and plummeting birth rates margaret atwood the author of the handmaid's tale as well as many other speculative works has in the past defined speculative fiction as literature that deals with possibilities in a society which have not yet been enacted but are
latent atwood reportedly got the idea for the handmaid's tale from a conversation she had with a friend in the early 1980s when in reaction to what atwood called the advances of feminism during the previous two decades a strain of cultural conversation worried over how to get women back into the home atwood wondered what it would take to do that what kind of regime might enact such a reversion she asked herself and in the dystopian novel 1984 author george orwell speculates a society ruled by totalitarianism mass surveillance and repressive regimentation of people and behaviors orwell muddled
the totalitarian government in the novel after communist russia under stalin and nazi germany as you can see from this list alone speculative fiction crosses many genres which is why it's often called a super genre we can see how the term was formed to fill a perceived need to define works that ask the all-important question what if but do not necessarily fall into the sci-fi fantasy or horror genres before we look at what can not be classified as speculative fiction as well as whether speculative fiction has a greater literary merit than say plain old sci-fi let's
get a clearer indication of what is widely accepted to be grouped under the speculative fiction umbrella most speculative fiction novels fall under at least one of the following genres some may fall under multiple depending on the story structure first we have science fiction stories with imagined or speculated technologies that either don't exist in the real world right now or haven't yet been designed or discovered such as time travel aliens and ai for example then we have science fantasy sci-fi stories inspired by mythology folklore and fairy tales that combine imagined technologies with elements of magical realism
we have supernatural fiction sci-fi and fantasy stories about unknown or arcane knowledge or hidden abilities including witchcraft spiritualism and psychic abilities then we have the space opera a play on the term soap opera sci-fi stories that take place in outer space and center around conflict romance and adventure urban science fiction fantasy stories that take place in an urban setting in the real world but operate under magical rules we have utopian fiction stories about civilizations the authors deemed to be perfect or ideal societies dystopian fiction which is the reverse stories about societies deemed by the author
to be problematic within the world of the novel often satirizing government rules poverty and oppression we have apocalyptic fiction stories that take place before and during what is often a huge disaster that wipes out a significant portion of the world's population the story is often centered around characters doing everything they can to stay alive for example trying to avoid being infected in a pandemic for example sorry something in my throat then we have post-apocalyptic fiction stories that take place after an apocalyptic event and focus on the survivors figuring out how to navigate their new circumstances
for example emerging after a global pandemic then we have alternative history fiction stories that focus on true historical events but are written as if they unfolded with different outcomes and lastly we have superhero fiction stories about superheroes and how they use their abilities to fight super villains so now we have a pretty solid idea of what speculative fiction is let's look at what it's not and ask is it really different to science fiction the key word to consider is speculative there has to be a speculative element of the story for it to come under the
super genre meaning it must contain an element that doesn't actually or presently exist in our world but importantly could exist the speculative element must also impact on the story it can't be something that is just in the background making no difference to what is going on stories that don't have this won't come under this umbrella regardless of what genre they may sit in work such as historically accurate fiction won't come under speculative fiction neither would works such as military thrillers that use advanced but not fictional technology this shouldn't surprise anyone really at this point however
what might surprise you is that there is an area of science fiction that could be argued as not falling under the speculative fiction canopy and this is referred to as mundane scifi in these mundane sci-fi stories authors go to great efforts to create what are arguably sci-fi stories that are so hard in nature that they only use real and accurate technologies and science in this respect there is very little speculation to them an example of this is the martian by andy ware in the story ware describes technology that exists today as well as a scientifically
accurate portrayal of mars and the obstacles a stranded astronaut would have to overcome to survive there of course there is a small speculative element to the story in that humanity has yet to send a manned mission to mars but that is just a matter of time in my opinion another example is the 2013 film gravity where a manned shuttle orbiting earth is hit by high speed space debris this film was labeled science fiction but it actually had very few speculative elements for it to be called speculative fiction margaret atwood who considers her own writing to
be works of speculative fiction says in her book in other words sf and human imagination that science fiction and speculative fiction are fluid in terms she says that to get an understanding of what encompasses speculative fiction look to stories from authors such as jules verne whose books include stories about submarines and balloon travel and such things that really could happen but hadn't completely happened when the authors wrote the book she says in her book atwood also mentioned a debate she once had with the late sci-fi author ursula le guin le guin said that science fiction
is speculative fiction when what is written about could really happen whereas narratives that cannot under any circumstances happen in our world such as le guin's earth sea these classify separately as fantasy this ties into the science element of science fiction it's generally agreed upon that science fiction should have well some kind of science in it holding to scientific principles or include technology or futurism in some way but as the late great articy clerk said any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic so you can see where things might get confusing but by this we can
generally see that speculative fiction ultimately comes down to two identical characteristics one does the story contain a speculative element and two does it relate to reality and our own world if yes then it's likely it will fall under speculative fiction along the journey of the speculative fiction from the time it was coined to today it has been suggested that the term is used by some writers that are unhappy with calling their work science fiction suggesting speculative fiction better defines an expanded open imaginative type of fiction with perhaps a greater literary merit new wave sci-fi writer
harlan ellison reportedly used the term in an attempt to avoid being pigeonholed as a writer allison was an advocate of science fiction writers embracing more literary direction which we saw an increase of during the new wave of sci-fi in the 1960s and 70s however the refusal by some authors immersed in what has been labeled the literary establishment to call their work science fiction has led to a degree of indignation by some sci-fi fans in an interview posted by moviechat.org when asked if the handmaid's tale was science fiction margaret atwood reportedly said in a quote that
upset some sci-fi fans no it certainly isn't science fiction science fiction is filled with martians and space travel to other planets and things like that that isn't this book at all the handmaid's tale is speculative fiction in the genre of brave new world and 1984. 1984 was written not as science fiction but as an extrapolation of life in 1948 so too the handmaid's tale is a slight twist on the society we have now side note for transparency purposes i want to say there is no indication as to where the interview for this quote originally came
from so i can't reference this however this quote in particular has been labeled as literary snobbishness by some and i wanted to give you an idea of some of the ways the rise in the label of speculative fiction has impacted science fiction moving on then in a 2002 review of ursula le guin written by atwood in the new york review she went on to aptly say science fiction is the box in which le guin's work is usually placed but it's an awkward box it bulges with discards from everywhere into it have been crammed all those
stories that don't fit comfortably into the family room of the socially realistic novel or the more formal parlor of historical fiction or other compartmentalized genres westerns gothics horrors gothic romances and the novels of war crime and spies its subdivisions include science fiction proper gizmo riddled and theory-based space travel time travel or cyber travel to other worlds with aliens frequent science fiction fantasy dragons are common the gizmos are less plausible and may include ones and speculative fiction human society and its possible future forms which are either much better than what we have now or much worse
however the membranes separating these subdivisions are permeable and osmotic flow from one to the other is the norm the use of science fiction proper didn't really help her argument with sci-fi funds however her overview is pretty accurate in its essence when it comes to how speculative fiction permeates through in my view a work of science fiction will have as much literary merit as the author intends to put into it and is not limited by the genre in the slightest doesn't matter if you call it sci-fi science fantasy or speculative fiction the only limitation might be
the reader's preconception about the genre and that's something that won't be helped by critics and authors being ashamed of the science fiction label i believe science fiction is the perfect vehicle for literary allegory and we can see this and modern and classic sci-fi alike i think of books by le guin of course philip k dick ender's game by olsen scott card stranger in a strange land by robert heinlein and many many more by authors such as arthur c clarke frank herbert and isaac asimov obviously but saying that i don't necessarily think everything has to be
about allegory and literary distinction often a great story is enough well it is for me anyway i will note however that literary merit is also subjective and often seems to be in the eye of the beholder much like the nebula supergenre that is speculative fiction so regardless of whether you decide you're reading speculative fiction or science fiction all that really matters is that it sufficiently blows your mind am i right you