many of you have told me that product sense questions are especially hard when a it's about a space that you haven't directly experienced or b it's a space that's not aligned with the company's mission so in this video we're going to go through a mock interview of a product sense example tackling these two situations hey guys i'm diana and i'm a senior product leader at a big tech company based in silicon valley california so the question we're going to go through today is build a product to help people buy antiques when was the last time
you bought an antique i know i have never bought an antique and the framework we're going to use today is the good old product sense framework which starts with why do we want to build this who we want to build this for what pain points these people have and coming up with solutions now let me first clarify antiques what are we talking about when we talk about antiques so in my head antiques could be expensive items with the things that people would be selling at an auction sale whether it's these like age-old paintings from monet
or these really expensive buzzes you've probably seen that are gorgeous but antiques could also be cheaper items that you might find at a thrift shop or a pawn shop and antiques what are antiques antiques could be things as big as furniture paintings we talked about or smaller things such as vases or collectibles even a coin could be counted as an antique all right so that helps me clarify what antiques are so my first question is like why the heck do we want to build a space and is this a good space for say meta or
facebook's mission so first i want to cover some trends that i'm seeing as to why antiques could be the next big thing the first is that we're seeing an increasing trend of people buying used goods either for environmental purposes or people love products with a good story and history secondly another trend we're seeing because of kovid people are spending a lot more time in their homes and people have the tendency to want to decorate their homes more or have the time to have a hobby collecting coins or comic books whatever that is now the mission
now i'm asking is the antique space aligned with the mission of say meta meta's mission is to build community and connect people so if i think about antiques there definitely is strong communities around collectibles like certain coins or maybe buzzes from the ming dynasty so i could definitely see that connecting people who might have not known each other and enable a great community but i would still characterize these communities as semi-niche and hence if i'm thinking about meta-investing in groups or community this might not be the most popular use case hence it's a semi line
to the mission but i don't know if it's the best use case if the company wants to invest in building groups and communities next let's talk about the market size how big of a market is the antique buying space i mean i don't have exact numbers but if i had to assume i think it's still pretty niche like yes i mentioned it could be the next up and coming thing but as of now the people that are buying antiques could be i don't know really really rich people or people who maybe have a history background
and no specific errors that they're like obsessed with so i would characterize as a niche market versus mass market but i could see the tam or total addressable market in the future increasing but not by like 100 fold because people still like buying new things now i'm thinking what strengths does the company have in improving this space for example when we talk about facebook their products like live shopping and we talked about the auction style so live shopping that feature could be great for auction style at the same time there are already a lot of
strong communities inside the groups product now i'm asking myself how would investing in the antique buying space benefit the company here i could see a benefiting if it increases engagement amongst people again those like crazy collectors or people who are obsessed with history would probably go gaga over certain antiques in groups and hence it might increase engagement so now my final assessment does this belong within the facebook ecosystem and from this analysis there's not a huge market size it could in the future become much bigger and does align with the mission sort of but probably
not the strongest use case and hence i'm gonna recommend that we do not build this for facebook for this question for now and instead we are a separate company a startup or maybe an auction house that wants to build a product to help people buy antiques [Music] next we're going to figure out the who should we build this for so if i'm thinking about the ecosystem there are buyers and sellers on the seller's side there are institutional sellers like museums or auction houses or they're private sellers so people like myself selling antiques which i don't
have any because i'm not rich next you have the buyer side and here i think of three personas starting with collectors people who again are collecting certain items because they are obsessed with it second are people that are buying to resell and a third group are people who are buying a antique to enjoy themselves and what differentiates these three groups in terms of problems i'm not going to go into pain points just yet but the collectors their major problem is trying to figure out is this real because they're really passionate about the space they want
to make sure they get the thing that is really authentic for example i don't know if you guys saw that video of logan paul who lost 3.5 million dollars on fake pokemon cards obviously these collectors would be super sad because they invest a lot of money into these collectibles the problem that people who are buying to resell would struggle with is does the product that i'm buying have a resell value so it doesn't necessarily need to be the most authentic thing but if i buy it at a price am i going to make a margin
on it and the last persona we talked about which is people that are buying to enjoy is this affordable does this fit within my home now i'm going to be building for the buyer side and i'm thinking about who to prioritize within the buyer side two criteria's come up first i want to think about total addressable market so which of these groups do i think are the largest and second which are these groups are the most frequent users because if i think about building a product especially early on i want to get people who are
the early adopters who are going to go crazy over my product and then help me spread it like wildfire so if i run down the list collectors are the one that maximize this formula or this criteria for me they are a medium on total addressable market so not the largest market but their frequency of use is very high because they're collecting they're gonna buy multiple items just for the love and passion of it versus someone who is maybe buying for the home they only need one piece of voz or one couch versus collectibles they will
they will go to town i want to know what are challenges that you face in the product design product sense question that come up over and over comment below and let me know so i can help you answer your most asked questions [Music] so now what are some of the pain points for collectors so i'm going to think starting with the user journey and i'm going to imagine myself again because i've never bought antiques it's hard for me to empathize with this space but i'm going to imagine myself as someone who needed to go hunt
down a vaz from the ming dynasty how in the world am i going to find that antique and buy it and what are some of the pain points there so i break it down into four separate steps starting with discovery of the item second seeing results and listings third looking at the product description getting details there and the fourth actually the purchasing cycle first let's start off with discovery how in the world do i find a vaz from the ming dynasty so i think about today like if i had to go this do this in
the next hour i one would start with the google search probably find some physical places that i would call and ask do you have this thing or it probably might lead me to some websites or it might take me to craigslist or ebay i don't even feel very confident i would find something and i think most products that exist in the world that are ming bosses maybe aren't even posted because they live inside a museum or someone's home that they're not selling so here's some pain points that i'm imagining a this is probably a fragmented
market again you have the physical stores and you have the online pieces and you have the craigslist marketplace type of classifieds and then b the other pain point is i'm imagining just low volumes of products that are posted online so just like low supply so our second phase is when we're searching actually seeing what's available and here if i'm thinking it's offline in store if i'm rummaging through let's say a thrift shop there's probably a lot of manual actual searching that's not pleasant and there's probably limited categorization it's probably a bunch of things dumped to
one side but we're talking about a ming bos so let's get let's say we go to a more official place and there i might imagine an expert would come up to me and show me some of the pieces or i might have to go and talk to the expert in terms of what i want and they go through their own categorizations in their brain to find out what's available if i'm taking the online route there's probably searching and i don't even know if my keyword would pop up to something like vaz would but would vaz
from the ming era pop up the results that i'd be interested in questionable so some of the pain points that i would imagine that exists here are a the keywords that i type in might not match the thing that i actually want and that might be because one i'm not using the right keywords or a lot of these antiques are actually not labeled i mean because they're older items there's no item description that you barcode you could just scan from the 1800s another problem is probably these items are not being categorized or cataloged in a
way that's organized for me to find those items and then the other big problem is again if i'm in physical place i need to depend on an expert to find this or i'm manually rummaging through a bunch of stuff to find the thing that i want phase number three so now let's say i do find something that looks like what i want and i'm looking at this item and trying to figure out one i want to learn about the description so if this is online i want to see photos of the details and here i
might imagine some challenges are the photos are not very clear they're not focused on the detail that i want i mean as you know for some paintings they have a little inscription i mean i don't even have a painting on the corner that tells you whether it's authentic or not so these little details are pretty important another big thing again for collectors that they care about is is this item authentic is it a real or is it a fake i mean i'm sure i'm able to find a lot of ming bosses on wayfair that are
lookalikes but no i want something that actually came from when was the ming era i mean i'll look it up and post it here i want something from that time period and me i mean i could be a collector and be an expert at these things but there's only so much that i can tell from my eye in order to appraise the product so there's a couple of challenges here one we talked about having few or little to zero product description b the photos don't show the details and see there's an authenticity problem how do
we know something is real or not i mean people are getting really good at creating fakes nowadays and the last phase is the actual purchasing and here i would be asking questions like well what's the right price to pay for this item is it a fair price am i paying too much so hence a big pain point here is how do i assess the value of this product and especially with antiques they're hard to price because they come from a different era you don't know how much it costs then you don't know the bill of
materials so a lot of the times it's less about how much the item costs to build it but instead how much the market values it i mean if we're talking about avas it's art right and you know how flimsy art valuations are here i'm going to do a quick prioritization based on one main criteria which is pain level looking at my pretty exhaustive list there are four things that i think create the highest pain and if we solve them could make us the company that differentiates ourselves and those are first there's low volume of supply
i mean in general even if people own antiques they're not posting them don't know where to find them again this is an assumption so i'm going to assume low volume of things like vases from the main era second high paying point is that keywords don't match what i'm searching for and this is if we're talking about online searches if it's physical searches that's even harder so we won't even go there third another big pain point is that there's no product descriptions for these antique items so how am i supposed to know what it is what
it's about where it's from and those are things i would want to know as a collector right i care about the history of products at the same time like who's going to write those product descriptions unless it was a really expensive item and the fourth biggest pain point i feel is how do you tell the authenticity of a product one i'd be scared is the seller legitimate or not am i going to be able to refund my item how do i figure out whether this product is actually really from the main era or from the
song era because if i'm a collectible i'm obsessed with the small details because if one of my friends find out that this vaz was from the song dynasty that would be so embarrassing so here i'm asking myself before i go into the solutions what is my strategy to win in this space i want to build a product that is going to beat out all the other competitors selling antiques so my three prong strategy or my focuses is number one is to drive more supply into the ecosystem and find creative ways to do that the second
is to help people effortlessly find but also discover items that they might not be looking for but they might be interested in and third is to create a system of trust within our product so that scams tend to happen less [Music] now let's go into solutions and here i'm going to go into solutions for the four high pain points that we talked about instead of focusing on just one pain point so then i have a volume my videos and here my solutions are going to entail a product slash features operational things we can do and
marketing related things that we can do so first problem was just low supply and here we can maybe partner with smaller antique shops slash boutiques in order to get all of their inventory online and to use us as a marketplace to sell online and offline that way they don't have to create their own separate website and we might incentivize them to upload their items online because we know it's a lot of work either hiring someone for them that can do it over a couple days a week a month or maybe even reducing their commissions fee
we can figure that out another way we can get more items online is maybe create a product appraisal tool so this is something where people can snap a photo of one of the antique items and get an idea of how much they can sell it for and here maybe people are hesitant about uploading their products online because they don't know how much it's worth or don't know if it's worth the effort but if you give them a tool to sense like oh wow this thing is actually really worthy and you can sell it for a
lot that might be incentive for them to sell it another solution for getting more supply online is to partner with collectors partner with individual collectors and tap into that community and maybe within groups of collectors for certain items getting them excited to upload their products onto our platform and this might be posting in certain groups or classifieds where collectors are certain communities maybe there's reddit subgroups where collectors are next we want to solve for the keyword matches that don't line up with what we're searching for some solutions here could be creating keywords upon upload so
this would use some ml technology and basically add some visual recognition where let's say you hover over the item you take a photo of it and it would start labeling different components so my ming vas that i've been talking about they would label it first of all because that is more obvious and then it would have to go do some research on from what era that vaz looks most closely like another solution here could be just crowdsourcing from the community what this item is and here collectors love to lean into the community and help the
community out and maybe we might even incentivize them by giving them points that they can then translate into credit to buy antiques next the problem is the photos aren't great or the item doesn't come with a product description and here you might encourage sellers to upload videos 360 degree videos of the product instead of just individual photos so they make sure that everything is captured another solution you might hire expert photographers who know what detail to capture in the photo for antiques or a more scalable solution is really to just create a video to teach
people who are selling how to take those photos lastly the problem of the seller authenticity well the first solution here could be we hold certain money that the buyer pays for in an escrow basically a fund that we as the marketplace manage and only give out to the seller after 30 days like if the buyer within 30 days doesn't complain or doesn't want to return the item we then the seller gets that money another way is to maybe consider address verification and this ensures that if the seller is committing fraud you have an address that
you can send the police to another solution for seller or item authenticity is to get these sellers to actually ship it to let's say our marketplace's warehouse where we appraise and see whether this item is fake or not obviously that would be more work on our side but let's say the seller would pay us for that or the buyer might pay us an extra fee for that and the last solution is creating a return policy that's semi-generous basically within 30 days if the buyer is not satisfied whether it's because it's authentic or just some other
parts of it they can return it and that could make the seller feel more responsible that they have to sell something or that it's in their best interest to sell something that is real we just walked through the question what product would you build in order to help people buy antiques and here's some things that stands out about this response it is not perfect of course but some of the things that i was intentional about that i see best candidates do the first thing is truthfully assessing does this fit within the facebook product of ecosystems
and not just force fitting it into it just because the question is from an interviewer from that company the second thing that i intentionally did was prioritizing clearly and objectively third i was also intentional about sharing clear strategy how we were going to win how we were going to differentiate ourselves from the market or be stronger than those in the market number four i actually tackle the multiple pain points in my solutions rather than just going with one pain point and this is optional you can either choose one pain point or choose a couple but
i like the couple pain points because it shows a multitude of creative solutions rather than trapping me into one pain point where i might feel a bit more stuck coming up with solutions and then my solutions actually solve the problem like that people take for granted but is important so if you want more examples of product sense questions and how we go through them take a look at these two examples here where we go through more product sense questions because in this case prepping for product stands product design interviews repetition really really helps and challenging
yourself to think in like odd unreliable spaces this challenge actually makes you stronger in product sense questions and i will see you guys in the next video