the medical method of psychology is the notion that mental illnesses can be attributed to things like biology or physical factors this essentially treats mental illness like a physical illness like a colder flu the medical method of psychology has led to a lot of advancements in how we treat and diagnose patients I'll focus on the diagnostic part in this video to a clinician it's important to appropriately analyze the symptoms of their patient so they can give them an appropriate Diagnostic in order to keep this diagnostic system really consistent and rigid throughout the psychological Community clinicians can
use the dsm5 as a guide the dsm5 essentially gives lists of symptoms and the mental illnesses they're associated with so clinicians can accurately diagnose their patients for example in the dsm5 in order to diagnose a child with ADHD a Criterion is that the symptoms or the behavior they're displaying would be considered inappropriate for their development level or their age now it would be great if the dsm5 was just some objective document that treats every patient perfectly but this is not the case the fact is that the dsm5 is heavily influenced by Western culture especially in
the United States the reason that this is a problem is that for example if diagnosing a child for ADHD because you consider the behavior inappropriate it may be just that the Behavior they're displaying is inappropriate for this specific culture but is not actually harming the child in any way this could lead to things like violations of Conformity leading to diagnostic of a mental illness this also eliminates a lot of the individualism that's associated with mental illness and it ignores the spectrum that a lot of uh psychological distress exists on it turns out that the consistency
and rigidness of the dsm5 is actually one of its biggest weaknesses this also creates a lot of stigma around mental illness for example a study has shown that if a child knows that one of their Playmates has been diagnosed with ADHD that child is less likely to play with that child again it also doesn't help that the dsm5 has led to a lot more Diagnostics of mental illness in recent decades an alternative to this is the systems method of psychology which gives in a holistic review of the patients's life looking at their environment and the
relationships and how that could cause psychological distress this is great because it actually caters to the needs of the patient but it's a very complex process and because the analysis of their environment is complex necessarily the treatment has to be complex as well this means that this is isn't always an effective way of treating a patient to more closely compare the medical and systems model of psychology let's see how it would work on our hero Freddy when he's diagnosed with with ADHD Freddy is a normal boy but he has some trouble paying attention in class
his teacher notices that he often Daydreams talks and jokes with other students frequently distracting them as well since this is a problem the teacher suggests Freddy's parents that he see a child psychologist his parents follow her advice and they take him to a psychologist Freddy's doctor prescribes Ridin which is a stimulant and it helps him pay better attention in class initially after couple weeks Freddy's mood seems to improve he's able to pay attention in class and the drug drugs seem to be working however there's one thing that Freddy psychologists ignored Freddy experiences a lot of
stress at home from his parents to be successful in school this is probably part of the reason why he was so distracting to other students then he just wanted to joke with them and have fun because the psychologists ignored this Freddy became dependent on the stimulus to pay attention to school his mood shift he lost motivation he no longer enjoyed talking to his friends and now all he has is a belly full of Rin a better method would be for the psychologist to observe Freddy's environment holistically and see truly what's causing him to behave in
the way that he does you'll notice that this does not necessitate that the medical method is completely useless the child psychologist can you still use things like behavioral therapy and yes prescription drugs along with observing his environment to to actually help Freddy and improve his learning situation at school from this example we can see that the medical method of psychology is most effective when it's actually married with the Sy systems method all the behavioral therapy and the prescription drugs that Freddy was taking became more effective once his environment was accounted for by a psychologist it's
also important to note that the systems method can exist by itself Studies have found that around 85 % of Diagnostics of ADHD are in fact due to biological factors such as genetics If This Were to go untreated Studies have shown that CH children that do not face treatment for ADHD grow up to have complications like depression or even substance abuse