Hey everyone Ryan here I am a Bible nerd today I want to tackle a comment video on one of my favorite videos on YouTube one of my favorite channels he's been putting out content a little more consistently and just love interacting with this content and wanted to do just a review video of it watch a little bit with you and have you hopefully watch the whole video and and like his channel I really recommend it that you like Subscribe check out his channel so you can see his name right here topic today is does God
exist AI debates atheist versus believer so what he's done is he's created these two different AI programs to basically debate each other one is an atheist one's a believer in God and then has AI programs judge their answers and then see where those programs kind of bias or which way that they lean after the entire conversation is over and what I love about this Format is it gives you a chance to listen to a debate without it turning into personal attacks or yelling matches you get to kind of see the arguments and the question both
ways and kind of How It's judged I I don't think it's a winner and a loser type thing even though there is a scoring that you'll see in here but I think it's really deep conversations that we don't get to see in these formats very often most of the time they turn into screaming matches or Personal attacks or or switching the topic to something else because maybe they're not as as Adept in that conversation want to kind of revert the conversation to something else I think there's a time and place to be able to watch
those types of videos on YouTube or like Pierce Morgan will have his panel on they'll just get yelling and talking so I think there's still an important part to listen to both sides of the argument but what I love about This is just more I guess civilized I guess is the best way to look at it because they don't talk over each other there's not personal attacks they're just simply answering the questions using their programming and then having the other programs judge how they did so I want to go through this video for a little
bit I don't know if we'll go through the whole thing or not love to have your comments on it feedback love to talk to you about this stuff I don't Know how that's going to open up my comments to probably ugly stuff too but I think this is important to talk about and a conversation we've had as humans since the very beginning of time is God exist or not and that's kind of what this video is trying to tackle in a very unique way love his Channel please make sure you subscribe I'll put a link
in the details but you got to check out his channel he does some really good stuff so let's watch this first video Look at that yeah so you can see he's got all these different AI models that come up with their different scoring methods up to a 50 point scale so if you're perfect on everything you'd get a 50 if you missed all of it you'd be a zero which I don't think that would ever be probably zero with the other uh programs also doing the debating so but it's pretty interesting to watch how these
programs kind of lean which direction based on the answers of the Other programs so it really is a cool use of AI I think it's really cool I love is Graphics I just really like the way he's put these videos together try to comment like all of his stuff and I I hope that through my video maybe you'll watch his video and like his channel as well but just love this conversation so let's see kind of where it goes but you can get an idea that basically he going to pit these two debates these two
AI programs against each other with these Guys doing the judging that's the ultimate question the problem of pain the problem of evil does suffering and evil disprove God's existence so the AI program that's representing the atheistic worldview is going to start answering that question let's see where it goes I I think it's interesting right here right off the bat it would have the desire and ability to prevent unnecessary suffering even the Atheistic Viewpoint has to say unnecessary suffering so that means there is still necessary suffering there's still suffering that happens that we know there's a
necessity for that now it's going to get to the Extremes in these arguments that why do we have you know children getting cancer and there's there's things that are just we just can't see the necessity of that suffering but I also would ask myself what is the suffering he's preventing That we never do see and if there is evil in the world why is there also so much good and I think many times we focus way too much on the negative when there is so much good that's out there and there's so many times what
looks unnecessary or looks like suffering turns out to be a very incredible thing I've seen in my own life where I didn't know why and why it was happening at the time it was when I look back I wouldn't have changed it in fact it it was Something that was important for my growth now I does that relate to every kind of suffering no just the same thing there's there is some necessary suffering and there may be some unnecessary suffering that doesn't mean there's not a loving God that's on the end of it knowing that
there will be something good that will come from it maybe and might not even be in this lifetime you know death isn't the punishment from this unnecessary Suffering because it isn't the end that's another thing that the atheist versus Believers going to have a a harder time with is we don't believe that death is the end as a Believer as an atheist I think they do they just think it's nothing it's just over it's just done when we have that belief that there is something after this that what we're doing here will lead on into
eternity the the skills that we're going to lose the perseverance the patience The the grit the other things that we're going to learn we can't learn without going through it there's everybody knows there's a big difference between watching the movie reading the book and living the life there's just something different some of the most immense emotions that we'll ever experience sometimes come from the most joy and the most suffering let's continue watching absolutely there's natural disasters but even there there's we've learned more And more that there is a necessity for that to have the inhabits
have the Earth inhabitable by all the different creation cre creatures that are on I I'm amazed at how diverse this planet really is when you look at especially if you look at the entire universe to have me be on a planet that can also live with all the other organisms and they all work and all breathe and we're all eating and we're it's just amazing how fine-tuned this planet is let alone the Universe and Mathematics and gravity and all those kind of things you look at the DNA structures you look at the fine-tuning of just
our planet alone is unreal and maybe some of these natural disasters that they're discovering as part of those processes to make the Earth inhabitable and unfortunately a lot of times the natural disasters he's talking about are some of the most desirable places on the earth because they've created that abundance in those Areas because of those natural processes I saw a report I think that 80% of the Earth's population within like a 100 miles of the coast just because that's some of the most inhabitable beautiful great parts of the Earth where people want to live but
they're also in the way of the train so to speak when the earthquake hits the tsunami hits whatever happens to hit and to say that a natural disaster is evil on it to itself is just like saying okay it's Evil if a lion eats a a baby or something it's horrific it's tragic it's horrible I'm not trying to downplay but we wouldn't necessarily call that an evil it's just a lion doing what it's doing it's just it's food it doesn't know that it's not it doesn't have a moral compass like we do but because we
have a moral compass we had to have a moral compass Giver we have to have something that says okay we know that's evil because we know the opposite of That thing we know that's not the ideal we don't know why all the time why that thing happened but we know it's not right we have an ought to and ought not to we have this sense of moral that's outside of ourselves it's outside of our Evolution it's outside of our genetics it's outside of our cultural our time frame there's certain things we just know throughout all
human history we're just not the best whether we label it evil or not sometimes depends on the Cultural context of it but we have some things that that are outside of that that are outside of whether you live on the American continent or the Asian continent there's going to be things that you just know universally are things you shouldn't do that are what we would label as evil so and then when it comes to horri horrific acts of violence that's consequence of that free will that God thought it was worth the risk he basically saw
what the the truest Form of free will the most choice would give them the chance to choose wrong or choose the the wrong thing or the right thing but being able to give him that he felt it must have been worth that risk to be able to allow those things to happen violence is horrible but a lot of that will come down to Free Will it comes down to human suffering which is most of the suffering I think we see in the world is from the human suffering yes natural disasters happen yes there's Diseases yes
there's those types of things but I think when you label most evils it's going to come down to human choice I think a lot of it is what is profound suffering versus not what is consequent what is Judgment for sin what is love in its purest form is to allow some of the suffering to happen and I also have to think if there is so much evil in the world there can't be a God but why is there so much good in the world if there isn't a God and how many Things he prevent or
has stopped I mean I hear countless stories of people that that were going to be into an area where there was going to be some sort of problem and they got a cell phone call or their alarm didn't go off or something like that now I'm not saying that why did that person's alarm go off and that one didn't there's going to be a reason but there's amazing how many times where there is some prevention of some of this stuff that God has laid out That has made preventions we may never know about now we
can see the suffering end because that's what we see the consequence of the people that did die in that situation but there's also a lot of people that didn't like it's amazing how often that things are actually prevented the suffering is mitigated I don't think it's just rampid I don't think the suffering isn't under his control as well now does that excuse why again there is certain suffering There's not other times no I no but I still trust him to make that decision more than me I still trust that there is a reason behind it
there is a prevention of a certain level I don't think there's just Mindless suffering I really don't I think a lot of it will have a purpose whether it's for that individual purpose that culture that time that space something in God's plan to make all this work and I just hope I'm in tuned with that to where I can either mitigate the Suffering or that I'm ready to be prepared for and use that as a a challenge or use that as a reason why I'm going through it is to be what God wants me to
be by going through and persevering oh oh I paused it too late but isn't that kind of cool it'll show you each Ai and kind of which one it does at the end he'll do a t a tally and kind of show you which one kind of lean more towards the the atheistic arguments or the Believers arguments I think it's Just a great part of this video just to kind of show which ones had their biases it's such a great argument it's one of the best arguments of of Christianity and really we haven't even we
haven't gotten within 100 miles of Christianity yet we're just talking about whether there's a God or whether there's a not a god you know this the the theistic view worldview or the atheistic worldview but I think that's really important that this idea that There is something outside of ourselves that creates a moral standard that we can say something is evil or something is suffering because we can know that the opposite of that thing just like we know what a rainy day looks like because we've seen a sunny day we know what not cancer looks like
because we've seen what cancer looks like you know we have that idea but a lot of it is outside of ourselves when it comes to morality and what we label as Evil versus what is Just is what is just part of processes and it's often said I can't remember off the top of my head that most of our sufferings in our own minds so if he's removing all suffering I mean how much suffering would you have to remove before You' believe in God like how much suffering would have to be completely gone all of it
so you have no suffering whatsoever at all you I I don't think that would be loving I don't think God Would look at us and say okay that's the best you can be that's the best you can prove to yourself I mean you talk to anybody that they've grown from adversity if you lost all that I don't think God would have these loving creatures they'd just be mindless babies all the time they'd never be they'd never grow up they'd never mature they'd never have any grit anything would come against them that had any kind of
hint of suffering they just collapse I think The strongest people in our history and our society have gone through some stuff and come out the other side that I think is what God's trying to create now unfortunately and he's allowed certain things we just may not understand like and and part of it's probably him going guys you don't have to make it this hard you don't have to suffer this much trust in me trust in the process learn through this experience and don't unnecessarily Suffer we suffer more in our minds than we do in reality
now that doesn't mitigate true suffering illnesses natural disasters like he's trying to say here but I think that's a low percentage of the suffering they're talking about the bigger percentage of the suffering is just dayto days stuff and this is a character building exercise as much as anything else s right let's let's keep reading or keep listening I think it's important part Now I would say on the a istic worldview that it again goes to the extreme like what's the point of some of the suffering what is the point of a child at 2 years
old four years old 5 years old whatever it is getting some sort of incurable cancer some sort of yes I I'm not going to sit there and say that's not challenging I'm not going to sit there and say completely blind like oh God is good and he'll yeah that's challenging that stuff's tough But I still believe that there's still more good that does come out of it because I have seen some of the things that people have done with fundraising I've seen people with advancements of Technology to overcome some of those things have been incredible
and even the stories of how mature those kids are and how much they help their family and how they go through it and realize that this it it sucks you know it's painful but there's still good that can come from it It's not 100% evil and that's why I believe there really isn't anything truly evil unto itself evil has to steal from good it's something that's usually good that becomes corrupted over time and the more it gets corrupted the more evil it gets in our eyes but almost everything starts as good it just becomes corrupt
it becomes evil yeah how many times have we solved a problem because of suffering how many times have we seen some sort of wrong And we triy to make it right and how much better comes of that thing that was meant for harm that turns into good that happens so much throughout our history so if the atheists just said hey all that suffering should be gone there's so many things that wouldn't Advance there wouldn't be any there wouldn't be any grit there wouldn't be perseverance there wouldn't be any self-sacrifice there wouldn't be any communities there
wouldn't be there's so much stuff we Would lose if suffering was completely off the table and I think that's what shows God loves us enough to punish evil to judge and to let us fall a few times to get ourselves back up with him being there to to prevent it from being too much I think I got to think there's times I know in my own life that he's had to have prevented some things from happening there's a couple times I almost died and I'm sure he prevented some some of those things why I don't
Know why he still wants me around I don't know but and why somebody else didn't I had I had an experience that I should have been a lot worse off and was okay and then I had somebody else that had the same experience and they ended up a lot worse I don't know why those differences happen some of it is our own choices of how we accept some of the things that are happening to us but I think that's an important part of why there is suffering and pain in the world See what see what
you I I don't I don't agree with this and this is where scientists will be able maybe have studies or that type of stuff but I don't think evolutionary processes promote co co social Co cohesion oh boy boy butchered that because what you get is Empires what you get is people that say okay our social construct our family is above yours our family is protected we're going to destroy everybody else around us so I Don't think that ethics grow from Evolution I think it's something outside of ourselves it's a process that we can see when
something is not good even even people that were doing horrible evil still go okay I think this has gone too far you'll still have people that go okay wait a minute this we got to dial this back this probably is getting a little bit too crazy and I think if it was just simply an evolutionary process that we get more ethical over time I Think defeats Evolution because it's an idea of survival strongest the fittest or the smartest or the most adapted to an environment weeds out the ones that aren't that's part of kind of
why this species has accelerated this one disappeared as part of their family line if you believe in The evolutionary theories I think there's some huge holes in that but that's a whole another debate and maybe he'll have a debate about that but for this the idea that Ethics or U moral good or is some sort of social um cultural thing now sure some cultures may be a little closer to better than good but almost all of them start Good Start idealistic and start to deteriorate I think that's what you see in the world even from
the story of Adam and Eve and the Garden of Eden started out good and became corrupt everything kind of starts from good and ends up being corrupted over time either by bad decisions environmental pressures or Other societies like if you're saying that just it's an evolutionary process then we would have Utopia by now wouldn't we I mean what's St everything from why would there be a war ever again e if ethics are a voluntary or a evolutionary process it doesn't it seems like it's always trying to negate that it always seems like it's trying to
pull backwards with Wars and famine and people treating each other bad as Powers rise up they squish the small people It's been throughout our entire history it's probably worse in the past and there's been es and flows of that as empires have rised and Fallen but that's a lot of times why they rise they rise on these great ideas and they collapse underneath them that's what we see throughout Human Society to say evolution is part of that process I think Falls incredibly short because it doesn't prove the things that are outside of that with moralistic
rules That we all try to adhere to when we see an imp empire collapse we kind of point to and say well that's the reason you're to do it we're not going to do the same thing oh we're idealistic here we go we got this great country great nation great Empire whatever it is and then over time it just starts to kind of collapse in on itself again so that's I don't see that being an uary process that's a strong argument it really is it's okay how do you exp we Would have say on the
at least the Christian side again this is just believer and atheist that a lot of it has to do with the fall of Adam and Eve that that Corruption of being away from the perfect and away from that Garden that corruption led to some of those things just breaking down and having issues as it's just removed from that holiest of sources as it's removed from the fall so a lot of it is blamed on the fall for a lot of these things over Human history and how we tried to justify or come up with it
but that's it's definitely a tough argument of childhood diseases or these some of these natural disasters but like I said earlier some of these what we call natural disasters are they evil no they're part of the process of allowing the Earth to be inhabitable by all of its wonderful creatures and us especially have to have some of these natural processes now why did God create It that way I don't know there's got to be some reason that he wanted that diversity he wanted those things to work he wanted us to experience all that this creation
can do and so some of that's going to lead towards okay some of it's going to have to be a little dangerous some of it's going to have to blow up once in a while some of it's going to move some of the tonic plates are going to have to move as just part of the pressures of making all this work and Unfortunately we're in the way of that sometimes I like I said before I mean I think it was like 80% of the world's population I could be wrong 70 80% of the world's population
is within a 100 miles of all the coast around the entire world like if an alien was smart or something just drop a big boulder or something in the ocean and just tidal wave you know the first 100 miles or whatever 50 miles in would wipe out half the Earth so but because those are the Areas people want to live but there's also the areas that have that much activity which also breeds more plant life and animal life and all the other things that just make earth so beautiful has some of that stuff that's part
of it to make it work now God maybe he could have created it without it but maybe it wouldn't have been as beautiful or as as recognized as beautiful as part of it and wouldn't lead to what he's trying to do to restore that to absolute Perfection so I is it a result of human choices I think it might be in my worldview it might have been Adam and Eve's sin that led to why these things have to break down like they do but that is definitely a strong argument on the atheistic case that why
do we have some of those but I think that suffering level is on the low end of the scale I think most of the suffering we're talking about is more based on human choice Choices there it is again no apparent purpose just like no un what seems to be unnecessary suffering so yes there is some gratuitous what we call what he says here is gratuitous but again he's setting a standard of how do you know it's gratuitous why do you call it evil why do you call it gratuitous suffering if you knew it had a
purpose would it then be gratuitous if you knew okay that sucks what you're going through what that person's going through what Earthquake happened that does suck but because you know the purpose you're able to say okay that isn't gratuitous the reason we know it's gratuitous suffering is because we think it has no apparent purpose but you still have to say no apparent you can't just say serves absolutely no purpose because people would be say well there might be a purpose to we just don't know what the purpose is God does and again I think he's
prevented it from Being overly gratuitous I think there's definitely times where he says nope can't go that far not there now why is it that person doesn't have to go through the suffering and this one does I don't know I really don't know I don't know what benefit that's going to have but I know there is one I know there is a purpose because of that belief in something that's outside of myself a standard that's outside of myself I can't explain the fine tuning I can't Explain there's so many things I can't explain without there
being some sort of intelligent mind that's out outside of time space and matter that orchestrated the whole thing and my job is to just get to know that person in God as best I can to be in line with that will as best I can because it's better than mine my will let me lets myself down all the time his doesn't so again even this sentence well constructed and that's great programs are great I just love This debate I think it's amazing still uses the big word gratuitous suffering with no apparent purpose so again I
ask him is there any purpose to that suffering and we just don't know what it is the answer would have to be yes we don't know what that purpose might be and who orchestrated that purpose is what we call God in the first place all right let's keep listening that's a good question I think that's really important there There's things we can't experience in heaven that we can hear because we are in this time space matter stuck in this human body stuck in time stuck in a location stuck in a weather pattern stuck you know
there's certain things we can't experience like the heartache of losing a loved one the heartache of losing your family pet I mean there is some severe heartache that you just cannot explain unless you've been through it and even people that sit There and try to go through an experience and they haven't been through it and they try to make you feel better you just know okay they don't really know what I'm going through so going through it is better than not and I think that's what she's trying to say here is that yes this is
a crucible there's just things that happen in this reality that cannot happen in heaven not only because we can see God and we're in a different state but there's just Things here that are as real as God could make them a reality that is a realist it it matters it really does matter there's consequence there's penalty there's there's judgement there's Victory there's joy there's sadness some of the greatest joy is from some of the greatest sadnesses because we are actually in the mud we're in the in the existence that we can't get other places and
why this is such a drop in all eternity but it's such a crucial Part of why we're here and I'm sure that's why God has so much patience for us why he's waited so long for another return or why he hasn't flooded the Earth again like the Noah story some of the stories that we know on the believer side is because I think of his love his just giving us as many chances as we possibly can and that is a loving God with a loving purpose behind this whole thing so I think that's an important
thing this might be a stupid analogy but I I remember the other day I had like a a football game basketball game I can't remember what it was was recorded and then somebody told me the score so I was like oh I don't really now I don't need to watch it and you know I watch it and then I I remember watching it and and my team that that ended up winning was like way down like oh this is kind of exciting they're they're they got down they rallied back but I already knew the outcome
so it didn't it it changed kind Of the the thrill of going through it because I already knew the outcome so I think that's what he's basically saying here if we're already in heaven we already have certain tools that'll be aware to us that we won't get the experience of the rush of the unknown or the the true pain or the physical pain or I remember there was a movie I can't remember you guys can probably put in the comments where this guy I think it was an alien or something like sneezed For the first
time and never experienced a sneeze and was like oh this is n what is what is this a sneeze you know and how do you explain a sneeze to an alien or to an angel or to a demon or something like that like what do you mean your body just all of a sudden has to expel a bunch of air really quickly so there's something about being in it and doing it that's always going to be different than reading talking watching Or in heaven where those choices now have that that has more the purpose behind
it so you're not as intense with it because you know it's just going to work out it's like well okay yeah I broke my leg but I know in 10 days it'll be healed and I won't have to worry about it and I'll be fine so there's something that's why I think this reality is so important that it is a true experience that we can't get anywhere else Okay so he's basically saying yeah if we did know all the purpose of it then we would be like God and I think that's one characteristic of God
but I think that's definitely not all the characteristics that make him God but that's definitely a good point it's like okay if we just knew everything then we wouldn't have the need for any knowledge or trying to work things out or try to persevere or or do any of the things that we can do by being outside of that that purpose or That knowledge of what God has I I don't want to have to worry about it J The Book of Job is really perfect where he basically says hey would you have any idea how
to run any of this even for a day would you be orchestrate and run all of this stuff that's going on the answer would be absolutely not you probably wouldn't want to because I think you'd then be able to see some of the things we care about so much really don't matter and some of the things we don't Matter really do we always seem to get that part backwards so let's see what the response is I think yes why not why couldn't a profound God you have to have one on the other because some of
the most profound Joy comes from recovering from the suffer suffering or there's just feelings that we get that don't come to the level without some of the suffering now why Does it have to be that way I don't know because it just expands our capability expands what we consider Joy or suffering it's amazing how often times that people will think they can't do something and then get pushed past that point and how much that grows their character but then you see the people that do crumble of through that that never recover from it as well
but these are experiences that have to have such extremes to really see what we do and Where we turn when we are in those situations and I think that that statement I don't I don't think for me it doesn't stand up is God created because of his love he created stuff that allowed us to experience as much as we possibly can so I I don't think you can have one without the other okay so are you saying that if somebody has aund suffering they need to have a 100 Joy I I don't think you can
I don't Think it works that way sometimes now why does it seem sometimes that people do have a hundred suffering and only 50 Joy I hope you're getting kind of the idea what I'm trying to say here I don't know that's a part I don't know with God because I don't know what he's going to turn that into and turn it into a thousand Joy so but I do think that that's his end goal and will be where we're heading with all this is a something that was meant to be harmful Suffering and all that
will be turned into Joy Maybe won't be in this lifetime but I think that's what God's ultimate plan is going to be is this restoration to use all these experiences for something that will be Joy beyond all understanding that's something in our scripture that talks about all the time there's sometimes where we just don't think there's G to be anything good that happens from it I looked at my own life and there's certain things that I would Not want to go through again but I look back on it and I wouldn't have changed it and
I think that's something that is very important on this worldview I would really like an example of that what is the immense suffering at microscopic levels are they really suffering is that is it a conscious suffering or is he just talking about like bacteria that's dying and so I may need to clarify that as well because I wanted then again it says no apparent Purpose again we don't know what that purpose is do we even know it's really suffering if we're talking microscopic levels of just things dying and living and dying and living I don't
I don't know is there I don't know the purpose again and even he has to admit no apparent purpose if he knew there was a purpose for he wouldn't use it as an argument because oh well we know that that thing needs to eat that thing because that thing eats this thing and Then that thing produces the air that then provides the life for everything you know I mean once if we knew what the purposes were even on a microscopic level then it would change what we'd call it evil in the first place or we
might be more profound and say okay we have actually found truest truest version of evil and that means evil in the devil does exist so it's almost the counter of that argument as well if we get so deep in the purpose that it is Just purely for Evil's sake which I still I I don't think that exists in a sense because I think even evil has to steal from good it just corrupts the things that are good I can't think of anything that is just evil for itself or unto itself it's always a Corruption of
something else so I love a comment on that let me know what you think about that but I always think and that's kind of CS Lewis kind of thing that just everything starts as as good and becomes Corrupted and becomes evil it's a great question I mean that is something where we look at some of the suffering it doesn't have an apparent reason we just don't know what that purpose or Reason is yet and and I think that he thinks it must be worth it I think that's what this is saying and what I would
say as a believer I would say I don't know but I would say that he must think that some of this stuff is worth it and I still think there's Things he has prevented we just don't know what it is because it was prevented so I still ask that question if there is no God because there's evil in the world why is there so much good in the world if there isn't a god it'd be the same argument let's see what we got I think that's part he must think it's worth it he must think
that the suffering that we that we have whether it's real or not he must think that the evil that we call evil is or not must be Worth it there must be a Divine reason why he lets some of the evil happen to certain people not to other people and why one person crosses the street gets hit by a car and another person's one hitting the person's breakes and stops yes there's got to be certain reasons I often wonder that in my own life that that why did God step in in this case and not
the other case and he knows there's a reason for it he's allowing it to happen or stopping it from happening But I think that there's way more that he stops then allows I just I just know that to be true and we just don't see it there's just so many things that could go wrong that don't there's just so many things in this world that are evil but there's so many more things that are good that are pushing down that evil we just spend way too much time looking at the evil we don't look at
all the good things that happen even within that evil or why that evil would be allowed to Exist now would we want to eliminate all evil probably that's our humanistic nature it's also something that's outside of ourselves why she's talking about some sort of conscious moral standard that's outside of ourselves that we do aspire to that but I think all of us would realize that if all of it was gone it wouldn't be the life we would want us to live or kids to live or anything we want to remove all suffering yes but we
have to also realize that There is some suffering that is necessary that is has a purpose so I think that's a great question I mean I think that really is the great question there and then I would ask okay Mr atheist what suffering would you allow because if you lowered all the suffering that's happening right now down to that standard you'd still be able to see all the people that thought that that's the worst suffering you could suffer you know what I mean so if We have our standards kind of up here at 100 and
you lower it to 50 that 50 becomes the 100 and now all of a sudden we realize stubbing our toe is is shouldn't happen there shouldn't be any Corners where we could hit our toe against the bed you know or step on a Lego I'm really not trying to downplay it but I'm just trying to go from the extreme of what we're talking about also to the extreme on the other side and realize that all suffering cannot be Mitigated that the suffering that is in the world I think is allowed for a certain extent because
of either judgment because of sin because of human choices or because of the Fallen state of the world but God allows for it I still think he's Sovereign over all of it and he does allow it with some sort of purpose in mind we just don't know what it is and if we did like she's saying we just become robots we just become puppets if we knew every reason Every outcome every purpose for everything without having to have some trust some Faith some understanding trying to solve the problem trying to fix it trying to make
it not happen anymore there's something in those efforts that is more character building and worth it to God than if those things are removed and I think that's an important part of this argument I don't think you can I don't think we if we don't have those things we don't Have the opposite of those things to their Extreme as well and he must think that that's worth it to have those things be a possibility because of what it can be on the other side and genocides and things like that are are the human choices that
we make where one society says they're better than another one human one family one street one city One Nation just builds itself up to be better than another one that then leads to the extermination of whatever is Dehumanized I think most of it's a dehumanization that allows most of this to happen which is that part of that human choice now illness in children and those natural disasters probably the hard hardest of those arguments but violence and genocide and wars and all that that's a man-made construction we know it's wrong and we know we fight against
it and both sides of a Waring Nations both sides think they're right and the other side is the evil side That's happened throughout all of human history I I think that's an important question is why doesn't he make himself more present but I would say as a Believer we see him every day we see him all over the place we see him in everything that's there the a are the one that don't see him anywhere so I think it it depends on that worldview and you see the people that are crushed by this suffering are
the ones that aren't Learning through it and I still think there will be something on the other side that they will gain from that that they can't gain while they're here or get crushed by it but I also think that God will make sure that there is a way out that there is help and guidance wherever possible and gives us as much patience as possible so I don't think I don't think God can create this world any other way otherwise I believe he would if he really is what I think he is He could have
created the world differently he found that this is the best way to get what he wants out of everything and to give us the choices and decisions and everything that we that we get to have so I I think this is the best that could have been or least as close to the best it can be with also being able to have that the knowledge that our free will is going to have issues that's it's going to have a choice to choose evil over good choose Something other than him and his plan and his will
and so I think his that's part of The Crucible of of what we're doing here I she probably should answer this one before I I start kind of going into it but my first thought again is yes there's going to be people that get crushed by the suffering there's going to be people are going to lose their faith but I think there's way more that grow through it whether it turns them to Religion or not that will say that that experience strengthened me that most people in it don't like it the discipline is not fun
all the things that we talk about as a society about how to grow and move through it and move past things some of the people that we honor and Elevate and respect the most are the people that have been through stuff and gone through the other side with a positive attitude that don't get crushed by it so yes there's examples of People that going to get crushed by it that just cannot handle it that just the suffering in their head and their body and their mind and their family is just too much to handle and
they just completely shut down I'm not I'm not going to say that's not going to happen but I'm also going to say there's way more I think on the other side there's way more people that go through that suffering that look back and say I would not change it I don't want to go through It again but I wouldn't change it because what it led to the doors had opened the strength had opened the perseverance had opened the strength I didn't even know I had that came out of me the joy I didn't know that
I had some of the things I would never had experienced had I not gone through some stuff so yes I think it's sad when people get crushed by it but I think the ones we Elevate and are most excited about are the ones that do Elevate over It and I think those are the ones that we write books and movies and sitcoms and and all the things that we see people that really look like they're crushed and they get back up that that is the people we honor and celebrate the most because we want that
in ourselves we want to be the person that has everything go wrong family friends job car all this stuff gone suffered and yet rise above it and power through it That's the people we aspire to be so if God took away that suffering we wouldn't have any of those types of people and I think that'd be a sad Society I agree yeah just like I said if you already if you knew God already existed would change how you would react to certain things so you wouldn't know how you would have reacted without it I I
know it's a analogy but I I use the same one about the sporting event if I already know the outcome of which team Is going to win watching it again changes a little bit and there just isn't any drama with it maybe there's a little bit like oh it's cool to see how they won but once you already know they won or once you already knew the outcome or you know it changes how much you have to persevere through because you just know the outcome of it so I think having that separation that Veil Just
that distance allows these choices to be more authentic because they don't have any Coercion or anything that could give you a additional biases or just not allow the growth that's that's necessary to happen so I think she's she's nailing it on the head right here or we just don't know it I I still think there's times where and I I've acknowledged it more and more when I see something lucky or just something where the smallest thing I just give a little wink and just say thanks God thanks for just avoiding that little Inconvenience I just
give credit to that because I don't know how many times he's done it on a way bigger scale that I can't acknowledge so I just made it a habit where if something just happens I drop something it doesn't hit my foot something like that or my keys or something I remember something real quick and I don't have to run all the way back home or there just little things like that that I kind of call the god Winks just the little moments that Hey I'm helping you out I am here here's the little stuff because
you're not seeing the big stuff that I'm doing you just can't you're not seeing the big big worldly things and all the things I'm orchestrating for the goodness of all the stuff and I think that attitude is one of the biggest difference between a Believer and an atheist is this idea that there is a God that is walking us through this that has a plan for all this so I think I I think she this is probably I don't know if she's going to score the best on this one I can't remember which one was
the best score but I think this one's just nailing it there's that argument again I don't I don't I need to understand that more I can't understand why Evolution explains that we know something is morally wrong when I've seen so many times within cultural that that those things e and flow a lot more than Universal things we Just know are bad we just there's certain things that transcend Evolution or culture or time or or so many of the other human constructs of society that this is there's still things outside of it now some things yeah
a certain Society might Elevate or punish differently because of some sort of what they call sin or evil or something like that but there's still a lot of them that have been Universal that are outside of all of us like I if I go to China 2,000 years ago there's still going to be the same kind of wrong selfishness certain murders certain treatment of elderly or kids I mean certain those things aren't always going to be looked at as wrong even the suffering we're talking about here it's going to always be looked at as evil
or wrong or just not right regardless of evolutionary societal changes that's why I think it's it's outside of that now maybe there's Certain things within that that that still could fall in that category but I think a majority of it is outside of that that's I don't I don't think that's a strong argument for that or don't observe again how much are we not observing I I bet you if the veil was pulled back God would be like look at all that I have prevented that you don't see and you don't have to see that
that isn't full evil running absolute rampant because I would say that if There isn't a God why is there so little evil if you call everything evil can it get worse you would say yes you would say absolutely yes it could be a million times more evil on the planet and still could be worse so we know that evil in in a sense is capped or is at least being held back by goodness whether it's our choices or God or anything else that's holding back some of that evil no apparent purpose again there's that word
why does he allow suffering That serves no apparent purpose parent if it was a parent it would have a purpose and you wouldn't call it suffering perceivable benef possibly but he didn't so even there you have to admit okay if he really is a powerful God he would not allow the suffering that he's allowing but I think he is capping it I think there is times where it could be worse sadly sometimes it's like wow that and And that's probably why you had to flood the whole planet if we believe it with the Noah's flood
how bad must it have been where God finally did say okay enough's enough starting over flooding the whole planet starting over I mean that goes to show it can be worse to the point where it's okay it's time to start over it's still a belief it's still a faith there's still things that always will come down to Faith almost everything When you start chopping it down will come down to some sort of belief or faith whether it's scientific things you just have faith that the instruments are working correctly that it is repeatable that the why
behind it is there all of it eventually comes down to Faith now religious people and the religious term has kind of stolen the word faith in a way but when you look at just what faith is we all have we don't live by evidence we don't or we don't live by proof we Live by evidence we live by constants we live by virtual certainties we live by most likely outcomes you know that's what we live by not by proof So eventually it all comes down to Faith it all does if you cut it and you
just keep cutting it down eventually you're going to hit faith faith is bottom I nailed it I absolutely believe that and again it's this idea see an animal that's that's suffering we don't know what that suffering is for that animal I I saw this thing that showed that the different levels that animals and humans perceive even pain that it's happening around them instead of to them there's there's some interesting studies that are out there that just kind of keep coming out what the relationship is for human suffering I even saw that plants can scream or
experience that they are getting cut or eaten or something like that which is like so it really does question what is consciousness when we Start at that type of stuff but again it's something where God says that okay that needs to exist because of these other reasons that it's overall a good in the long run that it will be restored if it isn't over time that there is a purpose behind it it said it so many times here we just don't know what that purpose is if we did it would change our outcome and our
response to everything and I think God says he wants those responses because he knows what the Outcome's going to be great question again if there isn't a god what standard are we using what standard are we using if it's not in within ourselves because if it's in ourselves my standard is going to be different than somebody else somebody's going to say Hey you looks like you're suffering it's like no no no or yes but it's because this is what happens because of that or yeah I remember there's a poem and maybe Somebody else can put
in the comments and basically said hey your your your kid off a horse and broke his leg that's really bad but then there was a war and he wasn't drafted so he didn't have to go to war so now it's a good thing that he broke his leg but then because he didn't go to war he didn't mean the girl or didn't get skills or it kind of played out this whole thing that the guy kept saying is this good is this bad is this good is this bad and it kept Switching based on new
information based on what the purpose of that thing would have been or what it prevented or what it started again we don't have that scope of being able to look back and see all the consequences of all the actions and and the purposes that are either self created or not but I still think a lot of the suffering does come down to human choice and human actions and reactions to things that are in our minds and in reality a lot of it's a lot Of sufferings in our minds it really is let's continue I don't
want this I wanted to try to keep this shorter but I mean I think there's like 20 minutes left to the video so we're not g to get through the whole thing so maybe I'll just end it here um let's let's actually go through this last little argument here with the atheistic worldview and then let's uh pick it apart one more time then we'll be done then hopefully you'll watch the rest of the video There's it just keeps going it's just a great video okay so that that's a very interesting point right there you're saying
that evolution is some of these roles but then Evolution seems to be extremely violent which would lead to more evil so how can Evolution lead to our moralistic ethical views yet it seems like it's actually trying to go the other way it almost seems like our Moralistic good is fighting against our evolutionary Tendencies so it's interesting that this is an argument against the moral argument he was making that was a positive that's pretty interesting twist evidence yes what evidence are you providing if there's if there's new if there's new evidence if there is purpose it
would change how we would call those things from good or evil if we had the purpose Behind it so because we don't have a purpose behind it we either have to trust that there is no purpose and it's just evil for Evil's sake or we make the justification that we don't know what that purpose is but we believe there's a good behind it that's again going to be the difference here between atheist and and believer views is who do we point to for all of it nothing or something I think that's going to be a
part of it so again I want to try to keep this video Is the longest I've done in a long time but check out the rest of the video I mean I could keep going on and on and on his other videos are great maybe I'll do another video but didn't want this one to go on this long but it's just so good can you see how much fun it is to be able to listen to Peaceful debate and thoughtful debate and go back and forth and try to push why you think the way you
think I might be wrong on this stuff I I admit that there may be some things I have wrong but that's why I'm trying to push my my knowledge trying to push the argument trying to hear the other side as best I can without just turning into yell Fest like Facebook and all this kind of stuff you don't really get any dialogue you just get people personal attacks and that's it it's like that's not an argument tell me why you think Evolution leads to more moral people I don't think it does from my experience but
show me an example that Might change my mind or maybe I've convinced you to take a look at it and say okay maybe I do need to look at the believer worldview and really start questioning why I think the world's so bad and why it's all evil for no reason I mean yeah that's what we're doing these videos for so anyway I'm going to stop the video here I could keep going and going I really enjoyed doing this stuff enjoy doing the stuff on the Channel please like subscribe comment Let's get the conversation going we
see where this goes but I don't mind having conversations with people I think that's the the fun part of being out there and trying to put your views and your your comments to to the test so I enjoyed this video hope you did too and we'll see you on the next one for