[Music] well hello everybody and welcome to cyos Spotlight and under the spotlight today is financial inclusion why do we care why should we care do we care how many people care that's what we're going to be discussing with a very special guest in just a moment or two let me tell you a bit about him he's director of the financial sector program at Harvard Kennedy um school's Center for business and government he's a Lector in public policy has 35 years under his belt of experience of international experience designing implementing and evaluating development policies he's worked
for private clients he's worked for governments um he's an expert on the development of bank and non-bank financial institutions um and of course he's talking on a very important subject that we've heard a lot about this week as I said Financial inclusion please give a warm welcome to Jay Rosengard [Applause] good afternoon it's a pleasure to be here and I think the timing is is wonderful when we think about financial inclusion I understand we just concluded a a wonderful panel discussion and then you all know the the keynote speaker in a few hours from now
Bill Gates will also be talking about financial inclusion so I was asked to just say a few words about what exactly is this what's the big fuss and why should we care so so that's going to be pretty much the extent of my comments and financial inclusion quite simply is trying to ensure access to formal financial services for everybody so not just those at the top of a nation's economic pyramid but also those who are most often excluded and that would be low-income households and family businesses and in many countries that's most people and most
economic activity and there also a significant subset of underbanked or unbanked um customers in high income countries um often in urban environments and immigrant communities when we talk specifically about financial inclusion and what it might be it involves a series of financial services or a package of financial services that um I'm going to list an order of demand so the most the service most in demand um among lowincome households and family businesses is payment services it's not credit it's not micro credit it's payment services and we're talking about transfers and remittances so if you're trying
to move money for example from rural areas to the city maybe your children are going to school in the city and you're trying to send tuition money then hopefully later they graduate they get a good job and then they send money back to the Village so just moving money around the country from rural to Urban Urban to Rural and then we talk about payment services payment of utilities and other regular routine expenses and then remittances so a lot of countries send workers abroad and the key is how do they get money from where they're working
not just back to their country but to their Village or Hometown so for example from the Middle East back to a town in mindo in the southern Philippines how do you manage to do that in a cost-effective way without actually giving the money to somebody to carry back for you the second most demanded service is saving services and this would be saving for a rainy day like we all like to do perhaps saving for an investment a business opportunity uh saving for for uh your retirement many countries there's not a uh very inclusive uh pension
program or healthc CARE program so your retirement is essentially your kids and any savings uh that you would um be able to accumulate also a lot of small businesses um are engaged in very cyclical activities seasonal activities so sometimes you would like to save simply for income smoothing between for example the time of the Harvest when you have a lot of money till the time much later when you're waiting for the Harvest and you don't have any cash available the third service most in demand would be microcredit Credit Services and this again can be for
small family businesses and mainly for working capital or very small investments in a in a small business it's very difficult to distinguish between a small investment like an extra so machine that generates income immediately and normal working Capital Loans could also be for a household um for consumption or for um some large investment and around the world the two largest Investments That households borrow for are shelter your home your family home and the education of your children um and also perhaps some large what we call consumer durables a fourth um service that's in growing demand
are more Innovative risk mitigation tools like health insurance life insurance and crop insurance and the crop insurance you've seen an awful lot of innovation in something called weather indexed crop insurance so that rather than try to figure out how much somebody lost going out to the farm measuring everything and all of the fraud that that encourages is to index the results of your farming to some neutral um easily verifiable indicator like rainfall so weather indexed crop insurance and here I suppose I should also mention um an even more rapidly developing area people call digital Financial
inclusion and that is trying to take advantage of mobile phone technology to get access to these formal Financial Services um and the reason is that there are many more for people who own phones around the world these days that have bank accounts and so if there's a way to kind of skip that step and get at least payment services through your mobile phone you're including a lot more people in your formal financial sector but I'm going to be a little bit of a naysayer here to remind everybody that using your phone for payment services is
really a means to an end um people are sometimes fascinated by the technology and The Innovation is technology driven but not really thinking about how does that actually benefit the customer in the long run and the idea of using your phone for payment transactions lowers transaction costs which does contribute indirectly to disposable income but in the end we want to have access to financial services to increase income accumulate assets and improve people's standard of living so again trying to think about how to be smart in utilizing um new technology so when we talk talk about
this bundle of services it's really not that different from what we all want payment services saving Services Credit Insurance um use of the latest technology to make it more convenient more accessible so the real innovation in financial inclusion is trying to adapt these services to the conditions the preferences the context of lower income markets and so we're talking about is coming up with innov of product design appropriate pricing and Delivery Systems to try to serve these markets in a way that's financially sustainable um so you're also talking about institutional Innovation to reach these markets and
financial sustainability is important because if you depend on a lot of external support grants government money donor money that's going to run out donors get bored flavors change and then you have a system that's really not sustainable and so what we see in the innovation of financial services for these demographics is a lot of what I would call social entrepreneurship in the micro finance and financial sector that is how can you do well and do good at the same time make money help people not as uh kind of gravy or um extra benefit but have
it as the core of your business model model that if you serve these demographics successfully you're going to have significant social impact and that's the key to generating profits so when we talk about some of the Innovation and adapting conventional products to non-conventional markets you think about the product design and so what you often want to do with for example microcredit is to try to match the repayment schedule to the cash flow of your customers sounds pretty simple but um it's of Overlook so if you're if you're lending to a a Trader a petty Trader
you can have maybe weekly or monthly repayments if you're lending to say a farmer you might want to have some type of seasonal loan but not have it all due at the Harvest the problem with having it all do with the Harvest it's that's when prices are the lowest so maybe have three payments or something spread out so that when there's not such a glut of product on the market the farmer gets a better price and and makes more money with the loan or say you you're um a uh brackishwater shrimp farmer so the cycle
there might be every three or four months there again you want to kind of tailor both dispersement and repayment along the cash flow um capabilities of the borrower when you look at pricing one of the things that's controversial is a relatively High interest rate for example for microloans but again what you're trying to do is to bring the product closer to the customer it's going to increase your transaction cost your delivery cost but it reduces the transaction costs of the borrower rather than having to go to the big city to get the loan use a
half a day or a whole day pay the transportation miss the business opportunities you're trying to bring the product to them so this is again Innovation and both pricing to pay for it it's got actually going to be higher than conven loans but that's not unusual Bankers know best rates usually go to the corporate customers large businesses get the next best rate small and medium-sized Enterprises get the worst rates you're going to have even higher loan costs for the micro loans because the transaction costs per dollar lend are going to be higher so again you're
trying to find a way to do this in a sustainable Manner and sustainability is also important on the savings side do you want to put your money in a bank that might not be there tomorrow unlikely um it's important for credit repayment the main incentive to repay for micro credit is the same as any other credit is it's future access to credit so if you think that I'm going to repay and they're going to fold tomorrow then it's not going to be available the smart thing to do is don't repay so again that the idea
of financial syst sustainability it builds trust and it and and it creates the positive incentives to develop a lasting long-term relationship between the customer and the financial institution um other types of institutional Innovations and trying to deliver these services to take advantage of the strength of formal Banks and the strength of community based organizations or development organizations and kind of a service provider contract model so you might take for example from Haiti the largest Commercial Bank soja bank created a community based nonprofit called soja soul and the idea is that soja Soul doesn't know anything
about how to manage all of the back office operations treasury operations IT personnel all the legal stuff but they're really really good at understanding the community I identifying good customers and providing good service to the customers so again you're trying to take advantage of being embedded in the community and in the end when we talk about financial services for low-income markets it's really just good Community banking I don't know if any of you have seen um the film it's very famous in America it's called It's a Wonderful Life Jimmy Stewart they show it every Christmas
and it's about this Banker who's about to commit suicide until people point out all of the good he's done in the community and all the people he's helped uh by understanding people's needs and providing them um in a in a timely and uh sustainable fashion so um when we've seen Innovations and product design pricing Delivery Systems and institutional models it is really the tool to try to extend formal Financial Services to a much wider market so that's really what Financial inclusion is and and some of the reasons that it's exciting where you see a lot
of the Innovation why should we care that was the second part of the question that I was supposed to address and quite simply we're trying to provide those with the greatest potential to benefit from economic growth with the financial tools they need to realize these benefits that's all we're trying to do and we're trying to address the Paradox we see around the world where you have rapid economic growth with rapidly growing inequality at the same time so nations are getting richer but the income gap and the wealth Gap is growing within the Nations and that
really starts with inequality of opportunity and if people have access to the tools they need to take advantage of these economic opportunities and rapidly growing economies then you've created a much more sustainable model politically and socially for development in the future so this is why we should care and because it is so important to the type of development model you want in your country I don't think that Financial inclusion should be an add-on it should be an extra thing you do on the side it should really be mainstreamed as a central part of your development
strategy so when you look at financial sector development as as one of the tools you need for overall Economic Development you want to make sure that the financial sector is inclusive of all segments of society so I believe I've addressed the two main questions um what is financial inclusion why is it exciting and why we should care about it and I had told the sponsors that I'm not going to talk any more than that if anybody has any questions or com comments from the floor feel free um and if you are shy and don't wish
to speak that's that's all good thank you very much oh we have a question yes sir the incentive for banks money seriously a bank you're talking about commercial Banks for-profit Banks you have a responsibility to your shareholders to earn a good return and have a responsibility to your depositors to protect the deposits so the incentive should be to improve your bottom line so not philanthropy not Corporate social responsibility not good politics and press although that's fine it should be a new business center a new profit Center so let me give you an example um from
probably the largest and probably least known micro banking program in the world it's from Indonesia it's from a bank called Bri funr Indonesia full service Commercial Bank International offices Corporate Finance Finance retail banking everything that you would look like look for in a bank it used to be a State Bank it had an IPO about 40% of it was sold to the public and the most profitable Business Center in this bank is the micro banking unit um and it often cross subsidizes other parts of the bank so that being said I should warn you that
most commercial Banks that try to do this make a mess of it and they fail because they think that for example microloans are just small big loans so if I do exactly what I do for big loans but just uh make smaller loans they will lose money um they don't know how to assess the credit risk and they don't know how to price the instrument they don't know how to deliver the product so most commercial Banks if you're getting in it not for profits don't do it if you're getting in it to make money you're
going to make the right decisions in how you design the product how you price the product and how you deliver the product and there are some examples around the world of commercial Banks often setting up a subsidiary because you're going to hire a different profile of person um you're dealing with very different markets so it's often either in in um Bri it's a special strategic business unit could be a wholly owned subsidiary or it could be some kind of a even a partnership ship like the example from Haiti but I feel pretty strongly that if
a Commercial Bank is going to do this do it to make money that's why I said doing well and doing good at the same time excellent question yes ma'am isn't there an element of Education that goes along with this as well to educate people who have not had access to the financial services about the responsibilities that go along with that as well and I haven't could you comment on that that again excellent question um and there are two parts of it and you touched them both one is General financial literacy so understanding how these tools
might help you how these tools might be of benefit to you but the other part that you implied is also consumer protection knowing the true cost of borrowing knowing the responsibilities knowing the commitments that you're making so a gener and there's a there are a lot of efforts around the world in financial literacy less so on consumer protection and I think that's a missing element in a lot of this because um and we saw it in the US part of the reason that the financial sector collapsed in the US was subprime mortgages and they were
targeting basically the same demographics of lower income communities not really understanding the products they were getting into not understanding the costs and not understanding the um commitments so absolutely important if if and and there's a third there's a third part of that you didn't mention that I'll I'll say is that sometimes Bankers really underestimate how smart these customers or potential customers are and they try to educate them on things that they really shouldn't uh they certainly know the value of money they know the value of losses and profits if you ask them for a set
of accounts from their their business they won't have it if you force them to make it they'll make it up but they do know making money and they do know generally how so again this is when you're trying to do the your credit analysis that it's kind of a bridge between the two questions the risk are exactly the same as big loans the credit risk it's willingness and capacity to repay but for the small businesses how do you assess the credit risk how do you assess character when there's no credit report there's no scoring system
how do you assess capacity to repay when there are no Financial accounts or standard Financial accounts counts so again The Innovation is often a really simple reconstructed cash flow statement um because they can tell you in their own terms either weekly or daily or seasonally how much is coming in how much is going out so financial literacy and consumer protection very important but don't underestimate uh the knowledge and wisdom and character of this potential Market well thank you very much for your patience and for contributing to our dialogue I understand this is going to be
posted um in the not too distant future on YouTube so available to all so for your friends and colleagues who couldn't make it here tell them to check it out on YouTube thank you very much [Music]