welcome back how long has it been maybe you're just watching these and you're binge watching some law 101 maybe it's almost exam time i don't know but welcome back to law 101 from the barn before i begin i just want to apologize in advance that tonight i am being visited by a number of mosquitoes um and i've actually killed one during a lecture earlier this evening for a different class and i elected to keep that moment in the video because i didn't want to re-record the whole thing and i apologize in advance should that happen
again today we're going to be talking about the limits on the charter now we've already had some of this discussion last day last video but we're going to reiterate some of it and then dive into the real limitations on the charter so we're going to start with a review of the application of the charter and how it's interpreted both these are technical limits on how the charter is to be applied but then we're going to dive into the reasonable limits section which is section one and we're going to talk about this section what it does
and its importance and how it's been used and later on in the coming days we will see some more concrete examples so here i'm mostly going to give you a high level 30 000 foot view of what the oaks text is which is how we do the reasonable limits test so that way later on when we apply it you have a firm understanding of the idea that we can put into practice we will have some examples today but primarily we'll be talking about just the test in its form and i just saw a mosquito fly
across the screen i'm not sure if you did but they're getting a free education so i'm not sure how i feel about it and then we're going to talk about the notwithstanding clause and that's going to be the substance of today's lecture so first the application well we've already had this discussion but it's really important to reiterate that the application of the charter is limited to the state and this is explicitly in sections 32 1 and 32 2 of the charter it explicitly limits the charter's application to the government into legislatures into parliament and so
actors outside of the state aren't subject to the charter now there are some important ways that this actually can be influenced in a different way the charter is not without consequence for individuals because as i mentioned last time there are human rights legislative acts within provinces and those legislative provisions of protecting human rights are have a kind of a quasi-constitutional role they are they're highly regarded because because they technically uphold much of what the charter is um is protecting and and often in many cases more but if the those human rights laws are not charter
compliant then the human rights laws are inconsistent with the charter and therefore of no force in effect so the charter does have big implications because provincial laws have to comply with the charter which means provincial human rights protection laws have to comply with the charter which means provincial human rights legislation laws have to have the same sorts of protections for individual rights and freedoms that the charter contains and there's actually case law there's a case name vreen that we're not going to talk about in detail but reigned was the case where a man was fired
for being a homosexual and having a lifestyle that the college she worked at in alberta said was antithetical to their beliefs it was a christian uh college and they they determinated his employment based on his his sexuality and and he challenged that firing using alberta's human rights law now the human rights law at the time did not provide protection for discrimination based on one's sexual orientation so in effect mr green had no no real recourse he could not use alberta's human rights legislation to protect himself just didn't have that protection embedded within it and so
his argument was if this law doesn't protect me then this law is not consistent with the charter and it is not consistent with the charter obviously it can be of no force or effect we're going to talk about various ways of enforcing charter rights and one of the things that you can do sometimes is require or request that the court reads in a particular interpretation the outcome of read was the supreme court of canada said that well the alberta human rights law does not provide protection for mr vreen that law was unconstitutional in its failure
to provide protection and therefore it read into the law it assumed that it was supposed to be there to make sure that it was compliant with the charter and that means the charter had a huge impact on a provincial law that had implications for a termination of employment in a private enterprise so charter does extend beyond the state but only in so far as that in that instance of reigned the charter was saying that the state's protection of human rights this time the state being alberta must be consistent with the protection of florida by the
charter i think i've beaten this one enough now that you understand the concept but the application is the state we talked in lesson two about interpretation i'm not going to go over this again other than to say there are some limits first off there's the limits in who right it actually has has uh the ability to seek protection so everyone has the ability to seek protection for their their constitutional freedom of expression rights under section 2b but only individuals which are natural persons can seek protection for equality rights based on the language of the charter
but some of the other words in the charter provide limits in how we interpret them because they may not mean what we expect in the mean or they might mean more those are less of a hard limit but there they have implications for the application of the charter the real substance of what we're going to talk about today is the reasonable limits clause and somehow despite checking this slides screwed up now if you've ever been in another class with me this happens i move stuff around and i must step up so just ignore reasonable limits
on the screen but you can imagine something exciting is going to happen so section one of the charter reads as follows it says that it guarantees the rights and freedoms set out in it subject only to such reasonable limits prescribed by law as can be demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society this is an important starting point for the charter because what it says is this document with the things this document identifies we guarantee that they'll be protected except when we can identify reasonable limits limits that are required that are justified by living in
a free and democratic society and this provision of the of the charter is actually has been very very important for establishing all sorts of laws that actually violate what are otherwise protected rights and we're going to talk about some but it's also been used as a way to put forward laws that may challenge rights in ways that we have to actually then have a debate about and we're going to talk about that in the context of tobacco advertising very soon so i'm going to pretend that i'm going to be dramatic and it's going to knock
that mosquito out of the way section one allows for the state to actually put limits on freedoms provided that they're reasonably justified well how do you determine if they are reasonable limits how do you determine if they are demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society well to do that there is a case that uh uh was put forward a few years back called oaks now we're not going to talk about oaks in detail you have an excerpt but what oaks did oaks became the test for how we determine what's a reasonable limit law allows
to have tests we have all sorts of tests you're going to learn all sorts of tests this year that derive from cases how we actually figure out what's going on and sometimes we we change them sometimes we they get they get tossed aside for a new test but the oaks test has been stood the test of time for how we determine what it is a reasonable limit and essentially the oaks test in this case what it determined was the first thing that you do in any sort of claim about a rights violation is you have
to define the right to define the right and determine if it's actually been infringed to note there's been an infringement the state has somehow interfered with the right it's important to know what that right is you have to know the scope of that right and later on in this term when you talk about section 7 this has been partly what has evolved section 7. i mentioned that it went beyond legal rights in the criminal kind of environment to include medical decisions and so much more and part of that has been because of defining what the
right actually means so you have to identify what the right is determine what it is and we actually have a lot of case all that does this for us we're able to say it has been established etc and so therefore we can point to this is how it's been defined and move forward that definition can evolve and can be adapted of course over time and they are but we we have an understanding for the most part about what the rights mean we have to first define it and then you have to determine whether or not
the right has actually been infringed and this can look like a variety of different things but someone may make a claim that their rights have been infringed but actually they have not in any sort of substantial way so that's the first part of an oaks analysis the second part of an oaks analysis is if there's actually an infringement you have to determine if the infringement is justified this is what we call the oaks test we're going to see the steps of the oaks test in just a moment but it is a two-fold process what is
the right and is there an infringement of that right and if there is an infringement can it be justified and this is actually a very important step uh because if it is an infringement uh and it passes uh it doesn't pass the test it is unconstitutional or if it does pass the test it's constitutional i'll restate that just to make sure that makes sense i think i said it in the opposite order of my slide anyhow but if you have an oaks analysis and the oaks test you determine that the infringement is not justified i.e
the infringement is not a reasonable limit that means that infringement is unconstitutional because it's not a reasonable limit then it won't be in accordance with the constitution of the charter's principles and therefore section 52 right so will not be constitutional however if you can demonstrate that a limitation or an infringement on our right is reasonable right but there is a reasonable limitation that it passes the test then according to the charter that's permissible you're allowed to have reasonable limits and if you're allowed to have reasonable limits and this is one instance of that then it's
constitutional it's in accordance with the constitution and therefore the law is upheld and is in effect