hi guys it's me quinn and as always if you appreciate my content consider hitting the like button it's the only way the youtube algorithm really notices me i apologize for the format of this video i am on the move and i don't have everything i need with me i'm gonna be seeing dune in a couple days but i wanted to talk about something before i saw the movie because it's something that i think a lot of people still have questions about and don't really get and it's one of the main questions that i get um
about dune from people and it's the question of why doesn't dune have any type of computers or a.i or robots and the answer to that is multifaceted but ultimately i think pretty simple so you had asimov before frank herbert who came in and said i'm going to take science fiction but i'm going to expand it an entire galaxy i'm going to stretch it out through a cosmos and he asked himself how would one manage an empire that was comprised of thousands of planets stretched out across the vacuum of space and the answer was not very
well but to some degree the answer was also robots and artificial intelligence now when frank herbert came along a few decades later he did several things to distinguish himself from isaac asimov but one of the things he did was he said i'm not going to put any type of ai and robots in my series now ai and robots do exist in the dune universe but in the original frank herbert books they are part of the long past history there were once robots thinking machines as doom refers to them as but they went through this thing
called the butlerian jihad which was basically when mankind rebelled against the machine overlords who themselves were being controlled by other men so it's not necessarily the whole terminator idea where it's machines gain sentience and try to rebel against humanity it's more to do with the men in power of those machines using those machines to control the rest of humanity which is something that i think is shockingly relevant for our society right now and the other aspect of it that i think is super relevant was that humankind was using machines as a crutch because we had
machines it was kind of just stifling our own development so after the machines went away human kinds had to find other ways to hone their skills and different schools popped up like the mentat school who are human computers and the benny jesuit sisterhood or these women that train themselves and hone their abilities to the point where they're almost superhuman there's the spacing guild whose mutated navigators took the place of the computers that were once used to navigate throughout the vacuum of space so essentially frank herbert is focusing on the potential evolution of humanity rather than
muddying things up with machines now of course brian herbert frank herbert's son and kevin j anderson who continue with the books in the expanded dune series have a totally different philosophy and they actually went back and filled in some of that history and the machine crusade trilogy and they also continue the machine thing in the later books which were meant to finish off the original franker six books which were never completed but that still doesn't change the fact that the philosophy of those original six books is that we're going to focus on humans and the
human struggle rather than having it be something that's not human that's doing it to us because really humanity is usually its own biggest enemy right so we see that also play out in the later two frank herbert books with the returning of the people from the scattering uh essentially people that have left the empire thousands of years ago come back to the old empire to basically cannibalize the old empire and it's always humanity feeding upon itself so i think that there's an argument to be made that sometimes when you introduce this non-human element and say
this is the cause of everything it kind of cheapens the whole thing because you're relieving humanity itself of responsibility so to break things down again as simply as possible there's no robots or ai in the original six dune books because one it's a human story two humanity used computers and robots and stuff like that as a crutch and three frank herbert wanted to distinguish himself from writers that came before him like asimov and others by not using computers or robots and it's also true that because frank herbert decided to go this route there's so many
interesting things narratively speaking that arise like you have the telexu who have this emphasis on biological technology and all sorts of absurd and grotesque things arise out of that so i hope that clears things up because like i said that's one of the number one questions that i get on this channel and also i just wanted to say thanks everyone for liking and subscribing it's been really exciting to see all the new people interested in dune since the movie is about to come out in the united states and china it's been really awesome to see
some of my videos being shared on websites like av club and boing boing and i'm just super anxious and excited to see the movie just two days away from me and then i can feast my eyes upon dune thanks so much for watching guys peace out [Music] [Music] you