[Music] hi and welcome back to Shameless potpourri I'm Joe heschmeyer of Catholic answers and I want to explore a popular question about whether or not Mary was a virgin after the birth of Jesus that you know Catholics and most Protestants agree Mary was a virgin at the time of the Annunciation she was a virgin at the time of Jesus's birth but there's this Question was she a virgin after and in fact a lot of Protestants saying Catholics are just kind of making this up that it's some kind of extra biblical idea that Mary remained perpetually
a virgin and maybe you're unaware that this is a view not only of Catholics but of Orthodox and uh overwhelmingly of the early Christians as well and so I want to explore kind of why that is and what this reveals about the Divergent ways in Which we read the Bible because I think that's what this really reveals because this is one of those doctrines where if you take the simplistic surface level reading of scripture you're going to get one answer and if you read it in a deeper and more ponderous way you get a different
one and that's not the only issue like this you know for instance in John 14 Jesus says the father is greater than I great and so if you deny the Trinity this is the verse you go to Right you just say ah Jesus says the father is greater than I how hard is that to understand and you take a really surface level understanding of it if you want the right answer of what this means you have to dig in and really say what is meant by this and what assumptions am I bringing to the table
where I'm assuming Jesus means one thing and maybe he means something different so that's what I mean that this isn't just a question about Mary's Perpetual Virginity as important as that is but as we'll see it points to how we have kind of a broken understanding of sex but also of marriage and of holiness that's what I hope to kind of show and so instead of taking that surface level reading I would suggest we should read scripture in a Marian sort of way what do I mean by that in the Gospel of Luke in Luke
2 verse 19 St Luke says that Mary kept all these Things pondering them in her heart that is she Witnesses these events but then she chews on him she thinks about them she Ponders him and it's in that way that we're actually encouraged to approach the mysteries of the New Testament not just to take the surface level reading but to actually go deeper if you read the New Testament you'll see over and over and over again the people who interpret Jesus at that surface level misunderstand him they get him Wrong and I want to suggest
that's exactly what's going on here now another place I think is worth going is as I've mentioned the early Christians so in the 300s a guy by the name of helvidius argued that Mary and Joseph continued to have children the standard Protestant position in Saint Jerome uh replies to him in a work called against elvidius or someone's called the Perpetual virginity of Mary and the introduction is really Biting it's really sharp he says I was requested by certain of the Brethren not long ago to reply to a pamphlet written by one helvidius I've deferred from
doing so not because it is a difficult matter to maintain the truth and refute an ignorant boar who has scarcely known the first glimmer of learning but because I was afraid my reply might make him appear worth defeating now this is sharp Jerome is not known For pulling punches but it should give any Protestants who believe that Mary was not a Perpetual virgin a little bit of pause here's why Jerome lived in Bethlehem he was fluent in Greek in Hebrew and in Latin he's the chief translator of the Latin Vulgate he knew Judaism better than
almost any Gentile Christian of the early like of antiquity and so he takes it as so glaringly obvious that Mary was perpetually a virgin That he finds it laughable that anyone would take a different View and clearly he's not alone in this right the other Christians of his day are so scandalized by helvidius writing a pamphlet that they write to Jerome asking him to reply that this is not the standard you know the Protestant view is not the standard view at all and it's not the standard view among ordinary Christians it's not the standard view
among Scholars of the day Who understand the ancient languages and who are familiar with Jewish culture and so all of that should lead the modern reader to say is it possible that Jerome who lives in Bethlehem in the Tomb or excuse me in the cave where Jesus is born and then who knows Hebrew who knows Jewish sources is it maybe possible he knows something I don't about ancient Judaism about Perpetual virginity And I think we're going to say this exactly uh what the case is but to get there I want to First go through the
arguments for why Protestants don't typically believe in the Perpetual virginity of Mary and kind of answer those and then lay out the positive case I'm going to start with all of the reasons you might think Mary and Joseph have other children so this is the case against marriage Perpetual virginity and I'm going off of The arguments I've heard in the arguments I've heard recently there may be other ones out there but I've done my best to try to capture the popular arguments and the best arguments the first is at Matthew 1 in the dream of
Saint Joseph the angel says Joseph son of David do not fear to take Mary your wife for that which is in her is conceived excuse me that which is conceived in hers of the Holy Spirit and so the idea Is that well take is a euphemism for sex and the answer to that is just it's not uh that is a misunderstanding of the passage that taking is actually uh about the nissuin which is the second stage of a Jewish marriage so if you don't know what that means well good that's what the second half of
this podcast is all about that the taking going on here is a specific idea we have to understand on Jewish terms and not apply our own uh kind of understanding of those words So that's simple enough but then after that in verse 24 Joseph gets up from the dream and we're told he did as the angel of the Lord commanded him he took his wife but knew her not Intel should born a son now taking his life is not a sexual euphemism knowing his wife is a sexual euphemism that you know Adam knew Eve and
she gave birth to Cain in Genesis 4 right like it's that that knowing that carnal knowledge this is about sex so That should immediately tell us okay well taking and knowing are clearly something different to Matthew so what does he mean by taking again we'll get back to that but then he knew her not Intel she'd born a son okay that seems simple enough right until means until the father is greater than I what could be easier than that right well again it doesn't really work that way because Intel both in English and in Greek
can mean up to a certain point but not after Intel but not after right or it could just mean to this point I'll give you an example if I say I tried to go to that party but the music was blaring from the time I get got there until the time I left I'm not suggesting that they started the music when I got there or turned it off when I left the from an Intel there are Referring to a specific point relative for the narrative they're they're not actually saying the condition stopped holding after the
Intel or to take a Biblical example in First Corinthians we're told that Jesus must Reign until he has put all his enemies under his feet does that mean Jesus doesn't Reign after his enemies are put under his feet no Intel doesn't mean that so assuming that Intel always means only Until this point and then not after is applying a connotation of Intel that it doesn't necessarily hold here it can mean that but contextually it often doesn't if you tell your kids be good until I get back you're not telling them I want you to misbehave
when I return it just doesn't mean that and the same is true in Greek and so we should be asking well what is Saint Matthew saying then why does he say until the births if he's not trying To say Mary and Joseph had sex on Christmas or that they had sex sometimes after Jesus was born why would he specify that they didn't have sex From This Moment until Jesus was born well it turns out Matthew actually tells us what he's saying so in Matthew 24 to 25. as I as we said he knew her not
until she had borne a son well right before that in verses 22 and 23 he Explains this took place to fulfill what the Lord has spoken by the prophet this is the prophecy from Isaiah behold the Virgin shall conceive and bear a son and his name Shall be Called Emmanuel now we often think of that just as one thing that the Virgin Mary will get pregnant and have a baby but those are two different moments nine months apart you know if you've got Christmas you got Nine months before Christmas that Mary has to be a
virgin both at the moment of the Annunciation and the moment of Christmas for this prophecy to be filled there's two prongs to it a virgin conception and a virgin birth if Mary's a virgin when she conceives Jesus but then goes on to have sex with Joseph sometime between then and Christmas the prophecy would not be fulfilled and so Matthew is not trying to tell us Anything at all about the sex life of Mary and Joseph one way or the other he's not trying to prove Mary's Perpetual virginity he's not trying to deny Mary's Perpetual virginity
in context the Intel here is very clearly tied to the preceding verse that this is about Kim sieve and Bear from the moment of Mary's conception of Jesus in her womb until the moment of Jesus's birth marries a virgin that's all he's trying to say that tells us Nothing about what happens after so the Intel argument is just ripping a verse out of context reading it in a superficial way and demanding that Intel means something it doesn't necessarily mean again either in Greek or in English it's another version of doing the father is greater than
I you got the surface rating but you've ripped it completely out of context you have no understanding of the Biblical context of the theological meaning Okay so so far the Intel argument doesn't really you know it doesn't doesn't prove the opposite it doesn't improve the Protestants are wrong it just doesn't actually mean the thing they're trying to make it mean Matthew to read this as Matthew arguing that Mary and Jesus excuse me Mary and Joseph have children after Jesus's birth is trying to read him as saying something he very clearly is not trying to say
in the context of the passage But there does seem to be positive evidence that point to other kids right the brothers or Brethren of Jesus so for instance in Mark 3 we're told that Jesus's mother and his Brethren came and the crowd says your mother and your brother are outside asking for you great clear enough mark 6. the crowd say is not this the carpenter the son of Mary and brother of James and Joseph and Judah and Simon and are not his sisters here with us so it sounds like Jesus has a ton of siblings
at least four brothers who knows how many sisters that's a lot of siblings that Mary and Joseph go on to have particularly since Joseph appears to be dead by the time Jesus reaches adulthood it's it's remarkable in fact we find Jesus Mary and Joseph with no mention of siblings going up to the temple when Jesus is 12 when he's 30 Joseph is dead but sometime that 18-year Gap apparently Mary and Joseph had a ton of kids right and it's great because we even know their names James and Joseph and Judah and Simon and what's the
problem with this well again we're reading this through Modern 21st century English-speaking ears and not reading it through Jewish years or Jewish eyes I think I guess with reading In Genesis 14 I'm using the kg because it's actually clearer Abraham and lot are described as uncle and nephew and his brothers so in verse 12 it says they took lot Abraham's brother's son who dwelt in Sodom and then two verses later when Abram heard that his brother was taken captive and people say oh look at that biblical contradiction islot his nephew or his brother well it's
his brother Actually it's his nephew but his baseball other means here that brother means a whole range of relations in fact the reason I'm using the KJV here is that many modern Bibles will translate that second use of brother just as Kinsmen which is a little bit shady I think because the word is just brother but it means Kinsmen here it could just mean any kind of close relative so just as like your your great great great Great grandfather is just your father you know Father Abraham is used all over they don't literally mean he
is one generation removed from them so likewise your cousin your uncle your nephew those are all your brother there's a very limited familial vocabulary in Hebrew in ancient Hebrew and so if you don't want to say constantly your brother's son you can just say brother and contextually we get what you mean Or Kinsmen it it means the same thing here so hopefully that's clear that we're not saying every time brother comes up that is literally a biological brother now that doesn't mean that it's not but uh it should give us some pause so Jesus's brothers
go back to mark 6. remember the brothers names James and Joseph and Judas and Simon well in Mark 15 when Mark is describing the Crucifixion he tells us there were some women who were looking on from afar among whom were Mary Magdalene and Mary the mother of James the younger and of Joseph's hold on a second James and Joseph have a different mom the other Mary who in the parallel account in John's gospel is listed as Mary the wife of clopas so this should give us some pause First of all whether you're Protestant or Catholic
you don't think brother means brother here literally right like you don't think these are the full Brothers of Jesus you either think they're his half-brothers or his Step Brothers or his cousins but nobody unless they deny the virginity of Mary unless they deny that Jesus is like virgin born nobody believes that James and Joseph are full Brothers of Jesus So the only question is what more complicated relationship is being referred to here as brother could be cousin could be half brother could be Stepbrother well we're given the clue in Mark 15 that James and Joseph
at least have a different Mom Mary and then we're given the clue in John 19 that this other Mary is the wife of clopus now So far the biblical evidence eusebius in the fourth Century has one of the earliest Church histories it's just called church history and he quotes an earlier Source hagasipus who is mostly lost to us today but he's from the second century in hagasipus records that clopus was a brother of Joseph so this is in the context of the church in Jerusalem and eusebius says that the church in Jerusalem with one Consent
pronounced Simeon the son of clopus of whom the gospel also makes mention to be worthy of the Episcopal throne that they chose Simeon or Simon one of these other brothers of Jesus who's the son of clopus and Mary uh as one of the Bishops of Jerusalem he was a cousin as they say of the Savior for hagasipus records that Globus was a brother of Joseph so you don't have to take that part that Part's not inspired scripture but it certainly makes sense of the evidence that if their cousins just like Abraham and lot uncle nephew
they're called Brothers well James Joseph Simon all these girls whoever else these are all cousins it also makes sense of why there's so many of them when we don't see anybody in Jesus's infancy we don't see anybody with Jesus as a sibling going up to the temple in Jerusalem So that's the brother's argument it could mean that he has biological Brothers but it doesn't actually mean that it doesn't require that meaning the next one is a prophetic argument in Psalm 69 verse 8 says I've become a stranger to my brethren an alien to my mother's
sons and so the argument says aha see it's a clever argument because it says okay sure Brethren doesn't have to mean that they're your mother's children but in Psalm 69 verse 8 he Clearly says my mother's sons the problem here is that you're using a prophetic Messianic solemn and just take it extremely literally and here's why that doesn't work because in verse 5 of the same song it says oh God thou knowest my Folly the wrongs I have done are not hidden from thee so if you're going to just say all of this applies literally
to Jesus you're going to have to also say Jesus Literally sinned and that doesn't work so the mother here could easily be Jerusalem could be Israel it could just be the psalmist not every part of a prophetic Psalm literally applies to Jesus so this is just a bad use of prophetic kind of argumentation this is I'd say not a valid argument from the Old Testament okay that just kind of wrapping this up there's three other arguments I've sometimes heard uh the first you know There's nothing wrong with marital sex well sure nobody said there was
right like we believe marriage is a Sacrament and this Sacrament is consummated through sex so this is an example of what CS Lewis calls bulverism in Lewis's words you must show that a man is wrong before you start explaining why he's wrong like you can't just say aha well you just think that because you're hung up about sex it's like no no we think that because scripture actually points In a different direction than your assumption the second kind of remaining argument well if they didn't have sex it wasn't a real marriage well this is false
uh once we get into the Jewish context we'll see that consummation in the sense that we think of it in the West in the Christian context is not uh the way it worked for Jewish weddings consummation for a Jewish wedding was actually coming together of houses And and so the the nissuin the carrying of the woman you bring her under your roof that's what consummated the marriage uh you could actually have sex before that as we're gonna see so marital consummation doesn't work the same way in ancient Judaism as it does in modern Christianity and
so that argument doesn't work it also isn't really true you still have a real marriage even prior to consummation but we're not going to get into all of the Ratification versus consummation bit like when the priest says your man and wife you really are men and wife even though the marriage hasn't been consummated and then the final argument is it would be cruel for Joseph to get married to Mary only to find out afterwards that he couldn't have sex with her that Joseph has been you know there's a baton switch here and I that argument
grosses me out to be Honest because I think it's an unhealthy attitude you know if if you get married and then your wife is paralyzed or sick or has some medical condition where you can't have sex regularly do you feel like deprived by God do you feel like God's done you in Injustice I it just seems like a really unhealthy attitude towards women towards marriage towards sex that you're not just entitled to Sex On Demand even when You're married it just doesn't doesn't work that way uh but additionally as we're gonna see this assumes that
Joseph didn't know Mary was going to perpetually be a virgin which is not I think a good assumption okay so far I've only handled objections and you might say this is not a very persuasive case well so far it isn't meant to be I'm just saying the arguments against don't persuasively prove the contrary So let's look at the arguments for what are the arguments in favor of Mary being perpetually a virgin and to get there I think we got to do a couple things the first is we have to unpack a Biblical view of marriage
and by this I just mean what did marriage look like in the first century in a Jewish context because it doesn't really look like what it looks like today it doesn't even look like what it looks like today in a Jewish context much less A Christian one and a way of exploring this question would be to ask the question was Mary an unwed mother and a lot of people will say yeah of course she was doesn't it say that explicitly in the Bible you know she doesn't have a husband and she gets pregnant well what's
the problem with that well Jesus in the temple that's the problem we're going to get back to a different Dimension of Jesus in the temple but for now just notice that in Deuteronomy 23 no bastard shall enter the Assembly of the Lord even through the 10th Generation none of his descendants shall enter the Assembly of the Lord in other words if you are conceived out of wedlock you were not allowed in the Temple and so the people saying Mary's an unwed mother are saying Jesus is a bastard and if you say Jesus is a bastard
then He's not allowed in the temple and certainly Jesus's opponents would have loved a chance to throw that at him if Jesus wasn't allowed in the temple you don't think the Pharisees would have brought that up you don't think the Sadducees would have mentioned that but in fact Matthew 26 when Jesus is being arrested in verse 55 he points out you've come out it's against a robber with clubs and swords to capture me day after day I sat in the temple teaching And you did not seize me so Jesus is in the temple all the
time which isn't possible if he was born out of wedlock or conceived out of wedlock doesn't work like that so that should make us say how are we misunderstanding Jewish weddings because clearly our reading of Luke 1 and Matthew 1 would say Jesus is conceived out of wedlock but their reading was that he wasn't and that's very much even people who Don't know about the Virgin conception even people who don't realize Jesus is miraculously conceived to assume that Joseph is his father still think Jesus is legitimately born that it's not just Jesus's followers who say
hey it's not really sinful because it was miraculous no there is no hint of there being any sin around this if all of the charges being raised against Jesus nobody is arguing that Joseph and Mary sinned by having a Baby have you noticed this this is a really significant detail Joseph resolves to divorce Mary quietly and the two alarm bells that should be going off in our head is one why is he talking about divorcing a woman who we thought he wasn't even married to and two how would divorcing her quietly avoid putting her to
shame you know in a modern context if you're dating somebody you get engaged you get pregnant and he leaves you you have not been preserved From shame because it's sinful to have sex during the engagement period well as we're gonna see we're mistaken when we think that Mary and Joseph are engaged in the modern sense of that and that it was perfectly fine for them to be having a sexual relationship except that they weren't but I'm getting ahead of myself so let's step back A Jewish wedding consists of two stages was called the kidushin and
the nissuin now these are part of one ceremony now but they used to be two separate ceremonies until the 11th century and the the major change is that you now have like a place you live as an unmarried man that isn't just your dad's house in other words like Bachelor pads and things exist now you can live with Roommates but this wasn't really a reality in antiquity so uh Rabbi Aiden steinsalt says a Jewish wedding is made up of two parts kadushan this is often called the betrothal it's not a great word for it but
there's not really a better word for it like if you're going to translate it betrothal is as close as we're gonna get but it's very different than our Western concept of a betrothal but the condition or betrothal and nissuin marriage Although it is called betrothal kadustrian is not just a commitment to Mary it is an actual marriage so you see why calling it betrothal in the marriage are really misleading because the first one is actually the marriage for example if the couple chooses not to complete the marriage with nissuin they will need a formal get
a divorce in the time of the mishnah these two parts normally took place about a year apart in order to give the bride and Groom time to prepare for the wedding and for their marriage but today they are done one after the other at the wedding ceremony now I just add to this a couple things one as we see the rabbi's description of the two stages is absolutely supported by the biblical evidence in Matthew 1 verse 18 to 19 it says now the birth of Jesus Christ took place in this way when his mother married
been betrothed to Joseph before they came Together okay so this betrothal that is coming together there's two stages here she was found to be with child of the Holy Spirit and her husband Joseph being a just man and unwilling to put her to shame resolved to send her away quietly so there's two stages what he's going the betrothal and the coming together and at the betrothal Joseph is already her husband and he needs a divorce to get out of the marriage that's uh Sending her away so uh just to kind of explain why this is
I I alluded to this before in the ancient world you're a young man you see a beautiful young woman you decide we're going to get married so you get married but you live with your dad she can't just come live in your house so you need to go and prepare a place for her to live and so if her dad is dead uh you have three months to do that if her dad's alive you have a year now There's other things that as you can imagine with Jewish law it gets complicated but that's the basic
idea you have a certain amount of time where you can go and prepare a home for her this is really beautifully described in the New Testament in a way that we don't notice Jesus at the Last Supper in John 14. says in my father's house are many rooms if it were not so would I have told you I'd go to prepare a place for you and When I go and prepare a place for you I will come again and will take you to myself that where I am you may be also that is gorgeous what
he's saying is church you are my bride the kadushan is complete what remains to be done is for the bridegroom to go get the house ready for his wife and then he brings her into the house they come together she enters the house She then is under his authority as we'll see and that completes the second stage of the wedding and so uh in the Jewish talmud and ketchup at 48 it says even after she's betrothed that is even after the kadushan a daughter is always under her father's Authority until she enters her husband's Authority
in marriage via the wedding canopy so the second stage of the wedding was about the transferring From being under the headship of your father to being under the headship of your husband it was not about consummating the marriage sexually it's about coming to live together and the spiritual significance of whose headship you're under as a woman Michael satwell who is a Jewish scholar talks about how during this first stage the caduce you Could have sex and uh there's a move away from this so when you're when you're reading about this it depends what era you're
kind of looking at because the rabbis hate this fact they want to preserve sex until the second stage but in Antiquity sex was widespread in the first stage and so he says rabbinic sources indicate that at least among some Jewish communities the perhaps lengthy period of betrothal was accompanied by Decreasing expectations of Chastity now I'm going to quibble with that tiny bit but he then quotes a Babylonian source that says in Judea he would be together with her during the patrol and then he says even Palestinian sources Jewish couples betrothed in Judea had a reputation
for having sexual relations before the marriage itself now I would again I would quibble with this because this suggests that they're Basically getting away with something you know having sex during the engagement and that's just not what's going on here the reason it's not scandalous for them to be having sex is because they're legally married during the condition they're just not living together in the same house and we know this from Jewish sources so there's an entire part of the talmud that's all about how the condition works and it says a woman is acquired by
I.E becomes Betrothed to a man to be his wife in three ways and it elaborates through money through a document and through sexual intercourse that you can contract the condition either by paying a dowry by signing a contract or just by having sex with each other this is why Saint Paul warns you not to have sex with prostitutes because if you and an unmarried prostitute have sex in the eyes of Jewish law you just got Married assuming you're both unmarried right and this is how it worked sometimes so for instance in Genesis 24 when Isaac
and Rebecca meet each other Isaac just brings her into the tent and they have sex and she becomes his wife it's that easy so there's no Scandal attaches like there's no even a hint or a whiff of Scandal with this they're not fornicating they're not committing adultery they're Contracting marriage Through sex now that is strange from a western perspective like that is not how we think of the relationship of sex and marriage and you know obviously this is a private way of Contracting marriage and so the rabbis prefer it to be done publicly through Dowry
or through a contract and so they push against this third way of Contracting the contusion but the fact is you could have sex and now you were legally betrayed then you'd Go back home to your parents houses like you don't live together yet because now the clock starts tipping he can he can go and prepare a house for you and bring you into his home that's how it works so why do I go to this length explaining this Jewish context because when the angel Gabriel appears to the Virgin Mary Mary and Joseph have already completed
the caduce they are legally married They may freely have sex without a whiff of Scandal they also live in Judea this is widespread this is normal and yet they aren't having sex in Luke 1 verse 34 the rsvce which is a version I usually like has a terrible translation Mary says to the angel Gabriel how can this be since I have no husband well we just saw from Matthew 1 she does have a husband right her husband Joseph that's what it says but turns out that's Not what it actually says this is a euphemistic translation
the KJV is a lot better here she says how shall this be seen I know not a man in other words she's not saying she's not married she's saying she's not sexually active so how is she gonna have a baby now that is a weird question for a married woman to ask you tell a married woman you're going to have beautiful children and she says how I'm not having sex with any man That should set off alarm Bells something weird is going on in this marriage the other thing that's weird going on in the marriage
is we're told Matthew 1 we've already seen this chapter this passage but let's look at it with new eyes that after Joseph is told to take Mary's wife that is to complete the nissuene he took his wife but knew her not until she had borne a son now we focus all This attention on the Intel but nobody's saying why in the world are Mary and Joseph not having sex the angel Gabriel didn't tell them to are they just trying to make sure Isaiah 7 gets fulfilled they're like by their own human power trying to work
the Fulfillment of this prophecy for God's sake what's going on here like why are they not having sex because Gabriel didn't tell them not to have sex Mary acts like she's not gonna have sex and they continue for nine more months at least not having sex what is going on so this should be setting off alarm about something weird is going on here well let me add to this and in the Dead Sea Scrolls we find the provisions laid out for what to do with a a young girl or a young woman makes a Perpetual
virginity pledge in the temple winds it binding under what conditions those those kind of questions and so the idea The early Christian said that Mary had taken some kind of Promise some kind of valve for virtual virginity it makes sense in light of the Jewish understanding of marriage and makes sense in light of the Jewish understanding of Perpetual virginity vows that's true then what Joseph and Mary are expecting out of marriage is not a sexual relationship they're expecting something like companionship That women in the ancient world were really vulnerable think about the care Jesus shows
to the Widow of nane when her son dies why because she's a widow and so she's very vulnerable as a woman in this world and so when her only son dies she's much more vulnerable well likewise if Mary's taking a valid Perpetual virginity it's not unreasonable that Joseph would be an important Aid in an ally for her in navigating a world that was often pretty Harsh especially to women so it makes sense in other words in light of the Jewish context but if we don't have that context the whole thing is just mystifying to us
okay so let's jump from Jesus's conception and birth to his death in John 19 we already saw a part of this passage that by the cross of Jesus or his mother his mother's Sister Mary the wife of clopus I didn't Even mention this detail if Mary is the wife of clopis uh this is the Virgin Mary sister-in-law remember clopis and Joseph are married to each other so it makes sense why his mother's sister would also be named Mary it'd be very strange if you had like a George Foreman situation where Mary's parents are just naming
all of their daughters Mary but if you take sister like brother to be a much more fluid term that you use it for A variety of relationships then sister-in-law you can freely call her Mary's sister Mary so his mother's Sister Mary the wife of clopus and Mary Magdalene when Jesus saw his mother and the disciple whom he loves standing near he said to his mother woman behold your son then he said to the disciple behold your mother and from that hour the disciple took her to his own home now this is remarkable This is I
think the if you've got to look at one Passage to quickly understand why the Perpetual virginity of Mary is true and why it's silly to think Mary Had other children this one this is where to go because Jesus just entrusted his mother to a non-relative the Apostle John and it just doesn't make sense that he would have done that otherwise in the Ten Commandments honor your father and mother we often think about That now as like children listen to your parents that's not what it means the Ten Commandments aren't written primarily for kids I mean
it means that as well but that's not all it means that it's about taking care of your age and parents and so here's Mary like the Widow of nain who's got no husband anymore whose son is dying And so Jesus is seeing to her care that makes sense if Jesus is her only son but if she has other children it is Unthinkable in either a Jewish or a Christian context that you would entrust Mary to John you would entrust Mary instead to any of the other brothers you wouldn't even need to entrust Mary because they
would step up to the plate and do that if they're even halfway decent And so what usually gets said in response to this Protestants will say well maybe these brothers were not Believers it doesn't matter first of all the Ten Commandments for binding on Jews and Christians alike they had a moral duty in fact First Timothy chapter 5 verse 8 says anyone who doesn't provide for his relatives and especially for his own family has disowned the faith and is worse than an unbeliever that's the Christian kind of stakes that's how seriously we take this and
you'll find similar kind of admonitions in the talmud that as a Jew or as a Christian you have a strong moral duty to take care of your aging parents but this also doesn't make sense because these same Protestants will say that James the Lord's brother is literally the son of Mary and we know he's one of the faithful Christians because in Galatians 1 19 Saint Paul says I saw None of the other Apostles except James the Lord's brother so we're supposed to believe that among the apostles are biological descendants of Mary now sure maybe they
don't show up on Good Friday only John does but they get punished for that for Life by having their mother taken away from them does that make even an ounce of sense that even after this when James is allegedly biological brother of Jesus is An upstanding member of the early Church in Jerusalem he doesn't get his mom back ever again this is such a bad reading of scripture you see what I mean like when you actually try to put these pieces together and say James and Joseph Jesus's brother have a different mom and dad but
we're still going to say they're his brothers and by the way Mary's just been entrusted to John who isn't one of these Brothers James or Joseph or Simon or any of the sisters allegedly Jesus has a whole slew of family and just gave his mom to the permanent care to go live with a non-relative for the rest of her life does that make any sense and the answer is no it doesn't it doesn't work like it is such a bad argument to think that's what's going on here okay so the final thing having looked at
this Through The Eyes Of a Jewish rather than a modern American Vision of marriage we should also reclaim a Biblical vision of Holiness here's what I mean by that today when you think about holy what comes to mind for many people it is something like morally upright someone who does good things or you know they maybe even like holier than thou right like we use it in kind of a negative sense but it's all about just like goodness And that is a very incomplete understanding of Merit of Holiness excuse me because Holiness in the biblical
sense means so much more than that in something actually radically distinct from that whether we're talking about the Hebrew version the so the Hebrew word for Holiness the the definition first and foremost is a Partners Holiness sacredness separateness that is something being set apart for God that's Kadesh well likewise the Hebrew or excuse the Greek hagios uh means something set aside for God it means other it's something that is just set aside consecrated for God you know think back to like Moses and the burning bush where God says to Moses to remove his sandal because
this is Holy Ground it doesn't mean the ground is morally upstanding the ground hasn't done anything virtuous the ground is consecrated to God it's set aside for God and God alone and so to put your dirty sandals on this ground is offensive that's going to be a really important sense of Holiness we don't use very much today unfortunately that's really important for understanding how to make sense of this and I would say Catholics do use that you know like holy water when we talk about holy water we mean this set aside for divine use but
so often we talk about like holy People we think about you know saintliness we think about virtue but it we can lose that sense of being set aside for God so with that important understanding where do we see Holiness in that sense in the Bible well one place we see it is the Ark of the Covenant and so in second Samuel 6 there's an important passage for making sense of Mary it says David arose and went with all The people who were with him from bald Judah to bring up from there the Ark of God
which is called by the name of the Lord of hosts who sits enthroned on the cherubim so the arc was this sacred container so holy it could not be touched that housed the shekhana the glory of God the presence of God and they're in the Hill Country of Judah and David has just created the new capital in Jerusalem and so he wants to Bring the ark from the Hill Country of Judah into Jerusalem and so we're told he arose and went from the Hill Country of Judah to try to bring in the ark but he
doesn't do it the right way he doesn't do it the way God told him to do it he just has some guys trying to move the Ark on a cart with some oxen and they're going through the Hill Country of Judah and they get to the threshing flow of Nikon and The Oxen stumble the ark starts to fall off And a poor guy named uza who shouldn't be in the situation he's in reaches out puts his hand to the Ark of God takes hold of it and he's struck dead for touching something that Holy now
it's easy to say poor guy named news as I did but the truth is he should not be messing around on something this holy set aside for divine use it should not be on an ox cart uh led by some laymen that's not what they're supposed to do it's supposed to be carried by Priestly Procession and so he is struck dead David then replies how can the Ark of the Lord come to me and so while he's scheming the answer to that he stays in the Hill Country of Judah for three months he eventually is
able to bring the ark into Jerusalem and we're told that he danced before the Lord with all his might and he was girded with a linen effort that's a Priestly vestment Now I want you to compare that to Saint Luke's description of the visitation in Luke 1 verse 39 it says in those days Mary arose and went with haste to the Hill Country to a city of Judah okay so the verbiage is the same she arels and went the location's the same she's going to the Hill Country of Judah she goes into the house of
Zechariah greets Elizabeth when Elizabeth hears the greeting of Mary The Babe leaped in her womb so just as David danced before the Ark John the Baptist who is of the Priestly line he's the son of a priest Zechariah so the linen effort is a symbol of priesthood John the Baptist son of a priest is dancing in the womb of Elizabeth and Elizabeth filled the Holy Spirit Cries Out blessed are you among women and blessed is the fruit of your womb and so just as David had said how can the Ark of the Lord come to
me Elizabeth now says and why is this granted me that The mother of my Lord should come to me it's a beautiful parallel and then goes on for behold when the voice of your greeting came to my ears The Babe in my womb leaped for joy then jump down to verse 56 and lo and behold Mary stays there three months before she returns home so you've got all of these very obvious parallels she Rose and went she goes into the Hill Country of Judah she has this very similar greeting Between Elizabeth and David where David
says Ark of the Lord Elizabeth says mother of my Lord the dancing of John the Baptist before the ark Mary just like the dancing before the original Arc David doing the linen effort John Bean of the Priestly line like all of these parallels and they stay for three months and then they go back to the area of Jerusalem these are not coincidental right like this is not just like a huh that's a Weird coincidence no Luke expects you to be able to read this with a Jewish understanding of Holiness and knowledge of the Old Testament
neither of which I think many Christians have and to know he's depicting Mary as the new Ark of the Covenant or if you prefer the Ark of the New Covenant that the Ark of the Covenant which is the Heavenly Manna the bread come down from heaven which Jesus says he is the law which Jesus fulfills Perfectly the staff of Aaron the the symbol of priesthood Jesus is our great high priest that's what's inside the ark and so the arc is this sacred totally holy vessel so holy that it cannot be touched in Mary John was
excuse me Luke wants you to know is the Fulfillment of that and the passage that he is comparing Mary to is one where you see with the story of uza she's so holy she cannot be touched that's the understanding of Holiness we Should have there that's the Holiness of the Ark I want to talk now about the Holiness of the temple and of the Temple Gate so in the last nine chapters of the Prophet Ezekiel there's this lengthy description of the new Temple and this is at the time when the first temple has been destroyed
and the second temple hasn't been built yet but it's not a blueprint for the second temple and in fact when the second temple is built it Doesn't match the things that the uh prophecies in Ezekiel said because there are these frankly Supernatural descriptions you know there's streams of water that are flowing from the side of the temple that they're living water meaning it's fresh water and it's turning salt water Fresh So streams of Living Water that can take a dead thing and make it alive the designers of the second temple were never going to be
able to do that And that's not what the prophecies in Ezekiel are really about in John 2 Jesus says destroy this Temple and in three days I'll raise it up and John tells us in John 2 verse 21 that he spoke of the Temple of his body this is an important theme uh particularly in the Gospel of John that Jesus is the Fulfillment of the Ezekiel prophecies so a bit later on in John 7 he says if anyone thirsts let him come to me and drink he who believes in me as The scripture is said
out of his heart shall flow rivers of Living Water Well the Old Testament doesn't stay out of his heart she'll flow rivers of Living Water Jesus is applying the temple prophecy to the transformation of the heart that Jesus who from whose side will flow blood and water on the cross those are the streams of Living Water that's transforming through the blood and the water through baptism through the Eucharist this is a transformation that's what he's talking about he's saying what looked like a prophecy about a building is actually the prophecy of the place of divine
dwelling first and foremost Jesus by extension all Christians in whom God is dwelling that's what ezekiel's really talking about why does this matter because in Ezekiel 44 around the temple is a gate and it shut And the angel says to Ezekiel this gate shall remain shut it shall not be open and no one shall enter by it for the Lord the god of Israel has entered by it therefore it shall remain shut that's a pretty clear description right and so the early Christians looked at this and said this is about the Virgin Mary so for
instance uh Rufus in his commentary in the Apostles Creed said the prophet Ezekiel 2 had predicted the Miraculous manner of that birth Colleen Mary figuratively the Gate of the Lord the gate namely through which the Lord entered the world free says the gate which looks toward the East shall be closed and shall not be opened and no one shall pass through it because the Lord God of Israel shall pass through it and it shall be closed he goes on what could be said with such evident reference to the inviolent preservation Of the Virgin condition that
is it sure means a virgin the Gate of virginity was closed through it the Lord God of Israel entered through it he came forth from the virgin's womb into this world and the Virgin State being preserved and violet the Gate of the Virgin remained closed forever therefore the Holy Ghost is spoken of as the creator of the Lord's flesh and of his Temple so that's the idea that this is not about you know early Christians Having some weird sexual hang up they realized look the East Gate of the Temple in the Ezekiel prophecy he's holy
God has gone through it personally and so no one else gets to touch it it's not that there's anything inherently wrong with going through Gates it's that you don't go through the gate God himself has gone through because that belongs to him forever likewise there's nothing wrong with sex or childbirth or anything like that Pregnancy is great the problem is you don't have sex with the mother of God she doesn't give birth to any other children no one goes through the gates except Jesus because Jesus has gone through that gate that's the idea so it's
not that there's again nothing wrong with sex nothing wrong with pregnancy nothing wrong with childbirth those are all very good Things are all praised right like Protestants don't think marriage is a Sacrament Catholics do it's weird to say both the Catholics are anti-sex and have way too many kids like if something doesn't match up in that critique but let's go on from there because a third area we should look is the holy tomb so Matthew 27 after Jesus dies Joseph Arimathea takes his body wraps it in a clean linen shroud and laid it we're Told
in his own new tomb which he had human in the Rock and the question we should be asking is why does it matter to Matthew that this is a new Tomb because John says the same thing he says that Jesus is placed in the garden in a new Tomb where no one had ever been laid why does that matter well because the tomb of Christ is Holy here's a place where God himself rests after death no one else is buried there it would be contrary to the Holiness of the Tomb To bury someone else in
the empty tomb of Jesus and likewise it would be contrary to the Holiness of Mary's womb to take this womb set aside for God and and have some other child just like it'd be contrary again it doesn't mean there's anything wrong with burial it just means this is consecrated to God what's so hard about like Holiness and this understanding and the final place we should look are The holy virgins and now this is going to be the most controversial one because this is going to make people think oh what about all these sexual Hang-Ups but
listen to the actual biblical evidence First Corinthians 7 Saint Paul says I want you to be free from anxieties the unmarried man is anxious about the Affairs of the Lord how to please the Lord but the married man is anxious about worldly Affairs how to please his wife And his interests are divided and then he says the same thing for women in other words the Virgin is able to be consecrated to God set aside for God in a way the married person practically isn't I cannot live radical poverty Chastity and obedience in the way a
monk can because it would be unfitting to my married state it would be an injustice to my wife if I said honey I sold the entire house I can Go live as a mendicant bring the kids we're gonna go knock on doors and try to get food that's holy for a monk it's not holy for me so the Holiness that is described here this being set aside for God this consecration that Paul is describing is a Holiness of virginity in the Book of Revelation Echoes this theme the 144 000 who've been redeemed from the earth
have a special song only they can sing and we're told it is these who have not Defiled themselves as women for they are chaste it is easy to follow the lamb wherever he goes these have been redeemed for mankind as first fruits for God and the lamb and in their mouth no lie was found for they are spotless this is a two-fold Holiness being depicted here a Holiness of Soul the spotlessness of the soul the soul is inhabited by God so no one else namely sin gets to dwell there and likewise a bodily Holiness a
bodily Consecration for God that their body is given over to God in such a way that it's incompatible with them than having sex in marriage again it doesn't mean that sex or marriage are evil it just means a thing given to God isn't for dual use so you know the example to to imagine and this is only going to work for those of you who have enough of a sense of Holiness for it to work is you would never hopefully use the Chalice from Mass for a tea party or for supper because it would be
radically contrary to the goodness and the Holiness of the thing that is the biblical understanding that there are some things that are holy that are set aside for God and that virginity is one way of doing that of living that out now obviously The Virginity uh signified bodily is only part of the story if you could be a virgin and still be a a horribly sinful person you haven't set your soul aside You've only set your body aside but the point is that to set aside body and soul for God is a rich offering to
the Lord and so that's the idea the reason that the early Christians cared both about Mary sinlessness and about her Perpetual virginity is because they wanted you to know she is set aside for God she is consecrated to God she's like the the East Gate of the temple she's like the Tomb she's like the holy virgin this as Saint Paul talks about but most of all we might say she's like the Ark of the New Covenant and the Ark of the New Covenant is uniquely and radically set aside to God in such a way that
that nobody else touches it it would be totally inappropriate to put even your Fine China in the Ark of the Covenant so likewise it'd be totally inappropriate To put a child in the womb in the Blessed Virgin Mary so hopefully that's clear that if you understand marriage properly and if you understand Holiness properly then you realize that the Protestant case against the Perpetual virginity of Mary just misunderstands both of those in a radical and profound kind of way that they don't get that there's something weird going on about Mary and Joseph's marriage they don't get
that marriage in The first century Judaism looks very little like 21st Century West and they don't get that the Holiness of Mary is signified and accomplished in her Perpetual virginity as well as in her sinlessness so I hope that makes sense I hope that helps um I know there was a lot of information today but I'm hoping that it lets you see these passages in a new light because this is one of those areas where it's very obvious today to so many People that Mary was not a Perpetual virgin but it was even more obvious
to the early Christians that she was and if we want to understand that disjuncture we have to uncover what we've lost in our understanding of the Bible for Shameless potpourri I'm Joe heshmeier thank you so much and God bless you [Music] find more great shows by visiting catholicanswerspodcast.com or search Catholic answers wherever you listen to podcasts [Music]