if you ever flicked on the news in last year you know I noticed that the talking hats were making just a bit of a big deal about the fact that Western tanks were finally being sent to Ukraine indeed one only had to go to the first page of that most venerable of websites Google to be met with headlines such as NATO Chief says Western tanks will make big difference on forces. net why tanks could be a game changer for Ukraine on NPR and Western tanks a vital part of recipe on Radio free Europe and given
that Ukraine has had them for a while now question naturally presents itself have they lived up to the hype well spoiler alerts they've certainly not hurt Ukraine's odds that much is beyond evidence but to call them a game changer might just be a bit of a stretch as we shall explain to you in the next 20 or so minutes so let's [Music] begin now before we get into the nitty-gritty analysis of today's video let's begin by getting something fundamental out of the way first that being what western tanks does Ukraine even have anyway first is
the leopard one a main battle tank developed by West Germany that ended service in 1965 designed to prioritize speed mobility and Firepower it features a mighty 105 mm British Roy ordinance L7 rifled gun Advanced Fire Control Systems and up to 70 mm of oldfashioned rolled homogeneous armor I.E normal armored steel as opposed to any kind of composite Arrangements which was only just beginning to be rolled out in some select tanks of Select militaries when the Leonard one debuted there is some debate over the choice to prioritize maneuverability and speed over armor with the leopard one
but generally speaking it is a very well regarded tank this is summed up best by historian Nicola banovitz quote its reputation holds it as one of the most effective main battle tanks in the world as for which variance Ukraine received as of the time of writing it is currently believed to have anywhere from up to 100 of them according to Militan the world's most popular UK ukine media Outlet covering the armed forces and the laian defense Academy up to maybe as many as 270 of them according to a swath of Articles of dubious citation note
for the leopard one specifically it is very difficult to say with any accuracy how many Ukraine actually has sure we know exactly how many of each type have been pledged by various governments specifically Germany Denmark and Norway but as for how many really turn up and in what kind of time frame we simply cannot say with laser Precision it's not as if the Ukrainian army ever releases a single pan Amic photo with the ball in frame it's exactly for this reason that we are giving you both the top and bottom estimates and we just want
to be totally up FR by saying that we don't know as for the specific variants they have received we know that they have the leopard 1 A5 an upgraded version of the standard model featuring a computerized Fire Control System and enhanced night vision capabilities for improved combat performance the burger Panza 2 arv 17 an armored recovery vehicle based on the standard chassis the Pioneer Panza 2 darks and armored engineering vehicle again built on the normal chassis equipped with a dozer blade Crane and other tools for Battlefield engineering tasks the bber avlb and an armored vehicle
launch Bridge system based on the standard chassis is capable of deploying a bridge to allow other vehicles to cross gaps up to 20 M wide the weisson 1 MC a multi-function sport vehicle designed for various engineering and Logistics tasks but primarily Adept at mind clearance the NM 189 ingenious pan of vogan a Norwegian engineering variant equipped with specialized tools and equipment for military engineering tasks and Battlefield support then there's the lonard 2 which with a name like that is naturally our previous tanks younger sibling first introduced into service with West Germany in 1979 it is
known for its Superior armor mobility and Firepower comp beds with Spore runer his main arment is the 120 mm Ry metal rh120 smooth board gun capable of firing High penetration rounds with Precision supplemented by sophisticated Fire Control Systems and thermal imaging the following variants have made it to Ukraine is the leopard 2a4 a slightly improved standard model equipped with improved Fire Control Systems digital electronics and upgraded armor protection the Leonard 2a6 an improved 2a4 that features the 120 mm l55 smooth Bo gun further enhanced armor protection and improved mind protection because of that it is
one of the most advanced iterations of the series then there's the BF Z3 buffle an armored recovery vehicle based on the standard Lenard 2 chassis designed for Battlefield operations it features a powerful crane winch and other recovery tools the Rival pananu Leonard 2R a mine clearing variant developed for the Finnish Army it comes equipped with a mine plow and other Dem mining equipment to clear pathways through minefields now if you want to ballpark figure for how many Ukraine has call it upwards of 130 but as they have come from as many countries as Germany Poland
Norway Portugal and Canada Finland and Spain take that figure as a really broad estimate another one which is lended to adjacent shall we say is the STDs vagen 122 heavily modified Leopard 2 designed for and used by the Swedish army based on the lonard 2a5 a standard variant that sits between the 2a4 and the 2a6 that we just discussed but Ukraine hasn't got any of them so don't worry too much about it it boasts enhanced armor protection including non-explosive reactive armor and additional composite screens which provide Superior defense against kinetic and explosive threats the tank
is equipped with the rh120 gun along with Advanced Fire Control Systems and improved crew survivability features we can also be fairly sure how many of these were sent as it was a small shipment from a single country and so there is no logistical web for us to lose ourselves in a humble 10 which were delivered in September 2023 then there's the British Challenger 2 which has been in service with the British army since 1998 it incorporates Cham composite armor of 120 mm l31 rifled gun and state-of-the-art Fire Control Systems known for its exceptional durability only
two have ever been lost in combat one to Friendly Fire in Iraq in 2003 and the second well we'll get to that later the numbers are also pretty simple here 14 units which were sent in March 2023 the next is the M1 ABS an American Tank which has been a Cornerstone of the US Army's armored forces since its introduction in 1980 renowned for its Advanced comped Chou armor just like the Challenger 2 and multifuel turbine engine it offers excellent Mobility protection and Firepower that's for the specific model sense this is the M1A1 sa situational awareness
model which comes with forward-looking infrared sites a rearm mounted telephone for better infantry communication and extra armor in the form of the Abrams reactive armor tiles or aat which offer increased protection against high explosive anti-tank rounds it also features the rh120 gun or bit1 licens made in the US it appears as though 31 of these have been sent to Ukraine with them arriving in September 2023 they all came from one country the US and there was no funny business reported with the 31 that were announced to be sent and so we can assume reasonably that
that is indeed how many were sent the final one sits a bit odd on the list because it's Deb able how Western it really is and that's the Polish pt91 Tui which at its core is a Soviet era t72 but one that was designed and put into production after the fall of Communism in Poland so oh we'll count it it features significant improvements over its predecessor including a dual AIS stabilized Fire Control System Advanced reactive armor a more powerful supercharged diesel engine and a reworked automatic loader these enhancements greatly improve its protection Firepower and overall
combat efficiency it also still has a Soviet G done specifically a 125 mm d81 TM it entered service in 1995 and has been primarily used by the Polish Army although it's seen some export success finding its way to both Malaysia and of course Ukraine we can also be fairly sure we know how many were sent to Ukraine too as again it's one country sending one type of tank nice and easy 60 examples which appear to have been shipped in April 2023 and that's a lot of them so now let's move on to tally up how
many have been lost in action [Music] fortunately while it can be difficult to say how many Western tanks Ukraine has it is much easier to tot up how many they've lost because the Russia Ukrainian war is one where near as damn it every combatant has a smartphone in their pocket and thus total tanks invariably ends up getting snapped and the resultant photos find their way online be it to either personal social media accounts of individual combatants or official social media accounts of various fighting organizations at which point they're picked up by open source intelligence operatives
and compiled into handy dandy cited lists for us to flick through so with that said let's have a look at the numbers shall we although do note that the coming list should not be taken as totally cast in Iron as there is always the chance that tanks may have been lost and somehow not been picked up on be it due to either the total loss of the crew and subsequent Battlefield movements seeing it Go undocumented or the fact that the photos are so poor that the tank picture simply cannot be identified as is the case
for this one this one and well this one beginning with leopard one we know of only one that has been lost so far specifically this one an A5 variant which was knocked out and subsequently abandoned by its crew in late November 2023 it appears to be artillery that got it the footage is shaky and unclear but the multiple explosions that can be seen going off in the near vicinity coupled with the Scorch marks that can be seen around it post abandonment very much imply this was the case rather than say a mine or cter tank
fire further still from the fact that all of its crew hatches are open post abandonment coupled with the otherwise good condition of it we can assume that all of its crew likely walked away alive from this one moving on to leopard 2os now where we know of at least 31 that have been lost specifically 20 A4 and 11 A6 variants of the a4s we know that 10 were complete losses such as this one this one and this one five were damaged and in a position to be recovered and potentially return to service such as this
one this one and this one and that a further five were damaged and subsequent abandoned such as this one this one and this one as for the 11 lost a sixes we know of six that were total losses with examples being this one this one and this one three that were damaged and left in a position to be recovered which you can see here here and here and two which were damaged and Abandoned and that's specifically this one and this one now moving on to the leopard 2's Swedish siblings the stgs vgan 122 we know
of seven of those that have been lost in total one of these specifically this one was a total loss it appears to have been destroyed around December 2023 and it's hard to tell exactly what got this one from the lack of obvious blast marks around it however in the crosshairs on the Russian discovered image it stands to reason that neither artillery nor mines were the cause and it was likely direct at fire of some kind as for the others one was damaged in a recoverable position namely this one which was knocked out in an uncertain
time and the other five were damaged and subsequently abandoned with examples being this one this one and this one next comes the American M1 Abrams of which we know of eight in total that have been lost of these eight three have been destroyed as total losses this one this one and this one of the other five this one was the only one that was damaged in a recoverable position and the other four were all damaged and Abandoned and here they all are as for the Polish pt91 we are aware of six of them that have
been lost with that number being split between three destroyed one damaged and recoverable and two that were damaged and abandoned this one this one and this one and the destroyed ones and do note however that this picture supposedly contains two tanks at least According to some in the open source intelligence space but hell if we can see it as for the other three here's the damaged but potentially recoverable one and here's the two which were damaged and abandoned when we get to the British Challenger 2 and let's spend a bit of time on this one
because this one's a bit contentious among the commentariat and that is putting it rather mildly one has been lost thus far this one which was lost lost in September 2023 and as you can see on screen now there can be no doubt that this was completely and utterly destroyed it will be a cold day in Hell before that thing ever drove again but it isn't its state of Destruction that is the contentious matter it's how it was destroyed as there is basically no agreement at all on this matter the BBC for example while speaking to
an unnamed Western defense Source reported that it had initially been immobilized by a really big mine before it was then targeted by a zala lanet kamakazi drone that drove in deliv the crew de gr after its crew had bailed out meanwhile reporter a Russian Pro government Outlet remain maintains that it was destroyed by a sandwich of artillery fire the Upper Crust of which was an initial volley that immobilized it and caused an onboard fire at which point as it was sat nice and still they emptied everything they had into it and left it in the
state that we just saw and which version is true if you'll allow to be blunt here knows never forget the truth is the first casualty in war and so while many watching Maybe even most of you will have a natural and understandable compulsion to distrust anything that comes out of Russia period it is an unfortunate fact of the matter that unless we see footage of exactly what happens beginning to end or wreck analysis is released postwar we will likely never be able to say for certain but why was the destruction of this Challenger 2 such
a big deal compared to all of the others that we've looked at well to summarize owing to its Posh armor and the fact that it went a whole two and a half decades without ever being knocked out by enemy fire some had begun to consider it something of an invincible tank and as this incident harshly proved there ultimately is no such thing as an invincible tank so then now that we've gone through that list of destroyed Western tanks is it time for us to change our whole perspective begin agreeing with the Kremlin sources and start
thinking that Western tanks are actually a bit old and a bit well to answer that let's bring this chapter to a close and look at what experts have to say on the matter shall we the military lessons of the Russia Ukraine war published in January 2024 by The Observer Research Foundation a Delhi based Global Think Tank and edited by kg bonan a senior fellow with the foundation strategic studies program presents an overall positive picture of Western tanks in Ukraine but tempers it with some very pragmatic considerations of their detriments and operational challenges quoting here Ukraine
has sought and received modern tanks from NATO although in fewer numbers than desired the ukrainians have faced unfortunate losses of nator provided tanks to Russian strikes in their attempts at regaining territory lost to Russia in donbas particularly in the battles for Novo dariva and rapil two villagers straddling the border between denet and zapor xiir blasts although armed Fighting Vehicle losses have been high when attempting to break through minefields up to 500 meters deep Ukrainian troops acknowledged that Western provided platforms were vastly Superior to their Soviet era protected Mobility platforms for one critical reason crew survivability
the quote ends the crew survivability element of Western tanks is something that analysts keep coming back to time and time again as you can see from the following extract from the paper tanks in the Russia Ukrainian War which was written by Anton py head of defense policy and strategy at the International Center for defense and security an independent Europe spanning defense Think Tank and published in March 2024 quoting here the UK has so far delivered 14 Challenger twos to Ukraine while no longer state-of-the-art the British tank is a capable machine particularly because of its excellent
protection but unless more vehicles are delivered in the future it is unlikely that they will make a huge impact the M1 Abrams also received similar praise quote the survivability of western-made main battle tanks such as the M1 Abrams in Ukraine is bolstered by their Superior armor better crew protection and advanced electronics compared to russian-made tanks a notable exception to this however is the leopards which of all the Western tanks receive by far the most criticism quoting payer again most of the leopard twos available for transfer to Ukraine belong to the A4 version which is over
30 years old it is still a powerful machine but it is probably not on par with the latest versions of Russian tanks quote ends do note however that the majority of Tanks fielded by Russia are not their latest models for every one t80 BVM or t90m that they deploy they also deploy as a ballpark figure three or four t-62s or t-72s which are much much older models an exception to this is the leopard 286 which P Praises very highly quoting again Germany and Portugal also sent 2 a6s to Ukraine this is a much improved machine
with advanced electronics and sighting systems and greatly improved protection in particular the A6 Sports the distinctive Arrowhead armor modules on the turret front already introduced on the preceding A5 model the modifications come at the cost of increased weight but apparently this has not significantly affected Mobility the quote ends as for what others say Cesar pintard writing for the international campus for security and defense in August 2023 observed that Western tanks such as the leopards particularly The Leopard 2 experienced initial difficulties but chalked it up to being down to operational mistakes and inadequate training rather than
inherent flaws in the vehicles the same opinion is shared by Matthew Schmidt a professor of international Affairs at the University of New Haven as he notes that one should consider the established interoperability with other branches in the militaries that these tanks come from and how that will take time to develop in the Ukrainian Army he gets no time frame on when he believes the Synergy will be achieved but does make it clear that he believes the ukrainians have already made great strides in this area but for all this tempered Praise of Western tanks there were
also those who sing their praises highly and argue that any of the shortcomings will not be the result of their inherent design but of their deployment a great example of which would be Gordon Davis a former US Army director of operations and now senior non-resident fellow at the center for European policy analysis think tank based out of Washington DC he said the following in January 2023 in response to the question does the decision to send Western tanks matter and quoting him yes Western tanks matter tanks in general could make a difference for Ukraine but Western
tanks in particular are more likely to make a difference as they can outperform their Russian counterparts the first two key questions for Ukraine will be how many and when timing is critical if we take time to prepare ship transfer train organize for combat and rehearse future operations the other critical question will be sustainability which will be determined by the answers to several questions for example how well do these tanks perform in the harsh winter combat conditions expected how well will logisticians be able to provide the ammunition the right parts and sufficient fuel where when needed
will donor Nations provide the ammunition lubricants and parts in a timely manner how well will Crews and units be able to keep the various tanks operationally ready will there be major repair facilities with the tools and expert mechanics needed to return the damaged tanks to the fire the quote ends although was of course speaking preemptively those words are still a fantastic summary of the overall position which you will not struggle to find argued to this day one solid thing we can take away from this discourse is that the debate is very much one of how
useful Western tanks have been to Ukraine not whether or not they actually are or it is outside Russia anyway naturally if you delve into the Russian side of things you will find plenty of commentary talking about how terrible Western armor is and how it will make no real difference to the outcome of of the war and if anything it'll actually be a deterrent to Ukraine's efforts but at risk of coming across as closed-minded given that we found essentially nothing outside of that partisan space that collaborated that opinion you'll forgive us if we don't commit any
of the video's precious word count to discussing it today so as you may have guessed from the structure of the last chapter we have no interest in spoon feeding you our own perspectives on this subject make no mistake we absolutely do have opinions on the matter of course we do but with all interested in you using everything that we've discussed today to arrive at your own independent take so with that in mind take heed of everything we discussed today and decide for yourself Western tanks in Ukraine War winners as much use as a chocolate teapot
or something in between [Music]