so there's one playlist that I've been meaning to check out with you guys a very special type of music which used to be memed on and is now um loved by everybody new metal [Music] what's up everybody I'm Finn mcentee this is the punk rock MBA and over the past few years I'm making videos one thing has become very very clear to me absolutely everybody loves new metal and it's not just old people like me who are there at the beginning and trying to like relive The Glory Days there's a whole new generation of people
it's also these Deftones loving e-girls on Tick Tock who mostly weren't even born when corn was battling Backstreet Boys for the top spot on TRL it's rappers like Lil Uzi vert the sick New World Festival just happened and was sold out I think in like half a day and according to Google Trends interest in new metal is at the highest point it's been in 20 years and the honest truth is that even though new metal basically died in the mid-2000s with the possible exception of emo nothing in the Rock and metal world has come along
since then that's had that same kind of Mass Appeal staying power and Incredibly broad influence and the question that I want to ask is why why is new Metals popularity surging and why hasn't anything else in the last 20 years of rock and battle Ben is popular as new metal those are the questions that I will answer in this video but first is something interfering with your happiness or preventing you from achieving your goals but regardless of the cynical mental health issue like depression or anxiety or if you're just a human who lives in this
world who's going through a hard time therapy can give you the tools to approach your life in a very different way and that is why I'm excited to tell you about today's sponsor betterhelp betterhelp's mission is to make therapy more affordable and more accessible and this is an important Mission because as some of you probably know finding a therapist can be really hard especially when you're limited to just the options in your area betterhelp is a platform that makes it easier to find a therapist because it's online it's remote and by filling out a few
questions betterhelp can match you to a professional in as little as a few days just go to the link in the description of this video which is betterhelp.com thepunk Rock clicking that link helps support this Channel and it also gets you 10 off your first month of better help if you really don't fit with that therapist which is a common thing with therapy you can easily switch to a different therapist for free without stressing about insurance or who's in your network or any other that stuff just click the link in the description or go to
betterhelp.com thepunk rock and thank you again to betterhelp for supporting this channel [Music] [Applause] so first of all let me talk about exactly what I'm seeing and then we can talk about why it's happening I've been on YouTube since 2017 and the one type of content that pretty much reliably gets more views than anything else is new metal which initially was kind of surprising to me because if you were around back in the day when all that stuff came out you'll remember that all the critics the older bands and the media all pretty much universally
hated new metal for example here's what Entertainment Weekly said about Slipknot back in 2001. slip knot a god-awful gaggle of corn fed mask wearing midwesterners who identify themselves not by names but by numbers zero to eight are the current Lucky Ducks their second album Iowa has arrived on wings of hype and Buzz it's an almost unrelentingly brutal disc that like so much of new metal often seems like a parody of itself but that was 22 years ago and the tables have definitely turned like I said earlier according to Google Trends interest in new metal is
now at its highest level in almost 20 years and it's not just limited to that this may the sick new world Festival happened in Las Vegas headlined by System of a Down with other bands on the bill like corn Deftones Papa Roach Kitty Coal Chamber pod if you didn't know better you would swear you were back in 2003. it's just one of those days [Music] and it's sold out in something like half a day which definitely tells you something but what's interesting to me is that this was more than just a sold out Festival this
felt like I guess you could say a cultural event in a way that you don't really see from metal festivals here in America for example a lot of creators went and documented it like my friends at neopunk FM we're neopunk FM and we go to internet music concerts and document the people and since new metal is getting popular on the internet we knew we had to go to the most hiked new metal festival of the Year sick New World there were even some I guess you could say like relatively mainstream creators there like SS sniperwolf
[Music] it felt special felt like people were just like ready for new metal to come back and people were losing their [ __ ] stop it stop it stop it stop it and speaking of Deftones If My Chemical Romance were kind of the flagship band of the emo Revival Deftones are the leaders of the new metal Revival and what's really interesting about it to me is that just like with MCR the Deftones Revival is not just old people in fact if anything I would say that the majority of Deftones fans that I see now are
these younger gen Z people who discovered the band through tick tock that's uh labia Genesis [Music] mascara that's too easy but it's definitely not just Deftones younger people learn to all the new metal bands from Limp Biscuit [Music] to slip knot [Music] and of course the Godfather is a new metal corn and one other interesting thing I've noticed about this new metal Revival is there's a lot of women who are into it especially Deftones which I think is a great thing to see because the sad truth is that metal has been kind of a sausage
fest for a while now and it's also encouraging from just like a bigger picture perspective because if you notice the scene is always bigger when there's a lot of women who are involved for example the 2000s pop punk ERA with blank and Good Charlotte and all that stuff and then a few years later all the emo stuff in the 2000s like Panic at the Disco and Paramore or all the metal core and death core stuff of the later 2000s like asking Alexandria Suicide Silence Pierce the Veil all that stuff from the Myspace scene girls were
kind of the key demographic and to me The Tick-Tock Deftones girls are really just an updated version of the Myspace scene girls from 15 years ago [Music] and this is a good thing because in case you didn't know women are half the planet and we probably don't want to exclude them from the scene but also because as I've talked about before young women are the single most powerful demographic in terms of deciding what becomes popular in pop culture I mean if you think about it almost nothing becomes really truly huge in mainstream pop culture unless
young women are into it K-pop stranger things The Beatles Harry Potter young women made all of those things blow up so we should be very happy to see them getting into new metal now and anytime I see some big Trend like this happening I always want to understand why why are people latching on to new metal and why are they doing it now 20 years after the peak of the genre and to answer that let's talk about why new metal got big in the first place the first thing that may seem obvious but I think
a lot of people Miss is just really truly great songwriting in a way that I just don't hear from a lot of current metal bands I think Linkin Park was probably the most accessible of all the new metal bands they had that kind of like pop sensibility that I think was a really key part of what made them sell more records than anybody else in the genre I think I've mentioned this before but my 40 year old sister-in-law from Vietnam who like doesn't even really listen to music she knows and loves a lot of Linkin
Park songs and I think that says a lot I mean you can play this for just about anybody who's into any kind of music and they would appreciate it Linkin Park could get played on the alternative rock station on the mainstream rock station some of their later stuff could and did even get played on pop radio and how many modern metal bands could we say that about and you can say what you want about Limp Biscuit personally I think they're kind of corny but their songs get stuck in your head like peanut butter on the
roof of your mouth I mean it is just straight up fun to sing along to something like break stuff or rolling a relatively extreme new metal band like Slipknot whose music was borderline death metal at times I know sometimes people don't believe me when I say that but in case you forgot the first actual song on Iowa which is an album that went to number three on Billboard opens with a blast beat [Music] s so heavy Slipknot songs were just incredibly catchy and full of hooks maybe not as accessible as Lincoln Park obviously but still
it was almost like death metal with a pop sensibility or if you look at corn they were just incredibly Twisted with lyrics about sexual abuse and all kinds of other like super dark stuff these really noisy sludgy riffs that even by today's standards are pretty intense bye [Music] and yet again they still had that pop sensibility with songs like Freak on a Leash which got them on mainstream radio and competing for the top slots on TRL with legitimate pop acts like insync and Backstreet Boys and so my point here is that when you look at
new metal from a songwriting perspective it's pretty clear why a lot of people loved and still do love those songs and how many current metal bands are even trying to write hooks like this I feel like this whole idea of trying to write accessible songs just went out the window and for anybody who may not be familiar with me I am not one of those like music was better back in my day type people so that's not what's going on here in fact in general I think music now is way better than it was 20
or 30 years ago that's just my opinion and I say you be the judge listen to Modern metal like this band invent animate that metal fans would tell you is the future of the genre and they're gonna take over the world what do you think do you think this songwriting is even in the same universe as a band like Slipknot or Linkin Park why and if you like modern metal that's totally okay I'm not telling you to stop liking it my point is just that yes modern metal is obviously way heavier and way more technical
than anything 20 years ago but most people don't care about heavier technical most people care about songs and so of course A lot of these young people are getting into new metal because those are great songs and if you're looking for great songs well modern metal has largely abandoned the whole idea of writing songs at all I feel like a lot of it is guitarists just sort of throwing a bunch of riffs together to try to impress other guitarists and the second big factor in the rise of new metal as well as its continued relevance
is that it was for lack of a better word a spectacle I just did a podcast with Kyle from brand of sacrifice and he said it perfectly new metal bands looked like video game characters the sort of the rock star age is is back maybe in the in the pop and hip-hop world the way people act and dress and portray themselves so I think we need to follow suit and sort of be characters that you'd want to select in a video game or something you know there's slip knot with their jumpsuits and masks and the
horde of henchmen on stage with them banging on steel drums and stuff there was corn with their dreads and Adidas gear Wayne static's hair Fred durst's hat the guy from Mudvayne who glued bugles to his face on his face glue in them and of course all the b-tier bands like mushroom head motogrator or Twisted method who maybe didn't have the songs but definitely had the look the point that I'm making here is that new metal bands have always had some sort of visual trademark that set them apart I want to use the word gimmick but
that feels like an insult and I don't mean it that way what I mean is that you can imagine picking them from the character selection menu of some imaginary N64 game that came out in a parallel universe and Beyond just the way that they looked new metal was full of these huge personalities these super charismatic people that you kind of just can't ignore Fred Durst was the biggest example of this I've talked about him before but he was just all over the media he was rumored to be dating Britney Spears he got dissed by Eminem
he did that duet with Christina Aguilera or take Corey Taylor for example who is still in the headlines of the metal sites almost every other day with what does Corey Taylor think about what David Lee Roth said about what Axl Rose thinks about what Corey Taylor thinks which on the one hand is kind of funny but I think really that just speaks to what a compelling person he is they're still writing about him 25 years after Slipknot came out because people care what Corey Taylor thinks there's also people like Serge from System of a Down
Joey jordison West Borland Jonathan Davis new metal is just full of these people and you can say that all the visual gimmicks and the gossip headlines shouldn't matter because it should be all about the music but the fact is that it does matter because remember this is the entertainment industry people call it the music industry but that's not really true because their job isn't just to show up and play their guitar it's to entertain us to put on a show and right or wrong Fred Durst is a very entertaining person and slipknot's crazy outfits are
entertaining it's like a WWE show but metal and where is all of that in modern metal I feel like these days in the metal scene it's almost frowned upon to be interesting or to stand out in any way I think we need to end just where in the regular band shirts on stage in the gym shorts I think that's got to be retired for good it's frustrating to me because I feel like the culture now in metal is almost like you know it's frowned upon to be different and I I don't understand that fans now
just kind of want to show up in black jeans and a t-shirt looking like the door guy from your local venue never say anything controversial or challenging on social media just hey our new single is out pre-save now and can we be surprised that people are looking past them to the new metal bands from 20 years ago where are all the big Personalities in rock now other than maybe Ronnie Radke I really can't think of many this is your song I've never done it like this [Music] this is my life [Music] oh my God [
__ ] kill that another big factor I think is that new metal had this rare ability to appeal to a very wide range of people of course when you think of new metal there's the stereotypical Midwestern kid with the jankos an addiction to Mountain Dew but new metal was much more than that it could appeal to everyone from like the tap out Bros to a tank crew in the military or a guy working in a machine shop or to the emo kid edgy moms or that sort of weird intersection of like redneck and emo I
mean that's a big part of why they were able to sell tens of millions of albums and I don't really think you can say that about modern metal which seems to be pretty much aimed at nerdy guys in their 20s who play guitar and there's nothing wrong with being a nerdy guy in your 20s who plays guitar but my point is that that is a relatively small market and so with all of that in mind it makes perfect sense that when a new generation of people discovers this stuff it clicks with them in a way
that modern metal just doesn't and so I think the simple truth is that nothing has come along to Dethrone new metal because modern metal honestly just isn't as good or at least it's not good in the way that most people care about I think the overall trendiness of Y2K fashion and culture is probably also part of it as well as of course Tick Tock being essentially the best platform of all time for people to discover some sort of Niche interest and just completely go down that rabbit hole and let's be real unfortunately the generation of
people my age who discovered new metal back in the day when it first came out we are now old enough to have kids in high school which is probably also a factor and so my biggest question is what's next where do we go from here I'm sure that some percentage of the Gen Z kids who discovered Deftones and Slipknot on Tick Tock will end up getting into bad Omens Lorna Shore or Spirit Box because those are all great bands who are doing a lot of things right but I think in general if you care about
the future of metal then you should be worried that new metal a genre which peaked 20 years ago is more compelling to young people now than 99 of modern metal to me that is a giant flashing red warning sign that all these modern bands need to do more than just copy slipknot's riffs they should be asking themselves much bigger questions than that like what did Slipknot Deftones corn Limp Biscuit Linkin Park what did those bands do that we aren't and of course they should take a page out of mudvayne's book and glue bugles to their
faces all right all right my friends that does it for this video as always let me know what you think in the comments also I want to thank everyone who supports me on patreon especially those of you who support at the true cult level or above patrons get all my podcasts and videos a week early there are VIP channels in my Discord and I'm super active in I do giveaways and there's a way to have me review your music so if any of that sounds cool to you hit the link in the description of this
video and with that I'm going to sign off for now but I will see you next time