hello and welcome to this ikmi Safety Center webinar on incident investigation and avoiding common pitfalls the web my apologies my name is Trish Caron and I'm the director of the IME Safety Center joining me today I have David Ramsey their group managing director and president of Kelvin top set and David will be presenting the webinar for us today this webinar will consist of David discussing incident investigation the IQ me Safety Center webinars have been developed as a tool to share knowledge and information amongst our members so what I would like to do now is hand
over to David so that he can actually go through his presentation I'll just pass over to him and very shortly he will actually show you his screen as we run through the presentation over to you now David is mostly invisible yes it is hello everyone whatever time zone you happen to be in is to be able to join me what propose to do this morning is to use 26 slides to accompany what I'm saying the slides don't have a great deal of detail ominous not our style it's a there really there is prompts for me
as I'm talking to you what I would you talked about is based on around 13 years of so of investigation but I don't want you to think of Investigation as just about safety and fines much wider than that all those things like process engineering quality control that's what I started out very many years ago who's been head of quality and a caring company in the food industry so a lot of the things apply there just as equally they would apply to what we call incident investigation I'm just having trouble advancing my slide here let me
just see if I can [Music] come to supper plan but let's see yeah there we go so really this is if you haven't seen it before this is me I don't normally smoke a pipe but relief of it the benefits of the kind of Shambo combs enthusiast this is me but this is really where the investigation can actually go wrong is right at the very beginning and it is and a half a cup of science on this it is about defining the problem what is the problem essentially what we're looking at is based on systems
thinking and in any systems analysis or systems problem solving very first thing you do is defining the problem and I probably found a couple of times to front-end engineering I know that my friend and colleague Chris is probably listening to be here and he really was a gossip introduced a front-end engineering to us it's exactly the same thing and anything you do in life if you don't define dislike what we're going to do and define not in advance it will go wrong and I've seen this happen so many times in the past you see here
on your screen now at Deepwater Horizon I in fact led a team for transition to look at deepwater horizon clearly it was a major event and when I went to America with initially small team but almost that team good to be very large and we were there for about six months working on this that rates at the very beginning defining the problem was very important because natural team leader for the company right at the beginning said to me David thank you very much because I wasn't sure what it was I was investigating so here we're
going to major disaster and what is it you're looking at is it in fact an explosion as the loss of a ship technically is a ship I would look at pollution loss of life and so on and find very simple death beginning was extremely important because we defined the problem I asked what I thought it was at the time which was again clearly an explosion and the trigger for that was ignition of hydrocarbons we went and further analyzed all that before we actually came to investigation then we found the team when we start any investigation
almost always starts with a telephone call in fact this week alone we've had two telephone calls for two investigations that we're going to have to do and both of these are in the North Sea and right at the beginning you've got this telephone call and you're trying to define the problem is on the phone very rarely do you get in my experience very rarely do we get investigation starting from an email or somebody walking into your office and talking to you so you've really got to try to work out in detail the incident step and
what you're going to do if I'm going back to my condo and sir I was on my way to the pub at the time when I was formed in the middle of the village street so the first thing we're doing we're trying to say well what is the event we're looking at so that's actually very easy in this sense if you think about this is the newspaper headline this is the event that so let's see an example here and the one I quite often use a long showing a chemical plant here isn't fun to Titanic
because of to say at the very simplest level you know what was the event or clearly ship sank and then what was the trigger for that well the trigger for that was it hit an iceberg and you can do exactly the same thing for something that will upon go where as I said a few minutes ago what happened was that we had a major explosion to be thought that analyzed and the trigger for that was my ignition of hydrocarbons as far as we could see at that time clearly is possible to go back over that
at a later point and change that death if you feel the parts weren't correct but I'd have to say - in all the many years I and my colleagues have been doing this it's very rarely we've had to go back and change that initial definition certainly the event is the event nuts what happened we often call that the consequences the event would be the consequences we're going to analyze those and we're going to underlies what happened to create those consequences but another way of looking at as what you see in the screen just now the
trigger and the event and I do want to emphasize as were talking about the pitfalls of an investigation by not getting this bit right then it all goes wrong I went along to major client nodes in America and they asked me to come and look at a problem they had with mother a rig very close to sinking and they couldn't get the root cause analysis to work out and I went through and I suggested don't give a cup of coffee look at it tell me anything so I went through the analysis and quite simply the
thing that was wrong the initial definition right once we got the definition right the whole thing fell into place so pitiful number one is really getting started if you don't get this way propellent gone and defining a problem then it's certainly going to be wrong we had a major one we looked at a long time ago which was a massive engineering project which at that time costs around a 500 million British pounds and this project was a complete and total failure and quite simply is because they did not define the problem at the beginning the
confidentiality reason to tell you what gender ship who should be walked it out but in fact this will never ever operate and it was simply because the problem wasn't defined an emergent understood we then want to say the next point is we need to plan with two aspects of planning and the first one is in fact about getting there but forming a team and again if you don't do this right things are going to go you know the first one is forming a team you may not have the choice of that but maybe define for
you there's very important that you get a team that you require do you get a technical specialist do you need their something it's been interviewing how many people do you need until that can't define that for you here too slow but once you've done that you then delegate the duties Nacional Tricia's listening to this one of the best ones I've ever seen but that was led by an Australian guy on a fit of accent we were exposed to industry it was very good at delegating and keeping the claim that such like clearly you will have
to discuss deadlines because you haven't got unlimited time and you can't run out of time quite easily finding a place to work is really important and here's one of the major pitfall we get a room you can walk the two days is one from a security point of view so the people don't get into the room when they should be in the room but the other one is quite a silly one with branch it wouldn't naturally think about is said to solve the clean air coming in at night and they're cleaning up all your papers
now has happened to me major paid for I come back in the morning and all your hard work is in the dustbin and then in Killian poplar is thinking about the security what we can tell you what we can't tell people and such like and ensuring again that that room is locked and then strangely enough make travel arrangements I trained in air crash investigation or one of the first things that you do is that you arrange the hotels I did the same with my condo because the press get there and suddenly you can't get there
because all the rooms are taken up by the press so you've got to make travel arrangements get a hotel and you get there and read the terms of reference or the school some companies don't know what a scope is or in terms of reference and you me enough to write that so you don't have a terms of reference or a school it's very difficult to do the investigation the next point where you can go wrong as a second part of planning and that is nice for planning the investigation itself with 15 who is going to
do what and then what areas will you be working the thing is to try to define the areas you know argument of some people interviewing for example I did certain loss promise at one point we were doing what an erect look like a fatality if watch it turned out not to be in the end but it might Clyde the guy like I'm very friendly with my dude but after drinking together now with him he said David I'm not good to have a good lead interview that's good absolutely right because it wasn't you sit into doing
that best we got really excited that they could have been angry so you're going to choose that team of what we're going to look up what bits are you going to look now but one of the difficulties of course that we all have natural biases be included so by using some means and we tend to use these charts and cards we have the stock you bring down that would seal it before it's a 46 it's a 92 whatever happened last year may be different so you've got to consider that when you're planning what you're going
to do who's going to do what what are the deadlines well do the next one is a major one here is change we cannot have an incident with the change being a factor in this and it's logical if you think about it everything's running along absolutely perfectly until something is different something changes now I had a situation in a major refinery in Europe where there was a structural failure and in fact the chief engineer was blocking the investigation all of the time and it got moderately aggressive and he would not accept that was changed clearly
you know there has to be change in somewhere oven or the thing with the renewal carefully so right at the very beginning if you can't identify change then I think that's a bit of a problem there to go through every aspect of the areas that you're thinking about using a planning chart such as we've gone and asking the question changing its stage identifying airport that might be that helps enormously and doing investigators do remember that we're always able change no fainting chains then you could imagine it from there and quit I actually got this picture
of the Internet's not one that I - and I'm suspecting as I am Udine problem was the change here an amusing picture then we go onto the next video which is really evidence is very important we have to gather the evidence I've got a couple of slides on this here and it's getting the detail and getting all of the backgrounds supporting information I will see that again on the next slide here could with coded this up I'm not a detailer so niche of somebody else who can gather the information remember doing a major railway investigation
have been a train crash and because railways are the oldest form of mechanized transport the rules and regulations are enormous and we had one side of a room filled with regulations and very very difficult we'd love to somebody as part of your team you can reference some of them because if you have to go to court but if you have to prove something from a legal point of view then you have to have the evidence this is one here which we used on the Macondo and Senate but also is based on stuff that the Dutch
accident investigation board years and you can see this sort of coding on this first of all top left you've got the time what was the time and there the date and such time then you've categorized what you're doing technology and then just as the ticket number the identification you've got God on the bottom you've got your evidence reference I knew then we started Macondo I think there were a million items of evidence to start then and I don't think I'm exaggerating that from memory obviously it's 17 years ago no so then we've a color coding
and coding we used was paint we're not quite sure we haven't proved it yet you'll notice to the right of that as one would mean we know that the agreements are proven the evidence for that and then look at that the narrative in the mid they're telling us what it was that this particular ticket was about no we had you know hundreds if not thousands of these but it's extremely important you've got that evidence and I do want to emphasize that again the pitfall here is if you end up going to court or in some
legal situation that how can you prove what proof have you got so you need two people within your team who are able to deal with that and record that information it happens not to be me detail at number broad-brush customers and businesses so moving on again really very very important in any investigation is that open thinking we haven't a problem again another pitfall if you go huffing down the wood I've seen it before I know what it is I can come up with an answer right there right away well maybe that's true but you've really
got to choose your time and you've really got to think that widely I often joke and emphasize I am joking some things perhaps better go to the pub I'm a couple of points for us to loosen up to get your thinking right so planning the investigation with open thinking anything's possible don't even consider going through the analysis stage until you've got all the facts so good cause analysis only comes after the planning so many people talk about yet we have to do a root cause analysis it can actually do one because they don't have the
factory information this says picture here is one that I'm very fond of not just because it's my granddaughter of a long time ago but children have this amazing ability to ask questions so those of you who appearance who have had small children will be well aware of the fact live an amazing ability to ask quite the incisive questions and sometimes often embarrassing questions but nevertheless they are very very good whereas we become well qualified we're afraid to make fools of ourselves at such pie and that is a huge pitfall I investigated in Far East Russia
the dropping were 240-ton Lord fortune and by pure chance too people won't kill a tip the other way and the problem was this has been a very well-planned job for a major international company and using some major international contractors but when did the risk assessment all the engineers nodded a true yes yes that's fine that's fine that's fine another problem that was to do a center of gravity and the pitfall here was that they had everyone have accepted everyone says expertise and yet the two people who asked me divin who could not fall over one
was a person out there from New Zealand and I said Brett what's your job he said I'm an accountant and the other person is Gabrielle who was my PA who's an English graduate they were able to pass the question because it didn't understand the and we tend to accept the engineers that's fine we could deal with this and yet using the children their approach is very good then I believe this is a true story many years ago the Dutch engineering company Hyrum immediate to draw our tunnel in Holland and as we know the Netherlands really
assert drilling through a wet sponge because thought was below what level and the answers of a brave thing they went along to children's primary school and give them jumped us and posed a question with them and they've got the paper and they've covered pens and the kids came up with the answer now I don't know what the answer was of something to do with wormans but nevertheless it is very brave thing that clearly the engineering company had to you know dimensions on that moving on again weren't very interested in weak signals and indicators and often
we miss these and looking after a fatal accident explosives front at one point and rather the starting right at the point where the person had been killed then of course we're doing the investigation all of the nasty part that has been clear that we're not dealing with in the immediate emedicine trying to find out what had gone wrong so rather than going to the immediate point where the person had been killed a who burned and looted all the things but I was speaking up weak signals which told me quite a lot very interesting little point
about the maintenance issue I came across and a couple of other points like that and very handy on in the investigation it was pointing truth in management failure in the the senior managers and directors didn't really understand what was going on we're all pretty familiar with Barney as a gear we're looking at James reason Swiss cheese model and they're certainly very very important in that the companies I'm sure don't listening to this all have very good systems of good buyers and defenses and the number of us actually work with say the tripod system and they
have four body are types that we analyze for doing that and from memory there are missing body and an adequate body are still valid and effective body these are very useful because in looking for these we should honestly cover everything again the major pitfall is if you discover that you don't have barriers of money or something or you haven't find out to which by a certain bypass again I'm almost very interested and we come to talk to people and I'm often asked the question David how do you know when somebody's lying well the reality is
I don't know what somebody's telling the truth because we all tell Warren truths and with a very interesting story of wills an incident with a helicopter with potential you very I fatality risk fortunately nothing happened but the people who whispered this time were all very experienced people at all offshore installation managers that all flew Ellicott's that's in them and I know after we've seen this event I asked them what color the helicopter was then nobody knew we had till 10 different answers so really an important point here is to don't assume that what the person
tells you is right maybe believe as I usually do believe it's right but you don't axonal and to your check and you'll see that I took a long time to learn how to interview but one of the pitfalls is watching too much television I think American cop movies it's such like because interviewing is not like that and the real way I find it best to get information from people is a relaxed conversation and you might think well that's pretty difficult to do under serious circumstances but in reality that's you seem to do if you're not
doing that pitfalls not by talking through the interviewee constantly seeking information from them rather than letting them talk so what you're seeking to do is to create a relaxed atmosphere Gridley walk talk and avoid things by eluded once and even then the favorite one to avoid is sing we're not here to blame you because what the person hears is blend they don't hear the knot but the only here blame and I don't even use the word interview now because I think that's loaded I'm just trying to get people to come and chat with me so
we can solve problems together interviewing is a big fit for Gideon I would suggest it and it's worth spending time looking at that and seeing how you can actually do deal with that to get people to talk to my structure incorrectly then you can actually get people to tell you almost anything it's truthful I think to avoid as well another huge pit for some companies of affect finding interview and their sense you look at a list of questions to be answered well the person will forgive you at the answer you're looking for rather than one
you actually need to have so do avoid having us the 20 question show were you wearing the correct PPE yes were you standing with schools were standing yes the waste of time doing that don't even bother doing that that's all so it has to be discussion for things to operate here we've got heard these human factors what time the human factors one of them support the reality of core since that people are involved at every stage of everything so two major points that cover here very briefly one is the investigation findings when you were doing
this where were people involved what would be doing what was their contribution to the innocent isn't necessary but people deliberately doing things wrong or errors mistakes violations and shortcuts that people say excuse me you got to try and establish exactly you know what those where people are at the heart of everything do bear in mind there was nothing in the nude world apart from you know an environment to sell trees see sand and such like there hasn't come out of somebody's head at some point so people have to be informed and I remember during one
major investigation for a railway company and the head of the railway company would accept offenders because we've got people who want to buy them generating well clearly he was wrong and there the company went bust he lost his job and many great sympathy for him then we've got the investigative performance we've all got different psychological profiles and I'd be very careful in what we were doing I'm a big introvert judge' and that's not necessary you need to have a mixture of people in there judges just want to get the answer right away I've seen it
before this is a you know sure I've got the answer though so you need to be enough this ability to relate to other people I was doing a major investigation for the team we didn't I wasn't a team didn't as a facilitator and the team didn't couldn't invite relate to the rest of the team if something his own officer walked away and hardly said good morning to anyone your job as a team leaders to relate to people to organize think discuss how things are going discuss with your client or your stakeholders so really you have
to be able to engage with people and what you're doing and then leave the interview in consent this as well I'm controlling the team so why the pills well if we think of going along to the doctor you probably get from I coughed so I'm probably needing to go to the doctor is that we need to gain from the symptom to the source because the danger is that we only get to the symptom of the problem we really get to the root cause so you'd be pretty upset you went along to Dalton it does often
happen is that do you get pills to deal with the symptomatic so just got me coughing that's fine but it doesn't like to solve the Bisset problem our job and doing the investigation is to get way beyond the symptom and to get to the source brilliant root cause analysis in this stage here because it's very strongly feel that it's an alien which we have to work very hard to get right I'm amazed the number of professional reports and we'll done and good reports that don't have a root cause analysis because having the root cause analysis
diagram doesn't mean that you can actually see what has gone wrong you should be able to trace that in for any additional information at all it was probably written usually to walk in and read that and perhaps just was supportive some recommendations the executive summary and photographs you got the whole story and yet so many reports are diving don't have either a good cousin on a stone or one that works well but remember a root cause analysis is essentially a logical diagram telling you the story and of course in doing that back to my earlier
point is that you your root cause is going to be about people it's going to come back to them if you find that your root cause is somewhere in the engineering and technology area then you haven't got to the root cause major pitfall with many investigations and one of the problems for all of us who could an engineering background the solution is to weld the gate shut in the sense but we're really going to abandon what was the people contribution in they're even at the same thing who decided we thought about it and has got
to come back there at some point this doesn't mean I thought might use the word blame but it doesn't mean were blaming something we all make mistake you see things differently we will discuss the property it's got to come back to people at some point this is an interesting one here the investigation findings it's so easy to see right let's issue a draft report what I can possibly avoid that don't do i draft report first of all I like to get all the stakeholders together so we can discuss what went wrong discussed and it missing
lives gonna be quite argumentative but it doesn't mean that people nor we're having had a chance to contribute understood the problem the draft report hasn't sat in the drawer of somebody's office and we've got it very late in the game and then it's not right I mean I had one client once I said we were wrong with people there three o'clock and Freddy afternoon they said we don't do that in this companies all you do know and you said afterwards gosh dear but you said we'd never do it any other week they give us a
chance to talk about it very quick list here to some of the things that I've learned this maybe not about the pitfalls of the investigation like we just scanned own that you'll see many of the things that well we've fun things have gone wrong so it does give you're gonna heads up where you want to go and do not a suspect all of you listening to this I hope you want to probably did this similar lists of events but briefly just talking about software here in that software's fantastic very very helpful this great whatever software
you're using well as a system might care the one that we love or anyone else's system but the danger is that the person on the keyboard was king or queen what you have to do is do all your investigation with computer support but not on the computer you'll have to discuss things with people you have to share because if you don't do that then we're in the danger of a no garbage in garbage out with the foods so si useful too as a pen that might be and then we're gone and this is a big
when I was in America last weekend Wednesday run a course on the port right in her to read reports many reports the detail and jerricans far far too great and the trick is to write in an understandable way and think of in mid-range newspaper because if a person can read it or understand of the point doing that it for some bit range newspapers bomb was a very good gain for that but wanted to very good reports that I would recommend you to look at did you get the things online in America the chemical safety work
they do a very good report a couple of British ones a marine acts of Investigation Branch and then also here acid investigation branch there is a world standard for here like sense investigations and they tend to work on you know simps of the model and another in doing the air crash course there was a specific part on report writing and of course don't need to be long I did an investigation on a fire aboard a ship something over the last year very difficult defend of what went wrong and I had to get a forensic fire
specialist to work with me so we did it we found out what had actually gone wrong with cinder gone on the center back to declined and the client said that's very good thank you for the draft report so that wasn't the draft report that's it and so there's nothing else I can tell you we could write more but there's no points no information to give you and by the way here's the invoice so very important just write what you need to write avoid planning at all costs getting just towards the end of my presentation or
webinar this morning is is the importance of staying independent relatively easy for me and for my team but quite often as a pressure for you within a company to confirm with somebody else's to you and someone else's sort we have been asked to change the report and to do things in a different way to suit the client's particular requirements well we can we go for a position that we can walk away from so you don't do that there is often a pressure to conform with what the company's expectation would be that didn't happen that we
we don't do things like that yet but the reality is this independence if you would remain independent you devalue everything you've done that everything we do in the future what easier times but extremely important really my almost said last slide here is to talk about legal issues and I can't tell you what the legal issues are in your particular situation but for me it is one of the big pitfalls we can start an investigation and discover in starting that that we're not actually working for the company as we thought the way it's been handed over
to some legal department on the legal department within the company or with external legal legal advisers and you really can get to put a lot of difficulty here but once privileged and confidential you can use and we once we then debate difficult situation with an organization of South Africa about this that we started out junior and investigation of a really really bad incident people have been killed and we established the company I heard they'd done some pretty bad things loss of control and there really weren't comfortable there's no question of that in this particular exercise
but partly through the investigation they found little things over to the wires so certainly rather than dealing with the company itself we were dealing with lawyers and their company was really building a castle for myself the preeminent defenses up to prevent us releasing what we've actually found real difficulty so please when you're doing something check with your legal position of your legal requirements who your accent is pointing to because for me that can be in a major pitfall the we need water well please judgmental listening thanks very much because I've essentially covered some of the
pitfalls as I see them based on the experience that I've had over quite a number of years and another in talking to my other team of investigators some of whom I think are listening this morning I think they would probably agree with everything I'm saying clearly there are further pitfalls but we can you know quite cover one of those in 40 minutes but very unhappy if nd wants to email me or contact me through Trish to give southern information okay thanks so much connect buses back to you Trish okay thanks thanks for that David that's
I think that was really useful we've actually got a couple of questions that have come through so far so and I've actually got one as well so I might first of all ask one of the two questions it's been asked by one of our our audience could you provide any more detail on the reference for a course on report writing so there's obviously some people online that are interested in understanding how to write incident reports more concisely that's that's a really interesting one Jill and on website this is the one area of inquiry more than
any other is about to report writing based attacks are very tricky one but I think that won't let me say that the first thing I have to say to the people in the street I can't teach you to write that was a job you a teacher at school what I can do is to teach her destruction report then each company may have a style which has to be reported if they don't hump that then I suggest you look around for one that suits well the job of the person right and report is to communicate and
he seems to to tell the story and if you keep the point of telling a story to the front of your head that that's what you're seeking to do is to tell the story of what happened however you put that time I'm back to this you know loo chaotic and a mid-range used to be that's very useful a very good style gate in fact that you might friend us can visit comes across as a hacking with business bill which really isn't is the newspaper the economists have a look at the economists and it is written
extremely well other videos to look at at the setting who you leader report so with photographs and diagrams and such pipe so for example if you to take a near accident investigation report it covers everything even things that do so for example it makes I can't remember the coding system there might say you know at one point two four fire there was no fire or two point eight three survivability this was not a survivable crash so tell people what has and hasn't happened and the other one I quite liked was the real axis Investigation Branch
they back here in the UK and we can get this safe online it is Google and the number the reports in the number side of the paragraphs every paragraph has got a separate number one two three four five and so on which I think better than they can academic type report but clearly the layer of having just an executive summary telling people what went wrong recommendations and very very strongly agreed and having a root cause diagram which logically shows what happens if you can read that essentially you probably don't need the whole report avoid parking
at all costs ensure that all abbreviations and the mornings are actually in the appendix so you know bear in mind you're waiting us to it for somebody to understand that's all okay thanks for that David so to anybody else on the line if you do have any questions you can actually type your questions in the question panel and they will pop up and I'll then ask them to David we have another one here interested to get some elaboration on variations in different parts of the world each year you mentioned some differences between Europe and the
USA so do you see any particular differences in practical sense around what you're doing in different parts of the world really aren't you fine I mean all right Mike Tim we've investigated you know many many countries around the world in terms of doing actual report I don't find too much difference of doing the accent investigation I think some of the problems really come with dealing with people in the sense that the cultural thing in certain cultures people want to tell you and what they think you want to hear you know you know yes mr. David
I don't tell me whatever so suppose that's a bit of an issue there rather than maybe they it was a stretch you know tell them how it is it's pretty straight the Scots are a bit like that as well it's not this difficult you know maybe to cut to the chase I think that's the problem I think the other problem is if you haven't get to use someone who you don't the language and then you enough to do it through it translator and I am emphasizing what translator not interpreter you know you get asked the
question and they just threw thee the interpreter of translator and you hear the bestest speaking Indian language nor sentence after sentence after sentence and then the interpreter said he said yes you know so that problem there in terms of I'd say if you've structured you'll approach whichever country you're in a shooting fight if you've got a good investigation approach it should actually work just the running through your mind at the moment all the different countries I fashion want and then don't see a big difference apart from in talking to the people certainly you've got to
look at how you manage your team and the big area in that for me is the ability to stick on time to tell not to do the job to do us to do and interviewing is always difficult at any point so really concentrate on the interview I think that's as much as I want to say okay just on that dainty I might ask a question so you said that you you don't assume that what someone tells you is basically accurate so how do you wade through all that different information and potentially conflicting information to actually
get to what is the truth I think that's a very difficult to answer but would you step away from instant investigation of such a lot of their management consultants in over the years and they go along you start talking with directors of the company it all seems very plausible than such my son gosh that's right there's only when you dig down through all the other people you talk to within the organization does a picture start to emerge and it's certainly true in terms of doing investigation if you talk to just one person and that is
really not satisfactory because they will tell you what they absolutely believed to be truth so for example I want I could think of where there was only one witness this fatality but that's by looking at all the other failures and the systems had to be supported by physical facts and as far as we could find them nine people and the real way incident now these nine people were the potential victims were nine of them who are likely to be killed in this particular situation so there absolutely nothing to hide nor was he trying to hide
anything but we got you know maybe not name different name different views but the depth and they were very different sense I've been saying difficult and to get much you got to look for as much proof as possible and I think if you put your hand in your heart in any investigation the end of you see how I got all the facts did I get everything like there's a very difficult one but talking to people is you have to structure it so you can get people to tell me as honestly they believes that telling you
they were study happens to be okay so following on from that we've got a question in here now that says a witness statements any use or is interviewing better the back of my head I thought must mentioned witness statements the thing number of reasons why I don't like with the stairs the first one is very often the person you're asking to write the witness statements may not in fact be all that good appointing a pen or whatever as a difficult skill for them and they're concentrating trying to get that right let me it collaborate other
people success them on the other hand if something happens you can't get there if they just write the headings don't that would be very very useful indeed if your distilled interviewer you get much more information in my view I'm not fond of witness dinners one of my colleagues did an investigation down in Brazil and it was an explosive plan and they said could I see the witness things no one said you know where you suddenly agree you're supposed to be standing yes when you're following procedures yes and so on so Jackie just stood out the
sheets I said what do you mean let me think you're on the red wonder with the explosion had been and one of the things that first ascended in stone in the correct position and of course for the person who sounds a great hole in the ground in the world has disappeared and so they had given the answer that yeah take the Box saying the center public was there whatever so I really think I think the school interviewer is the best way of the dream but clearly attention have to work with with with statements one funny
thing once it please don't record with this say interviews you tell them to police interview really just trying to have a note-taker can't train so many of the headlines I think student back across with people afterwards unless you interviewed a person so it ought to try to write notes but don't use a tape recorder if you possibly can avoid them okay thanks for that that's an interesting point because I think sometimes we do think I'll that might be the easiest way but there's obviously some nuances that get lost in that we've got another question which
I just wanted when I'm speaking of stupid 180 words a minute so if you multiply that by a 20 minute interview a half-hour interview that's a lot of words to go through if you've done 10 of 20 interviews so it's not all that useful thank you got another question here do you have a specific investigation method that you follow and gives you the structure I assume it's very difficult to get the right or useful information from the documentary interviews and facility procedures etc in in terms of what's evidence well I think this is a point
where we clearly are not you know that surely you know we are but one so I devised a system and says we've got top set you know many years ago and there that's involved we've worked on it so my team of water extensively where we have a very clear structure for working through the whole process and that's very fact and that's why we did the Macondo investigation but not work very well for us but you know there are other systems and they're some of my team of trained to use the tripod analysis method you feel
they got to have a structure and sadly I want the police forces may be the changing though well the police forces don't have a clear structure and we're fine police it was a silly David could we have some of your materials because we don't know anything as structured as that but in fact one of my very good investigators I was a very senior police officer in a particular part of the world and he said David I've even paid to come in an investigation with you and I've you know P I don't want to be killed
though all most people do investigation and just to compare assistants so it's very important in terms of their competency the team how do you know which skills you're going to need of the straightforward I mean I think a lot of people are talking to the snow the chemical areas of a chemical engineer groan I'm a food technologist originally so you need to have an understanding of that it's very interesting point in here you think what a real we stuff in the past and on a real we expert and it's easy to assume everyone else in
the room is an expert and remember doing stuff the London Underground there's a problem of something called the switch rail and I've trued up in the wall and London Underground's X philia was there and so David haven't got that point rate and at least I didn't look at what he was doing he was trying I looked at the other real big experts in the room and they didn't understand either so the danger is the assumption that people actually know everything about everything and that's not the case so it's difficult selecting the right person we've got
together a mixture people who've got the confidence not an exclusive thanks a lot about it no so I have to have the technical expert there I have to have a person yeah who's good detail predicting you've got the interview and so on so it depends on the size and severity of the investigation how many people you need okay good in terms of you mentioned the independence is critically important and that at times the organization will inadvertently or even at times perhaps deliberately try and influence that that independence or the findings and and that would result
in in them applying pressure in some way do you have any standard tips for people that are facing that situation where they are essentially being confronted with an ethical dilemma of being pressured to do something that they don't actually believe they've got the evidence for for that finding or such I think you've just gotta be tough and sinner or another killer frost last wing and the person the center within the company the company what did you achieve Edge's from the report said well if you do they get my name off the front so it's a
very difficult one it's very easy for us as an external reg'ment organization to see we're not doing that that's the problem with the South African one we had they didn't want to or the truth they wanted they - the truth we just can't be there so there's a and it's difficult for people to do I know that my undelivered that my doctor sent me an email last week she works in the Prison Service and she said that she had to be a whistleblower who said it was very uncomfortable to do that because so she didn't
do that there she did was a license it's a social worker person and of course a bank things could happen so I think it's a it's a moral dilemma and it's difficult people to do you have to do yeah I know from my own experience I was faced at one stage with an investigation where I had done the investigation and I had found issues with the systems and processes that were being used and a manager to levels above me rejected the report because he wanted it clearly to say that someone should be fired and as
a manager once removed from my position that was also then very challenging to deal with because I was not willing to change the findings from the report which I believed were accurate and felt that it would have been unjust had that person been punished with dismissal absolutely that's all the questions we have at the moment so what I might do is I'll just take back control to just close out the the webinar now so thanks very much for that David I think that was actually quite quite informative and and certainly I've done a lot of
investigations myself over the years in various different roles so I could certainly relate to to some of the the the pitfalls that you were talking about some of them I know that I have personally fallen into what I wanted to just very briefly run through with with the audience now is just some of the things that the Safety Center has been up to lately so we now have four different case studies released and in fact the fourth one that we released earlier this year is called offshore platform and it does have an incident investigation focus
on it so if you are interested in knowing more about those all of you on the line as Safety Center members means that your companies do have access to this material so please contact us and let us know if you have any questions about those in terms of some of the other activities that we've been doing earlier this year we published a couple of chapters into the OHS body of knowledge which was really designed to try and highlight for people a basic understanding of Process Safety it's particularly targeted at those that work as Occupational Health
and Safety professionals but it is actually quite helpful for a number of different different people including for example new graduate engineers or people within an organization that are starting to become a bit more aware of process safety there's some good information there and they're available as a free download from that URL of HSB okay dot org dot au lastly just some of the work that we're doing at the moment we're doing some more work in competency in terms of how to actually achieve competency in the range of different topics that we published in our first
guidance documents back in 2015 we're also doing some work on developing toolkits to implement the process safety metrics that we also publish back in 2015 this is to help with the consistent application we've got a project happening with undergraduate education where we're looking at developing some resources to assist universities in teaching Process Safety within their engineering undergraduate degrees and lastly we have a project on Process Safety in the 21st century and beyond we're actually launching this think piece that we've been working in collaboration with the Mary Kay O'Conner Process Safety Center in for for about
the last 18 months we're launching that on the first of October at the World Congress of chemical engineering in Barcelona and we will then be publishing that out very broadly and seeking further input and comments from people on that particular document as to what the challenges are of today and how we may overcome them to improve process thinking for the future if you have any further questions that you'd like to ask or if you'd like to send through anything that you'd like me to pass on to David at Kelvin top set then please contact us
at the Safety Center there's a couple of different ways you can also follow us on Twitter or check out our LinkedIn page the last thing I wanted to mention is that we're also doing another series of webinars we're actually doing those on behalf of I cami itself so these are actually courses that you would pay to attend or webinars you'd pay to attend we have six different webinars occurring over November and December and we'll be discussing in each of those each of the six pillars of process safety so knowledge and competence engineering and design etc
they'll be being hosted by myself and Suzanna Gaines who works for me as the deputy in the IME Safety Center it looks as though we've just got one more further question commit now it's - someone's actually thanked us very much David they really enjoyed the the webinar and I can certainly echo that I found it very interesting so thank you very much David for your time and contribution that you put into this I see my member webinar as a member of the ISC we certainly value Calvin top sets contribution and very much your contribution in
doing this webinar so thank you very much my pleasure thank you and with that we will close out the webinar have a safe evening or day wherever you might be in the world take care bye