kurk Cobain thought Penny Royal te was a Surefire hit but he ended up hating the Final inudo Mix so why did he choose to Performance solo on MTV Unplugged leaving his bandmates behind do it by yourself and did Courtney Love really help write it welcome to story behind iconic songs on soundscapes rock all right so the song we're talking about is Penny Royal te it's the ninth track on Nirvana's thirdd and final studio album in utero which came out in September 1993 but to really understand it we need to go back a bit in time
so Penny royal tea is a tea made from an herb that's been used as an abort atient since ancient times it's also been used in love potions and as a symbol of illicit sexuality in the 19th century Penny Royal was even sold in pill form to cure menstrual blockages which was a coded phrase for inducing miscarriage what is Penny Royal tea used for um if the fetus um is not thriving and has died in the womb and needs to be uh eliminated from the body this is an herb combined with other herbs in proper dosing
that will be used to effectively U do that in Kurt's journals a collection of his personal writings that includes diary entries lyrics and musings on various songs he was working on Under The Heading Penny Royal te he noted that it's a herbal abortive and added it doesn't work you hippie who do you think think he's talking to let us know in the comments below when it comes to who actually wrote the song things get a bit confusing there are two different statements from Kurt that seem to contradict each other according to Michael azerad Kurt said
he wrote Penny Royal te during The Bleak winter of 1990 in an apartment on Pear Street right after the band signed he said Dave and I were screwing around on a for track and I wrote that song in about 30 seconds and I sat down for like a half an hour and wrote the lyrics and then we recorded it but then there's another story from a 1993 interview with author Gavin Edwards for the book is Tiny Dancer really elton's Little John in this interview Kurt revealed that he actually wrote Penny Royal T together with Courtney
Love he talked about how much he loved making music with her but also mentioned that they probably wouldn't release their collaborations because it was a bit too reminiscent of JN and Yoko so here's where things get interesting even though Kurt said he wrote Penny royalty in just a few minutes the recording process for the song actually took years and went through quite a few stages Nirvana first performed it live on April 91 at the okay hotel in Seattle that poost [Music] [Music] [Applause] [Music] fast forward to October 92 two unfinished instrumental takes of the song
were recorded by Jack Andino at Word of Mouth studios in Seattle but these takes were missing vocals so it wasn't until February 93 that Steve Albini recorded the final studio version of Penny Royal for the in Udo album however Kurt wasn't happy with how this version turned out he told Rolling Stone magazine that the song was not recorded right and it should have been recorded like never mind because that's a strong song So Kurt had producer Scott lit remix the song again with plans to release it as a [Music] single they even planned to make
a music video and Kurt personally asked Anton corbine the director of the Heart-Shaped Box video to direct it however he declined so instead they brought in director Jeffrey plansker Kurt went as far as creating a mood board to show the vibe he wanted for the video but these plans were abandoned after Kurt's death in 1994 and the release was quickly pulled the timing was just too sensitive and the potential controversy around the song's topic was a lot to handle still a few hundred copies of this single got out before it was cancelled and then melted
down these rare copies are now highly sought after with prices reaching around $500 or more each in fact a truly 100% genuine version of the penny Royal tcd single is considered one of the top three most collectible Nirvana items then in 2014 the single was officially re-released as a limited edition 7-in vinyl for Record Store Day with only 6,000 copies available this re release was a big deal and the single even became the top selling vinyl single of Record Store Day in the US and hitting number one on the Billboard Hot 100 singles [Music] chart
Kurt's meticulousness with the song also showed during the MTV Unplugged session in November 93 the set list initially planned for Kurt and Pat smear to perform Penny Royal te together however during rehearsals earlier that day the band tried different approaches to the song including playing it in a different key and with Pat on backing [Music] vocals you have to do the power cord version of the G he was singing the harmony but had to go lower and quieter than usual which made it hard for him to find the final note in line with Kurt he
ended up slightly Out Of Tune and without much power behind his voice so it just sounded like mumbling in the background and Dave tried to help Pat find the Harmony but it wasn't working so they decided a barebones performance was better with Kurt doing it by himself are you going to not sing do it by yourself okay despite the issues in rehearsals this solo approach allowed them to do it right in fact Penny Royal T was the only song during the MTV Unplugged performance that Kurt played alone [Applause] now let's take a closer look at
the lyrics and their meaning in his book Michael azerad shared what Kurt said about the song He said I've known girls who tried to drink it because they thought they were pregnant it's a cleansing theme where I'm trying to get all my bad evil spirits out of me and drinking Penny royal tea would cleanse that away you have to drink gallons of it and I heard it doesn't work very well I've never found herbs to ever work for me anything gin sang and any of that other [ __ ] is all a bunch of hippy
left-wing fascist propaganda so when Kurt sings to still the life that's inside of [Music] me he's talking about wanting to cleanse his life and start fresh possibly through some form of self-abortion and the line warm [Music] milk references the remedies Kurt used to try to alleviate his gastrointestinal issues it also hints at his addiction since many use laxatives to combat the chronic constipation that comes with it Kurt also referenced another famous songwriter prone to depression by [Music] saying he explained that this reference to Cohen was his way of dealing with his depression though he said
it actually made him feel worse Cohen wrote many introspective songs dealing with death and his place in the universe something Kurt did as well another perspective is that royalty is traced through Bloodlines those who are anemic royalty are people who claim to be distant relatives of a Royal bloodline Kurt's use of this phrase likely comments on his rapid rise to being revered as a king in the music world or the lyrics could simply reflect Kurt's view of himself as a lazy weak figurehead who is depressed and sad and wants a new life so which interpretation
seems closer to reality for you and most importantly what does the song mean to you let us know in the comments thank you for watching and don't forget to hit the like button and subscribe if you haven't already see you in the next video [Music]