On advanced argumentation today the reason we picked this very broad label was because it can sort of mean anything because there's a lot of people who have lots of different questions from the local circuit so i want to accommodate them as much as possible in the broadest possible sense what we'll be looking at are argumentative techniques that i Think are not well enough used or in any case not enough used in many parts of the world and we'll cover those but having said that if you have any questions uh feel free to just make yourself
audible and ask the question you don't necessarily have to put in the chat like i'm very happy with you just interrupting me and if i'm going too slow if i'm going too quickly Obviously those are things that you can point out yep i think that's enough housekeeping but again feel free to jump in so i want to start with something very very basic but i think isn't done enough in debates and that's the idea of analysis at the level of the actor so usually speaking when people analyze debates they analyze Them at this level and
this level usually means something like if a motion is i know this house believes that israel should uh kind of or should not depends on the day build settlement or something then the analysis would be um at the level of israel so it would be something along the lines of um You know good for them bad for them etc now i think that this is very limited argumentative debating and i've made this point sometimes elsewhere as well that you need to do two different things which are sort of stay away from this so one is
analysis what you're doing is that you are breaking down the actor into different sub-actors so for instance what this would look Like is israel becomes you know a conglomeration of the urban left the conservative religious right um ultra orthodox jews local arabs living there um and then similarly like you know what does liquid think about this which is the ruling party what does the red and blue coalition think about this which is like sort of a different party all of those things so what this means Then is that you're not talking about israel holistically what
you're doing is that you're talking about israel within the context of the things which make up israel and then it becomes more interesting to debate this so for instance uh if the motion is you know is it it's good for israel to not build settlements anymore whatever instead of being like you know this is genetically good or bad for israel You're like we're going to analyze the incentives or six or seven actors in this debate and systematically show to you how all of these groups benefit by settlements not being built and if you do it
in that context then it becomes much easier to win the debate because you're compounding your analysis right like it's a lot more things to say about a lot more people But then the second thing that really helps here is not just amount of analysis it's also being more precise in your claims argumentatively so for instance if you say this is good for israel or bad for israel or whatever the problem with this is that you can't make a very strong moral claim but what if you make a moral claim about um local arabs living in
israel where you can say you know the three million arabs who Currently live within the confines of israel if you start building new settlements don't build new settlements these are the people who are most vulnerable in the region so they need to be protected so another thing that you cannot play around with is that when you have six or seven different sub actors you can choose how precise you are towards one which actor is more morally worthy of our concern all of Those things so you just have a lot more content to work with so
i would heavily suggest this the one thing i would make very clear now is that this doesn't just apply to countries or governments it also applies to like companies for instance so with companies you know like it can't it doesn't just have to be microsoft did this that microsoft holistically you know Is made up of like workers within that you know upper level versus like lower level hierarchy workers and then there's like researchers they are um foreign foreign workers they are financial stakeholders all of that stuff so lots of ways in which you can do
this with microsoft as well another example i often use is that you can often do this with social movements As well so for instance like you know black lives matter okay now let's take something i'm just going to take like local examples from now on because then it's difficult um what's the local example okay let's take like a local student group like a student action committee or something right like they're not just made up of uh in pakistan of like you know Just student action committee people there's different people within them right so there'll be
people from elite institutions non-elite institutions there'll be you know uh women in there men in there there'll be non-binary people in there they'll be like uh people from punjab which unfortunately happens to be the case but there will also be representation from Uh periphery area so-called you know people who have different lived experiences of being a student all of that stuff so even within the student action committee in pakistan there's so many different actors who are doing different things and all of them have different incentives to get into the committee all of them have different
incentives to keep fighting for the struggle all of them have different incentives why they Will stay or leave so always remember that like this sort of analysis below the level of the actor can be applied to a bunch of different actors it doesn't necessarily just have to be a uh specifically a country or a government are there any questions so far about this before i do the flip of this sort of the opposite of this any questions Okay it's either going that well or that badly let's do analysis above the level of the actor so
this is also like now should be intuitive right so like for instance in the israel motion israel itself is made up of uh a system right so for instance um israel is in the middle east so if there's an argument about how this threatens middle east instability you Should probably make it here israel also happens to be uh close to iran close to saudi arabia um close to a bunch of different places like lebanon jordan the list goes on but the point is how are these countries impacted the point at which israel starts building or
doesn't build settlements right um but then not just that further on israel is part of the international system so For instance if this increases the threat of a nuclear confrontation between iran and israel 10 years down the line then that impacts international security so what you're doing here is again trying to find analysis which fits above the level of the actor as opposed to below whereas this was all about breaking down the actor into different sub-actors What you're doing here is sort of the opposite which is you're taking this actor technically as a sub-actor and
then going above and beyond you find different argumentation there generally speaking um you can also do this for other things so like very similarly with companies you can be like you know um the financial system impacts if microsoft does something the global uh development impacts if Microsoft does something instead of just talking about like you know things within microsoft or microsoft itself and then finally with with social movements you can do the same thing so like taking the same example of the student action committee you could say that like you know anything that they do
can like you know inspire social movements in other regions within pakistan Or abroad elsewhere in south asia or something um so so again what you're doing here is again going above the level of the actor instead of only talking about the level of the actor um at the level of the actor you try to break them down and then try to bring them up and that's how you find a lot more argumentative analysis than you would otherwise are there any questions about This so far at all this entire thing that we've talked about anyone one
second let me check i think that's like okay great let's move on um let's talk about the next thing which is equally important so i okay so let's start very simple so there's this thing called a correspondence theorem In uh mathematics i think libraries came up with it or something it's very simple which in all it says is like you know if whatever makes x well x is the same thing that makes y y then x is like you know i'm using loose language here basically the same as why i i think this is important
in debates and it's often myth That we often define our terms through description as opposed to through outcomes so what does that mean and how does this impact debating um think about this think about the fact that like whenever there's a debate about the us you know or like any other country big country invading intervening in small country which is like you know a lot of the International relations debate topics which come up one of the things that often happens in this debate is that there's a strange hierarchy so the hierarchy goes something along the
lines of first we should try diplomacy then we should try you know partial diplomacy whatever it is um then we should try economic sanctions and you know finally last resort we go In with the guns right like this is sort of like uh the sort of orthodoxy within which i've seen a lot of ir debates take place um the the problem with this and i want to focus specifically on the economic sanctions and uh military intervention bit is that they this assumes that military intervention is different from economic sanctions now you would Say uh obviously
because you know one of them is about shooting people and then the other is about setting up a trade embargo or something but again they're different in terms of the description of the process but do we really care about that in debates unless you're making some sort of deontological argument like very rarely in debates do we care about The process by which outcomes occur be often much more care about the outcomes themselves because it's sort of consequentialist bent in the global debating circuit so then let's think about that in terms of outcomes is military intervention
so much worse than economic sanctions so for instance um the united nations published this report i think four or five years ago where they basically Talked about how you know over a hundred thousand iraqi children had died as a direct result of u.s economic sanctions and this had variously do its starvation malnourishment all of those horrible things right and when you think about this the like it sort of flips your intuitions about economic sanctions doesn't it because you know you don't Expect a hundred thousand kids to die because of sanctions in a way that you
would be much less surprised to hear if it was in a war like with the military intervention similarly think about the fact that sanctions also threatened your sovereignty because now other countries control what you produce sell by um like basically everything else on many Levels like short if you're trying to make everything else in your country your state sovereignty is now out of the window they're basically controlling what your people are eating they're basically controlling what your people are wearing they're basically controlling what your people are driving all of those things so sanctions also sort
of threaten your sovereignty and then you can also argue that like You know sanctions disproportionately just like with war impact the poor while the rich escape the point i'm trying to make here is that if the reason that military intervention is bad is that you know uh military intervention bad because lots of people killed plus violation of state sovereignty then this is something that's also Happening in the case of economic sanctions like they're happening in different ways and maybe even different scales but they're both still happening like these are definitely very similar things if not
the same thing and the reason i want you to think about this is because people often miss that you can flip arguments by Thinking about not just why is military sanctions good or via economic sanctions bad but sort of trying to equivalent them to be like you know there's an equivalence between the harm and benefit by sanctions and harm and benefits by military intervention otherwise common example i want to give you because i think it will help is the example Of one second physical and mental harm so often there's in debating there's a distinction drawn
here which is it sounds like you know physical harm worse than mental harm okay sure um you know sort of like make sense in a first step sort of way where you're like you know if someone hits you in the head with the baton seems more painful than depression sort Of thing but then how we how do we how do we flip this intuition because i think again if you think in terms of outcomes hard to draw a distinction between the two so what makes physical harm bad um physical harm is bad because well um
it might impair your body in some way also happens because of mental harm um Might lead to permanent damage also happens in the case of permanent heart of uh mental harm might lead to trauma also happens in the case of uh mental harm so like if you start like going through the distinctions for or even the definitions of why physical harm is bad instead of thinking about the process which is you know the hit in the head with the baton versus depression like The process are different but purely in terms of outcomes both seem very
similar then mental harm should probably be put on the same pedestal of concern that physical harm is because they both seem to be equally bad because they're equally back for the same reasons so i can keep doing this over and over but the general point is that this is really important you need to start equival Creating an equivalence between different arguments in terms of outcomes as opposed to in terms of processes and this will really help you strategically win in debates where you're defending the more extreme position when and then you're like wait what is
the distinction here anyway we're both defending pretty much the same thing and then we can argue on the merits So it becomes a very easy way to win debates in that sense um between different things in terms of outcomes okay are there any questions about this one at all i actually can't check so someone will have to okay that's let's hope that's a good thing um let's move on the third thing i want to talk about in terms of like advanced Argumentation is uh use of break vertical examples there's something i talked about recently elsewhere
but i think it's really important it's just uh often there is a bias in debates towards okay no i have to start like simpler okay so so there's two sorts of reasoning in debating um the first Is what most people would call logical or structural reasoning and then the second is what people call factual or trivial reasoning so factual and trivial reasoning is a lot more about the what of things and logic and structural reason is much more about the why of things so for instance if you want to make a claim like The the
u.s should or i know the imf let's pick the imf the imf is a bad actor to pakistan the way that you would make the factual slash trivial reasoning is to say something like imf's previous bailout to pakistan included terrible structural adjustment policies so you know which harmed Pakistan's economy so this is again you're giving an example here essentially so you're explaining the what of things and then the more logical structural reasoning would be something along the lines of one second my computer has gone here by would be something along the lines of why this
is true so imf has incentives to hurt pakistan in order to for instance um open up its borders To foreign multinational corporations um to exploit the cheap labor it has um to leverage against iran of china or something so again what you're doing here is that you're giving factual or trivial reasoning and then sort of explaining why that's the case is the logical of structural reasoning every claim on the planet should be made of these two reasons Which is a the facts be the logical structural reasoning so i really hope that this is like something
that you're already on board with because this is really important i think i might have gotten a question is creating an equivalence different from proving why an argument isn't exclusive okay that's actually a very interesting question i okay so so no ras if everyone can see this that Is creating an equivalence different from proving why an argument isn't exclusive no i do think it's different because here the intention is not to wash the argument right so often what we do when we try to draw exclusivity is to say something like you know you're arguing that
you have this good thing happening for you we're gonna argue we also have that good Thing happening for us because it's happening for things which are nothing to do with the debate so that's what you're trying to do there is to wash the intention here is different and important which is what you're trying to do here is lessen the extremity of your position you know military interventions are great compared to economic sanctions um you know the psychological trauma as An argument is just as important as physical harm like in order for you to advance those
sort of out of left field arguments you need to make analysis which makes both arguments controversial so again it's it's it's sort of like in a very nuanced way different from exclusivity it's much more about sort of almost reducing the controversy around your argument by showing that both Arguments are equally controversial if that makes sense does that make sense nor thank you okay great um okay so often the bases are biased towards structural or logical reasoning and and the reason for this is obvious so what will happen here is something along the lines of uh
you know pm will come up and the first Speaker will come up and be like um i have an argument which has an example right and then oh or like leader of opposition will come up and then be like yes but i have a counter example and at that point like you know your example doesn't count for much anymore because the leader of opposition can say i have a counter example which proves otherwise Or leader of opposition can say which is most often said but it's the same theme of things which is yes but that
example is not representative so even if leader of opposition does not even have a counter example leader of opposition didn't come in and very validly say you know sure but this specific example that you're giving is not necessarily representative of the broader thing that we're talking About how do you fix this problem i think the problem is that a lot of debating i've noticed assumes that examples are inherently weak ways to prove debates but this is not true in reality the problem is with the sort of examples you're using so the more constrained i will
explain what this means Within space and time your facts and examples are the weaker they are likely to be and the more they capture across space and time the stronger they are likely to be so what does this look like in a debating context um let's say that you're having a debate and then um someone comes in let's take the in fact the same argument you know pm comes in And says imf is a bad actor to pakistan and then the the the sort of factual or trivial reasoning that they're using here is to say
something along the lines of you know what we said here basically imf's previous bailout to pakistan included and then you just put here now remember that leader of opposition can just come In and say something like you know oh but what about this other bailout or what about this example is not representative so instead of using this specific fact maybe i am trusting him to do would be to instead say imf has issued 17 bailout programs in south asia none of them have ever been paid back back brought more broadly Of the 110 countries imf
has given money to to have been able to pay back and the rest are in that now the importance of doing something like this is that this example is so immensely broad across space in the sense that you know geographically and then also across time which we'll get to in a second what this means is that now they can't come in and say This example is not representative of you know uh the general reality or like you know i have a counter example because your example has so much factual immensity that it's impossible to sidestep
this example they now have to invest a lot of energy in rebutting this example and they are now on the back foot so always remember that what you are looking for Are these sort of examples you're looking for examples which are capture as much as possible across space and time and the less nerdy way of saying this is simply you are looking for trends and patterns is what you're looking for so if you can find trends and patterns for instance this is a trend this is a pattern um that's much more powerful as an Example
to use other than you know in 1993 even being as you would like that that doesn't necessarily matter like because they can just be like in 1998 when the washroom was and then like the counter example keeps happening so always in debates try to find research and facts and empirical examples which uh capture as much as possible across space and time and this will be true for anything so For instance if if you want to make a argument about how u.s is not a reliable actor to militarily intervene anywhere you know it has bad intentions
all of those things as a sort of argument you're trying to make and then instead of using the example of you know um look at what happened in iraq because the other side can come and say you know Look at what happened i mean this is debatable but like you know look at what happened in kosovo so you know they'll be like you know sometimes they're good sometimes they're bad you haven't proved anything here but if you do something like you know um over the last 120 years the us has illegally intervened in the regime
change of over 60 countries also happens to be True by the way so you know like once you say this they can't come back with this their singular example of kosovo right and here what you're doing is instead of going across space which is what we're doing here we're going across time that there's a historical trend and pattern where the us continues to do this so they can't come in and say that they're going to be Any different now um i hope that makes sense because this is a really important point in terms of using
empirical examples i do think there's a question though um how do you sound more persuasive when making a factual claim or a trend considering that judges can't fact-check um i mean i would just just as persuasive As you would sound when you're making a factual example does that make sense so like so i don't intend for this to replace structural and logical reasoning which will still be part of debating it's more to replace really bad empirical examples used right now because they will consistently run into the problem of uh you know being washed by a
counter example Or being shown that there is a representation or a generalization problem there so i think the question sort of assumes that you know uh this is intended to replace this logical structural reasoning but you would run into pretty much the same persuasive problems that you were using any examples and in this case you're just using an exponentially better Example more generally though whether you're using a limited example or a much broader example in terms of fine sounding persuasive to judges about um uh your facts like it helps to be persuasive in the sense
of being precise so for instance if you say like you know this is like you know when you ask your friend like have you Seen that movie oh yes yes with the with the hero and yeah that was that was good like you can clearly tell they haven't seen the movie but if you're like uh have you seen the movie but they've read the wikipedia page because they're sneaky like that you'll be like yes john cusack was fantastic in that and the production value was 100 million what a great movie and then you're like okay
maybe maybe maybe they've seen the movie So similarly here as well like precision and accuracy really helps because if you're like you know a world bank report from 2015 pointed out that there were six different bailout packages given to you know greece portugal ireland spain pakistan bangladesh respectively and this is what happened it sounds so precise it almost sounds hard to be made up i know this sounds weird but like This is like a precision bias we all have as opposed to you being very good things so that's like one tactic i would suggest for
you know sounding more persuasive with your fact checks um okay great wait so sorry was that a comment generally or was that a question i'm confused by the punctuation of this so um i think it's a question like you can move on Okay okay um so examples showing a trend or behavior fact-based precise backwards precise examples are better um good question so i think generally speaking in debates uh trends and patterns are much much much more useful than precise examples are and this is actually sad you know because a lot of the culture behind debating
around for instance prep motions and pakistani debate tournaments is All about not just uh university students but specifically getting school kids to learn more about the world so so i think it's it's unfortunate that the activity rewards you know vague knowledge about general trends as opposed to by specific knowledge about specific things but i think um it is what it is right like and also like trends and patterns knowing them isn't necessarily bad Information either so the short answer is unfortunately the activity generally tends to reward trends and patterns over precise very specific examples i
think i'll give you one case where that might not be the case so for instance um let's just say that you're debating um let's say that you're doing this um where is it yeah so let's say you're doing this like This analysis below the level of the actor now in the analysis below the level of the actor if you're going to talk about how local arabs in israel are split over the settlement issue depending on where they live in jerusalem or tel aviv this requires you to know things about israel to a lev at a
level of precision which requires you to Research that much right so there will be sometimes cases where this precision and nuance helps and this will usually be in the context of you really zeroing in on a very specific subgroup subgroup and then trying to find some nuance analysis there in closing for instance but outside of those cases like i think trends and patterns still work in fact trends and patterns are a More economic way to research in the sense that um let's just say so you know how like this like unfortunately not enough debates about
the african continent people just throw out like you know countries like africa and speeches because there's no nuance there unfortunately but think about it this way let's just say that you want to like you know make a Matter file on the african continent or the european continent or the like um you know the asian continent one way to do it is to now systematically read through the histories of like 50 different countries on the african continent or like uh you know 35 different countries on the european continent another way to do it would be trends
and patterns right so you know generally speaking on the African continent what is the infant mortality rate trend generally speaking on the african continent what is the trend of development aid inflows and outflows what is the general trend towards democracy now obviously the problem there is that there will always be nuance that you're missing right because the difference between like sudan and the congo is probably all the difference In the world but in a world where you can't have enough time to research this trends and patterns things really helps because it helps you have a
general feel for each part of the world as opposed to having very precise knowledge about one country and i'm trying to incorrectly apply it to other countries in the region which i think is actually worse So i hope that also answers the question [Music] um i'm not gonna say this later on so tanya how about you become audible and ask the question is that right no no problem to the other tanya uh but yeah yeah sure so i just wanted to ask like it's usually the case with like econ or ir emotions that you have
like a lot of specific knowledge on that particular Motion or you know like so much about middle east or like that particular territory that you have like so much of that knowledge but you don't exactly know how to exactly strategize in like when you're case prepping but also like how to use that specific knowledge and like uh in arguments or like how much do we need to say all of that information when you're contextualizing the debate as well So like how do you prioritize that okay okay um i okay so this is actually a surprisingly
the broad question but i think the way i will put it is something along the lines of think about this way so if you so a good test in terms of knowledge is what bits of knowledge the judges absolutely need to know in order for my argument to make sense And they have to be those bits of knowledge because without those bits of knowledge your argument doesn't make sense and in those bits of knowledge you can be as precise and as specific as you want to be so for instance and this is a good test
it's like the argumentative minimum that's right like what the number of axioms you need to believe in order for my argument to be Operational and that's what you're doing here so let's just say that you're making an argument on um let's take something like in from financial economics so let's just say that you're making an argument on how apps like robin hood which like you know lower barriers to uh to entry in the market for like uh Investors who don't have a lot of money they cause equity bubbles which leads to you know a commodities
crash down the line now in order for you to make this argument the judges need to know what the financial economic transmission mechanisms are right why does increased speculation lead to increased hurting lead to increase in the speculative Value of like equity x which leads to more herding which leads to the bubble expanding which has problems because the equity might be invested in uh different financial services which might have knock-off impacts on more stable things like commodities in the form of houses or whatever it is so so in order for you to make the argument
They need to understand the economic science behind it why does impactx lead to impact y and so so it's almost like making the arguments impact intuitive you know there's this joke about how sometimes in debates like people would say something along the lines of uh we killed someone and then someone died right like like in in killing and physical harm and all of those Things impacts are actually very intuitive it's very easy to be like you know this is impact x this is impact why but in economic and ir emotions in order for you to
get to the impact you have to make sure they understand what exactly happened here so for instance if you tell the average person you know uh if the central bank prints more money it causes inflation it's not obvious why like you need to Explain why that's the case so i think that's the threshold i would say which is what the minimum number of facts that we definitely need to know in order for the argument to make sense and then outside of that it depends i think the only other exception i would draw here is to
say that um examples can often be used or this sort of specialized knowledge can often help within closing teams so for instance in Opening teams they'll always be broad debates especially in finance and ir motion so in finance and ir motions the opening teams are going to come in and they're going to say the typical things about you know democracy or financial stability and all of those things in order for you to win at closing you often need to have a specificity that the opening teams have not had and that specificity is your virtue So
for instance um in a debate about i don't know the t-grade liberation on the tigre people's liberation front in uh ethiopia or the rakhine salvation army in like uh in myanmar like if you know specific things about these armies and dissident movements that other people don't and they're just making the generic arguments about why you know protect the minorities and prevent u.s Intervention and all of those things then you can come in and win the debate and part of that is not just having a better argument part of that is also posturing to the judge
that you know incredibly more about this than the opening teams do so it's almost a credibility problem so once you establish that level of credibility it becomes much easier um i hope that makes sense Are there any other questions okay uh i will keep moving on then just check i think the fourth thing i want to talk about is okay i've most often taught this to western team so this example is difficult but like i can i i'm sure i can think of like a islamic example but like um you know there's this idea of
um David versus goliath which comes from the bible and all it means is like you know david is like you know human or doubt in this case like is a he's a human being and then like fights against goliath which is like a massive thing and then david sort of wins and we sort of use this colloquially to mean like you know a contest between a big power and a small power right that's what you would call like a david Vazquel i think this is obvious um i want to talk about how arguments should always
be in search of david even when defending goliath this is really important um how does that work so for instance um let's say there is a debate about like you know microsoft or amazon or some big company right there's something happening there etc And then you're making the argument that they should be regulated more slash broken up into smaller companies like something is happening to them which like you know is like more um government intervention or something so you are on this side and on this side it's easy to make the arguments of you know
um these companies are exploitative to workers God that was such horrible spelling exploitative to workers they are exploitative to consumers let's take two one very proud of myself they are exploitative to consumers etc so then you win the debate and then the other side also has to have an argument right but the other side in this case is in a strange david versus goliath contest because um opposition seems to be in the awkward position Of defending goliath which is microsoft and the thing is that like the global debating circuit is actually like shown that like
it's not just the global debating circuits like most of us across the planet but like debating circuit has a very strong what's called in sociology underdog bias like we would much rather that like someone have make a hundred thousand Pounds the first time then make it the 20th time the same year sort of thing right like you know if someone is significantly weaker than the other person our intuition sort of like aligned towards that specific person um now in that world you are in the awkward position of defending goliath which is like microsoft even though
this could debate would literally be about the syrian government Or like you know the big government versus a little guy it could be lots of different debates but there's often david versus goliath sort of position set up so you're here now you're like okay what do i do because they keep saying microsoft did bad things to workers and consumers and we're like you know but don't hurt microsoft you sound like they're corporate lawyers so how do we get out Of it and the way to get out of it is to search for david within goliath
so what this would look like is you'd be like wait so you have to prove that microsoft being regulated might lead to workers of the most vulnerable kind being hurt consumers of the poorest groups Being marginalized and then you win the debate so what you've done here is that instead of and how you do it would be like you know look microsoft isn't just microsoft so we're not defending microsoft what we are defending are some of the most vulnerable workers who work for microsoft namely workers like you know abroad workers on low wages these are
workers who would be the first to face The x if microsoft gets more regulation that that has to put money into or if it's broken up or whatever it is right so these are people who are going to be the first ones to go from their jobs not the richer people who are higher up in the company so if you want to protect those wonderful workers you need to make sure that you don't regulate microsoft so what you've done there is that you're Still defending goliath but you're doing this in the context of like you
know pretending to like or at least these valid arguments on either side but at least posturing by saying that you're actually looking out for david and you will notice that this is a very common way to debate in our politics as well so in politics like no one will say by the way i hate the poor right like no That's not a very common slogan but even a right-wing government would say um you know tax breaks for the rich are important because they open up the economy hire more poor people do more charity etc but
if this right-wing economically right-wing government had said taxes for the rich are important because they are my best friends not a lot of people would vote for them right so We do this all the time we often have uh in politics people defending goliath but they're doing it in the context of defending david um i mean there's obvious examples in pakistan as well can anyone think of an example in pakistan where goliath is often defended by you know thinking of david publicly anyone okay is everyone just that apprehensive about naming an example or Do you
want me to just uh throw one out there okay no that's fine um okay what do you mean by that uh okay so we have two different examples so so let's take uh uh ajwa what do you mean by the bdm does that no no you can also be audible by the way but if you're not comfortable being audible you can say it on the chat but feel free to be audible wait can't can't everyone speak i Thought the default was that anyone can be unmuted at any time i didn't know that sorry i i've
been expecting like um audible interruptions throughout yeah so i mean like uh the alliance of pdm and the way they try to kind of like argue for their for their like very for their party to like come back into power even though it's full of like dynastic rich people who are going To keep on exploiting the poor is by saying is by like tap going into how like what they want is for like the poor what they want is like for the poor to do better and extra so like they kind of use that same
strategy yeah yep no that's true in fact i i think that argument actually cuts across both ways before that um i just want to check tanya if anyone wants to unmute themselves and speak they're they're Allowed to do so right like they don't have to ask um so they weren't allowed to do so but i think we have like changed the settings now okay there will be everyone yeah yeah you guys can do it now okay great um but but anyway so so i think that pdm example sort of cuts across both ways because on
the pdm end it would be the argument of Uh you know uh sort of like you know like i know that corruption is endemic but at the same time like this is a necessary component of policy making all of that stuff just one second rehan and then but i think the argument is also made in the opposition camp to the pdm where if the pdm for instance critiques like uh like a goliath institution like the army Or something then the anti-pdm camp would make a very oddly similar argument where they would be like yes but
in reality the reason that we need to protect the goliath in this case the army is to ensure stability for the masses for the poor so note that both of them are using the same david but they're defending different goliaths it's it's actually very interesting and It's very pervasive across all of our politics um rihanna you had a question i'm pretty sure you can be a mutant um yeah my question is that um if you're saying if you're trying to defend the big countries who are invading the smaller countries then the opposition can say that
the big countries are villains because um one can one big country is not can Really attack but the other big country is trying to attack or like have some political leverage in order to show their power so these small countries are getting sucked up in their power vacuum or like their hunger for power so how do you defend from the gulf side no but but you argue that you're going in to protect the people of that country right like like Never would even america make the argument of i mean with the exception of afghanistan which
was absolutely nuts but like the never is the argument made that like you know we need to go into country x in order to protect ourselves like the argument that's consistently made in public discourse is we need to go into country x to protect the people of country x often against Other people in country acts for instance like a civil war in rwanda or by government x which would be the case in kosovo and uh libya and all those places so i i think that that clash sort of assumes the government argument being made badly
but i think that government argument will be made the way we're talking about here right like goliath would defend its interest by Simply saying we're going there exclusively to help the davids which are in this case the poor people of whichever country is being intervened in within that motion if that makes sense does that does that sort of answer your question yeah just a small extension um would you mind you won't cause one um for example there is a faction in kashmir who does really want kashmir to Be independent they don't really want to go
neither from to the pakistan side or neither to the indian side so what are the ins so what should i talk about these small countries who want to be liberated from or like doesn't really want any big countries but the big countries are literally wants to um devour it in the name of political safety or any kind of Providing safety so what do you think about that what do you mean like in what context like in as in like ethically and intellectually or do you mean like how would this come up in a debate um
like um think of it as like um these countries do really want to be liberated but they are getting constantly uh um dragged into these kind of political power vacuums Yeah so how should you defend these countries or like how should you uh the opposition should try to defend the small countries to antagonize the big countries so how these smaller countries incentives are not really taken into consideration and we are always talking about the big countries i mean but that's like if you're saying this in the context of judges not realizing that smaller countries are
Important stakeholders then that's just a problem with bigoted uh judging so so i i think then the problem occurs not at the level of you making the argument where the level of who's listening to the argument so that may be like a cultural problem in the debating community i didn't recognize and perhaps you've pointed out but i think outside that it's actually very intuitive to make the The smaller country or smaller stakeholder argument because there you're not making the numbers argument right like smaller groups are by definition smaller so you help less people by helping
them but you make it in the context of duties right that a these big countries have done things to these small countries which means that they owe a moral obligation to fix those problems now B these people have suffered a lot more again the underdog bias than um people in these big countries have so we should care about them more so there's a lot of ways in which you can make this argument which doesn't have anything to do with the size of the country does that make sense yeah that does really make sense and it
answers the question perfectly thank you okay no no problem um any other questions before we move on Now that people's yeah going on i'm going kind of to the extreme right wing um route and this might just sound horrible but gone uh yeah so in the pandemic uh companies are downsizing uh they're they're downsizing their employees and that's something that is inevitable for the company's survival yeah now okay yeah that directly Supports the capitalist at you know the basic surface level but if we try to prove that this is important for two reasons that the
products of the company is producing and selling out to the market it needs to retain the same price value so it does not put an added pressure to the consumer who already has less earning than before Yeah and secondly the competitive market needs to exist so does this validate then does this validate what exactly uh does this validate the debate not being um just horrible stakeholder analysis um i don't know about that i i think i think i think the anal if you mean ethically probably yes but i think in a purely argumentative sense no
because I i think it's a valid argument to make like empirically at least i'm sort of like normatively agnostic as to whether it's a good thing or a bad thing because you know it's like the lockdown argument like especially where i'm i'm in in london right now like uh should we lift the lockdown or not there is a very real argument for the deaths caused by the lockdown versus the deaths caused by Not having a lockdown now you can land on one side of the trade-off and say fair enough we need to care about the
epidemiology or the epidemiology is necessary to care about before we care about the economy but i think in all of these cases there is analysis there and i agree it's not great to listen to it's ethically also not the best but but i would i would consider it to be valid analysis maybe i'm more charitable As a debater than like some other people are but like i i think that's uh that's that's valid analysis in my opinion um does that make sense yeah um are there any other questions before we move on i have one
question but it might be like it's about the example for related to that so the thing is like um yeah there are some like emotions or areas that you don't know specific knowledge About you know you know our vague things right so like what do you do in those kind of situations because then you are at a particular like disadvantage so how do you make your big enough analysis like like sound not bad okay so let's just say the debate is about like you know let's take the worst example it's about a random country Which
is random to you but not to like every everyone else and it's like it would be racist to think that like you don't know anything about this country and now you're debating about this country and you somehow need to make arguments about this country um i think there's a couple of things that you can do there so one is and i've obviously like talked about this before Is do you know things about not one specific country next to them but hopefully general trends but or even one specific country next to them worst case which might
display a trend so for instance if pakistan and this is hypothetical if pakistan has extremely high infant mortality it would be really surprising if afghanistan has extremely low infant Mortality knowing nothing about the two of them if um sudan has extremely low literacy it would be very surprising if neighboring congo has extremely high literacy it's because most things tend to geographically correlate and the reasoning for that is because the environmental factors are more or less the same Even though you have like you know borders drawn up in different governments and whatnot so often they'll be
more or less the same they're not equal you can think of some examples which are not true so for instance you know the us and the can and canada are pretty similar but the us and mexico aren't right so there's some exceptions generally but like like 99 percent of time you can Look at things around that specific thing and then sort of extrapolate information from that and be like okay if this was happening in country x more or less must be happening in country why so you can start talking about that but the second way
in which i will answer your question is actually the next thing i wanted to cover so we can get to that now Or does this also for now partly answer your question and then you can also tell me like jump in and say like if it doesn't answer it later is that fine yeah yeah okay great um in fact let's let's just do this here so actors versus actions so in debates you can run into some problems such as the one that ajwa pointed out which can Be a problem of knowledge you simply don't know
enough about something to make it a defensible argument you can also run into a problem of ethics where you simply are defending someone that you would rather not defend you also just run into a problem of reasoning more generally which is like you know you can't think of good reasons to Defend this person irrespective of what you think about them and how much you know about them in this case it is crucial that you move away from making arguments about the actor to making arguments about the action and this is how i've seen like a
lot of clever debaters been very been very very tough rooms pretty easily think about this way let's say the motion is This house believes that um this was actually the oxford semi-final i think this year it was it was really stupid it was something like this house believes that the this house as okay you know let's not do that it's so complicated that won't make sense let's just do a simple motion this house believes that the rakhine salvation army should be sanctioned By the west for its illegal military actions or this house believes that like
i'm going to keep it even more simple this house believes that the new uh the new military government in myanmar okay this is really easy should be sanctioned by the west for its recent coup this is the motion and in this motion you might not even know that a coup has occurred well a coup occurred in myanmar But and you're like okay the coup occurred don't really know much about that so be taken off guard by that but then also you're like but who is the new military government also don't know who that is why
is the west sanctioning them sort of no maybe because like you know something happened about the rohingya and myanmar but that's about as much as i know and then what you do there is that you Just completely ignore the terms of the debate which is the new military government in myanmar should be sanctioned by the west for its recent coup i would just be like this is a topic about actor x being sanctioned by actor y this is the first way i would read it and then what i would do is give lots of reasons
Sanctions work and lots of reasons they don't depending on which which side you're on another way to look at this motion is military government in developing world is sanctioned by west and now you're like okay lots of reasons that helps like you know it brings them to the negotiating table it makes them more likely to listen to western demands and Like you know also like lots of reasons that it doesn't so you know the that uh they double down now they have a strong man complex they need to show that they respond with the west
they can't act weak in front of it so these set of reasons you came up with about the action that is being taken which is in this case sanctions without knowing anything at all about the new military junta about Myanmar per se about the west about the recent coup because you're focusing on the sanction and if you can focus on the sanction part chances are that you can probably win the debate and you can do this in lots of places like if a topic comes up about how should should this like your niche um activism
movement use writing or violence as a tactic Instead of focusing on what the movement is and panicking just be like you know 10 reasons for why violence works or like 10 reasons or why violence doesn't work depending on which side of the debate you're on so you can often make the argument in the context of the action as opposed to the actor and this also happens to answer i think ajwa's question insofar as it shows that You can sidestep the entire problem by focusing on the basically the verb in the motion um does that make
sense ajwai did you have any further comments there can i ask a follow-up question to that uh yeah i just wanna before you do that no i just want to check if uh uh ajwa was cleared up there was that fine yes yes okay great right so uh the kind of technology that You told about or let's say about the action should be focused when you don't know much about the actor so it's context specific so even though telling how word is bad you can like there was a recent motion uh about japan if i'm
not wrong at yale which actually required specific knowledge about the context of the area so even at openings you could not go far without Telling how war is bad and how defense your offense actually works but you actually acquired quite specific knowledge for that to go deep which is why people with less knowledge of that could end like what should what is a better thing to do in that context to strategize and how to pick up a context or make it relevant within like a specific little amount of time um Okay so so one uh
i'll just make this clear for everyone else listening so there was a motion about how the so the japanese government currently has constitutional provisions for only having what's called a self-defense force which means this is constitutionally a force which can only attack in defense against aggression but uh there was a motion about whether japan should sort of scrap that and have like a Military force which can intervene other places as well and obviously the question is how do you do the thing i just said but not in opening i think actually because opening gets lost
in the details like i've often noticed there will be a debate about the imf and like some random african or latin american or asian country and they would just like spend so much time showing the context of that Country the context of the imf and then like someone would come in in closing and be like seven reasons the imf is bad and then take a first in the debate and walk away so one i would say i i push back against this idea that like you know in debates like these everyone takes the obvious stuff
in opening i think especially with debaters there's a tendency to flex their you know information as much as Possible like you know i read the economy so i know what you're talking about so i'm just gonna spend the next four minutes like citing from the article or whatever so i do think that often happens so closing often has a lot of space to just make generic arguments about you know japan will be bad at having a force like this people in japan might be sad at them having a force like this China might be angry
at them having a force like this and the reasons many reasons why that's bad america might be sad that they do something like this so so again i think you will still have lots of intuitive argumentation left still but however assuming that's not true um let's say that they've taken those things how do you reframe the debate i think That's a general question about extensions and if i'm not wrong my friend taha is giving an entire session on extensions if i'm not wrong but um the short answer here would be that you either fill the
analytical gaps which is to say they made the argument that they made it poorly so you figure that out um or you use the strategy that i actually discussed with taha a few months ago so I hope it comes up in his discussion which is known as the wash way new metrics actually so whenever you're speaking in extension sorry this is a digression but i think like it's an important thing for you guys to know anyway you generally should focus on these three things wash means to make the analysis of opening irrelevant Way means to
have better analysis on same point as opening and then new metric means is to have different analysis arguments from opening if you can do all three in extension you will never lose a debate so i'll give you a very simple quick example here so so so rocket so rakim just asked me a message about like you know don't you think japan must have an army or force to get rid of the american Resistance assistance regarding the defense of the what are variously known as the uh south china sea islands like you know the singapore diu
islands and i i think yes but i i i wasn't being prescriptive here so the idea wasn't that i was endorsing in japan can't do this it was more that uh uh that was in the context of the debate however if you message me on facebook or something i'm very happy to have like a Uh more extensive discussion on you know like east asian politics because i find that really interesting uh but yeah so how would you do this so let's just say that this is very simple motion which is like you know um this
came up like before euros like you know um you are a young talented professional in the balkans which is Like you know um europe but not really europe would be the joke from my friends in the balkans but i basically mean places like um serbia etc here and then the motion was this house would travel to live and work in the eu sure fair enough so opening does all of the obvious stuff og will do all the obvious stuff about you know how you know good for you because eu Much bigger more market more jobs
better jobs better standard of living all of that stuff who came in and then said like you know bad for you because uh lots of racism against you much more much bigger problems with um competing against more skilled people um will generally face discrimination this is all stuff that Came up in so we were ceo and what we did was we were like we have to wait we have to wash we have to have a new metric so how did we uh weigh so first we went towards oh and we said that oos so we
said os claims are about how this is economically bad for you and then we gave like three better reasons so one was just like you know Purchasing power parity like you know a serbian currency denomination counts for much less in europe the second would just be different educational standards so even if you're an extremely talented student in serbia just like you are often in pakistan because of global problems recognizing educational qualifications your qualifications just don't count the same in many places abroad such as the eu And then there was something about how you're competing against
like you know global pool as opposed to local pool because you know in europe you're competing against like indian doctors and nigerian engineers like you're not just competing against uh uh people within your own community so this is how we sort of weighed and got our way out of like proving o zone claim better than they did But then we weren't done right because we want to win on every metric so then the second would be to wash and the wash is to make analysis board openings irrelevant so we said both openings had long term
analysis about living here versus not living here and we said that is irrelevant because serbia is about to join the eu in five years which would mean that living in serbia Would be same as living in the eu so in that case this debate doesn't make sense so so then we were like then the only arguments that exist in this debate are necessarily short-term arguments which is what we did with the new metric thing so we were just like our new metric is the psychological trauma of being dependent on immigration status and then we talked
about lots of things how once you move into this area You consistently have to keep the same bad job in order to not lose your immigration status you could literally be kicked out legally for any reason if the country wants you to whenever you move into a new neighborhood it's all about getting the documentation signed you're so constrained in so many parts of your life it is which relationships you should start with relationships You should keep because you never know when you will be asked to leave the eu so there's lots of psychological trauma which
comes from being an immigrant within the region so we just use that as our new metric and that's how we attempted to win by a weighing their reasons against our reasons for the same claims b washing their arguments and then c drawing up a new metric so this was a very long answer to that Question but i think like the answer is that like everyone should generally know this this is a very useful tactic in coming up with analysis when you otherwise don't have any no does this make sense yep it does now thank you
okay great are there any other questions and can also like someone discipline me for time like what how how long do we want this to be um as Long as you want uh there's a question in the comment side of the chat box by the okay um let me try to open it i don't know how i would do that there we go okay sorry that's added this question and the question is what you said about lack of knowledge definitely makes sense in terms of ir but how do you do that for econ motions Specific
to countries um oddity do you want to make yourself audible and then like throughout a specific motion maybe we can very quickly look at that if ality is still here she might have just given up considering i spent like 10 minutes from the last question okay there we go yeah so i don't have a motion in mind but like uh when you're debating in india so you have like very specific uh indian Economy like related to those motions which we probably don't know about or even in global terms also there are these economic motions which
are very specific in terms of the economies of specific countries so like how do you then go about debating so okay but can you can you can you give me an example of not emotion but like what you're talking about because i'm still uh unclear on what you're getting at Here uh okay like any example um okay so if if it's about a banking system or say uh like you were talking about bailouts also right and i just don't have any clue about how all of this works at all and like i i might have
a very vague idea but not like if i could make a very strong reasoning or analysis so Uh like in aya you said that you know you can go about talking about countries which are very closer or like in terms of like generalized in generalized terms but then economic it becomes difficult uh doing that in economic motions right and that's specifically because the action that you would be analyzing the transmission mechanism you just don't have enough knowledge about how that Works is that the case yeah yeah yeah okay okay so for instance like if the
motion is like you know uh this was an actual again motion at oxford which was horrible but something like uh this house would not buy bonds from the venezuelan government now you're stuck in a bit of a bind here because a you have to know what's happening in venezuela so that's the first bit But then the second bit is what are bonds why does buying bonds matter and how does not buying bonds lead to outcomes so so that's like a classic example of the sort of motion you're probably talking about right i think there what
we try to do at least was then just make it much more about the country as opposed to the action so you can sort of flip the analysis right so it'll be all of the stuff will then be about Um you know venezuela doing better or doing worse or characterization analysis basically and waiting for the other team to say something unless you're og as opposed to uh specifically looking at the action now you might say what if i don't know either and i i you know what like i think there's a implicit search for an
answer there and i think i'm going to be A good person here and say that the answer is that you have lost the debate probably because that's just a bad motion setting or that's like setting inaccessible motions or you know what maybe it's your fault or my fault for not reading up enough about that part of the world or not reading up enough about um you know uh specific financial mechanism so yeah i i think implicit in your question is uh What if i know nothing i need to win and i think the answer is
you've probably lost because you lost like two weeks ago when you didn't read up about it so i i i i don't think i have a very satisfying answer here but i hope that helps someone yeah it definitely makes sense okay okay that that's all i can hope for from that answer um Great one new message oh wow that's a long one okay okay bob can you send this to everyone so that everyone can see this because then i have to read out the whole question and this is lengthy so what is it okay so
how do you deal with factual claims that you know are clearly wrong but isn't intuitive to the average reasonable judge And b is fundamental to their case yeah no i remember this like you know ethiopia having a coastline means saudi arabia wants to be friends with them ethiopia doesn't have a coastline eritrea has a coastline which is next to ethiopia so that that is pretty close now that's fair um i don't think there's an answer there because again um it's a flaw in the activity right so let's just say that you're a debater From pakistan
and you're in in like a room with three british teams being judged by a british judge now hopefully when you say something about pakistan they believe it but at the same time if they might not believe it because everyone else has a very similar knowledge it can't even be about pakistan could be about something else um and i think the answer there is just like you know I don't know the answer probably is people will keep doing that and we need to hold people to account and debating is a good faith activity like i've seen
people like lie a lot to win finals and you can't do anything about that and again all you can do is to keep reading and hope that the average reasonable judge or average reasonable voter of directors becomes much more likely to know these things so That's part of the culture of the debating community that we want to change to make it more global but two to make sure that like cases aren't one uh on the context of singular facts right like like if they literally won the entire debate on the premise of ethiopia having a
coastline then that was either a bad debate or a bad judge right because i can still Think of several reasons for why despite the coastline like there are many reasons why saudi arabia wouldn't want to be friends with them so like i i think it sort of goes both ways um finally this the question by nadeem which is if i add more um emotional stuff or retric um does that work as a new analysis compared to the opening half um [Music] i think it depends on what what you call it right because like i would
i wouldn't call it emotional stuff or that trick i would call it like uh like a principal analysis for instance would definitely count as legitimate closing material so for instance if you have emotion about like you know this house believes that the military government in myanmar should be Sanctioned by the west for its recent coup um and then you are ceo and you're saying it shouldn't be in co if you're in like a principally pure argument about how the violation of myanmar sovereignty is the most important thing in this debate it's not a great argument
but it's an argument that is legitimate and you can maybe even win the debate on it so so you can make principal arguments which Aren't hung on outcomes but i don't think that it necessarily needs to be like just pure that trick because then that's actually very hard to prove i say this is like having jokes in like 80 of my speeches so it works sometimes but i would i would heavily suggest against it um any other questions yeah i have a question um how about tanya first and rihan go ahead tanya Okay no worries
tanya can go first one yeah so like i usually have heard like judges talking about how like maybe that one particular argument was actually good but it wasn't maybe impacted enough so like even if you are doing the impacting how how do you know that like this impact of an argument is like plausible enough to complete that particular that one argument and like you know that like This argument is complete and like you can actually win on this argument you don't exactly have to do like more being or more impacting of this argument now okay
and do you have a do you have an example there from a debate that has happened to you and uh okay it's like uh one could be regarding there was uh probably one regarding uh maybe because you were in the motion Setting committee so you would probably know that motion as well uh black gingers uh so it was about uh i think uh best actually putting the sanctions on um chinese tech and the chinese goods and services etc something somewhat related uh so uh probably like maybe i was talking about like as opposition talking about
why me uh like doing that to china is like Actually a bad option because china can actually retaliate as well because china won't exactly um have that kind of opposition anymore because you're putting sanctions so china can literally go on exploiting the countries that like third-world countries that they were talking about and they won't even have any opposition in that case like like things like that like talking about like uh Different reasons why china wouldn't exactly be held accountable or why china wouldn't exactly uh do the things probably you want them to do like things
like that maybe so like okay and then the judges felt that it was insufficiently impacting so maybe like oh so like the idea about accountability is like like according to them was a good enough argument but maybe like there could have been more Being or impacting into it so like how do you make sure that the impact thing is like good enough or like grounded enough for you put that argument to like win you that debate okay okay that's fair um i think that impacting becomes intuitive when it's now down to it's sort of like
uh do you know what what like uh like you have you guys like grown up and done Like obviously you have i really hope so because i was really bad this like least common multiple and highest common factor that sort of thing and then do you remember this hopefully okay great so so so so you know how eventually you get down to like something like um wait yes yes that's right i mean uh lcm so like you get down to like some combination of like multi like prime numbers like you know Two into four isn't
a prime number three into three or whatever right so you get to this sort of space where you started by some with some weird numbers so i think that's how i think of impacting actually psychologically which is that um the impacting has to come down to that level of simplicity for it to be intuitive for instance more people hurt um or more people benefit Like it needs to be that clear um but in this case the argument you are making powerful country becomes more powerful which creates inequality but this would also sort of also default
to more people hurt or more people benefited also like more inequality generally is a pretty good one that you can come down on Um hurting the most vulnerable is another one violating duties is another one um [Music] is there any other ones um this is this is this is more or less it but this is what this is what i do like i'm just like can you keep going through the impacts of an argument until you get to a point where you can literally say and because of this this will end up Hurting more workers
hurting more consumers because of this there's more inequities within the global political system because of this you're hurting the most vulnerable workers or consumers because of this you're violating duties that we have to other countries whatever so if you can sort of do this thing with like with the prime numbers and everything and then you can come down to here then you've basically made your Impacting intuitive that is how i think about it does that does that answer your question yeah it does okay okay i'm glad i took a very weird way to get there
but we got in the end um rihanna what is your question yeah my question is a bit like throwing an oddball to the turf so my question is regarding the sports kind of motion you suppose you're in a room full of sport Sports nerd and you don't you are not what's next by the way is a contradiction in terms but go on uh yeah okay so you're in a room with sports nerds what happens okay so so this so the motion is like michael jordan is overrated michael jordan is a basketball player but you don't
really watch basketball but all the three teams have a lot of knowledge about basketball team basketball so how do you make you Not make yourself a laughing stock into the room even though you have lost all the lost the debate from the get-go but you haven't lost the debate from the get-go because you don't need to know about basketball to win that's what i'm trying to say um if we had a motion about nfl draft picks at uh was it was it doc's i can't remember like there was a motion about like you know Should
the nfl have draft picks about like something to do with hiring managers or i can't i can't even remember we knew nothing about this uh i think it was called the rooney rule if i'm not wrong but there was there was there was something about this and we basically knew nothing about this motion and then we just won because we just thought it had to do with politics and society because i think a general I know you use the sports example as a demonstration of your general point but specifically with regards to sports um no
sports motions are about sports is a very good rule to follow because they are never like it's never about like you know with what what does this mean ronaldo is offside or like you know um those sort of things like most motions are about society About inequality about in about economic impacts political impacts all of those things that's the first thing i would say um and then the second thing i would say is i think you can win dependent on how much they get lost in the technicality of things because i think often what happens
is um you can go in and then someone knows everything about basketball so they'll spend the next 15 minutes Talking about it as opposed to having argumentative analysis so i think it's almost liberating to not knowing anything about these things because then you can just walk away with simple argumentation as opposed to you know showing off that you had sports illustrated or whatever that hopefully answers your question a little bit is that yeah that answers questions my question I asked it because a few months ago i did a new zealand comp and there was a
motion regarding a rugby so as i was in closing and they were like saying spouting all kinds of technical terms and it was like confused in my mind so that's the reason why i asked like saying no that's very fair lost that's the reason why i said that Okay very very fair i i think i've noticed a general trend in the questioning here as well i think sometimes the problem is not with what you're saying but with like you know like i don't want to be on those people and be like beta muslin but like
it is true like like on some level this is just a problem with that judging or bad debating tactics or bad debating cultures or whatever it is so So don't don't like you know uh blame yourself too much here that's what i would say i'm also gonna wrap up supposed to wrap up in about 10 to 15 minutes so although i have a bit more stuff i wouldn't mind covering i would also be very happy for me to take questions like these because there are like a bunch of people on the call so taking more
questions would also be Very with something i'm very happy to do instead of typing into something new okay so sutani i suggested i cover more um i was just checking if the people agree with her but the people seem to be eerily silent so i will stick with um okay there we go we got one so ayan asked i've heard a ton of good judges say i've lost to my opening because i haven't paid enough so the way I whip is this this this is to say opening has these holes that my members fill them
but that doesn't seem to be working oh but that's because that's one sort of thing right so um wait there's another question oh brilliant oh yes please cover more okay i feel like tanya messaged whoever said nice and be like also also say this but fair enough um and and manal you probably have a Whatsapp chat going guys but um let me quickly answer ayana's question and then we can um uh move on from that so the question is pretty simple um so i okay so i think vayne can be of several kinds i actually
had like a the lecture of like six different kinds of thing but like like very quickly main can be of several times so So one is probability wing which is both teams reach for outcome x but you prove outcome x better the problem with this sort of thing which is what you're doing or the limitation of it it's not necessarily bad is that you're still proving outcome x so it's not always clear that you won and it's always subjective as to which team has better proof the probability of an argument another one is impact Weighing
right so this would be more like uh both teams both teams reach for different outcomes and both teams attempt to prove that impact that their chosen outcome is more important and this will usually be in the context of the things we just said more people hurt more people benefited a numbers game uh onto logical arguments like Inequality uh hurting the most vulnerable violating duties according to that metric who's winning and yeah no so so let's stick with these two for now so so i think if you do more impact wing ayana instead of just probability
wing it becomes easier to win the debate because i do think that uh probability weighing can be hard to adjudicate well because If they give three reasons for why outcome x is true and you give four reasons did you really win it past them i think there's also this general bias on the circuit that like you know analytical extensions aren't amazing so i would i would usually try to reach for impact weighing also not just probability weighing does that sort of answer your question i truly hope so okay great amazing um let's cover A little
bit more because we have like let's let's cap ourselves at uh in like 10-15 minutes okay let's do a little bit more um okay great um so another thing i want to talk about in terms of advanced argumentation is difference between different okay no that's a redundant sentence different moral duties okay i'm gonna try to speed through this this will be difficult but I think we can make it so first thing we have rights yes hopefully obviously and rights are only operational in so far as they impose obligations on others so this is this is
a very important idea to understand which is um okay so the first thing i want to caveat here is please don't make analysis about how there used to be pre-nation societies and then They did not have rights and then we started having rights when nations came into existence and then since then we've had rights because we have states like i don't know where what the genesis of this analysis is is in the local circuit but i've seen it so many times i would heavily insist against um using that analysis if you want the reasoning for
why i'm happy to give it later but like That's just a caveat i want to make here before we dive into this discussion um okay so rights are only operational so far as they impose obligations on others so for instance my right to life only makes sense in the context of everyone else around me not now having an obligation on them themselves not to kill me so this is important rights imply obligations this is the first steps Important to understand so which is this is why when you make an argument about like you know this
violates my right to association or my right to freedom of liberty or like my right to freedom of speech or the reason it sounds so weak is because you guys sometimes maybe don't make it in the context of obligations which makes it a lot more principally powerful because Then it's not necessarily about your right being violated so much as other people violating the obligation that was placed on them right so so i think the obligation analytical step is very important very important in terms of making a principled argument more weighty that's the first step the
second step here is um states also have obligations now the first part of this is that This is the thing that you will definitely know which is that you can have two sorts of rights or liberties this is the part you will definitely know which is like sort of negative liberties which are freedoms from so like you know freedom from intervention freedom from violence those sort of things and then you will have what are called Positive liberties which are freedoms too so you know freedom to participate in the political process freedom to voice your concerns
and have freedom of speech and all those things so he has two sorts of liberties so in terms of freedoms from the reason that states also have obligations is in this context um states must protect your rights But in doing so they necessarily have to impose obligations on others so let me try to make sense of this for you so let's just say that pakistan signs the convention against torture you know the city just sign this is just a convention which says like you know torture is illegal and bad now the state is in a
legally binding position to not torture its citizens however Along with the state's obligation to not torture you it has to similarly apply an obligation on others not to torture you because state is the arbiter is the only arbiter of obligations so let me explain what this legal legalese means this is really important because this is how you make the argument from State responsibility which i think is again not it's it's made in a sort of like flaky rhetorical sort of way but it's never made seriously as an argument so the way that you make it
seriously as an argument is that you say look the states has certain duties towards you this is something that people will universally agree like for instance the state does not have the right to kill you the State does not have the right to torture you however considering that the state is the only agency in the country which can also impose obligations on others part of its duty to not torture you must surely include ensuring that others don't torture you because the state is the only actor which can do so So what would be what what
happens then basically is that alongside the state's duty to not torture you it has to apply an obligation it's not to talk to you to guarantee your right to be free of torture because remember that the state's obligation to not torture you comes from the initial premise that you have a right to be free from The fear of violence and if the state the agency which can protect that right it has to do so both in the obvious sense of not torturing you but also in the most substantial sense of creating an environment where they
won't doctor you this is precisely why even if you have governments which are more or less well-intentioned But they are completely inept and incompetent in terms of ensuring outcomes for their people the international community has to step in and intervene because the state has violated its minimal obligations to citizens even if it's not explicitly hurting them it the violation of its duties is so deep that it's basically hurting them do you have any questions about how Individual rights or state responsibility arguments work before i quickly make a final point okay great um the second thing
i want to talk about quickly here is about duties and in sort of two ways so the first thing is and i you might have seen me use this a lot if you have ever seen me which is certainty versus uncertainty so using this argument well is really Important so one second what does the chat say uh okay so how about you make yourself audible and like explain what you mean there unless you can't which is fine like you can just like type out the whole question on the chat is that okay i'll just wait
for you to do that meanwhile i'll just keep typing okay so certainly versus uncertainty so this argument is often made in the Context of when it is obviously bad that doing nothing it it is obviously it is obvious that doing nothing is bad but it is unclear as to how bad it is to do something this is by the way an intuitive argument for status quo reform like this is one of the most classic philosophical arguments used for Reforming whichever world you live in right now so the and this is like i've used this argument
so many times so for instance if like if there's a debate about the us intervening in some country one side would be like you know the u.s can't go in because the u.s might make things worse my more people might die what if other powers get involved all of those things and the Line that you take there is you say yes those things are possible i am going to give you reasons for why they're unlikely but nonetheless they're possible but if the us does nothing it is definitely sure that people keep dying so i we
would rather pick the option where you're doing something where the harms are unclear to doing nothing where the harms will Continue to occur and are absolutely clear so using the certainty versus uncertainty modeling or framing model responsibilities is really important because it just gives you an intuitive advantage whenever you're reforming status quo in any way whether that's like a local policy or intervening in another country so that's an important thing to remember um Sanam are you going to come back in on your question i i i'll i'll wait in any case um the second thing
then that you should think about is passive versus active duties so the way this works is sort of the flip of what we were talking about with certainty versus uncertainty so for instance you can say that all active duties are in fact passive duties in order to Win the debate or you can do the flip which is that all passive duties are in fact active duties again depending on which side debate you're on so what does this mean um think about this way let's just say that there's a motion which is something along the lines
of uh you know the us should you know intervene or in some country or like let's take Something simpler so let's just say that the u.s has to pay a reparations to you know black community because of the history of slavery and everything so let's say that's the topic and the reason that the u.s has to do so is because the u.s has an active responsibility towards what happened in the case of slavery now there's this a couple of problems which Happen there so you can argue it from from culpability or you can argue it
from beneficence oh i actually spelled that right no i didn't but so what does this mean so if you say that the us has an active responsibility to what happened uh in terms of slavery people will be like yeah but like you know The u.s government was different then and like much more importantly like you know not all white people were responsible for this so why invite people getting reparations all of those things come up so this is why culpability is a much higher bar to mate usually the lower bar to meet is beneficials which
is to say um it's not that All of you were actively responsible it's more that all of you were complicit because all of you benefited from it and did nothing about it so that's why you're responsible so for instance you don't have to be someone who's you know cracking the whip on a plantation in the south in order to qualify someone who should be uh who should have money taken away from them For operations you can also be a neighboring farmer who has no slaves on the plantation but whose economy thrives on there being slaves
in the economy more generally and does nothing about slavery so you can be like millions of people like that note that this argument also makes sense in the context of Sexism and racism where you know a lot of people would come up to you and be like you know um i i get that like you know hashtag all men but really hashtag all men because like you know i haven't done this or whatever it is so so and then like you know so i'm not responsible for this or whatever and then in addition to you
arguing that like you know you can argue it from culpability which is the no you are Responsible a much lower conversation bar they would just be like yes but the reason that we're talking to you as well is because you benefited from the system where many people were responsible so you're still complicit so so i think this this this is like passive benefit versus active benefit so keeping that in mind is really important in terms of establishing the sort of Argumentative bar you need to win the debate otherwise it becomes a bit harder to win
these sort of debates there's like other distinctions here as well that i would want to make but i'm also very happy to come back at some point and then give another lecture but having said that aren't there any parting questions i have a couple of questions if you don't mind How about you pick your favorite one go ahead um the first one is regarding like the rights and the second one is like the epl bias judges so which one do you really want to answer like okay quick okay quickly cycle through them let's see what
happens um my question regarding rights like uh regarding rights so a criminal has been verdict uh like proven guilty totally like strongly so with like Empirical evidence but what about his right string when he's in jail for example there were there was an example regarding a scandinavian cell a scandinavian country where a rapist was given extra facility and he demanded that he should have get some kind of extra facility into himself so how should you like why should you Preserve his rights when he's a criminal in the first place because he has done something really
vicious to not and what and the second question is like when you are in opening you are clear you are making some making the mechanization of your arguments but then the closing comes and the paraphrases your mechanism and claims it as their own and the job judge is a bias towards epl uh to that Epl team so how do you mechanize so well in the opening so that the judges will feel guilty to make some kind of epl biases okay how do you work hard enough so as to overcome systemic racism i do not know
the answer but what i will say is that this is definitely a very serious problem and the way that you deal with it again is like you know making sure that you don't blame yourself that much making Sure that if you do blame yourself it's in a productive way which is like you know if this is something that's happening what i can do is work on myself and ensure i give the best speeches and also being open and frank with your debate uh fraternity being like you know uh this person was like this and and
maybe we can go and talk to them in terms of their judging but i think the final thing i'll say about that very Quickly is really really make sure that this conversation happened in a way that's a conversation starter and not a conversation stopper because i've seen that these conversations often escalate very quickly and then just like stop so like you know uh if you go up to a judge and be like wasn't this an epl extension from the closing or whatever um that's such an incendiary charge That that would that would just halt the
conversation as opposed to continue it so i think uh having this conversation in a way that's you know uh cognizant of you feeling misguided but then also feeling uh misled but then at the same time also keeping an open mind basically having lots of good faith in the conversation it reminds me of Like uh i was having dinner yesterday with a couple of friends and uh one of them uh his his his boyfriend they're getting married zone and my my third friend had lots of questions about how that works and everything and he dealt with
it really well like like like he knows that the questions are somewhat problematic in some way because you know what like gay people have the same edges that straight people Do i promise but like you know he answered them with the oh that's a really good question that's really interesting about this maybe you read about say that like when you deal with people like that like just have lots of good faith just assume until you're absolutely sure that this was a good faith problem and it can be dealt with in good faith um in terms
of quickly Your prisoner question i think the answer there is just basically we don't do it to protect the prisoner we do it to protect broader moral goals that we have as a society so for instance i don't want to live in a society where even the most like you know while people who commit the most violent inhuman acts have to suffer for the same reasons that i don't want to taliban as society where if you like you know kill someone they Get to kill someone from your community so i think we give that person
rights and privileges and uh education and rehabilitation not because they did something like that but despite them doing something like that and for broader goals that we have as sort of like a progressive society um hope that answers both questions um very quickly how do you debate if you have limited life knowledge in regret motions where no specific Action is happening i would definitely need more context to answer this one um but um for now i can say um so like let's say the topic is this house regrets the indian partition but you have no
idea what the indian partition was about i guess it's difficult i think if you're closing you can still manage because like opening sort of sets Up the terrain this is about religious minority protection or this is about religious polarization if those are the two different arguments on both sides and then you just like sort of like give generic arguments about that but if that doesn't happen and you're og on a regrets motion not knowing what you're regretting then i don't know buddy i think i think i think you've lost a debate like i'm being honest
like I think any answer i come up with will be speculative like you we just need to read up more or make sure that c is at better emotions um bob very quickly what are your favorite resources for matter loading principles i have if in complete honesty never matter loaded anything so i'm the very bad person to ask this i generally enjoy reading a lot so maybe that's where they come From but um i think like my my debate partner taha would be a good person to ask about this maybe uh but if you have
like questions about for instance like a specific uh philosophy text that you're looking at or specific ethical problem feel free to message me on facebook and i'll probably have a reading that i was reading or a book that i would be happy to recommend on that question Um no aren't there any resources or sites you would recommend to keep up with practical evaluative information that isn't mostly about u.s or china um yes so a bunch actually so so i think so i think if you actually read um the imf world bank unhrc unhcr reports like
undp reports uh oxfam reports um like most international organizations and i ngos Have really fantastic reports like i just don't think people go through them like i i think it's a sort of like a straw man to say that they're always about the us or china i think the headlines are which is like new york times and bosch po but like um that that that reports that soup and potato stuff the everyday stuff it's really fantastic so i would just literally go through international organizations i ngos And then look up like extremely good analysis that
they have on by the way the thing we were talking about friends and patrons what is digital access like across the world what are human rights records now as it stands what are democracy indicators from freedom house like i i think you can find lots of stuff that isn't about the us or china if you look in the think tank ingeo um io policy space and then finally Read other newspapers which aren't american or british so i would suggest reading the south china morning post it's a very very good newspaper just fairly international i would
also suggest reading al jazeera which is not the best on qatar because of its located but it's at the same time a fairly decent publication generally also try to read other Newspapers which are uh western but not british or american right so le monde from from france is a fantastic one um deutsche ballet from germany dash beagle are really good newspaper options so yeah i think long story short you can find them um the hindustan times you want to report india is decent india today is fine Um so so you can definitely find them like
i would just expand the diversity of your news diet and then start reading more reports which is boring but like you know that's how you get there um thereby i remember you were talking about well-based universe somewhere could you just mention the headings i will have to explain this divine so if you could message me on facebook or something i will i will send These to you and then we can discuss this then there's a random v from someone and oh just ignore this please never mind and then ayanna says are there any specific exercises
drills that you recommend for someone who are who was prepping for a major um so again i'm such a bad person to ask about this because i i have like no No no training discipline because like we just like you know just like chill outside and have a coffee and then maybe prep promotion and then speak a tournament like that's it like i i think we're actually back people to ask about this specific question about exercises or drills having said that i did speak with someone who last year who had a lot more discipline than
i did so um i Think i can tell you what her tactics were so for instance um one is obviously watching debates and then the other is prepping motions but then you can do this in between which is helpful which is that you can watch really good rounds and rooms and then speak as leader of opposition or you can speak as deputy prime minister in that debate assuming you were there And i think that just like that's really hard to do initially and sort of awkward but like if you can start assuming that you're in
that room like you know hws top room or world's final or whatever it is and you start speaking like that i think that's a very good grill to have in terms of prepping for a major also finally like digital Uh stuff like you know because of covet everything's online now so please always feel free when you're prepping for a major to reach out to circuits across the world everyone is really happy to do sparse so just reach out to different teams for spars everywhere i'm sure some of them would be happy to do a spa
so that would be another way to prep for a major in a way that was like impossible to do Previously so so that's that's really good um sana said can you please write all those names i will do that in a second and then there's a question about if you have any official facebook page or any other debate group kindly inform no i don't um and then sana finally asks of reports which you just talked about right now okay no i was just naming organizations Left right and center but like examples here would be oxfam
does great research on global inequality um human rights watch obviously works on human rights but in a progressive space so for instance like unlike many traditional human rights organizations they would be very happy to focus on things like trans rights issues or uh things which i just like usually neglected Um obviously undp um unhcr all of those places and uh freedom house so they look at um democracy indicators obviously transparency international which looks at corruption amnesty international which looks at state repression um and i could go on and on and then the newspapers that i
was talking about was al jazeera um south china morning post their Spiegel yeah and so basically what i would do this is actually good when you think about this if you want to read good international newspapers a good criteria is to google a random country and then find the most read english newspaper from there and chances are that newspaper is also good international newspaper so if you find the most well-read like english newspaper In germany or in france chances are that you've also stumbled across a good international newspaper generally that doesn't talk about u.s or
china that much so if you do it for like you know brazil or nepal or whichever country that you want to look at you will just stumble across a very good newspaper so that's a good predict to do it um And then finally uh oh thanks a lot like uh that's that's very helpful okay i just got like hold some messages that's that's fine um great so that's okay perfect okay now people feel pressured to like send me more wholesome messages i was just there was just a comment on what i discovered but um the
point is i hope this was Really helpful uh this is like a very small part of what uh we ideally should cover overall but i i hope this helped i tried to discuss things which were as fundamental as possible and then hopefully we can get into the nitty gritties if we ever do this again but thank you for having me