As we all know recently, HSBC Holdings (5) is a very popular stock among Hong Kong people, and HSBC Holdings has unknowingly reached a record high. If you look back at the valuation chart of HSBC, its stock price valuation has been reflected. In fact, HSBC is now near historical highs.
In addition, Hong Kong banking stocks, such as Bank of China Hong Kong (2388) and Hang Seng Bank (11), are also the choices of many investors, especially those who focus on interest income. These interest-earning investors will use Bank of China Hong Kong, Hang Seng Bank, and HSBC Holdings as their interest-earning targets. So I took the opportunity tonight to update some information on the Hong Kong banking stocks sector.
This picture is about a ratio called CASA. As mentioned before, CASA is the Current Account Savings Account. Basically, it is the lowest cost source of funds for banks.
If we look at the entire banking industry, we can see from the blue line in the chart on the left that the CASA ratio of the overall banking industry in Hong Kong has continued to decline in recent years. The trend is downward. The reason is that due to the interest rate hike in the United States, the bank time deposit interest rate in Hong Kong was once as high as more than 5%.
This has caused many people, including my friends and even myself, to pay more attention. In the past few years, I have tried to make time deposits. This time deposit will cause the CASA ratio to fall.
That is, when bank depositors' funds are transferred from demand deposits to time deposits, CASA's deposit ratio will fall. This is the main reason. It is because the interest rates on time deposits are very attractive due to interest rate hikes in the United States, causing people to switch their deposits from demand deposits to time deposits.
This is called term deposits. This has resulted in the CASA ratio of the Hong Kong banking industry falling in recent years. This is the overall situation in the banking industry, but the CASA ratio is different between different banks.
As you can see from the chart on the right, ranked from high to low, HSBC (here refers to HSBC in Hong Kong). Everyone knows that one of the main businesses of HSBC, No. 5 stock, is HSBC Hong Kong.
Of course Hang Seng Bank is also a subsidiary of it, and of course it also has overseas operations, but here we only discuss HSBC Hong Kong. Its CASA ratio is 61%, the highest among Hong Kong banks. Although it has dropped from the peak of 75% to 61%, it cannot resist the trend of regular deposits.
But it still remains ahead of other banks at 61%. The second place is Hang Seng Bank with 51%, and the third place is Bank of China Hong Kong with 46%. The industry average is 41%, which means HSBC.
The CASA ratios of Hang Seng and Bank of China are higher than the industry average. But Bank of East Asia only has 29%, which is much lower than the industry average. What does this mean?
CASA, which represents the lowest cost of funds for East Asian banks, has the smallest proportion of deposits. This is actually not very beneficial to Bank of East Asia, because the higher the CASA ratio means the lower the bank's cost of funds, so a high CASA ratio is actually one of the bank's core competitiveness. Next, look at the second picture, which talks about the growth trend of loans and deposits of Hong Kong banks.
In the growth trend, light blue is deposits, and light blue is deposits. Dark blue is the loan. From the picture on the left, you can see the years, from 2026 to 2024.
The growth of overall deposits and loans of Hong Kong banks in recent years. You will see that in the past, when the economy in Hong Kong was good, the loan growth rate (that is, the dark blue line) of Hong Kong banks was very good, sometimes reaching more than 20%. Moreover, the loan growth rate in dark blue will be higher than the deposit growth rate in light blue, which means that loan growth exceeds deposit growth.
That is when Hong Kong's economy is doing well. But you will see a phenomenon in recent years, especially starting from 2020, the growth rate of deposits (that is, the light blue line) is higher than the dark blue line. This means that the growth rate of deposits is higher than the growth rate of loans.
You can even see that starting from 2022, the growth rate of deposits has been rising, from a growth rate of 1. 7% in 2020, to 5. 1% in 2023, and to 7.
1% in 2024. The growth of deposits is not bad. But loan growth is negative.
You will see a drop of 3% in 2022, a drop of 3. 6% in 2023, and a drop of 2. 8% in 2024.
This is helpless. From this growth chart of deposits and loans, you will see that Hong Kong's economy has indeed been bad in recent years. These conditions actually reflect the economy.
The good or bad will be reflected in the bank's loan growth rate, which is now negative. In addition to loan growth, loan quality is also very important. Regarding loan quality, look at this picture.
This is called the specific category loan ratio. We will explain what the specific category loan ratio is in a moment. First, let’s look at the trends in the past few years.
You will see that the dark blue line is total loans, while the light blue line is mainland-related loans. Whether it is total loans in dark blue or mainland-related loans in light blue, the loan ratio of this specific category is rising. An increase means that the quality of the loan is deteriorating.
Because the higher the loan ratio for a specific category, the credit risk of loan quality is actually greater, so the higher the ratio, the worse it is. You see the trend is upward, which means credit risk is rising. This is actually a figure that the Hong Kong Monetary Authority regularly publishes on the loan ratios of specific categories of the Hong Kong banking industry.
The latest data is as of June 2024. The specific classification loan ratio in Hong Kong's local market will be 1. 57% at the end of 2023.
Rising to 1. 89% at the end of June 2024, this is the dark line. As for mainland-related loans, Hong Kong banks will participate in mainland loans.
If you look at the specific category loan ratio of mainland-related loans by category, it will rise from 2. 58% at the end of 2023 to 2. 78% at the end of June 2024.
They are all rising, and you will see that the specific category loan ratio of mainland loans is higher than that of Hong Kong, which means that the risk of mainland loans is higher than that of Hong Kong. Here is an explanation of Hong Kong's loan classification system. According to the loan classification system of the Hong Kong Monetary Authority, it will be evaluated based on the repayment ability of the borrower (usually a company), the recovery of the loan principal, and whether the interest can be recovered.
It evaluates the repayment ability when borrowing and whether the principal and interest can be recovered. This requires an assessment, and the bank needs to do an assessment. Based on the assessment results, the bank will classify the loan into five major categories.
The first category is called qualified loans, the second category is called special mention loans, the third category is called substandard, the fourth category is called sluggish, and the fifth category is called loss-making. If you are included in the three categories of substandard, sluggish, and loss-making, it is the last three categories of loans. It's called a classified loan, so you just saw the so-called classified loan ratio on that line.
That is to say, among the loans lent by Hong Kong banks, all loans will be divided into five categories, and the latter three categories include substandard, sluggish and loss-making. If your loan falls into one of the latter three categories, add them all up and divide by the total loan. This is called the Category-Specific Loan Ratio.
The higher the loan ratio for this particular category, it means that the quality of your assets is deteriorating. And if it is a specific category of loans and special mention categories (i. e.
the second category), the first category is qualified, and qualified is of course the most normal. You need to start paying attention to the second category. The next three levels must belong to specific categories.
That is, if you add the specific category to the second category that needs attention, it will be categories two, three, four, and five. Basically adding up the second, third, fourth and fifth categories, this is called a problem loan. However, the line in the picture just now refers to the ratio of loans of specific categories, that is, the sum of the last three categories with the worst asset quality.
That statistic is loans of specific categories. In fact, the length of time that interest and principal have been in arrears, as well as measuring the chance of recovering the loan, are some very important indicators . If the interest and principal are not repaid for more than 3 months or 6 months, banks will generally classify it as substandard or sluggish.
However, delinquency means that the principal or interest is obviously in arrears, which is already a consideration for problematic loans. But sometimes even if you repay normally, if you have reason to believe that this borrower may have problems, that is, you may see some company news, or there may be big problems suddenly appearing in the industry, although he is repaying normally now, if some news suddenly appears in his company, or some news suddenly appears in his industry, and you think this may affect his future repayment, you may need to classify him as substandard or sluggish, even if he is currently repaying normally. But depending on each company, if there are some special circumstances, you have to classify it as substandard or sluggish.
In any case, based on statistics on the loan ratios of specific categories in Hong Kong's banking industry, everyone can see that the trend is upward, which is a bad situation. The next issue that the market is very concerned about is the credit risk of commercial real estate loans of Hong Kong banks. This is the current focus of investors investing in Hong Kong banking stocks.
The bank with the highest proportion of commercial real estate loans is, of course, not talking about all the banks in Hong Kong, but the banks we cover. You will see that the higher ones are Hang Seng Bank, BOC Hong Kong and Bank of East Asia. They are Hang Seng Bank with 16.
2%, Bank of China Hong Kong with 15. 4%, and Bank of East Asia with 12. 1%.
The higher the ratio, the higher the proportion of commercial real estate loans among its loans, which is what you need to pay more attention to. If you think Hong Kong commercial real estate is a relatively high-risk type of loan now, the proportion of commercial real estate loans of these three banks is relatively high. You need to pay attention.
On the contrary, the proportion of commercial real estate loans in Hong Kong of HSBC and Standard Chartered Bank is relatively low, with HSBC only 3. 8%. Standard Chartered Bank's is as low as only 0.
9%. Relatively speaking, HSBC and Standard Chartered don't need to worry so much. This is often relative.
For Hang Seng Bank, it is one thing that your loan ratio is high, but the quality of your loans is another. The NPL ratio of Hang Seng Bank's commercial loans is relatively high at 9. 6%, compared with only 0.
2% for BOC Hong Kong. That is to say, although Hang Seng Bank and BOC Hong Kong currently have relatively high proportions of commercial real estate loans in Hong Kong, if you compare HSBC and Standard Chartered, from the perspective of loan quality, Hang Seng Bank’s loan quality is high. For the time being, it is worse than BOCHK.
This is the quality of commercial real estate loans that investors need to pay attention to. The next discussion is the shareholder return rate. Everyone knows that it is very important now.
Not only the mainland attaches great importance to shareholder returns and dividends, but Hong Kong investors also attach great importance to this dividend, especially if you buy Hong Kong bank stocks for dividends. It's important to understand how well the bank is giving back to shareholders. As you can see, the dark green line is the constant dividend.
This is regular dividend payment, and the yellow one is repurchase, which means some companies will repurchase. Buybacks are actually a way to give back to shareholders, so we have to include regular dividends as a way for this bank to give back to shareholders. Share repurchases must also be included, because shareholders will benefit.
The light blue line is a special dividend. Because special dividends are not available for every bank, judging from the summary here, you can see that the regular dividend yields of HSBC (5), Bank of East Asia (23), Hang Seng Bank (11) and BOC Hong Kong (2388) all exceed 6%, which are all good. HSBC even relied on this special dividend to return 1.
9% to shareholders. And if we look at the yellow part, it is 5. 7% of shares repurchased.
This is a way of giving back to shareholders by repurchasing shares. Bank of East Asia and Hang Seng Bank both repurchased shares to give back 1. 5% and 1.
6%, which are both good. Standard Chartered Bank is special. Standard Chartered's method of giving back to shareholders is mainly by repurchasing shares.
It's almost a 7. 4% shareholder return that was given back to shareholders through share repurchases. And using the constant dividend method, it is only 2.
6%, that is, if you calculate the constant dividend rate, it is 2. 6%. But no matter what, in fact, if you add regular dividends plus special dividends plus share repurchases, these banks in Hong Kong are all good, that is, they have not done a bad job in giving back to shareholders.