hey everybody this is lee hall from teachingacademia.com and today we're going to be talking about this concept called thick description and i'm going to be talking to you about what thick description is and giving you some examples of what a thick versus a more thin description looks like and actually the benefits of making sure that you have both kinds in your field notes all right so let's dive right into this what is thick description why does it matter so the term comes out of anthropology and you're gonna have to forgive me because i i've always
struggled with how to say this gentleman's last name it is attributed to clifford it's either geertz or gertz it's g-e-e-r-t-z i always mix it up somebody always corrects me and then i always forget i'm sorry um but the idea here is when you're taking your field notes with thick description you're going to be moving past a basic surface level in terms of um your observations your notes and and what you're writing down what you are describing now the um you know the surf this idea of a surface level those that those pieces of information are
necessary and they have value okay but you don't want to only have surface level documentation in your field notes there are moments when you are going to want to engage in this more thick description kind of work okay so with thick description you want to include things like the context detail maybe content that's being you know taught or examined at the moment emotions social interactions things like that all right and these details help you and the larger community as a whole better understand your observation okay you may want to include direct quotes from others sometimes
it's a sentence sometimes it's a paragraph okay and you will use your best judgment and that will be aligned with your research question right so obviously if people are having a conversation and it has nothing to do with your research question you don't need to document that right you might want to note that a conversation about a particular topic happened that's an example of a more thin description but a thick description isn't necessary because it's not related to your question when you know or you even think there's a possibility that you observe um a conversation
that does align with your research question then you either want to document that in the moment or if you're recording it you're gonna go back and transcribe it right catch what you can in the moment and then clean it up later all right but that that research question helps you understand what to take more and less off in terms of your field notes so what is this thick description versus a more thin description look like so let me give you an example here out of my background of education so let's say i'm observing you know
an eighth grade english class and a student that's in my study comes into the room and immediately walks over to his desk sits down puts his head down and just that's it right he's just sitting there with his head down okay if all i do is say so and so came into the room you know at 11 o'clock went to his desk and sat down sat down and put his head down that's pretty thin now it's important information okay so i'm not knocking this level of information because we do need to know the student came
into the room we do need to know you know it was at the beginning of class or maybe that student was 10 minutes late right that information is important the fact that they came over and that person came over immediately and put his head down on the desk that's very important okay that's all still very relevant all right but we're also missing some things which we may or may not be able to get at that moment in time okay so we know the facts of what happened what we saw but what else is going on
okay and it's when you start providing that context right that you start to shift from a thin into a more thick description so for example some things that i could include in that scenario is what's happening in the class at the moment okay so for example if that student comes in the room and maybe there's an assignment on the board maybe you have to come in and you have to turn in your homework and sit down and maybe do a quick writing in response to a question and that student came in and didn't turn anything
in and didn't do that opening quick write assignment right that's important information to know versus you know the expectation was just come in and sit down in your seat right those are two very different contexts all right um and putting your head down when the context is just come in and sit down signal something potentially very different than you know come in turn in your homework from last night and do this other assignment right so that context is very important it helps us start to get a handle on the situation and to know kind of
what we might want to investigate later either with the student or potentially that student's teacher all right so um you might ask the student in that context and it might be that day it might be that week it might be in an interview later on um you know you use your best judgment about when the best time is to have conversations like this with participants you might ask that student to explain what they did you might say i noticed you came in you know you got to class on time but you didn't turn in your
homework and you didn't do that opening quick right i noticed you put your head down on your desk and you didn't look up until the teacher called your name can you talk about what was going on that day can you help me understand what it was that i saw all right that's getting at a more thick thick description all right the other thing that you might do in that situation is you might document how people react in relation to the student so for example the student comes in right we'll say it's that situation where you
got to turn your homework in and do a quick write but the student doesn't do that he puts his head down on his desk um does the teacher notice that pretty promptly and go over and have a discussion with that student um do other students try to engage with the student and if so what happens or does everybody seem to kind of not say anything to the student right the student is just left alone by themselves and nobody's talking to that student is it 15 minutes before someone says something to that student right these are
all very important contextual things to know that allow you to build up this thicker richer description and allow you to move past those surface level observations which are still very important because those are the facts of what you saw right but it helps us kind of get at what's the real underlying thing here what's really going on so um some kinds of things that you may want to include in your thick description is um or in your descriptions in general are biographical who's involved okay historical what might have led to this now when we're talking
about what led to this it could be that you're speculating you have some ideas you have some questions in which case you probably want to put that in a separate spot on your field note forum or you may actually have some information okay in which case you can fill that in um the context right what's the situation right what's the environment okay um relational what's happening at that moment and then interactional right what you know who's talking to who or who's not talking to who right what are the and and what are the meanings of
those relationships and those interactions you won't necessarily be able to get at what are the meanings of these interactions or lack thereof in that moment in time but you can make notes you can make notes to yourself you can leave questions for yourself that allow you to backtrack later on to have conversations with the people involved so that you can get at understanding the meanings about the interactions that you saw or lack thereof